Firefly Ferro rod.
-
I have yet to experience conditions where my mini bic and tiger tim wafer firelighter combo have failed me. Extreme cold, extreme wind, extreme wet.
Been in lots of situations where, if I'd just had my ferro rod on me, it would have been insufficient or more time-consuming.
That being said, I carry (and use) both.
-
Incorporating Ferro rods as a backup to your lighter is not a bad Idea. Giving up another function however is a personal decision that should not be taken lightly.
I for one like the idea of the Firefly. Its is a cool concept that many will find usefull, but its not for me.I have already incorporated 2 mini rods in my edc. The first is on my OH Trekker, notice the middle bead. The lanyard is long enough to reach the spine of the saw to use it without removal.
The second are those cheap fire starter buckles. I'm too cheep to replace my edc watches and a new band costs half as much as a new watch. So I have braided bands on both my Timex Expedition and Casio Forester (pic).
Those more than serve my needs in the event of a Bic or Zippo failure.

-
@Noa Isumi said:
I have already incorporated 2 mini rods in my edc. The first is on my OH Trekker, notice the middle bead. The lanyard is long enough to reach the spine of the saw to use it without removal.That is a very nice lanyard! It's the first time I see a firestarter bead in a setup I like! I'm going to make one of those too.
-
@Noa Isumi said:
Incorporating Ferro rods as a backup to your lighter is not a bad Idea. Giving up another function however is a personal decision that should not be taken lightly.
I for one like the idea of the Firefly. Its is a cool concept that many will find usefull, but its not for me.I have already incorporated 2 mini rods in my edc. The first is on my OH Trekker, notice the middle bead. The lanyard is long enough to reach the spine of the saw to use it without removal.
The second are those cheap fire starter buckles. I'm too cheep to replace my edc watches and a new band costs half as much as a new watch. So I have braided bands on both my Timex Expedition and Casio Forester (pic).
Those more than serve my needs in the event of a Bic or Zippo failure.Efficient way to carry ferro rods
. -
Ive fit the smallest firesteel firesteel.com sells, into the back drawer of the Ti scales I make. Its small, but does work fine.
This idea on the surface seems ok, but...
- This is too thin to not snap easily. Much thinner than the thinnest rod Ive used, and have had that snap. This would snap after a few uses.
- The toothpick is retained in the scale not by friction but by a little riser catch on the toothpick body. As soon as that was used and no longer there how would the firesteel be retained? It would just fall out. (this is the reason I dont want to make Ti toothpics, too fiddly)
- The video of it in use if very deceptive. That is not what a firesteel looks like in use, nor creating fire. Maybe he had lighter fluid on his tinder?
On a traditional SAK, Id just look to attached some type of firesteel to the keychain ring. There are longs of small ones with various options. Google keychain firesteel.
-
- This is too thin to not snap easily. Much thinner than the thinnest rod Ive used, and have had that snap. This would snap after a few uses.
- The toothpick is retained in the scale not by friction but by a little riser catch on the toothpick body. As soon as that was used and no longer there how would the firesteel be retained? It would just fall out. (this is the reason I dont want to make Ti toothpics, too fiddly)
- The video of it in use if very deceptive. That is not what a firesteel looks like in use, nor creating fire. Maybe he had lighter fluid on his tinder?
I think you are asking the right questions. I think to prevent it from breaking you have to scrape the firesteel on the side, not the top or bottom.
That way the depth of the material is thicker. Nor will the catch be worn down as quickly.I do like the concept though, I'll be waiting for the reviews. If it's good I will order a set.
-
I've used a very small steel. 2 inches long and very thin. As you know, with each use, some of the bar is lost as you scrape it. My concern is a SAK toothpick sized steel will get whittled away in no time.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Tired_Yeti said:
I've used a very small steel. 2 inches long and very thin. As you know, with each use, some of the bar is lost as you scrape it. My concern is a SAK toothpick sized steel will get whittled away in no time.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yup. Wouldn't be so bad if you could use it from the end rather than the side, like the wheel on a lighter does. Nail file maybe?
Probably not, but I can't think of any other way to avoid thinning it out further -
I would agree it will wear down pretty fast and break or lose its grip in the slot, at the end of the day though if its for survival most of the time you would just need to light one fire anyway, certainly in my case where i'm never too far away from civilisation.
I am not knowledgeable about such things but isn't the advice to stay put and await rescue? of course there are a multitude of reasons why you sometimes cant do that and that's assuming someone is coming to rescue you but its got to be better than blindly wandering around the forest, also iirc the old timers used to carry their fire with them? be it a hot coal in a bucket or a smouldering mushroom, maybe an art we need to re learn.
I plan to get one when they are on general release depending on reviews but its not something i would use a lot, however i will go along with the old adage, its better to have it and not need it, than to need it and not have it
-
@Borg said:
I would agree it will wear down pretty fast and break or lose its grip in the slot, at the end of the day though if its for survival most of the time you would just need to light one fire anyway, certainly in my case where i'm never too far away from civilisation.
I am not knowledgeable about such things but isn't the advice to stay put and await rescue?It depends on how long you're lost. Lofty Wiseman recommends relocating after about one week (if I recall correctly) because, he says, your location will become soiled with your waste and depleted of food and maybe even water.
That said, once you start a fire, there are several techniques for transporting fire. Our ancestors used these methods and Les Stroud demonstrated one in one episode of Survivor Man (don't remember which episode, sorry). If I remember it (I'm not in a location where I can look it up right now), you can wrap embers in a wad of punk wood and moss and carry a warm, smoldering bed of coals. Stroud safely carried embers for several miles doing this without getting burned and was able to fan a fire at his new campsite.
If you have to travel at night--NOT ideal--you'd want to carry a torch anyway. Stroud demonstrated that also. Once at his new site, he simply set up his fire pit and started it with the torch.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Tired_Yeti said:
It depends on how long you're lost. Lofty Wiseman recommends relocating after about one week (if I recall correctly) because, he says, your location will become soiled with your waste and depleted of food and maybe even water.Like all absolute generalities, it's a very vague rule of thumb. But I will say that if SAR hasn't found you in a week and all you have a tin kit and a SAK, well...
-
@ironraven said:
...if SAR hasn't found you in a week and all you have a tin kit and a SAK, well...You'd better have a strong will to survive and epic survival and bushcraft skills. And you'd better keep reminding yourself that your ancestors somehow managed it with primitive tools. Our chances would be poor, but we cannot give up.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I want one or twelve...
-
@Tired_Yeti said:
You'd better have a strong will to survive and epic survival and bushcraft skills. And you'd better keep reminding yourself that your ancestors somehow managed it with primitive tools. Our chances would be poor, but we cannot give up.Yes, please note the emphasis. I'm competent, not "epic". You'd have to have lived that life style from birth, or at least spent years in intensive and immersive study. I'd also ask you to keep in mind that the archeological evidence shows that they died of old age by the time they were 40. Assuming they weren't part of the majority that died due to illness, infection, or starvation before puberty.
I'd also point out that if you are somewhere where SAR can't find you within a week, you really screwed up something or pissed off the gods if you only have an SAK and a tin kit. :P If you can follow a rough compass bearing for three days, you'd be hard pressed south of the 60th parallel to NOT find a road.
More realistically, if you have a SAK, preferably a 111 becuase every bit counts, and one of these in your PFD or on a neck lanyard, if you lose the canoe or your pack, this gets you to dawn. Stack the deck, hope you never need it.
-
You'd better have a strong will to survive and epic survival and bushcraft skills. And you'd better keep reminding yourself that your ancestors somehow managed it with primitive tools. Our chances would be poor, but we cannot give up.
Yes, please note the emphasis. I'm competent, not "epic". You'd have to have lived that life style from birth, or at least spent years in intensive and immersive study. I'd also ask you to keep in mind that the archeological evidence shows that they died of old age by the time they were 40. Assuming they weren't part of the majority that died due to illness, infection, or starvation before puberty.
I'd also point out that if you are somewhere where SAR can't find you within a week, you really screwed up something or pissed off the gods if you only have an SAK and a tin kit. :P If you can follow a rough compass bearing for three days, you'd be hard pressed south of the 60th parallel to NOT find a road.
More realistically, if you have a SAK, preferably a 111 becuase every bit counts, and one of these in your PFD or on a neck lanyard, if you lose the canoe or your pack, this gets you to dawn. Stack the deck, hope you never need it.
This kind of was my point originally, for me that Ferro rod would be a last resort ,if i was going somewhere this extreme I would have a good kit, but if I had a sak in my pocket and some how lost my entire kit I would rather have that Ferro rod over a toothpick that I could make out of a bit of wood ;)
-
I came across this pic online.
It's a SAK platform where a pipe has been built in.

