Writing an article about the Magnifying lens, can you help me out?
-
Looks like the change in the old style happened with the introduction of the SwissChamp, all 3 of my 1st gen. (1985/6) SC have the beveled frame. Took shots of my only old-old style Champion mag glass, front and back also, not sure the year, but def. pre-'85. The actual lenses appear to be the same on all.
Good info! I thought all the gray magnifiers were the same.





-
@twiliter said:
Looks like the change in the old style happened with the introduction of the SwissChamp, all 3 of my 1st gen. (1985/6) SC have the beveled frame. Took shots of my only old-old style Champion mag glass, front and back also, not sure the year, but def. pre-'85. The actual lenses appear to be the same on all.Good info! I thought all the gray magnifiers were the same.


If this is true then there can't be any SAKs out there with a Type1 magnifier and an awl with hole... Can´t wait for my Explorer to arrive and see!
Reading the document Frater_Martin provided (thanks!) I think it's confusing to speak of a type 1-4 magnifying lens. Perhaps this makes more sense: Gen1a, Gen1b, Gen 2 and Gen 3.
This also leaves room to count on if more variations are discovered. I'm going to change this is my notes.The difference in Gen1a and Gen2b has to be very subtle as the part numbers are the same :A.5630 magnifier (?) My guess is they just changed supplier or changed the production process.
Seeing the part numbers I am very curious if there is a complete parts list out there... I did a quick google search and could not find anything. I am at work however and can´t start an extensive search because I actually have to do some work

-
-
-
@twiliter said:
My Explorer is a transitional model, it has the old gray frame, but also a thinner tang (2004-5), which is appx. the same year they dropped the crossbow stamp, so some odd factory tool combinations do exist. Makes exact dating difficult sometimes. ???Your Explorer is really rocking those yellow scales!
Judging from your image it would be a Gen1b magnifying lens.
Going by the date (2004) is probably is one of the last batches with the Gen1b. You lucky man! You could have had a Gen2 if you bought it a little later! -
-
-
Hi again. Below there are two compilations combined from two Victorinox Champions as a result of special investigation. First one was made in 1983-1985, second one was made in 1986. Evidences are on the photos. These knifes are not mine, I have collected photos of them on the Internet (by the way this collection is a basis of my comparative analysis. Usually I do not have enough money/opportunities to buy every knife I wish, so I have to collect large galleries. At least they are free
).
So as we can see, on the knife made in 1983-1985 there is a lens Type 1 (Gen1a) and the knife made in 1986 there is a lens Type 2 (Gen1b). As I could find, all knifes were made before 1985(86) have Gen1a lenses (with one-side bevels) and all knifes were made after 1986 have Gen1b lenses (with both-side bevels on it). And I suppose that year of 1986 become a border between Gen1a and Gen1b lenses productions.
Any other ideas or evidences are welcomed to show here in this thread.Of course we have to remember about year divergences/shifts related to production process. I mean the situations when old tool/tools were assembled in a knife together with modern ones for several years.


-
When I get back home I'll measure mines.... ...Magnifiers.

You guys... This is getting interesting...
I called to review all my knives with magnifiers.

I'm surprised that I have only 2 translucent magnifiers. Swisschamp and Explorer.
The figures are clear.
14mm for old ones and 18mm for the translucent ones.Between all the grey ones it has turned out to be only one different.
It's a black champion which I date 1983-1984 by its 4turns fluted corkscrew, no hole in the awl, no pen and no 90° lock for the bottle opener.
I don't know I the difference is clearly visible in the pic.
I have questions about the new mags.
How do you distinguish between them?
How do you know their mag power (5x/6x)?Mines to my eyes seems to be the same variation.
Explorer:

Swisschamp:

What do you think are both the same variation??
Cheers!!
-
Good point.

When I get back home I'll measure mines.... ...Magnifiers.

You guys... This is getting interesting...
I called to review all my knives with magnifiers.

