84mm SAK love
-
@m47mu74nt said:
I do think this Elinox Gourmet will be my new signature for a while :)Nice!

-
Salesman and Huntsman small otw

-
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus..jpg)
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

Got an Evogrip 18 last saturday which has alot of tools in common with your Golferjack here. Even the size is quite close.Edit: not that much in common... just scissors and saw in a -91mm platform...
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

Got an Evogrip 18 last saturday which has alot of tools in common with your Golferjack here. Even the size is quite close.Edit: not that much in common... just scissors and saw in a -91mm platform...
has to be something with the size. Even when there was the Wenger version of the Waiter with Vic tools they still used the 84mm blade and combo tool.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I somehow find it hard to believe Vic's reason, today, for not bringing back the 84mm scissors to be the broken machine excuse... ??? If every part is made from the specific stamping mold and if the machines are multitasking (one machine makes different tools) it would just be tha case to create a new stamping mold for the scissors and corresponding back spring...

I really thing that the case here is: they just don't care, or want to bother with it >:( Since they have the 85mm series with scissors, i really don't think they will ever bring back the 84mm versions.
I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Sorry for the rant, but that's just my honest opinion these days
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I somehow find it hard to believe Vic's reason, today, for not bringing back the 84mm scissors to be the broken machine excuse... ??? If every part is made from the specific stamping mold and if the machines are multitasking (one machine makes different tools) it would just be tha case to create a new stamping mold for the scissors and corresponding back spring...

I really thing that the case here is: they just don't care, or want to bother with it >:( Since they have the 85mm series with scissors, i really don't think they will ever bring back the 84mm versions.
I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Sorry for the rant, but that's just my honest opinion these days
Don't feel sorry.
I think lot's of people think the same way. -
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much ** more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes**at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Don't want to hate, and I know a LOT of people like these but I feel the same way. It's gotta be a helluva a lot cheaper to slap different scales on there than make/reproduce older modes.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much ** more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes**at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Don't want to hate, and I know a LOT of people like these but I feel the same way. It's gotta be a helluva a lot cheaper to slap different scales on there than make/reproduce older modes.
Totally agree, why should they invest more money in making another 84mm scissors and spring stamping mold, or even try and adapt 85mm scissors to the 84mm line to sell at standard prices when they can spend a hell of lot less on making fancy scales and cool boxes for standard existing models, slap them on, and sell them for premium prices...?
Financially for a corporation, it makes perfect sense. Utility wise for a user (like me) it makes none

-
Sportsman. Bliss. But I used the Wenger to slice the tomatoes.

-
@Fast Bill said:
@El Corkscrew said:
@Fast Bill said:
Sportsman. Bliss. But I used the Wenger to slice the tomatoes.

Chevy the Golfjack again today

Nice one Dan

A little green Dane today

Love the green Cadet! The Pioneer X was supposed to be my one and only Alox model but I came down with Alox fever. :)
I didn't warm to the Cadet right away but after purchasing a silver model, it grew on me. I have all available colors now including orchid.

Jim
-
@Fast Bill said:
@El Corkscrew said:
@Fast Bill said:
Sportsman. Bliss. But I used the Wenger to slice the tomatoes.

Chevy the Golfjack again today

Nice one Dan

A little green Dane today

Love the green Cadet! The Pioneer X was supposed to be my one and only Alox model but I came down with Alox fever. :)
I didn't warm to the Cadet right away but after purchasing a silver model, it grew on me. I have all available colors now including orchid.

Jim
Kind of the same story with me but I have been able to show some self control and have limited myself to a silver one. Soldiers on the other hand... Let's just say I have more than a couple decades' worth. -
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I somehow find it hard to believe Vic's reason, today, for not bringing back the 84mm scissors to be the broken machine excuse... ??? If every part is made from the specific stamping mold and if the machines are multitasking (one machine makes different tools) it would just be tha case to create a new stamping mold for the scissors and corresponding back spring...

