Things I hate in 'Bug Out Bags', or... How to Start an Argument
-
@ironraven said:
While I don't fully agree with all of your points, Lynn, it is merely from a matter of local terrain and gear preference...
But part of why I have kind of dropped out the "prepper community" is that most people say their plan isn't to run to the woods and play out their Robinson Crueso/Mountainman fantasy, but then that is what they pack for. I think it is becuase no one can reconcil the mental disparrity between the following kinds of sources:
-bushcraft, overly romantized descriptions of being a cowboy or a mountain man, or traditional pre-industrial skills (usually practiced by people who don't walk the walk, talk the talk, and die of old age at 35 assuming they made it out puberty- I like my running water)
-WWII-vintage aviator survival manuals and more modern manuals that trace their way to those
-fall out shelters (and the delusions that follow)
-political wackiness and the panic that can be stirred up by one guy on a dirt bike screaming into the night, "ISIS is comming! The ISIS is comming".
People have no idea what their plan is, so they try to absorb knowledge, never practice, and never try to apply it to their particular needs. But they will sure try to buy toys that can substitute for wisdom.One of the things that makes me cringe is what I'll call "fad gear". Not all of it is "gucci gear", but the tool of your guru of choice. Like the Mora. I own a Mora. It's a nice knife. It isn't a great knife, but 10 years ago before they became super fashionable for their price they were good. They still are, honestly, but the prices have jumped two, three times and many of the more useful and traditional styles dropped there becuase they are a trendy
...It's a lot more fun to think about how to deal with zombies and north korea invading, than it is to think about how to be a refugee. Particularly in modern natural disasters- have a way to keep that ID and cash and bank book on you at all times.
...When I lived an afternoon's walk from work, fine, yes, I had a 72 hour pack wiating for me. But now, it's a two day walk, and with my medical condition, I'm not sure my feet will still be useful if I have to do that in winter. Or my lungs. Come February, it's less painful and just as final for me to eat my pistol than it is to try to play out some hollywood fantasy.I'm not damning anyone who keeps a 72hour pack loaded at all times. Go for it. Just think long and hard about what it is really for, and act on rational, coherent, deliberative thought. Not trying to look cool.
My personal philosophy is to prepare for the highest likelihood. I live in a city in the middle of a tectonic plate, quite high up (maybe a five or six hundred metres from the water but a good four metres higher), and there aren't any tornadoes so my two likeliest emergencies are a massive ice storm (we had one in the early 2000s that cut power, water and emergency services from the entire city for almost a week and caused a bunch of trees to crash to the ground all during -20c weather) and a fire. As for your point about Moras I use them because I've inherited them, my family has been using moras for 300 years, long before mora was a company and the ones I've bought I bought while I was in Sweden (I got a Mora 511 for $6CAD, buying them elsewhere just subjects you to massive hikes in price), I like them because they're attractive and I know I can trust them. As for your last point I'm still in my prime so I would have some chance of getting away but it would still be incredibly difficult and I cannot imagine anyone over the age of 45, with some exceptions of course, hiking twenty kilometres with a backpack that weights almost as much as they do.
In conclusion I think that the majority of YouTube preppers are the exact opposite of who would last during an emergency: unrealistic idealists who are convinced that a rifle will be more useful than a couple hundred dollars in cash and who have never spent a day working with their hands and because of that they buy something not because they trust it but rather because it looks cool or because it's popular.
-
I think I was being over cynical and under expressive. Let me sum up.
I hate what I don't see. Planning. I rarely see realistic planning. And I rarely see realistic expectations. But when we strip off all fuzzy words, we're talking about becoming a refugee. Even if you have a place to go, that's what you are, a displaced person.
Should you have basic "wilderness" survival tools? Sure. PSK level stuff, light weight, compact. But don't think running for the hills is a plan. It isn't. At that point you go from being a refugee to a vagrant.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Now I have had a laugh, I must begrudgingly admit a few items in my camp bag (can be used for a bug out I guess) designed for the Alabama woods.
and lastly a Thompson sub-machine gun.excuse me? :o ???
-
@ ironraven.

Just today on the news it was announced to have a evacuation plan in place for wild fires. This is the most likely scenario I face and have faced. No bugging out for us here in SoCal. The more likely situation will be going to a family members or friends as long as they weren't evacuated. The other situation would be to go to a evacuation site. My plan is have what I need to be self sustaining for a week. A bag simply wont do. NOW that being said if all I grabbed was my bag(s) I've discussed a hand cart to transport them. I would be ok in a evacuation site but I'd prefer to "camp" nearby.
I do believe however ironraven pretty much summed up what I feel about these bags and those that go on video showing the contents.
-
Great thread Lynn

-
+1 and funny too.
IMO many Youtube prepping vids are not about prepping at all. They´re about making money. The Prepper Princess is right. You don´t need tons of stuff. Food, water, and protection against the weather are the most important.
Of course I do carry tons of stuff myself, but that´s for fun.
-
@Ronald Schröder said:
You don´t need tons of stuff.I agree.
Food, water, and protection against the weather are the most important.
I (sort of) disagree.
