Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Wool as an outer layer

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved The Outdoor and Survival Forum
203 Posts 1 Posters 21.3k Views
  1. Home
  2. Outdoor Section
  3. The Outdoor and Survival Forum
  4. Wool as an outer layer
Wool as an outer layer
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Gareth Offline
    Gareth
    Admin Team
    Posts: 37,725
    Gareth Offline
    Gareth
    Admin Team
    wrote on last edited by
    #132 Quote Reply

      @Pablo O'Brien said:

      @Syncop8r said:

      @Pablo O'Brien said:

      Not to mention, warm and dry beats warm and wet....

      Must... resist........ must... behave..... :facepalm:

      :whistle:

      :D :D

      Merit Badges
      Scale Changer Mod User Hacker Reviewer Camping Outdoor Cook Flashlight Airgun User ALOX with Scissors Traditional Folder Challenge Axe User Minimal SAK Challenge Birth Year SAK Jack'O Lantern Badge Delemont 30 Day Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Case XX 30 Day Challenge
      1 Reply Last reply
      • 4everYoung Offline
        4everYoung
        Posts: 692
        4everYoung Offline
        4everYoung
        wrote on last edited by
        #133 Quote Reply

          @Syncop8r said:

          @4everYoung said:

          @Syncop8r said:

          @4everYoung said:

          So wonder why he dipped them in that secret concoction??? Hmmm [emoji848][emoji848][emoji848]

          Because as well as wool performs when wet, it performs even better when dry. ;)

          So that's to say that dry wool performs better but wet wool performs worse than dry wool... pretty sure that's been my argument all along. [emoji16]☔️

          I thought your argument was that the adage that "wool keeps you warm when it's wet" is a myth.
          I'm saying it still keeps you warm when wet, not to the same degree as when dry, but a lot better than what was traditionally the alternative - cotton.

          @4everYoung said:
          I could see wool as an outer layer in dry conditions but not in wet. For all it's properties, waterproof/resistant it is not.

          The above was my short response when this thread first started. Unfortunately the old classic debate ensued. So that requires arguing from different angles.

          But my whole point is and always has been that wool is a good insulator and makes a good layer, but keep it dry. It is not waterproof. Unfortunately you can't simply make that statement without all the hubbub and todo about it. Hearing about how wool is a magically mythical fabric that is able to defy all physical properties.

          Cotton retains more moisture longer than wool. Wool also retains moisture. Is it more effective and drying out than cotton? Yes ! However that was never my contention.
          Wool is not waterproof on its on. So unless you make it that way by coating it, it will eventually saturate as well. Saturated wool is no better than saturated anything else: Cotton, down or whatever.
          That's why in the article you posted, the inventor used a secret concoction to waterproof the wool. And my point about why he did it.

          Merit Badges
          The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
          1 Reply Last reply
          • 4everYoung Offline
            4everYoung
            Posts: 692
            4everYoung Offline
            4everYoung
            wrote on last edited by
            #134 Quote Reply

              @Gareth said:

              @Pablo O'Brien said:

              Wool may or may not perform nice when wet, but there is no way I would want to get wet in the first place. If it's drizzling all day, raincoat over something insulating (such as wool or a fleece) for me.
              I went camping last weekend. It drizzled for half the day on Saturday. :rant:
              I was dry, thanks to my raincoat, but on the cold side due to not having something properly insulating. :facepalm:
              I won't make that mistake again, and will go buy something warm. :cheers:

              This seems to be the sensible way to approach things I'd say. I still think anyone expecting to be warm when wet is likely to be disappointed sooner or later, whether what you are wearing wool, cotton or something synthetic. I wear a lot of different wool coats/jackets from tweeds to pea coats and army surplus, but none of them would be my first choice of what to wear when it's raining heavily. Not saying they're useless at all, but I wouldn't want to spend a whole day in the rain in one and certainly not overnight. An afternoon of drizzle is OK, but I'd still want to know I could dry out afterwards.

              Yes, thank you!

              Merit Badges
              The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
              1 Reply Last reply
              • Syncop8r Offline
                Syncop8r
                Posts: 8,801
                Syncop8r Offline
                Syncop8r
                wrote on last edited by
                #135 Quote Reply

                  @4everYoung said:
                  Saturated wool is no better than saturated anything else: Cotton, down or whatever.

                  I'm not convinced.... or not yet at least.
                  Does cotton hold more water than wool? Perhaps the wool is more difficult to saturate?
                  This is something I will look into more when I have time...