I thought "replace that pipe part with a switchable firesteel and that thing would be AWESOME!"
-
@ironraven said:
I'd also point out that if you are somewhere where SAR can't find you within a week, you really screwed up something or pissed off the gods if you only have an SAK and a tin kit. [emoji14] If you can follow a rough compass bearing for three days, you'd be hard pressed south of the 60th parallel to NOT find a road.You've made a couple of references to having nothing but a SAK and a tin kit. Why would anyone knowingly venture far out with only a tin kit? Even Lofty Wiseman doesn't suggest that. I think that unless you fell off of a cloud into the middle of nowhere and survived, you'd probably be within just a few miles at the most from a road or manmade structure if you're traveling with only a SAK and a tin. The people who would do that wouldn't have the knowledge to survive anyway. Sounds like a very unlikely scenario to me.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I'd also point out that if you are somewhere where SAR can't find you within a week, you really screwed up something or pissed off the gods if you only have an SAK and a tin kit. [emoji14] If you can follow a rough compass bearing for three days, you'd be hard pressed south of the 60th parallel to NOT find a road.
You've made a couple of references to having nothing but a SAK and a tin kit. Why would anyone knowingly venture far out with only a tin kit? Even Lofty Wiseman doesn't suggest that. I think that unless you fell off of a cloud into the middle of nowhere and survived, you'd probably be within just a few miles at the most from a road or manmade structure if you're traveling with only a SAK and a tin. The people who would do that wouldn't have the knowledge to survive anyway. Sounds like a very unlikely scenario to me.
I think you're both saying that it would be silly (or you really stuffed up somewhere) if you had only those items with you out in the wilderness.

You do get the odd person going to extremes to 'test' themselves. -
@Mechanickal said:
I came across this pic online.
It's a SAK platform where a pipe has been built in.

I thought "replace that pipe part with a switchable firesteel and that thing would be AWESOME!"
I suspect that is your SAK. What are you smoking in it?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login