Time for a FIGHT
-
That is SO smurfing annoying >:( Bunch of smurfs!
I'm very pleased to hear you're going to take them on

Neil
-
que?
-
Are you implying you don't like the word, y'all?
I'm originally from the Left Coast of America and so it was foreign to me as well. However, over the last decade or so, I've come to the conclusion it is sorely missing from the standard lexicon.
Y'all is extremely handy when referring to a numerically vague, but distinct group of people in a less than all inclusive way.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Seriously, y'all are being taken over by flower hugging vegans.
Or operatives of the new world order who must first disarm the public before than can subdue it.
Along with upgrading their Black helicopters
-
Good luck Flash.
It's obvious who is right and wrong here, let's hope you can get them to see sense.
-
-
We Americans could be headed down the same path. Every year we gotta fight Sarah Brady and her merry bunch for gun rights. Knives can come soon after.
-
I sure hope not....seems wrong that we have to fight for a documented right.
-
Sorry to hear it Flash >:( Hope everything goes your way in court

-
This is exactly what I was talking about over in the UK legal thread /topic/8384 . Like I said in there, this is just happening so much now that anything even remotely "tactical" should be purchased from within the UK and Europe.
Tough break mate, I hope you get it all sorted. I don't think I have seen anyone challenge their decision so it will be interesting to see the outcome.
-
@Sean said:
That is really a shame. I rather suspect in a lot of cases it just depends who at customs is doing the checking. Spyderco is a pretty popular brand of knife. They sell them everywhere don't they?
In Canada it used to be and probably still is that if you could flick it open while holding the handle and the blade would snap out into the lock position it was considered to be a gravity knife and illegal.
What confuses me to no end is a few knives that walmart carries like the gerber gator and some of the buck units are capable of gravity opening. I remember when the gator first came out walmart stopped carrying them because of the way they were shipped from the factory (loose) but then later on they started showing up at their stores again.
Ballisongs are illegal up here in Canada as are switch blades yet you can buy blade assisted knives and spyderco type opening blades that are alot quicker opening than those "dreaded switchblades and ballisongs" are.
Technology in the knife industry is ever advancing forward like most others too bad laws aren't to support it. It looks like someone at Customs thought wow neat knife, decided to play with it and decided that they better check it out further and discovered gravity.
Well my friend, if I was the customs officer doing the check I would have tightened it up for you and included a note along with it stating what I had done with respect to the law. What a waste of material and resource to confiscate it.Sean
Yes, but....
Canadian knife law is basically a footnote to firearms laws, and is quite basic. No gravity blades (not well defined), no automatic blades (more on that in a minute) and no balisongs.
Bear in mind that I am no great lover of laws or lawmakers, but I have to say that for the most part, Canada has it right. We have no length restrictions on blades- you can legally wear a 4 foot English broadsword slung on your back in Canada, provided it isn't concealed. Concealing any blade makes it illegal. However, since Canadian law is based on mens rea or a "guilty intent" you are protected against having a fixed blade on your belt, then putting a long coat on if it's snowing. Basically, if you weren't purposely concealing it then you still haven't broken a law, even though the blade isn't visible.
However, the minute you use that blade to threaten, injure or kill someone, it becomes classified as a weapon, regardless of how "legal" it was moments earlier. The benefit here is that any instrument used to injure, kill or threaten someone is automatically classified as a weapon, whether it be a knife, broken bottle, pipe, chain etc. In short, something is only a weapon if used as a weapon and assuming it doesn't correspond to any "weapons" as defined by the Canadian Criminal Code.
On to "Automatic Knives" which actually gives me some hope that the government hasn't completely lost it. Inspired by the US laws against switchblades, which were in turn inspired by Hollywood's early gangster films, switchblades were made illegal because they scared the hell out of people. The law states that automatic blades are illegal:
"(a) a knife that has a blade that opens automatically by gravity or centrifugal force or by hand pressure applied to a button, spring or other device in or attached to the handle of the knife"
The phrase "hand pressure applied to a button, spring or other device in" is the key. Technically since there is no button or lever to activate the spring, assisted openers are not illegal, and I have somewhere a document from Canada Customs and Revenue Service that states that. Usually I send it to whomever I am buying an assisted opener from to print off and include with the knife to guard against overzealous Customs Officers.