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • 4everYoung Offline
                    4everYoung
                    Posts: 692
                    4everYoung Offline
                    4everYoung
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #136 Quote Reply

                      @Syncop8r said:

                      @4everYoung said:
                      Saturated wool is no better than saturated anything else: Cotton, down or whatever.

                      I'm not convinced.... or not yet at least.
                      Does cotton hold more water than wool? Perhaps the wool is more difficult to saturate?
                      This is something I will look into more when I have time...

                      I'm doing real time test for you now. Stand by

                      Merit Badges
                      The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • Gareth Offline
                        Gareth
                        Admin Team
                        Posts: 37,725
                        Gareth Offline
                        Gareth
                        Admin Team
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #137 Quote Reply

                          @4everYoung said:

                          @Gareth said:

                          @Pablo O'Brien said:

                          Wool may or may not perform nice when wet, but there is no way I would want to get wet in the first place. If it's drizzling all day, raincoat over something insulating (such as wool or a fleece) for me.
                          I went camping last weekend. It drizzled for half the day on Saturday. :rant:
                          I was dry, thanks to my raincoat, but on the cold side due to not having something properly insulating. :facepalm:
                          I won't make that mistake again, and will go buy something warm. :cheers:

                          This seems to be the sensible way to approach things I'd say. I still think anyone expecting to be warm when wet is likely to be disappointed sooner or later, whether what you are wearing wool, cotton or something synthetic. I wear a lot of different wool coats/jackets from tweeds to pea coats and army surplus, but none of them would be my first choice of what to wear when it's raining heavily. Not saying they're useless at all, but I wouldn't want to spend a whole day in the rain in one and certainly not overnight. An afternoon of drizzle is OK, but I'd still want to know I could dry out afterwards.

                          Yes, thank you!

                          I will caveat my above statement by saying that, while I wouldn't necessarily reach for a wool coat if it's already raining, if I was already wearing one the fact it starts raining doesn't make me run for cover. They're fine...up to a point. :D

                          Keep in mind it's now getting on for Autumn, I've got a dog to walk and I live in Scotland, I've got lots of opportunities to put this to the test coming up very soon. :D

                          Merit Badges
                          Scale Changer Mod User Hacker Reviewer Camping Outdoor Cook Flashlight Airgun User ALOX with Scissors Traditional Folder Challenge Axe User Minimal SAK Challenge Birth Year SAK Jack'O Lantern Badge Delemont 30 Day Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Case XX 30 Day Challenge
                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • 4everYoung Offline
                            4everYoung
                            Posts: 692
                            4everYoung Offline
                            4everYoung
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #138 Quote Reply

                              This is cotton t shirt and a merino wool buff

                              Wool before dunk

                              Dunk for 2secs

                              After 2sec it is fully saturated and dripping

                              Cotton shirt before dunk

                              2sec dunk

                              Fully saturated and dripping

                              Both had the water squeezed out so it wasn't dripping and tied around my upper arms.

                              Will let you know the results of feel and drying time.
                              But I can tell you that the wool and cotton bot sucked up the water fast. There was no noticeable difference in the two fabrics. Both were fully saturated after 2sec.
                              And preliminary I can say I don't feel warm from either side. As the air cond is on and I right beside a vent. It's chilly on both arms.

                              Merit Badges
                              The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • 4everYoung Offline
                                4everYoung
                                Posts: 692
                                4everYoung Offline
                                4everYoung
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #139 Quote Reply

                                  20 minutes so far, both arms still cold and wet. Still quite uncomfortable in here.

                                  Merit Badges
                                  The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • styx Offline
                                    styx
                                    Posts: 9,851
                                    styx Offline
                                    styx
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #140 Quote Reply

                                      @4everYoung said:

                                      @styx said:

                                      again, to be fair most peacoats, overcoats, greatcoats and similar items are made of wool too and used as normal outerwear.

                                      this whole thing is slightly less confusing at times than the whole wind shirt/jacket vs rain jacket thing. when did hiking/backpacking/woods bumming clothing get so complex?

                                      Yea wool coats are designed as outer wear, so are knit cotton, denim, and even down filled jackets and a slew of synthetic materials. Doesn't mean they should be worn in all weather conditions. Which is the whole point of all your of this. At least I thought it was.
                                      Picking the right outer wear for the right conditions.

                                      at some point it was. but considering there are many nuances to this whole debate, I think that the bast way to go hiking and backpacking is by having a half cotton, half synthetic base layer (not a blend, literally 2 different shirts sewn together), a wool sweater and an oilcloth (or similar water resistant material) overcoat, a pair of merino longjohns under hiking pants (one of those that have 45 zippers so the pant leg length can be adjusted, icebreaker socks and swimming fins.

