Chuck Yeager Challenge
-
Nov 01:

I'm sitting here this morning with a cup of coffee and reflecting a little on the challenge.

First, let me congratulate all the guys who have wrapped up the challenge!
This challenge was a lot of fun and you guys made it especially interesting and enjoyable. So, in addition to my congratulations, let me add my thanks for your companionship as well. 
I've completed the official part of the challenge, but, the Exec is still in my pocket this morning. Maybe that's out of habit, but part of me is also not quite ready to stop. I've carried the knife exclusively now for 33 days and a morning, and yet, think there is still a lot more to do with this knife and more to learn. The Executive has become a very nice companion knife.
I was motivated to do the challenge because the Executive "didn't make sense" to me. I wanted to learn why this knife was so popular and to try to figure it out. While I have come to appreciate it more, I'm not sure I've accomplished my primary goal. But that's OK, I have learned to love this little guy.
I'd like to hear more from some of those who have now completed the Chuck Yeager Challenge on what they've learned along this challenge.
Here are some observations on what I have learned:
-- Great size for EDC. The Exec slips into any pocket of pretty much any sort of attire. I've worn it with shorts, I've worn it with suits. I hardly ever notice it's there. Small and light, it seems like the SAK James Bond would wear with a Tuxedo to the Casino.

-- Didn't miss the keychain attachment. I filed this off the day I got the Exec, never missed it. The Exec always felt nice in my hand. I've got big hands and the small Classic line can seem a bit 'fiddly'. The Exec offered a good grip. Not as good as a Rucksack, but a good grip.
-- I did miss the opening layer tools, like the ones found on the Cadet. The Cadet makes an interesting comparison knife because it's also quite small, easy to carry, and light. On my kitchen scale, the Cadet (with keychain attachment) weighs in at 46 grams, the trimmed Executive at 45 grams.

-- I loved the large blade on the Executive. Thin and sharp, I found it could really cut above it's size class. Like other challengers found, the thinness meant it wasn't quite as good at spreading tasks, e.g. spreading butter or vegemite on toast. And the blade, at only 74mm could be challenged by thicker food items like a big sandwich. This sometimes meant sinking the blade to the hilt, not a big deal, but did then require a little more clean up. Here again, the Cadet makes an interesting comparison SAK. I've found it's larger and wider blade to be a bit more useful in general, but maybe not for carving pumpkins. :D
-- The Cable Tie Cutter tool is a fun feature. Some guys found it to be excellent for peeling oranges. It works OK for opening boxes and packages too. This may save a bit of wear on the other blades. While fun, I'd rather see the space and weight allocated to a small opening tool. Maybe like the little opener/driver on the Rambler. And since the Executive has a small and large blade, there is always a sharp blade available.
-- Which brings up the small blade. To my surprise, I found that I loved, loved, loved
this tiny SAK blade. Is there a smaller SAK blade out there? The small blade combined with the larger handle gave me the feeling of great control. This turned out to be my "go-to" package opener and small task cutter. I usually think that a pocket knife only needs one blade, but I don't think I'd be quick to give up this excellent secondary blade.-- T&T. As much as I love my Alox, I do like having T&T. I used the tweezers once during this challenge to remove a splinter and the toothpick several times for it's intended purpose.
-- Scissors. What can one say? SAK scissors are awesome, and these are more functional than the Classic's smaller scissors. I used the scissors a lot. The Exec's scissors seem as useful to me as those in the Pioneer X. At least for my purposes. While I haven't gotten the Executive out for a fishing trip (where has Fall gone?
), I'm pretty sure that part of the appeal of the Executive for General Yeager, the fishing enthusiast, was these scissors. I've used SAK scissors in the past to trim line, cut knots, and trim flies. They're great. I'll get the Executive out on the water when I can.-- The nail file is really good. Lots of file area to do good work and the file really works. I used it this morning along with the scissors to trim and smooth a broken nail. I meant to try to use it to sharpen a fishing hook point--maybe some of the appeal for General Yeager?--but haven't tried that yet. Regardless, the file works better than any of my other SAK nail files. The file alone might make the Exec a keeper. But what's up with that funky spade point? I used it once or twice to poke a hole in a disposable coffee cup, but, I think it might be better as a small driver. Perhaps it could be used for small Phillips head screws, I never had the chance to try that out.
So that's my review. A great SAK. I agree with Barry that the Exec would make a great pairing SAK to go along with another larger SAK. I'll be pairing mine up with a Soldier or Hiker for sure. But really, on it's own, I found it does everything a pocket knife needs to do and does it well. Maybe General Yeager was on to something here......
-
Congratulations to all on a successful completion of the Chuck Yeager Challenge!
Many thanks to Nix for his recap & review! I am also someone who didn't "get" the Executive and ignored it along with other 74mm SAKs. I purchased two Executives (a red and a black) during the initial discussion about having a challenge just to see what all the fuss was about. I was amazed at their appeal! Following the daily posts in this challenge had quite an affect on me in that I ended up purchasing 9 more of these small knives. Aside from getting four new and multiple colored scales (red, black, white and blue), the others can be explained by my search for better initial condition, more fodder for reconditioning, grooved vs not grooved and because I really like them. Although I am no longer among those who don't "get" the Executive, I am not sure that I can adequately explain its appeal. One thing that I really like is how comfortably they fit inside the pocket of my gym trunks--so much so that I forget that they are there! This alone is worth having an Executive.
I appreciate the way so many shared photos and narrative, giving us all a close look at the Executive in action. Although I was not a full participant because I couldn't agree to keep my hands off my of SAKs, I did feel very much a part of the excitement of this challenge.
Many thanks to all!

