Wool as an outer layer
-
Ok can someone enlighten me without me having to read everything, I mean I’d love one of those old heavy military wool blanket sweaters that supposedly are perfect for all winter long in subfreezing weather and winds, yet there like $300?
JR -
@MadPlumbarian said:
Ok can someone enlighten me without me having to read everything, I mean I’d love one of those old heavy military wool blanket sweaters that supposedly are perfect for all winter long in subfreezing weather and winds, yet there like $300?
JRWool is amazing. Wool isnt the best for prolonged wet weather IMO. Wool is great for any one of three layers, base, mid, or outer.
-
@Syncop8r said:
Probably most of this discussion belongs in a thread called "Wool/cotton/synthetic as an inner layer".Well it is natural to look at all components of clothing since they do effect each other. Just think about having a wet t-shirt on you that isn't drying out quickly. No matter your outer shell, wind can sometimes sneak up under and then it is not a very pleasant experience.
For instance I've recently seen arguments for a one jacket that is both a rain shell and a wind blocking item and for dedicated items in both respect. And the mindset of people didn't differ all that much since both sides were presented by UL hikers, more traditional backpackers (those not counting grams or oz) and very sedentary instructors (survival/bushcraft/what ever name they want to use these days) that drive up to a location and spend there several days without walking around beyond the basic needs
-
The things I do for you lot. ::) So I decided to wear one of my wool coats out in a pretty heavy rain this morning while walking the dog It was raining pretty hard for periods and only lightened up at times and I was out for about 45 minutes and in that time it absorbed quite a bit of water but was still showing the new spots at the end of the walk, showing it wasn't saturated.
I was very pleasantly surprised to find the inside felt completely dry to the touch. My jeans on the other hand were soaked though and very unpleasant.
After getting home I hung it up in a unheated room (about 17degC) and checked again about two hours later and the outside was mostly dry. However the inside now feels, very slightly, damp.
My feelings about this are; I was pretty pleased with how it preformed TBH, it really was raining hard and I didn't get wet the whole time I was out. In fact I would easily put this performance on par with a decent "soft shell" outer. I do think we need to be thinking as much about construction and weave as much as material. However, and I've said this more than a few times already, I'd not want to rely on this unless I knew I would be able to dry it out at some point.
I think there is an important distinction to be made here. There seems to be two almost entirely different types of garment being compared here. One being your coat here, It looks very much like my Austrian Loden and I guess that's what you have tere too, and things like tweed.
The second is the much less dense wool, often merino, that's used in things like underlayers.
These seem to work very different and it seems to me like which one you think of when talking about haswool might explain how well you expect it to work against rain. Generally here or seems like the people who doubt wool the most talk about the lighter merino garments and the people, me included, who are more on board with the idea are referring to the denser tweeds and similar.
Not so sure I agree. Merino is a breed of sheep that produce some of the finest quality and particularly prized wool not necessarily a type of clothing. The wool however is graded and not all Merino sheep produce clothing quality wool. What I am referring to personally is the wool specifically produced and graded for clothing as it has those prized qualities. Like I've said earlier, I dont live in a rainy environment so for me any such wool would do fine however I dont see myself using wool as an outer layer be it Merino or another type wool. Yes it has wonderful properties and yes its pretty fabulous in terms of how it performs. To me however its a mid layer or base layer for those wonderful and fabulous properties. Would I choose Merino for a cold day? Yes no question. For a windy day? Without hesitation. For a snowy day? Well it would have to snow in SoCal first but yes not a problem. Rainy? No. However looking at the link I provided I may have a change of heart. I am always open to learn and learn I am.
It was interesting to see Gareth coat and how it handled the rain. ** What concerns me is not being able to get it dry at whatever level of "wet". ** If one was out say, 3 days then what? Seems like a bad 2 days once the article of clothing is wet. Can it survive better than say Cotton? I'd most certainly agree yes. So the question to me is less about can it survive, but how long and then what?
In the days before we had any options I suspect the answer was to make sure you had somewhere dry every night and a fire to dry stuff out next too. Of course soldiers have managed to survive with woollen clothing for hundreds of year in all weathers. Though campaigning in winter was always seen as a bad idea, just ask Napoleon. For all the horrors of WW1 millions of soldiers survived for weeks st a time in the rain and the mud without it being an automatic death sentence.
-
Can't argue with you at all Gareth. I guess seeing this from the perspective of why things clothing has changed. Yes to everything you've mentioned. I see current evolution of materials coming as a result of good is not good enough. Wool in particular as addressed in the link has undergone changes. The wool product in the link seems to have addressed issues wool had/has. It seems they have a wind and water repellency dialed in. As a result of this discussion I am learning more about newer wool products and technologies applied.
I want to be clear wool is amazing I just never thought of wool as an outer layer in wet conditions. I have several lovely pieces that are not ideal for wet weather. I also don't live in an area that sees much rain. The link I shared should be very clear that wool is a must for anyone looking for a truly amazing performance material. The industry has clearly been making some terrific strides in wools capabilities. I am not 100% convinced wool is the best choice for prolonged wet weather. This was not the OP question but as in any good conversation we've touched on many ( to me ) relevant side topics and discussions. There is lots to learn and this thread has been great for that.
-
I’ve always wanted one of those old school packing coats with the sheeps collar, but in the long run would probably be better off with a hood, but after learning about these military wool blanket pull overs and how warm they are I’ve really been interested, but I’ve never liked pull overs, I kinda always liked a button or zipper down, but again, the pricing is through the roof, I guess I’d have to make my own, I did find these but they no longer sell them, at the same time they don’t zipper or button, just use a belt, but that’s easy, to throw some buttons on,,
JR