                                      Merit Badges
                                      EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Ignore Mora User Axe User Victorinox Spirit Challenge Fixed Blade Challenge 30 Day Axe Challenge 30 Day Fire starting Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • 4everYoung Offline
                                        4everYoung
                                        Posts: 692
                                        4everYoung Offline
                                        4everYoung
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #141 Quote Reply

                                          50min in. Both are still damp. The part that is stretched out is drying on both. However on both the part that is tied around in a knot is still very wet.

                                          Here is a tissue test from the stretched part of each fabric.

                                          Wool

                                          Cotton

                                          This is after 5 secs of contact with my hand on top.
                                          Very little difference in each one.

                                          The skin under both fabrics is colder than the skin that is not in contact with it on both sides. I would not want either one on in a cold environment if they were wet. It's 70*f with a constant cool breeze from circulating air. It would be frigid if I was in actual cold temps.

                                          Merit Badges
                                          The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • Gareth Offline
                                            Gareth
                                            Admin Team
                                            Posts: 37,725
                                            Gareth Offline
                                            Gareth
                                            Admin Team
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #142 Quote Reply

                                              Very interesting so far mate. :tu: I know you (probably) only have two arms, but I'd be interested in seeing this repeated with a wicking shirt vs the "winner" of this current test.

                                              Merit Badges
                                              Scale Changer Mod User Hacker Reviewer Camping Outdoor Cook Flashlight Airgun User ALOX with Scissors Traditional Folder Challenge Axe User Minimal SAK Challenge Birth Year SAK Jack'O Lantern Badge Delemont 30 Day Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Case XX 30 Day Challenge
                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • 4everYoung Offline
                                                4everYoung
                                                Posts: 692
                                                4everYoung Offline
                                                4everYoung
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #143 Quote Reply

                                                  Ok so 2hours have elapsed and this is the results.

                                                  Both fabrics are still damp. The wool feels dryer than the cotton. However both are still cold against the skin. Neither ever resembled anything like warmth.

                                                  The tissue test at 5 seconds again.

                                                  Wool

                                                  Cotton

                                                  Both were still significantly wet at the knot portion of the fabric. The knot hung at the bottom so I would say that a fair bit or water went that direction due to gravity.

                                                  One observation about the wool, it felt dryer at the top most portion of my arm, and as the fabric went around the sides more and more moisture was retained.
                                                  The cotton seemed consistently damp all the way around (except the lower knot portion on both pieces).

                                                  I removed both pieces at the 2 hr mark. Both arms were still cold to the touch after removing the fabrics as well as damp. I let them air dry and within 5min both side had warmed up to the rest of my arms temp.

                                                  I hung up the fabrics and will them dry on their own. Will report back in that.

                                                  In conclusion of this part, it seemed that the wool was starting to feel more dry around the 1hr 30min mark, but still damp and cool. At the 2hr mark I was still cool and damp.
                                                  Overall the point of the test was a comparison of wool vs cotton in regards to water absorption and retention. In a dunk, there was no difference in absorption after a 2 sec dunk. Both items were saturated and dripping. Wool did not resist the moisture anymore than cotton did.
                                                  Secondly after wringing out the fabrics both were still considerably wet feeling.
                                                  Both were cold and resulted in heat loss through convection.
                                                  Both pieces were still damp at the 2hr mark. The wool had dried some in relation to the cotton starting to notice at 1.5hr mark. This still did not make a differences in the feel. I still felt cold and wet on both sides.

                                                  Merit Badges
                                                  The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • 4everYoung Offline
                                                    4everYoung
                                                    Posts: 692
                                                    4everYoung Offline
                                                    4everYoung
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #144 Quote Reply

                                                      @Gareth said:
                                                      Very interesting so far mate. :tu: I know you (probably) only have two arms, but I'd be interested in seeing this repeated with a wicking shirt vs the "winner" of this current test.

                                                      Well I'll see what I can make happen. It would be the wool vs synthetic. Once the wool dries I'll plan for that one.

