Wool as an outer layer
-
Very interesting so far mate.
I know you (probably) only have two arms, but I'd be interested in seeing this repeated with a wicking shirt vs the "winner" of this current test.Well I'll see what I can make happen. It would be the wool vs synthetic. Once the wool dries I'll plan for that one.

-
OK what about the amount of water absorbed by wool Vs cotton garments after say an hour of drizzle?
With your experiment I would like to have seen a measure of how much water was absorbed by measuring the water before and after dunking.
-
@Syncop8r said:
OK what about the amount of water absorbed by wool Vs cotton garments after say an hour of drizzle?
With your experiment I would like to have seen a measure of how much water was absorbed by measuring the water before and after dunking.
Sounds like you have yourself a couple good experiments of your own to conduct.
-
Here's more of an impromptu test for you with some numbers for you.
My son is 1 and he's battling his first cold. The little fella has been running a temp today. As normal it goes up at night. Well he was very uncomfortable so I checked his temp. It was 101.6*F.
We normally run a bath and cool them that way. But i figured I'd let him help me test my theory.So I wetted the wool buff and laid it in his head. The buff was wrung out very well so it was just damp.
After being in his head for 8minutes
His temp has dropped to 99.3F
A 2.3F drop in 8min is pretty quick.
Clearly the wet wool did not insulate while wet. If it had the temp would have remained the same or increased.Now before you accuse me of bad parenting by testing theories on my kids. I knew before hand it would work. As we use damp clothes on their heads to help when fever strikes.
I just found it more compelling to have these numbers show what science tells us happens.Here's the poor lil fella.

-
Awww, pour little fella, feel better!

JR -
@MadPlumbarian said:
Awww, pour little fella, feel better!
JRThanks
-
Awww, pour little fella, feel better!

JRThanks
Wife went :-\ and said children’s Morten and then Tylenol..
JR -
@4everYoung said:
My son is 1 and he's battling his first cold. The little fella has been running a temp today. As normal it goes up at night. Well he was very uncomfortable so I checked his temp. It was 101.6*F.
We normally run a bath and cool them that way. But i figured I'd let him help me test my theory.I hope he gets better soon.
Some would argue that a fever is the body's way of fighting off illness and is often better left untreated (within reason). Not me though, I'm tired of arguing! -
Awww, pour little fella, feel better!

JRThanks
Wife went :-\ and said children’s Morten and then Tylenol..
JRYea my wife picked up some meds for him. Got him some meds and put him to bed. Will see how long he sleeps...
My son is 1 and he's battling his first cold. The little fella has been running a temp today. As normal it goes up at night. Well he was very uncomfortable so I checked his temp. It was 101.6*F.
We normally run a bath and cool them that way. But i figured I'd let him help me test my theory.I hope he gets better soon.
Some would argue that a fever is the body's way of fighting off illness and is often better left untreated (within reason). Not me though, I'm tired of arguing!I used to never worry about a fever. However when my daughter turned a year old, she contracted a virus and would run a fever. We tried the methods of cool baths, alternating Tylenol/Motrin and cool wraps. However he fever spiked rapidly and she had a febrile seizure. One minute she was watching a cartoon and the next she was non responsive and seizing. Short version, it took her about 6hrs to be able to talk or act herself. It was the scariest moment of my life because I didn't know anything about what was happening.
After going thru it, turns out to be very normal at that age. She's been fine since, but we don't play with fevers anymore. -
Poor little guy. He should get a SAK for helping out with your experiments at such a young age.
Here a lot of people stick to traditional remedies which oddly work. A gauze dampened with rakija put on the chest, ankles and or wrists. Not sure how the rest of the world would react to treating a small child with alcohol soaked wraps
-
Poor wee chap. :-\ I hope he's feeling better soon.
-
Awww, pour little fella, feel better!