I really thing that the case here is: they just don't care, or want to bother with it >:( Since they have the 85mm series with scissors, i really don't think they will ever bring back the 84mm versions.
I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Sorry for the rant, but that's just my honest opinion these days
If the sales justified it before the tools crapped out, they would have replaced them. To resurrect them, they would have to replace the stamps and dies for the fixed scissor arm, movable arm, backspring, leaf spring, plus jigs and fixtures for drilling the holes, peening the scissor pivot etc etc etc. That level of investment needs the confidence that the sales demand will be there for several tens of thousands of units. A few nostalgic members of an internet forum aren't going to tip the balance :D There's one way to get the scissors back, and that's to place an order for 50,000 units. ;)
Aside from this, their cost management approach seems very much to be minimising inventory these days. An example of this would be the Alox Solo blade. They now use a standard Pioneer blade, which sits off center in the handles due to the asymmetrical grind (NOT crinking). The Alox Solo stamps/dies/coining tools obviously crapped out at some point, and the sales of the Solo's aren't worth reinvesting in dedicated tooling - or even running a few coils of steel through the machine while the tooling is set up, and putting a decades blade blanks into stock for a relatively slow moving item. Even if they had the tooling in good condition, it probably wouldn't be worth the down time of switching the tooling over just to run off 500 knife blanks. The down time / change over time may well cost more than the stamping/coining time, thus doubling (or more) the production cost in terms of rate/hour and appropriation of overheads.
Due to the mass production and efficiency models they operate on, and which keep their knives so affordable, any new development/releases have got to be costed out in terms of many tens of thousands of units. If they don't think they are going to sell them in those quantities, they aren't going to make them - simple as that. Sorry guys. Wenger tried doing smaller batch runs of speSmurfpillst items, but we all know how that story ended - and so do the Elsener family

Just my personal perspective

-
@50ft-trad said:
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I somehow find it hard to believe Vic's reason, today, for not bringing back the 84mm scissors to be the broken machine excuse... ??? If every part is made from the specific stamping mold and if the machines are multitasking (one machine makes different tools) it would just be tha case to create a new stamping mold for the scissors and corresponding back spring...

I really thing that the case here is: they just don't care, or want to bother with it >:( Since they have the 85mm series with scissors, i really don't think they will ever bring back the 84mm versions.
I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Sorry for the rant, but that's just my honest opinion these days
If the sales justified it before the tools crapped out, they would have replaced them. To resurrect them, they would have to replace the stamps and dies for the fixed scissor arm, movable arm, backspring, leaf spring, plus jigs and fixtures for drilling the holes, peening the scissor pivot etc etc etc. That level of investment needs the confidence that the sales demand will be there for several tens of thousands of units. A few nostalgic members of an internet forum aren't going to tip the balance :D There's one way to get the scissors back, and that's to place an order for 50,000 units. ;)
Aside from this, their cost management approach seems very much to be minimising inventory these days. An example of this would be the Alox Solo blade. They now use a standard Pioneer blade, which sits off center in the handles due to the asymmetrical grind (NOT crinking). The Alox Solo stamps/dies/coining tools obviously crapped out at some point, and the sales of the Solo's aren't worth reinvesting in dedicated tooling - or even running a few coils of steel through the machine while the tooling is set up, and putting a decades blade blanks into stock for a relatively slow moving item. Even if they had the tooling in good condition, it probably wouldn't be worth the down time of switching the tooling over just to run off 500 knife blanks. The down time / change over time may well cost more than the stamping/coining time, thus doubling (or more) the production cost in terms of rate/hour and appropriation of overheads.
Due to the mass production and efficiency models they operate on, and which keep their knives so affordable, any new development/releases have got to be costed out in terms of many tens of thousands of units. If they don't think they are going to sell them in those quantities, they aren't going to make them - simple as that. Sorry guys. Wenger tried doing smaller batch runs of speSmurfpillst items, but we all know how that story ended - and so do the Elsener family

Just my personal perspective

To expand on this ...
If we assume stamping and coining of a blade blank on an automated run takes 2.5 seconds (which I don't think is unreasonable), every half hour of down time, switching dies over, costs the same time / share of overheads as the production of 720 blade blanks. Plus, on top of that, there's the labour involvement of both the toolsetter, and the guy retreiving the new tools from the stores, and returning the previous ones, compared with the automated stamping where the operators can walk away and work on another machine. It's far more cost effective to run through several thousands of components in one set, as and when bin stock needs replenishing.
I've always worked in lower volume, more speSmurfpillsed and significantly heavier component production, but I have been on tooling changeovers on heavy machinery which have taken two men (me and one other) between seven and eight hours to tackle up and the same again to tackle down at the end of the run. That's viable if you have a two week production run to do (or in our case, a batch of 25 components that take three or four hours each), but if it's just a one hour job - forget it. While my experience is not directly relevant to Vic's processing due to the differences in scale, I do have first hand experience of running production facilities where set up / change over times can make or break your entire company's profits for the month, subject to the batch quantities involved in each order / production run.
-
Good inputs Al

-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=El Corkscrew link=topic=27753.msg1559160#msg1559160 date=1506352430]
I'm in love.
84mm Golfjack recently modified by our brother, Magentus.That's neat!
I keep wondering though, it's rumoured that Vic no longer produces 84mm scissors because the equipment to build them broke and was to expensive to replace.
Yet Wenger knives are 85mm and still contain scissors...
Vic owns the Wenger machinery...
85mm scissors for 84mm SAKs won't be that hard to fit, would it?