For the most likely scenarios for me having to leave quickly, for instance if the block I'm living in started burning, industrial accident, etc, the most important would be credit card, ID, and the digital copies of my grades and certifications (I have off-site encrypted copies of those anyway, but that's exactly because they are valuable). I live in a small city, shelter isn't a problem as long as you salvage ID and means of payment... Or, the tool for shelter isn't a tarp, it's a credit card (till the insurance company comes through). But, you need to live after the first 72 hrs as well. Same thing for the nasty scenarios where you end up a refugee: You need the building blocks for reassembling a life.
Now we're talking the depressing scenarios, those which are really no fun planning for, but are rather more likely than the invasion of the flesh-eating sheep.
I'll echo what Ironraven said earlier, the most important part is planning.
-
... and I think the above probably is the most depressing post I've ever written for MT.o.
-
@Steinar said:
but are rather more likely than the invasion of the flesh-eating sheep.wait you are saying thats less likely but possible? :ahhh im replacing my bug out bag with a bug out tank asap :D
I like what the lady on the video said about learning from poeple who actually deal with real situations, on that note one could wonder how people managed to survive in the wilderness, deal with emergencies before cool tactical gear for every possible thing was invented

-
@Steinar said:
Now we're talking the depressing scenarios, those which are really no fun planning for, but are rather more likely than the invasion of the flesh-eating sheep.:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-ExKYM5xQY -
Syncop8r beat me to it. :D
-
I haven't actually seen it yet, looks pretty funny.
-
I've seen it, I prefer the Peter Jackson splat fests, but it has its fun moments. :)
-
Can someone explain one other thing - why are some people spending very big sums of money (let us say over $500 or €500, depending on where we are) on backpacks that weight more than the contents of the bag put together (especially those 120liter "backpack" that requires a frame and straps and a hip belt which are all sold separately) but then count grams on eating utensils, folding knives (the back up for a fixed blade), fixed blade knives (have to be light to strike fast
) and just about everything else with the exception of a wool blanket which is often in itself heavier than most well rounded sleep systems of equal warmth can be?Beats me about the packs. I just use an old ALICE pack I got for 25 bucks. Has a frame, light weight and tough as nails.
I do like wools blankets. But I use them when it is warmer and I don't need a bulky -30 sleeping bag.If done right, even with wool blankets and older gear that is heavier, the pack with everything in it should only weigh about 25 to 30 pounds at most. Give or take on the climate. Food and water is about the only thing that should really start to weigh the pack down. And that is just for camping. A BOB or 72 hour or what the hell ever they are called now will have more in it. But of course, it is a totally different situation. You may have kids with you or other factors.
I have said in a another thread before, people are really over thinking this anymore and are just going at each other. The thing is, it is you who is going to be using the bag and make the bag according to you skills and the things you like or are used to and make it to fit you needs.That's what I've been saying for about a decade now. Sure the new packs might have bells and whistles, but an old Alice pack will do the job and won't be an eyesore. Now I don't have anything against a bit of extra weight but if I'm willing to take heavy items when there are alternatives that are lighter, just as good and oddly in the same price range then I certainly shouldn't be taking compromises on the rest of the gear. A plastic spoon is maybe 3 grams, a spoon from my kitchen is about 24. Sure I'd save 21 grams but if I'm willing to not save 1200 with other choices, then those 21 grams aren't that big of a deal.
Can someone explain one other thing - why are some people spending very big sums of money (let us say over $500 or €500, depending on where we are) on backpacks that weight more than the contents of the bag put together (especially those 120liter "backpack" that requires a frame and straps and a hip belt which are all sold separately) but then count grams on eating utensils, folding knives (the back up for a fixed blade), fixed blade knives (have to be light to strike fast
) and just about everything else with the exception of a wool blanket which is often in itself heavier than most well rounded sleep systems of equal warmth can be?I cannot talk about other people... but I own two EVOC backpacks (10 & 20L). They are both fairly heavy and fairly expensive. They are heavy due to the many pockets on the inside, letting you organize stuff (Ok, the 20L is also heavy because it has a back protector built in, not the worst idea when you cycle on icy roads).
CON
- Heavy
- Expensive
PRO
- Excellent quality and waterproof (the 20L has a built in water cover)
- The many pockets/sleeves let you organize your gear for easy access and saves you some weight as you don't need additional organizers like a Maxpedition pouch.
- They are small (as opposed to wide) allowing you to move unhindered in crowds
And yeah, if I can find equivalent/better gear that is lighter, I go for it. I have to carry it all the time.
If you are talking about those ridiculous "tactical" backpacks with molle webbing (which no one uses but adds tons of weight) all over... I have no idea :DI was talking about the tactical backpacks.
-
-
Sure the new packs might have bells and whistles, but an old Alice pack will do the job and won't be an eyesore.
No, but they will give you a backsore. External frames? Horrible. Ancient technology that puts the weight on your back instead of your hips. Yuck. Never going near one again.
I am not sure about yours, but mine never gave me a back sore. The internal frame are way to hot on my back. But that just may be me.
-
Sure the new packs might have bells and whistles, but an old Alice pack will do the job and won't be an eyesore.