                                                      Merit Badges
                                                      The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • styx Offline
                                                        styx
                                                        Posts: 9,851
                                                        styx Offline
                                                        styx
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #145 Quote Reply

                                                          the things you do for us

                                                          Merit Badges
                                                          EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Ignore Mora User Axe User Victorinox Spirit Challenge Fixed Blade Challenge 30 Day Axe Challenge 30 Day Fire starting Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • Gareth Offline
                                                            Gareth
                                                            Admin Team
                                                            Posts: 37,725
                                                            Gareth Offline
                                                            Gareth
                                                            Admin Team
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #146 Quote Reply

                                                              @4everYoung said:

                                                              @Gareth said:

                                                              Very interesting so far mate. :tu: I know you (probably) only have two arms, but I'd be interested in seeing this repeated with a wicking shirt vs the "winner" of this current test.

                                                              Well I'll see what I can make happen. It would be the wool vs synthetic. Once the wool dries I'll plan for that one.

                                                              :cheers:

                                                              Merit Badges
                                                              Scale Changer Mod User Hacker Reviewer Camping Outdoor Cook Flashlight Airgun User ALOX with Scissors Traditional Folder Challenge Axe User Minimal SAK Challenge Birth Year SAK Jack'O Lantern Badge Delemont 30 Day Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Case XX 30 Day Challenge
                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • Syncop8r Offline
                                                                Syncop8r
                                                                Posts: 8,801
                                                                Syncop8r Offline
                                                                Syncop8r
                                                                wrote on last edited by Syncop8r
                                                                #147 Quote Reply

                                                                  OK what about the amount of water absorbed by wool Vs cotton garments after say an hour of drizzle?
                                                                  With your experiment I would like to have seen a measure of how much water was absorbed by measuring the water before and after dunking. :pok:

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • 4everYoung Offline
                                                                    4everYoung
                                                                    Posts: 692
                                                                    4everYoung Offline
                                                                    4everYoung
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #148 Quote Reply

                                                                      @Syncop8r said:
                                                                      OK what about the amount of water absorbed by wool Vs cotton garments after say an hour of drizzle?
                                                                      With your experiment I would like to have seen a measure of how much water was absorbed by measuring the water before and after dunking. :pok:

                                                                      Sounds like you have yourself a couple good experiments of your own to conduct.

                                                                      Merit Badges
                                                                      The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • 4everYoung Offline
                                                                        4everYoung
                                                                        Posts: 692
                                                                        4everYoung Offline
                                                                        4everYoung
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #149 Quote Reply

                                                                          Here's more of an impromptu test for you with some numbers for you.

                                                                          My son is 1 and he's battling his first cold. The little fella has been running a temp today. As normal it goes up at night. Well he was very uncomfortable so I checked his temp. It was 101.6*F.
                                                                          We normally run a bath and cool them that way. But i figured I'd let him help me test my theory.

                                                                          So I wetted the wool buff and laid it in his head. The buff was wrung out very well so it was just damp.
                                                                          After being in his head for 8minutes
                                                                          His temp has dropped to 99.3F
                                                                          A 2.3
                                                                          F drop in 8min is pretty quick.
                                                                          Clearly the wet wool did not insulate while wet. If it had the temp would have remained the same or increased.

                                                                          Now before you accuse me of bad parenting by testing theories on my kids. I knew before hand it would work. As we use damp clothes on their heads to help when fever strikes.
                                                                          I just found it more compelling to have these numbers show what science tells us happens.

                                                                          Here's the poor lil fella.

                                                                          Merit Badges
                                                                          The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • MadPlumbarian Offline
                                                                            MadPlumbarian
                                                                            Posts: 38,623
                                                                            MadPlumbarian Offline
                                                                            MadPlumbarian
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #150 Quote Reply

                                                                              Awww, pour little fella, feel better! :tu:
                                                                              JR

                                                                              Merit Badges
                                                                              Mod User Scale Changer Photographer Camping Flashlight Outdoor Cook Scaler User Sporkman Paracord Hacker Fire Making Duct Tape Time Lord Level 3 ALOX with Scissors Hook User Carabiner User SAKMC Titanium MTo Store User Zip Tie User MTO Tool Chili Award Farmer X Challenge Advanced Modder
                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • 4everYoung Offline
                                                                                4everYoung
                                                                                Posts: 692
                                                                                4everYoung Offline
                                                                                4everYoung
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #151 Quote Reply

                                                                                  @MadPlumbarian said:
                                                                                  Awww, pour little fella, feel better! :tu:
                                                                                  JR

                                                                                  Thanks

                                                                                  Merit Badges
                                                                                  The Pioneer X Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge
                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 6
                                                                                  • 7
                                                                                  • 8
                                                                                  • 9
                                                                                  • 10
                                                                                  • 11
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Outdoor Section
                                                                                  3. The Outdoor and Survival Forum
                                                                                  4. Wool as an outer layer
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0