Jim
-
It's been fun watching you guy's SAK deprivation exercise. I'm sure you're all excited to carry a different SAK now.
:DBut seriously, pretty cool

-
Cool to see all you guys finished the month with success and are fully enjoying your exec!
Heres a pic of mine, just opened a few boxes and other post. Simple stuff but usefull!
I gave him a companion: the fenix E01
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Nice little light. I have one of those somewhere around here......

-
Congratulations to those that made all thirty days!

-
@Mactire404 said:
October 30thI had to work late today. So I brought noodles for lunch.
The Executive removed the foil and opened the packets.
Executive Nissin NoodlesFor dinner I had... more noodles. And the Exec again opened the foil and packets.
And no, that's no 58mm classic on the lid, the cup of the noodles is about twice the size!
It's a matter of perspective.
Executive more Nissin NoodlesThe rest of the day was uneventful. The Exec kept me company for the rest of the day, watching me work.
EDIT: My day was uneventful... until later that night...
I made a mess...

An Executive messI've never done any pumpkin carving and had one left from a Pumkin Ginger Soup I made earlier this month. It was going bad so I decided to give it a go.
Halloween isn't really celebrated here in the Netherlands. Perhaps in the past dew years it has gotten some attention.
I'm quite happy how it turned out. It's real fun to put a candle in and see the result at the end!
Pumkin, scary huh!I used the large blade to cut out the top. A spoon to get rid of the inside. Then I drew a face on the front and cut it out with the large blade.
Then I drew something else on the back, traced it with the small blade, cut it with the small blade and used the SD on the file to add more depth to it.
Victorinox PumpkinOne more day to this challenge, keep it up!
Happy Halloween everybody!Like, like
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using Tapatalk
-

Back on orange duty!
Am I the only one left or are there more late arrivals to this party?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Good question. I though you had company..... But regardless, carry on!

-
@Nix said:
Good question. I though you had company..... But regardless, carry on!
No worries! I’m loving it and cant wait to join the exec lounge! (Is that topic started yet?)
Sad thing is I’m flying to the uk tomorrow no hold bags so’ll have to leave my exec at home for a few days :(Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Good question. I though you had company..... But regardless, carry on!

No worries! I’m loving it and cant wait to join the exec lounge! (Is that topic started yet?)
Sad thing is I’m flying to the uk tomorrow no hold bags so’ll have to leave my exec at home for a few days :(Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Greetings!
The Chuck Yeager month-long challenge completed on October 31st. I enjoyed this month-long challenge and wanted a topic location where Executive owners could display their Execs in action (or just display them). I started the Executive Lounge yesterday and the posts have started.