No, but they will give you a backsore. External frames? Horrible. Ancient technology that puts the weight on your back instead of your hips. Yuck. Never going near one again.
One thing that sucks is being younger and or injury free (at least when it comes to the back). I don't think about these things because they don't bother me.
Now this is a mild example of what I mean. All these packs are about 45 liters:
Karrimor Sabre 45 is 1.84kg (tactical)
Kelty Redwing 44 is 1.40kg (basic backpacking)
Gossmer gear Gorilla is 0.74kg (ultra light backpacking)Now these are just the ones I had on a spreadsheet since they are more reasonably priced and I'll be the first to admit that there are far worse examples out there of heavy backpacks (Eberlestock). On the other hand I'm not sure a lot of us would be jumping from joy with an UL pack simply due to the lighter materials that could be susceptible to breaking more easily
-
Can someone explain one other thing - why are some people spending very big sums of money (let us say over $500 or €500, depending on where we are) on backpacks that weight more than the contents of the bag put together (especially those 120liter "backpack" that requires a frame and straps and a hip belt which are all sold separately) but then count grams on eating utensils, folding knives (the back up for a fixed blade), fixed blade knives (have to be light to strike fast
) and just about everything else with the exception of a wool blanket which is often in itself heavier than most well rounded sleep systems of equal warmth can be?Beats me about the packs. I just use an old ALICE pack I got for 25 bucks. Has a frame, light weight and tough as nails.
I do like wools blankets. But I use them when it is warmer and I don't need a bulky -30 sleeping bag.If done right, even with wool blankets and older gear that is heavier, the pack with everything in it should only weigh about 25 to 30 pounds at most. Give or take on the climate. Food and water is about the only thing that should really start to weigh the pack down. And that is just for camping. A BOB or 72 hour or what the hell ever they are called now will have more in it. But of course, it is a totally different situation. You may have kids with you or other factors.
I have said in a another thread before, people are really over thinking this anymore and are just going at each other. The thing is, it is you who is going to be using the bag and make the bag according to you skills and the things you like or are used to and make it to fit you needs.That's what I've been saying for about a decade now. Sure the new packs might have bells and whistles, but an old Alice pack will do the job and won't be an eyesore. Now I don't have anything against a bit of extra weight but if I'm willing to take heavy items when there are alternatives that are lighter, just as good and oddly in the same price range then I certainly shouldn't be taking compromises on the rest of the gear. A plastic spoon is maybe 3 grams, a spoon from my kitchen is about 24. Sure I'd save 21 grams but if I'm willing to not save 1200 with other choices, then those 21 grams aren't that big of a deal.
Can someone explain one other thing - why are some people spending very big sums of money (let us say over $500 or €500, depending on where we are) on backpacks that weight more than the contents of the bag put together (especially those 120liter "backpack" that requires a frame and straps and a hip belt which are all sold separately) but then count grams on eating utensils, folding knives (the back up for a fixed blade), fixed blade knives (have to be light to strike fast
) and just about everything else with the exception of a wool blanket which is often in itself heavier than most well rounded sleep systems of equal warmth can be?I cannot talk about other people... but I own two EVOC backpacks (10 & 20L). They are both fairly heavy and fairly expensive. They are heavy due to the many pockets on the inside, letting you organize stuff (Ok, the 20L is also heavy because it has a back protector built in, not the worst idea when you cycle on icy roads).
CON
- Heavy
- Expensive
PRO
- Excellent quality and waterproof (the 20L has a built in water cover)
- The many pockets/sleeves let you organize your gear for easy access and saves you some weight as you don't need additional organizers like a Maxpedition pouch.
- They are small (as opposed to wide) allowing you to move unhindered in crowds
And yeah, if I can find equivalent/better gear that is lighter, I go for it. I have to carry it all the time.
If you are talking about those ridiculous "tactical" backpacks with molle webbing (which no one uses but adds tons of weight) all over... I have no idea :DI was talking about the tactical backpacks.
I cannot help you with that. Tactical and camo seem extremely counter-productive in emergency situations.
Being seen avoids a great deal dangers
Being seen allows for being rescued
And as much as we like to be "self reliant", most emergencies require people to work together, or are at least far easier resolved when collaborating.I mean most "preppers" seem to have a rather skewed perspective. There is a far bigger chance of getting run over by a car, than getting robbed. Chances of bodily harm or death is even greater with car accidents than robberies.
Furthermore, the "tough" look actually makes you a target for robberies, rather than deterring others. Because, a "prepper" will carry emergency cash and very likely he has some expensive gear on him (looking at knife prices / guns are among the most popular things to steal). Whereas Joe Average might just have a pack of gum.I virtually see no benefit to camo/tactical clothing/gear.
-
I first started hiking with this model of pack. It was only 45 litres but it felt like 100kg.

-
[quote author=Etherealicer
I virtually see no benefit to camo/tactical clothing/gear.[/quote]
It is great for hunting and I can get the stuff at a military surplus store for a fraction of the cost than what Real Tree and Mossy Oak stuff is going for. I do wish some of the tactical stuff would come in different colors so it does not look so tactical. Some of the stuff is very versatile and practical.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login