I somehow find it hard to believe Vic's reason, today, for not bringing back the 84mm scissors to be the broken machine excuse... ??? If every part is made from the specific stamping mold and if the machines are multitasking (one machine makes different tools) it would just be tha case to create a new stamping mold for the scissors and corresponding back spring...

I really thing that the case here is: they just don't care, or want to bother with it >:( Since they have the 85mm series with scissors, i really don't think they will ever bring back the 84mm versions.
I don't want to be grouchy here, but sometimes it just feel's they are much more interested in making endless "limited editions" of standard models with fancy scales and neat boxes at ridiculous prices for collectors to buy, than in making and creating new tools or variant's for actual users and Sak enthusiasts.

Sorry for the rant, but that's just my honest opinion these days
If the sales justified it before the tools crapped out, they would have replaced them. To resurrect them, they would have to replace the stamps and dies for the fixed scissor arm, movable arm, backspring, leaf spring, plus jigs and fixtures for drilling the holes, peening the scissor pivot etc etc etc. That level of investment needs the confidence that the sales demand will be there for several tens of thousands of units. A few nostalgic members of an internet forum aren't going to tip the balance :D There's one way to get the scissors back, and that's to place an order for 50,000 units. ;)
Aside from this, their cost management approach seems very much to be minimising inventory these days. An example of this would be the Alox Solo blade. They now use a standard Pioneer blade, which sits off center in the handles due to the asymmetrical grind (NOT crinking). The Alox Solo stamps/dies/coining tools obviously crapped out at some point, and the sales of the Solo's aren't worth reinvesting in dedicated tooling - or even running a few coils of steel through the machine while the tooling is set up, and putting a decades blade blanks into stock for a relatively slow moving item. Even if they had the tooling in good condition, it probably wouldn't be worth the down time of switching the tooling over just to run off 500 knife blanks. The down time / change over time may well cost more than the stamping/coining time, thus doubling (or more) the production cost in terms of rate/hour and appropriation of overheads.
Due to the mass production and efficiency models they operate on, and which keep their knives so affordable, any new development/releases have got to be costed out in terms of many tens of thousands of units. If they don't think they are going to sell them in those quantities, they aren't going to make them - simple as that. Sorry guys. Wenger tried doing smaller batch runs of speSmurfpillst items, but we all know how that story ended - and so do the Elsener family

Just my personal perspective

To expand on this ...
If we assume stamping and coining of a blade blank on an automated run takes 2.5 seconds (which I don't think is unreasonable), every half hour of down time, switching dies over, costs the same time / share of overheads as the production of 720 blade blanks. Plus, on top of that, there's the labour involvement of both the toolsetter, and the guy retreiving the new tools from the stores, and returning the previous ones, compared with the automated stamping where the operators can walk away and work on another machine. It's far more cost effective to run through several thousands of components in one set, as and when bin stock needs replenishing.
I've always worked in lower volume, more speSmurfpillsed and significantly heavier component production, but I have been on tooling changeovers on heavy machinery which have taken two men (me and one other) between seven and eight hours to tackle up and the same again to tackle down at the end of the run. That's viable if you have a two week production run to do (or in our case, a batch of 25 components that take three or four hours each), but if it's just a one hour job - forget it. While my experience is not directly relevant to Vic's processing due to the differences in scale, I do have first hand experience of running production facilities where set up / change over times can make or break your entire company's profits for the month, subject to the batch quantities involved in each order / production run.
[/quote]Thanks for the detailed and knowledgeable input on the matter mate

I completely understand all your point's and agree with them. I really have no proper perspective on how much investment and labor it would take to bring back the 84mm scissors again, but for example the 84mm Walker (former Lumberjack), i don't know if they still had the old stamps around for the 84mm saw assembly or if they bult new ones. That had to toke some investment, so why go with the wood saw? Why not the 84mm small Climber instead? The Climber is probably one of their best selling models, so why would an 2 layer 84mm sak with a saw be considered more viable vs an 84mm of their best selling model in a more pocketable size? Or even still for 2 layers why not the 84mm Golfer?
I just don't understand why they would consider an 84mm saw more usefull than an 84mm scissors, since they brought back the 84mm saw .... :-
And given the fact people who carry 84mm models are more likely to use them in an urban/suburban environment, where scissors makes more sense.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
it's like a mini version of my super tinker other than the file on the Phillips :ahhh
.jpg)
