Social Acceptance
-
@Ronald Schröder said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Half a million years ago, or thereabouts, some hairy ape picked up a stone and bashed in another ape´s brains. Humanity was born.
You must be much older than I am. I'll have to take your word for it. That was before my time.
I´m only a few thousand years old. But I read history books. 8)
Modern Homo Sapiens is only 200,000 years old.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Half a million years ago, or thereabouts, some hairy ape picked up a stone and bashed in another ape´s brains. Humanity was born.
You must be much older than I am. I'll have to take your word for it. That was before my time.
I´m only a few thousand years old. But I read history books. 8)
Modern Homo Sapiens is only 200,000 years old.

Closer to 6 or 7,000 according to what I believe in.
-
@gdoolittle said:
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
[quote author=Ronald Schröder link=topic=74774.msg1590081#msg1590081 date=1511694076]
Half a million years ago, or thereabouts, some hairy ape picked up a stone and bashed in another ape´s brains. Humanity was born.You must be much older than I am. I'll have to take your word for it. That was before my time.
I´m only a few thousand years old. But I read history books. 8)
Modern Homo Sapiens is only 200,000 years old.

Closer to 6 or 7,000 according to what I believe in.
[/quote]
I do not believe either way. As a (former) mathematician, I require proof. Evidence, however, doesn´t support the Creationist view. You must be a courageous man. -
@Ronald Schröder said:
@gdoolittle said:
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
[quote author=Tired_Yeti link=topic=74774.msg1591329#msg1591329 date=1511888787]
[quote author=Ronald Schröder link=topic=74774.msg1590081#msg1590081 date=1511694076]
Half a million years ago, or thereabouts, some hairy ape picked up a stone and bashed in another ape´s brains. Humanity was born.You must be much older than I am. I'll have to take your word for it. That was before my time.
I´m only a few thousand years old. But I read history books. 8)
Modern Homo Sapiens is only 200,000 years old.

Closer to 6 or 7,000 according to what I believe in.
[/quote]
I do not believe either way. As a (former) mathematician, I require proof. Evidence, however, doesn´t support the Creationist view. You must be a courageous man.
[/quote]
At least evolution seems to support the evidence.
Scientists have been observing it in action since 1986 on one of the Galapagos islands.
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Half a million years ago, or thereabouts, some hairy ape picked up a stone and bashed in another ape´s brains. Humanity was born.
You must be much older than I am. I'll have to take your word for it. That was before my time.
I´m only a few thousand years old. But I read history books. 8)
Modern Homo Sapiens is only 200,000 years old.

According to Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig we should adjust that figure:
The oldest fossil remains of anatomically modern humans are the Jebel Irhoud fossils from Morocco which are approximately 300,000 years old.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomically_modern_human
Oldest Homo sapiens bones ever found shake foundations of the human story
Idea that modern humans evolved in East Africa 200,000 years ago challenged by extraordinary discovery of 300,000-year-old remains in Moroccan mine
the Guardian (www.theguardian.com)
Doesn't change the actual point made, though. :D
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
@gdoolittle said:
@Pablo O'Brien said:
[quote author=Ronald Schröder link=topic=74774.msg1591332#msg1591332 date=1511889308]
[quote author=Tired_Yeti link=topic=74774.msg1591329#msg1591329 date=1511888787]
[quote author=Ronald Schröder link=topic=74774.msg1590081#msg1590081 date=1511694076]
Half a million years ago, or thereabouts, some hairy ape picked up a stone and bashed in another ape´s brains. Humanity was born.You must be much older than I am. I'll have to take your word for it. That was before my time.
I´m only a few thousand years old. But I read history books. 8)
Modern Homo Sapiens is only 200,000 years old.

Closer to 6 or 7,000 according to what I believe in.
[/quote]
I do not believe either way. As a (former) mathematician, I require proof. Evidence, however, doesn´t support the Creationist view. You must be a courageous man.
[/quote]
At least evolution seems to support the evidence.
Scientists have been observing it in action since 1986 on one of the Galapagos islands.
[/quote]
Yes. But nevertheless, evolution theory is just that, a theory. -
Yes, and while I could debate back and forth about how we got our intelligence and how the millions and millions of tiny pieces that make up our body and the tiny pieces inside those tiny pieces came together with the absolute precision necessary, i think I will bow out of this thread before it turns into an argument. I enjoy being part of the community here and I am more than happy to discuss my faith and my beliefs with anyone who would like to, i don’t think that is what this thread was intended for by the OP.
-
@Ronald Schröder said:
Yes. But nevertheless, evolution theory is just that, a theory."(Scientific) theory" is the shorthand for "the strongest supported scientific model of reality at the time of writing". Reality itself cannot be logically proven to exist, but it seems to be the most useful and simplest to assume it does.
Saying "just a theory" is like saying "oh, it's just the best explanation humanity collectively have managed to come up with, but I'm holding out for something better". Empiric science is about building models of reality and refining those into more robust and general models as we gather information. Newton's models are still perfectly valid for the systems they were derived for; Einstein gave us tools for correctly working at high velocities and strong gravitational fields, but that doesn't make Newton's law of gravity wrong. It just breaks down when you exceed, let's say, 1 million kph (0.1% of speed of light), depending on your need for accuracy.
-
Yes. But I´m with GDoolittle on this. MTo is not the place for arguments about religion versus science.
-
@gdoolittle said:
i think I will bow out of this thread before it turns into an argument. I enjoy being part of the community here and I am more than happy to discuss my faith and my beliefs with anyone who would like to, i don’t think that is what this thread was intended for by the OP.I will follow your (very wise) example.