-
MadP, there has to be someone who has free wool blanket coat patterns online. I'm sure you can make one for the price of the blanket, zippers, thread, time, for much cheaper than $300. Go go it.
-
@Aloha007 said:
MadP, there has to be someone who has free wool blanket coat patterns online. I'm sure you can make one for the price of the blanket, zippers, thread, time, for much cheaper than $300. Go go it.True, but I ain’t that good, knowing my luck it would probably end up not fitting me and look wacky.
JR -
That lined one looks interesting. I also like the short cape on the shoulders. Other than the possibility of design though, I'm not quite sure what these are supposed to do better than a good surplus military coat would do just as well, if not better.

-
An interesting point has been touched on here. These days, we fixate upon getting the kit to suit our routine (first world problem), whereas in the old days, you adapted the routine to suit the kit available. We survived a good few millennia without synthetic materials, but it is almost deemed defeatist these days to have to compromise your routine in any way to accommodate kit limitations ....

-
@50ft-trad said:
An interesting point has been touched on here. These days, we fixate upon getting the kit to suit our routine (first world problem), whereas in the old days, you adapted the routine to suit the kit available. We survived a good few millennia without synthetic materials, but it is almost deemed defeatist these days to have to compromise your routine in any way to accommodate kit limitations ....
That's an excellent way of thinking about it I'd say.

-
@styx said:
I've been seeing a bit of uprise in the line of thought that wool is a great outer layer for hiking, backpacking and other outdoor activities even in rain, snow and sleet.While I understand that wet wool still keeps it's insulation value, tests have shown that it still acts like a wet piece of clothing when it comes to windchill. And I can personally attest to that.
So am I missing something with this wool outer craze?Yes, you're missing something...and it's in your own post. wool as an OUTER layer.
If it's your outer player then it's not directly against your skin. If your middle layer is windproof, it will block the windchill.
I lived in Alaska for 32 years and wore either a Filson Mackinaw Cruiser or a Filson Double Mackinaw Cruiser (pictured) for a couple decades worth of winters without a problem. Both are virgin wool.


I still have my Double mackie even though I live in Texas now. It's just too nice a coat to part with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@50ft-trad said:
Seems to work for sheep


[emoji14]
The fiber we know as wool that comes from sheep is made up of amino acids, which are the building blocks of protein. As wool grows on a sheep, it gets keratinized, which simply means it hardens. Other examples of keratinized proteins are fingernails and hair.
Wool fibers on a sheep have flat, overlapping scales that always point away from the sheep's body. When these wool fibers get processed and made into clothing, however, the fibers are stretched out. The orientation of the scales gets mixed up and they can be pointing in any random direction.
As any shepherd will tell you, sheep do just fine in the rain and don't shrink like a wool sweater. This is because their wool fibers have scales that are all pointing in the same direction.
When they get wet, they can slide back into position without getting caught or locked into place. No felting takes place on sheep in the rain, so they don't shrink!
Sheep also produce a natural oily substance called lanolin. Lanolin covers the wool fibers of their coats, acting as a natural lubricant that prevents fibers from locking together. Lanolin also repels water, which makes sheep somewhat waterproof when they're out in the rain. This is good for sheep, since it prevents their wool from getting soaked and waterlogged, which would be very uncomfortable since they have so much wool!
Hmm...except that wool is curly so the orientation of each fiber changes over its length. So the overlapping scales, which are also found on human hair, don't always point away from the animal's body.
Lanolin is the secret--which you had mentioned. It's what gives wool it's water resistance.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I've been seeing a bit of uprise in the line of thought that wool is a great outer layer for hiking, backpacking and other outdoor activities even in rain, snow and sleet.
While I understand that wet wool still keeps it's insulation value, tests have shown that it still acts like a wet piece of clothing when it comes to windchill. And I can personally attest to that.
So am I missing something with this wool outer craze?Yes, you're missing something...and it's in your own post. wool as an OUTER layer.
If it's your outer player then it's not directly against your skin. If your middle layer is windproof, it will block the windchill.
I lived in Alaska for 32 years and wore either a Filson Mackinaw Cruiser or a Filson Double Mackinaw Cruiser (pictured) for a couple decades worth of winters without a problem. Both are virgin wool.