Jim
-
Challenge is ended for me, and here you are my conclusions. Executive for me is really an EDC. Is possible to use it among people and in every place,because despite it has blades, it seems a keychain, and is very small. Why prefer it to a classic or manager? For its dimensions, scissors and blades do some tasks better, and the file is very good. The "strange" orange peeler is quite sturdy and has versatility.
The only sak which I think it can be compared, is the alox cadet, like it's just written. But it miss scissors, that are very useful for me, idem for tweezers.
Cadet gain points for its aspect, because alox is really nice, whereas 74mm are common only with red and black scales. Also the Cadet is better for using with big screws and for prying, so adding a classic or a swiss card is possible to have something quite complite. But I miss a saw and pliers, so I can add something else...Well, if I had to go minimal in urban environment, I choose the Executive, and nothing else.
Thanks to all, I really enjoyed the challenge!
-

Nice review! And I find I agree with your thoughts there. There isn't a "perfect" SAK for me. The Exec does many thing well, and makes a super urban-EDC.
-

Good summary, Mini!
I do like the comparison of the 74mm Executive with the 84mm Cadet since from a carry consideration, they are almost the same light weight. The little Cadet has amazing build quality and more robust tools with better capability including prying. The lack of scissors can make a big difference depending on one's needs. As this challenge proved, the Executive is a very capable tool in a small package. The fact that this capability comes in what can be considered a keychain size would not alarm people who would be concerned about larger pocket knives.

Jim
-
Some very interesting thoughts here.
I've decided I'm an 84 mil fan and I do like the Cadet for its slim Alox character and toolset though strictly I like the Sportsman more with its T&T and mini screwdriver. Paired with a Classic I think they give you a very versatile package. And you can fix your glasses.
So where does this leave the Executive or the Ambassador? I carried the Ambassador for the CY Challenge and it's a great gentlemans pocket knife. It does just slip into the pocket with ease and covers the day to day bases effectively with a decent blade. The Executive though has a better file and that orange peeler. The extra width is something I can live with. I don't strictly need the extra tools but they're nice additions.
So Chuck Yeager wasn't wrong to rely on an Executive. In the end I'll keep both Executive and Ambassador in my regular rotation but I do like to make the choice day by day. And that draws me back to 84mm time and again.
-
Wow what a great challenge guys
I think most of you have the minmalist SAK 30 day badge now but if you don't just go on over and request it and we will see that you get it 
The Executive truly is a great SAK and I need to carry mine more

-
That was an awesome challenge. I have carried the Swisstool for so long I was scared to try the Surge challenge. I can't even fathom the fear such a minmalist challenge would cause me.

-
I enjoyed the challenge. I didn't post pictures every day, but I did use my Exec most days, and it was the only knife i carried and used for the month of October, barring kitchen knives and such.
My thoughts are that I really like the 74mm platform. It makes for a very comfortable to use pen knife. For me, the Exec is definitely too large on the key ring for my comfort. I'd rather carry it loose in pocket. If my Ambassador weren't buried in my .50 caliber box o knives, I'd pull it out. As it happens, I am lazy.
I really like 2 blades, the scissors are smooth as silk, and the pointy bit on the file rocks as a poker. I can say woth certitude that i dislike the peeler as a serrated scraper and screwdriver. In fact, I do not trust screwdrivers with a blade on the side. I'm not hot on the file either. A part of me just likes the file found on the Classic better, even before taking the SD tip into account.
I'm swapping back to my Classic. The Exec will be put away, for now, until I get a wild hair to start carrying it again. It's been fun, but not something I wish to carry daily.
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
-
And to finalize this challenge;
I haven’t posted a lot, but I’ve kept to the challenge all along. It’s proven to be a great little tool and, though I was sceptical, it’s proven me that I can do with less than full sized multitools on me.
I’ve been carrying around just the exec and my light.
Frankly, even though i’ve never had one before, the most used tool is the orange peeler!!
The two tiny knives are great for what i use them for daily anyway. I’m going to continue with my current setup for a while!
Thanks Chucky!!Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login