JRThanks
Wife went :-\ and said children’s Morten and then Tylenol..
JRYea my wife picked up some meds for him. Got him some meds and put him to bed. Will see how long he sleeps...
Hope he feels better, please let us know!
JR -
The things I do for you lot. ::) So I decided to wear one of my wool coats out in a pretty heavy rain this morning while walking the dog It was raining pretty hard for periods and only lightened up at times and I was out for about 45 minutes and in that time it absorbed quite a bit of water but was still showing the new spots at the end of the walk, showing it wasn't saturated.
I was very pleasantly surprised to find the inside felt completely dry to the touch. My jeans on the other hand were soaked though and very unpleasant.
After getting home I hung it up in a unheated room (about 17degC) and checked again about two hours later and the outside was mostly dry. However the inside now feels, very slightly, damp.
My feelings about this are; I was pretty pleased with how it preformed TBH, it really was raining hard and I didn't get wet the whole time I was out. In fact I would easily put this performance on par with a decent "soft shell" outer. I do think we need to be thinking as much about construction and weave as much as material. However, and I've said this more than a few times already, I'd not want to rely on this unless I knew I would be able to dry it out at some point.
-
your sacrifice is admirable
-
Austrian Dachstein mittens are absolutely amazing
They are 100% wool and preshrunk.
I have worn them in the depth of Scottish Winters in complete white out conditions.
The outside gets caked in snow - But they are still 100% dry inside and your hands are as warm as toastI have also used them to 'rescue' friends hands that have poor circulation - after a few minutes in the gloves their hands warm up and circulation returns.
You can hold an ice axe in them - But they are not good if you need your fingers - eg if you are climbing
Although I think they may do a glove versionNot read the whole of this thread - But I would not use wool as an outer layer for my body - Maybe in completly dry conditions - Although I'd worry about the windchill
-
Some good info in this thread. I tend to go with the philosophy, "Do You". If wool works for what you do then go for it. If you require something water proof then theres certainly better options. When it comes to staying dry, I like to error on the side of DRY. I'm not looking for good enough or it can get wet and I'll be warm type clothing. I have wool and appreciate the material very much. Lots of great properties with regard to wool clothing. I also have synthetics that are great. When I camp in California mountain winter I choose a combination of materials. I am not limited nor limit myself when it comes to wind, rain, sweating, or how my clothing reacts to any such conditions. I go with cotton Ts then a layer of merino then a heavier layer if needed of wool of a less density and finally a wind proof layer. I've camped in 27F with not as much as a bother as to cold. Conditions were dry but I have been out in rain. A nice waterproof outer shell is how I roll. I am not going to get wet period. Pants however are typically jeans but I do have a layer that will go on top but they dont breath so great. Thats my next purchase down the road. I don't live in a rainy part of the world so I can get away with wool as an outer layer with little worries to it getting wet. I wear leather in out winter with a light merino layer under and stay quite toasty.
-
@Huntsman said:
Austrian Dachstein mittens are absolutely amazingThey are 100% wool and preshrunk.
I have worn them in the depth of Scottish Winters in complete white out conditions.
The outside gets caked in snow - But they are still 100% dry inside and your hands are as warm as toastI have also used them to 'rescue' friends hands that have poor circulation - after a few minutes in the gloves their hands warm up and circulation returns.
You can hold an ice axe in them - But they are not good if you need your fingers - eg if you are climbing
Although I think they may do a glove versionNot read the whole of this thread - But I would not use wool as an outer layer for my body - Maybe in completly dry conditions - Although I'd worry about the windchill
As someone who has poor circulation in my fingers really love my Dachstein mitts. :D As you say they are fantastic in the snow but, without wanting to sound like a broken record, I wouldn't want to wear them soaking wet. :)
-
This thread as gotten me thinking about staying dry and I realise that I, like most of us, normally assume that our Gore-tex jackets will keep us 100% dry. This isn't actually completely true as even Gore-tex (and other similar materials) will eventually "wet out" under continuous rain, leaving you no dryer than anything else. Living and hiking in Scotland I have had this happen to me more than once, but breathable fabrics are all about compromise and if you want to move and not sweat to death then that's just something you have to live with.
-
Hey Aloha
Two things you wear that are absolute 'no-nos' for me - Surprising :oIn my experience cotton as a base layer is very bad.
If it does get wet, either through sweating or precipitation, it is very uncomfortable as it does not dry out .... at all
It then gets clammy and can give you a chill - even in summer
Merino is best as a base layer for me as it keeps you wonderfully warm and is a 'wicking' material'
Synthetics are also OK, but then you have the stinky problem - especially after a few days !Then jeans :( ...
Which are even worse than a cotton Ts if they get wet. Are impossible to dry out and also shrink
The thick material is also not so comfortable/stretchable if you are moving around a lot!!I guess for both, if you can guarantee dryness, (California :) ) then you could get away with it ???
But who does not sweat when you are exerting yourself - Or even if it is very hot!!
And if you are carrying a pack your back is guaranteed to get wet - HmmmI have been advised not to wear either of these fabrics by outdoor instructors etc
Ah well - sounds like they work for you.@ Gareth - yes My Dachsteins are definitely for snow/Winter conditions - And would be too warm for summer - even high up.
I think I may have worn them in wet conditions and they still work/stay dry - But can't quite remember - It's been a while :( -
@Huntsman, I know the adage you sweat you die, or something like that. For hiking I'll use a Dry Fit base followed by merino in winter and whatever else is appropriate. For pants I don't use jeans but its still blend with cotton. They are 65/35 ripstop/cotton. I tend to be ok in these but yes a nice pant for hiking would be great. For around camp I find myself ok with cotton t and jeans along with the merino layer on top. I failed to mention I do have a synthetic layer under jeans they are Dry Fit long pants. I am not a terribly sweaty person even on hot days hiking. I run Dry Fit Ts when hiking on those hot days which is nice for me. I have some older synthetics that are Dry Fit type material.
I will say tho in our weather (75-80F) most days and 60s nights I can get away with quite a lot. "Winters" in Cali are a little cooler but again I can get away with a lot. In the mountains it does get cooler during winter with some snow. I tend to camp in those months and when I leave outside of camp ( hike/explore ) I try to omit as much cotton as I can. Again my pants are a blend but so far they are ok. With the long Dry Fit pants I find myself ok. Wool socks help and keeping my core warm does too.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login