I'm surprised that I have only 2 translucent magnifiers. Swisschamp and Explorer.
The figures are clear.
14mm for old ones and 18mm for the translucent ones.Between all the grey ones it has turned out to be only one different.
It's a black champion which I date 1983-1984 by its 4turns fluted corkscrew, no hole in the awl, no pen and no 90° lock for the bottle opener.
I don't know I the difference is clearly visible in the pic.
I have questions about the new mags.
How do you distinguish between them?
How do you know their mag power (5x/6x)?Mines to my eyes seems to be the same variation.
Explorer:

Swisschamp:

What do you think are both the same variation??
Cheers!!
I was told that the latest variation is made of glass and can be rotated within the frame... not as fixed as the previous version... maybe someone can confirm this...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
-
-
-
-
-
@koke said:
...How do you distinguish between them?
How do you know their mag power (5x/6x)?...This is a very good question indeed. Unfortunately I don't have any new magnifiers to make photo's.
It would be very helpful to be able to tell the difference from photo's but that's near impossible.
There are no clearly distinguisable features to the Gen2 or Gen 3.
However...If I may be so bold to link to this image:

The plastic on the Gen2 curves around towards the hinge. As opposed to the Gen3, which curves to a straight piece towards the hinge.
Also, the Gen3 appears to have a notch on the back when closed. Comparable to the notch that is visible on the newer 90' locking bottleopeners.So, when you have them in hand it's much easier.
- The lens of the Gen3 is colder to the touch opposed to the Gen2.
- The lens of the Gen3 may rotate.
Distinguising the difference in power is very hard. Even if you work with lenses. The Gen2 has a power of 20dpt and the Gen3 a power of 24dpt.
If you have a lensmeter at hand it's far more easy. But who carries one of those around
-
Champion C 75-78
Passenger 74-78
Passenger (Alpineer)81-85?
Explore pre 85
Yeoman 9?-0?
BSAyeoman 9?-0?
Explorer 92-04?
Pikachu - same as Explorerafter measuring the glass. The only real difference i see with these is the ring in the plastic around the glass. One is flat, one has a ring and bevel. But I'm sure you knew that already

.jpg)
-
@El Corkscrew said:
...
after measuring the glass. The only real difference i see with these is the ring in the plastic around the glass. One is flat, one has a ring and bevel.For distinguising between Gen1a and Gen1b, right, that bevel is a single characteristic. On Gen1a the bevel is on one side and on Gen2b the bevel is on both sides of the lense. And if we look at Gen1a attentivelly we can see a fairy ring on plastic arround a lense on the same side as the bevel.
-
@koke said:
What a surprise!!!
Not only turns inside the frame.
Did anyone else removed the glass before???Finally I have found the link. Here it is "New Phillips / Mag glass layer found (With REAL glass Mag!)" /topic/45331
@koke said:
...
How do you distinguish between them?
How do you know their mag power (5x/6x)?Here http://redsgoodvsevilcowbarn.blogspot.com/2014/02/the-newest-victorinox-magnifier.html it is visible: a modern glass made variant is a little more poverfull than plastic one.
Moreover the autor have found some differences in plastic surround:
Regardless, these magnifiers are obviously not the same difference. But what are the different differences? OK. The differences we are fixing to discuss shall proceed from most to least obvious. Also, the differences we are fixing to discuss are just those differences apparent with the magnifiers actually fixed in the knives. So an average collector, aware of these differences can tell the type magnifiers apart at a glance. The most obvious difference is the shape of the magnifier frame. See how concave the top of the frame is on the 2nd generation. Not so noticeable on the actual magnifiers as on the diagram. Next, check out how the twain magnifiers enlarge the rule. Obviously, the 3rd generation is the more powerful. Finally, on Crumby's samples, the frame plastic is granulated on the 2nd generation, while it is smooth on the third generation. Unfortunately, the granulation does not show up in the picture in this venue, even enlarged. However, it is obvious in real life. Crumby would be interested to learn if the granulation difference repeats.

-
I am pretty sure Syph007 was the first to spot the new glass lens - Came as a surprise to him and many of us - as no one knew about it
Probably in his "Adventures into alox thread'This is what he does to make his brass mag glass tool - ie removes the glass lens from the regular tool, then inserts into his custom brass holder

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