Someone high up in CCRA actually put thought into this and realized that an assisted opening knife is no more dangerous than an X-Acto knife and that the hands holding it are the real problem, and decided to take action to not screw over the general populace.
Sorry that's so off topic... Flash, please let me know if there's anything at all I, or the various sites I represent can do to help you out. You can't let the small minded and membered bureaucrats take away the few rights we all have left, regardless of what flag you live under.
Def
-
Oh, and I'd consider contacting www.kniferights.org to see if they can offer any support. They probably can't, but they are good people to know, and besides, the site was designed and built by MondayTech, a company started by our own Esteban "Mcniac" Soler! :D In fact, it was on my recommendation and the success of both Multitool.org and SOSAKOnline that Esteban got that contract! :D
Def
-
-snip-
Def
The intend part is good, but the vagueness of gravity knife etc. still allow cop/custom to screw people if they want. A mil surplus store in ontario selling knives got busted for gravity knives even thou what they sell aren't designed to be, just that cop can flick them open (which I can do to pretty much any OH knife). Also you gotta admit the balisong, numchuck, or ninja star ban is just retarded.
-
This sounds to me like a simple case of a postal worker pocketing your Spyderco and writing it off as "illegal". What do they do with "contraband" being sent through their postal system? Is everything they find incinerated at some point? I doubt it.
Good luck in any event, nothing is worse than getting tangled up in shipping problems, especially international.
-
Yes, but....
-snip-
Def
The intend part is good, but the vagueness of gravity knife etc. still allow cop/custom to screw people if they want. A mil surplus store in ontario selling knives got busted for gravity knives even thou what they sell aren't designed to be, just that cop can flick them open (which I can do to pretty much any OH knife). Also you gotta admit the balisong, numchuck, or ninja star ban is just retarded.
Yes, but....
Given the vague description of "gravity knife" allows for a certain level of defense if you are picked up for it. If it isn't legally defined, it's open for interpretation, and interpretations can be flawed, especially when viewed under the concept of mens rea. If you didn't intend to sell "gravity knives" and can prove it, you aren't guilty. The best defense I ever saw for that was a guy went to Wal Mart on his way to the court house, bought 6 different types of knives in clam packs, opened the packs in court and passed them around to the various court officers to see if they could "flick them open" and when they all managed to do it one way or another the case was thrown out.
Balisongs I disagree with, but lets face it, the world is much better off without twits buying throwing stars. The only people out there likely to buy and carry throwing stars are also the kind of people who probably don't realize how useless the damned things are, and are surprised when their friends, family and pets all are missing eyes. Ditto for nunchucks. I studied with various weapons in my younger days, including nunchucks and they are the worst striking weapon ever developed. Even Bruce Lee admitted they were only used in his movies because they seemed mystical and the swinging motions looked great on camera. Anyone who has ever tried them in real life has learned how quickly and easily you can injure your back or kidneys, or knock yourself senseless after the other end bounces back after contact with the target. At best they are great for joint locks, come alongs and pressure points, but no one gets them for that use...
Def
-
@Corrugated said:
This sounds to me like a simple case of a postal worker pocketing your Spyderco and writing it off as "illegal". What do they do with "contraband" being sent through their postal system? Is everything they find incinerated at some point? I doubt it.Good luck in any event, nothing is worse than getting tangled up in shipping problems, especially international.
I actually don't think that happens at all. This hasn't been picked up by a postman but by Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs. Britain is a country that thrives on red tape. I'm certain that any item picked up will be "bagged and tagged" and in the fullness of time be destroyed. I may utterly disagree with their interpretation of the law but I do believe they are honestly just trying to do their job.
-
@Defender said:
The best defense I ever saw for that was a guy went to Wal Mart on his way to the court house, bought 6 different types of knives in clam packs, opened the packs in court and passed them around to the various court officers to see if they could "flick them open" and when they all managed to do it one way or another the case was thrown out.Good one, I'm keep that in mind. :D
@Defender said:
I studied with various weapons in my younger days, including nunchucks and they are the worst striking weapon ever developed.Def
Watch out people Def is a ninja, remember that next time you want to piss him off.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