-
@Ronald Schröder said:
Yes. But nevertheless, evolution theory is just that, a theory.
"(Scientific) theory" is the shorthand for "the strongest supported scientific model of reality at the time of writing". Reality itself cannot be logically proven to exist, but it seems to be the most useful and simplest to assume it does.
Saying "just a theory" is like saying "oh, it's just the best explanation humanity collectively have managed to come up with, but I'm holding out for something better". Empiric science is about building models of reality and refining those into more robust and general models as we gather information. Newton's models are still perfectly valid for the systems they were derived for; Einstein gave us tools for correctly working at high velocities and strong gravitational fields, but that doesn't make Newton's law of gravity wrong. It just breaks down when you exceed, let's say, 1 million kph (0.1% of speed of light), depending on your need for accuracy.
I was just about to post something like this, expect that I was going to say that despite gravity being "just a theory", I'm not going to try to disprove it by jumping off a building. :D
@gdoolittle said:
i think I will bow out of this thread before it turns into an argument. I enjoy being part of the community here and I am more than happy to discuss my faith and my beliefs with anyone who would like to, i don’t think that is what this thread was intended for by the OP.
I will follow your (very wise) example.

I agree, I'll quiet up too.

-
I'm just glad I didn't have to be the one to explain the difference between a theory and a hypothesis, again.
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Yes. But nevertheless, evolution theory is just that, a theory.
"(Scientific) theory" is the shorthand for "the strongest supported scientific model of reality at the time of writing". Reality itself cannot be logically proven to exist, but it seems to be the most useful and simplest to assume it does.
Saying "just a theory" is like saying "oh, it's just the best explanation humanity collectively have managed to come up with, but I'm holding out for something better". Empiric science is about building models of reality and refining those into more robust and general models as we gather information. Newton's models are still perfectly valid for the systems they were derived for; Einstein gave us tools for correctly working at high velocities and strong gravitational fields, but that doesn't make Newton's law of gravity wrong. It just breaks down when you exceed, let's say, 1 million kph (0.1% of speed of light), depending on your need for accuracy.
I was just about to post something like this, expect that I was going to say that despite gravity being "just a theory", I'm not going to try to disprove it by jumping off a building. :D
Being a scientist myself I would like to add that this sadly does not hold true anymore. Science noways is mostly about publications. So many valid results are swept under the rug because they do not fit current model and as such are hard to publish.
Case in point, I have strong indication that different proteins behave differently while traveling through the Golgi stack. So, when meeting with THE leading expert on that topic (who only uses one protein), I asked him if he ever has tested his theory with another protein. His answer was:
Yes, I have, it didn't work.So, its more that the current theory is the most supported by the leading experts of science and published data.
P.S.: It is now recognized that there are two valid models, that most likely co-exist with different proteins follow different pathways. And this was quite a small matter. Nevertheless it makes it obvious that scientific progress is hampered by publication pressure and the immense ego of some scientists.
-
Here in Nebraskaland, it’s still a pretty common occurance to see knives clipped in pockets, etc. Mostly tend to be lower end models though from the big box stores. No biggee.
In the family, everyone knows Grandpa always has a knife. Whenever the grandkids have something to open, they always say to give it to Grandpa to open cause he has a knife. Or if the battery compartment on a toy needs opened as well. Trusty Minichamp. Smart kids. :D
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ronald Schröder said:
Yes. But nevertheless, evolution theory is just that, a theory.
"(Scientific) theory" is the shorthand for "the strongest supported scientific model of reality at the time of writing". Reality itself cannot be logically proven to exist, but it seems to be the most useful and simplest to assume it does.
Saying "just a theory" is like saying "oh, it's just the best explanation humanity collectively have managed to come up with, but I'm holding out for something better". Empiric science is about building models of reality and refining those into more robust and general models as we gather information. Newton's models are still perfectly valid for the systems they were derived for; Einstein gave us tools for correctly working at high velocities and strong gravitational fields, but that doesn't make Newton's law of gravity wrong. It just breaks down when you exceed, let's say, 1 million kph (0.1% of speed of light), depending on your need for accuracy.
I was just about to post something like this, expect that I was going to say that despite gravity being "just a theory", I'm not going to try to disprove it by jumping off a building. :D
Being a scientist myself I would like to add that this sadly does not hold true anymore. Science noways is mostly about publications. So many valid results are swept under the rug because they do not fit current model and as such are hard to publish.
Case in point, I have strong indication that different proteins behave differently while traveling through the Golgi stack. So, when meeting with THE leading expert on that topic (who only uses one protein), I asked him if he ever has tested his theory with another protein. His answer was:
Yes, I have, it didn't work.So, its more that the current theory is the most supported by the leading experts of science and published data.
P.S.: It is now recognized that there are two valid models, that most likely co-exist with different proteins follow different pathways. And this was quite a small matter. Nevertheless it makes it obvious that scientific progress is hampered by publication pressure and the immense ego of some scientists.
That is quite an interesting anecdote.

