I'm cool now.... sort of...
-
If you're paying fifty bucks, that's another sign.

-
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
If you're paying fifty bucks, that's another sign.

Absolutely!
Def
All we need is a through test of the strength of the fake tread vs the real tread.

-
aaand there it is, it had to be the easiest and most direct explanation (Occam's), which is cutting costs, as like you said Grant cutting out those barrel ends with precision and good tolerances would be a PITA. Skipping them takes a complex step from the process, one which probably needs of special tooling and an expensive procedure.
I guess that this, coupled with a (probably) lower quality steel makes for the $ difference, adding to that the obvious "Plus" that you can concede yourself to add to the price if you're the one and only Leatherman, and the inventor of the original tool.
Nice Sherlock eyes!

-
Yes, good catch Grant!
With the stampings of lettering and measurements sizes being so close to the real production values, I have to wonder then, whether or not this manufacturer was asked to mock up a prototype at some point, which did not have the barrels, or if they bought one and used silly-putty to copy the stampings so accurately and skipped the barrels.
I second the motion for a double blind durability test. Although I disdain the Tread as gimmicky, it would be good to know, for those who do like it.
What Grant said to me makes sense. The forum is dedicated to all multi tools, not beholden to any one manufacturer, and a fair assessment should be made of this one.
-
Well, here is the bad news- I am probably going to bite the bullet and spend the $$ to get a read Tread at some point in the near future, at which point I will do said tests and see where the limitations lie for each, as well as do more (better) direct comparisons of each link, the clasp etc.
I am really curious now.... so i anyone has a Tread they don't need and would be willing to sell me, please feel free to PM me.
Def
-
Not so fast. We'd need other members who have what they think are real Treads weigh in. That could have been a prototype of how they intended on manufacturing that part. I just checked mine and mine doesnt have those barrels. The screws are very different than yours as well. I'll take pictures tomorrow. I wonder if the screw are the "tell tell" sign? I posted pictures of the screws which are not tapered and have a "collar" which would strengthen the screw and allow the rotation of the link. Not sure I don't have a fake but I can say the person I got it from buys from the store. This has got very interesting.
-
See 2:12 of this video showing the link in question. I don't see the collars on that link. Please look at the screws which show the collar I was referring to. Mine have that exact collar. In looking at a few videos I believe there maybe other ways to determine a fake/counterfeit Tread. I saw in one video that the ball bearing was really sloppy. I do believe the screws can be used to determine a fake as well. Looking at the screws Def shows mine do not look like that nor do the ones in the video.
-
And heres is another Tread showing the link collars. I think I'll take mine apart to see if any links have those collars. My initial guess is the early ones may have had those collars on the links
. I really am a bit confused now.See 3:06 of this video.
-
So I am now thinking there was an early iteration of the Tread. The early one had the collars on the links and screws without collars. I am not sure I am clearly explaining this. The next iteration was links without collars and screws with. The 1st video I posted shows the links without collars and screws with. The Urban Prep'r Tread was an early one that shows links with collars and screws without. I think it maybe time to ask Leatherman for more insight.
Does anyone have an early LM Tread? One they know is legit?
-
Ok last video. Here is the Urban Prep'r a year later with a Tread. The link at 6:08 is without the collar.
-
Y-yikes. Care for some muddy water, anyone?
Seems that this could be solved rather easily. While not beholden to any manufacturer, this site is all about Multi's. I'm sure that contact could be arranged with Leatherman - not a customer service rep, but a contact with the boss or an engineer who can give us the scoop on what constitutes a real Tread and any variations.
Their interests lie in confirming real ones, especially if we are doing a review of sorts. No? A review or test of an inferior fake, if we didn't know it was fake, would reflect poorly on Leatherman.
Honestly at this point, I'm surprised they don't send Grant one of each new tool when they come out, expressly for the purposes of reviews. They would expect it back, of course, but it would make the rounds for reviews...
-
Interestingly, the barrels don't appear on the individual links on the Leatherman site:
404 Not Found
From our factory in Portland, Oregon, we are committed to bringing you the best multipurpose products to help you solve expected and unexpected problems in everyday life.
Leatherman (www.leatherman.com)
I think I am going to have to send the folks at Leatherman a few questions now.... >:D
Def
-
I did see that as well on Leathermans web site. I wasn't sure the picture was accurate. It'll be interesting to hear what they have to say.

-
I agree- the really interesting thing to me is that we could be looking at multiple production versions resulting from a change in manufacturing, and this is the kind of info that really interests collectors. I have to say that I am getting more and more interested in purchasing Treads because of this potential variance... and I am going to have to try to find an early version with the barrel ends. :ahhh
Def
-
If any members purchased a Tread from a reputable supplier early in its release, please chime in.
It's very interesting indeed.
-
I have zero interest in owning a Tread but this thread is proving to be a great read.

-
A fake popped up on our local site:
https://www.2dehands.be/bijoux-horloges/bijoux/armband/leatherman-tread-380458292.html -
I have zero interest in owning a Tread but this thread is proving to be a great read.

hahaha just what I thought: "why the hell am I following this thread with such interest if I have no Tread nor do I care for it?
"MTO illness

Lol +1
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login