I still have my Double mackie even though I live in Texas now. It's just too nice a coat to part with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
so basically a windproof mid layer under the wool outer. why does that sound reversed somehow?
-
I've been seeing a bit of uprise in the line of thought that wool is a great outer layer for hiking, backpacking and other outdoor activities even in rain, snow and sleet.
While I understand that wet wool still keeps it's insulation value, tests have shown that it still acts like a wet piece of clothing when it comes to windchill. And I can personally attest to that.
So am I missing something with this wool outer craze?Yes, you're missing something...and it's in your own post. wool as an OUTER layer.
If it's your outer player then it's not directly against your skin. If your middle layer is windproof, it will block the windchill.
I lived in Alaska for 32 years and wore either a Filson Mackinaw Cruiser or a Filson Double Mackinaw Cruiser (pictured) for a couple decades worth of winters without a problem. Both are virgin wool.


I still have my Double mackie even though I live in Texas now. It's just too nice a coat to part with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Those look like fantastic coats.

-
I've been seeing a bit of uprise in the line of thought that wool is a great outer layer for hiking, backpacking and other outdoor activities even in rain, snow and sleet.
While I understand that wet wool still keeps it's insulation value, tests have shown that it still acts like a wet piece of clothing when it comes to windchill. And I can personally attest to that.
So am I missing something with this wool outer craze?Yes, you're missing something...and it's in your own post. wool as an OUTER layer.
If it's your outer player then it's not directly against your skin. If your middle layer is windproof, it will block the windchill.
I lived in Alaska for 32 years and wore either a Filson Mackinaw Cruiser or a Filson Double Mackinaw Cruiser (pictured) for a couple decades worth of winters without a problem. Both are virgin wool.


I still have my Double mackie even though I live in Texas now. It's just too nice a coat to part with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
so basically a windproof mid layer under the wool outer. why does that sound reversed somehow?
Maybe you're envisioning a thin wool jacket? The Filson coats I wore were made of 24oz. and 26oz. virgin wool. They were definitely made to be your outer layer. You'd have a hard time fitting something over one. You might be able fit a very oversized raincoat or poncho over one, I suppose.
Wool is durable and retains its thermal properties even when damp so if your under layer blocks the wind from your skin, a heavy wool coat will still keep you warm. At least in my experience.
The downside, in my experience, is that wool can be rather heavy; whereas, Gortex isn't. You can imagine a coat made of 24oz. per square yard fabric isn't lightweight.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I love them! They look stylish, have pockets for days, and they're warm. They're virgin wool so they can feel a little scratchy. Below about 20 degrees F, you might need to start adding layers under it.
https://www.filson.comSent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I've been seeing a bit of uprise in the line of thought that wool is a great outer layer for hiking, backpacking and other outdoor activities even in rain, snow and sleet.
While I understand that wet wool still keeps it's insulation value, tests have shown that it still acts like a wet piece of clothing when it comes to windchill. And I can personally attest to that.
So am I missing something with this wool outer craze?Yes, you're missing something...and it's in your own post. wool as an OUTER layer.
If it's your outer player then it's not directly against your skin. If your middle layer is windproof, it will block the windchill.
I lived in Alaska for 32 years and wore either a Filson Mackinaw Cruiser or a Filson Double Mackinaw Cruiser (pictured) for a couple decades worth of winters without a problem. Both are virgin wool.


I still have my Double mackie even though I live in Texas now. It's just too nice a coat to part with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
so basically a windproof mid layer under the wool outer. why does that sound reversed somehow?
Maybe you're envisioning a thin wool jacket? The Filson coats I wore were made of 24oz. and 26oz. virgin wool. They were definitely made to be your outer layer. You'd have a hard time fitting something over one. You might be able fit a very oversized raincoat or poncho over one, I suppose.
Wool is durable and retains its thermal properties even when damp so if your under layer blocks the wind from your skin, a heavy wool coat will still keep you warm. At least in my experience.
The downside, in my experience, is that wool can be rather heavy; whereas, Gortex isn't. You can imagine a coat made of 24oz. per square yard fabric isn't lightweight.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Could be that I'm also thinking about something more loosely woven.
So how did you layer the things under it? For some reason a windproof layer to me is a bright colored windshirt and that is tripping me up very much -
I've heard of those Filson jackets. Really great looking and from your account sounds like a wonderful article of clothing.
-
@50ft-trad said:
An interesting point has been touched on here. These days, we fixate upon getting the kit to suit our routine (first world problem), whereas in the old days, you adapted the routine to suit the kit available. We survived a good few millennia without synthetic materials, but it is almost deemed defeatist these days to have to compromise your routine in any way to accommodate kit limitations ....
Chalk that up to how much we're bombarded by advertisements. Most magazines are nothing more than disguised press releases to get you buy the next better thing.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login