I have heard that new results that are inconsistent with the old theory can take a while to be accepted by the scientific community, there are many theories that are now well known were "fringe" and not generally accepted at some point in the past.
Maybe it can be a good thing, as it can prevent "crackpot" theories with no substantial basis in fact and results from gaining support?
Unfortunately, there is also sometimes money at stake depending on the results, if there sponser of the experiment is biased toward a certain.... outcome. So the experiment and paper may not be impartial.

Warning: I do not have the training to be considered a genuine scientist, I am just an interested layperson who knows a little bit here and there, and my statements could well wrong and unfounded.

You know, in the interest of stating possible bias. ;)Maybe we should take this scientific discussion to a new thread if it is to continue?

-
@Joe58 said:
Here in Nebraskaland, it’s still a pretty common occurance to see knives clipped in pockets, etc. Mostly tend to be lower end models though from the big box stores. No biggee.In the family, everyone knows Grandpa always has a knife. Whenever the grandkids have something to open, they always say to give it to Grandpa to open cause he has a knife. Or if the battery compartment on a toy needs opened as well. Trusty Minichamp. Smart kids. :D
The 58mm phillips is a beast

-
Here in Nebraskaland, it’s still a pretty common occurance to see knives clipped in pockets, etc. Mostly tend to be lower end models though from the big box stores. No biggee.
In the family, everyone knows Grandpa always has a knife. Whenever the grandkids have something to open, they always say to give it to Grandpa to open cause he has a knife. Or if the battery compartment on a toy needs opened as well. Trusty Minichamp. Smart kids. :D
The 58mm phillips is a beast

It's a good tool.

And it even has a bonus beer opener! :D
No need to close the tool and open another tool to start drinking a cold beer after you finish the task.
-
In the science press over here there is currently quite a lot of talk about unpublished studies. The government finances a study, the data have sometimes simply been lost. One problem is the studies with "unexpected" results, as Etherealicer mentions, but I'm personally more worried about the forest of studies where the results were negative. They are valuable for the public, but since they are pretty much impossible to publish, they are worthless for the research group's hunt for funds, and get lost.
As an anecdote on the matter of publishing, back when I was a student at a (non-prestigious) university, one of the professors found an error in a paper from CERN. He was justifiably proud, since it was from one of the teams which aim for the Nobel prize (physics). He had to work a lot to get his correction published, simply on cause of CERN's prestige. I think he stopped doing peer reviews for journals after that, since he felt the process was corrupt. On the other hand, the correction did make it out in the open, and attributed to the correct person.
(Yeah, I was going to shut up, but we changed topic. Again.)
Back to social acceptability again. I think it mainly boils down to whether people are surprised. A surprised person is often an irrational person. Also, we have the sport of exercising power over others by either being the champion of the Law and happily jumping on stuff as being illegal, or by being "offended" or "scared" and thus controlling others by taking on a role as a victim. I think part of the perceived lowered tolerance for knives isn't about removing ourselves from nature, it's about people being forced into being "reasonable" all the time while at the same time fearing for their jobs and the future while becoming more and more alienated from lack if power to affect their own situation. (Working for a faceless corp, always with the ghost of "downsizing" hanging over the shoulder, doing something which doesn't even feel useful...) So power, any kind of power, becomes a highly sought drug. And, the best thing about being a champion for somebody else, is that you don't even have to claim responsibility for your own opinions. Finally, you can drink the savory juice of power and indulge in righteous anger, without ever straying from the narrow path of what is "reasonable". A lot of people really should get out in a quarry and blow up stuff. The Japanese idea of hiring a room filled with ceramics and getting a baseball bat handed out when entering is pure genious.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login