Gerber Crucial
-
IMO, that's just awful! You don't see LM coming out with pliers that open with the flick of a wrist or anything! I like the look of it, but I don't think I would buy one; they definitely copied LM's idea!
-
Yup I agree. I cant understand how this will ever come into production.
-
I like how the blade isn't pointed though; it's more of a sheepsfoot design! Wouldn't that be cool if LM offered a Skeletool with a fully serrated sheepsfoot blade for EMS/First Responders/LE and the like? That would sell really well, IMO!
-



@Defender said:
Actually it didn't seem all that bad. We played with it for a while, but it's still a prototype, and while it did feel a little wobbly, that's typical for pre-production as they are constantly fiddling with them. I can't say whether it will be great or not yet, but it certainly is worth watching, and at the price point they are suggesting, I'm sure it will be quite popular.Def
Look Def, I know you're a businessman so I don't expect you to take sides here.
But damn do these photos make my blood boil. One cannot blame Gerber for making folding pliers - that's like stealing blueprints for a Phillips screw head. But taking an original Leatherman design, one that probably cost the company hundreds of thousand of dollars and hundreds, if not thousands of man hours, then pretending you've made a breakthrough takes this rivalry to a cartoonish level.
This "unveiling" means Gerber is at a dead end, with nothing to offer but a cheaper price. I'm ashamed to have ever considered purchasing any of their multi-tools. Fend for Yourself my аss.
-
I guess one could say it's *faux Leather *man

That is a pretty bad rip-off from a competing company that has been known to
stealborrow ideas from other companies like (cough Atwood) ::) :o :D -
I agree this is pretty shaky and looks more like a LM Skeletool than I would prefer. It's almost a copy with some gerber crap throw into the mix. I seriously want to know what Leatherman things about this, would be interesting what Tim says. I think with the new replacement for the clutch they made it look ugly (with this radioactive green) and now a tool that looks like the competition, so very not cool. Somehow I have lost faith in the folks at Gerber, I agree "fend for yourself my ass"

I just thought I would edit my post and add, I guess this is the difference between made is USA and made in CHINA (oh wait...or is that TAIWAN??) :o
-
I'll risk being called a traitor or worse, but I wonder what LM were saying when Vic came out with the SwissTools...

-
@noth said:
I'll risk being called a traitor or worse, but I wonder what LM were saying when Vic came out with the SwissTools...
I think Bear beat them to it and they had some legal litigation with LM and i believe they lost because there Bear Jaws looked to much like a PST then Vic bought Bear and came out with a different tool based on Bears designs and patents
Or something like that
:D -
I'm not going to get steamed up design similarities - That's how the world works, and presumably, we the customer, are the better for it, as multiple companies compete for our attention with their various takes on the same theme.
Especially for poor customers like me, who would need to sell their body to afford a Skeletool!
Imagine the pickle we'd be in if only one beer company was allowed to bottle their drink in long necks!
The (very few, three I think) Gerbers I have handled have not impressed me though. They are still very expensive in Aus, and they are presumably better than the $20-$30 multis I can buy at a hardware store, but they don't strike me as having the same quality as a Vic or Leatherman tool.
I'm always happy to be pleasantly surprised, and one day I might buy a Gerber and use it to my full satisfaction.
So far, not so good however.
-
Wow, that's pretty bold of Gerber to blatently copy Leatherman.
I'm not commenting on the Crucial itself as I haven't handled it, and for a lot of tool users it might be just what they are looking for in a pocket clipped/light multi, but it's kind of embarassing IMO.
-
Actually I am surprised that we haven't seen Skeletool knock-offs from China before now. After all, that is what they seem to do best. ::)
-
Yeah they would have even put the metal cutouts in the same spots ::) :D
-
You got to see that it is just to damn close for me. I really will pass of that tool.
-
@Leatherman123 said:
I like how the blade isn't pointed though; it's more of a sheepsfoot design! Wouldn't that be cool if LM offered a Skeletool with a fully serrated sheepsfoot blade for EMS/First Responders/LE and the like? That would sell really well, IMO!I agree with you on the blade design. I as well would like LM to come out with some sort of tool designed for First Responders
-
Well, I guess LM had to expect copies before too long. That's the bane of being an innovator in a capitalistic free market... you do the dirty design work, test the market, and then watch others make money. But, like I said, I'm assuming LM isn't surprised in the least, and will just continue to make a higher quality, higher price-point model than the rest, and figure it'll be ok. That's what they've done for years, and it's seemed to work for them, so I expect they'll be just fine. :-\
-
It's a PMS (Poor Man's Skeletool).
Lucky for Gerber, I am a poor man, and I actually quite like the look of that.
Did anyone get to handle it? If so, what was the quality like?
-
@Nomad said:
I'm not going to get steamed up design similarities - That's how the world works, and presumably, we the customer, are the better for it, as multiple companies compete for our attention with their various takes on the same theme.Especially for poor customers like me, who would need to sell their body to afford a Skeletool!
Imagine the pickle we'd be in if only one beer company was allowed to bottle their drink in long necks!..........
sigh I'm starting to come around to Nomad's way of thinking on this matter. The Crucial is NOT an exact copy of the Skeletool. Instead, it takes the Skeletool "minimalist" concept and adds a couple of twists like dedicated screwdrivers and a fold out carabiner. As such it may actually be preferable to some folks over the Skeletool. In short, it's just barely enough different that I can feel okay about Gerber producing them.
I'm sure the folks at Gerber will rest easier knowing that. :D
-
Gerbers stooped to an all time low here >:( Not only have they ripped Leathermans design , I bet its made in China too which I bet they don't make too big a deal out of . On the plus side I like the blade shape but the only way I would have one is if it was given too me . Im not a fan .
Dunc
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






