Walmart's Ozark Trail Ot Knife Multi Tool 8 Function (Lynn's $5 MT Challenge)
-
Okay, so I'll get this post done ASAP for The Peacent.
Drivers.
The big flathead driver combined with the cap lifter.
First, it has a 90 degree halfstop...

Or, maybe 'almost 90 degrees'. which might be explained by the 'almost 180 degrees' full open. Weird.

In any case, I have a house full of flathead screws in the hardware, so I tested all I could. It slots nicely, turns fine. This is my favorite screw to test, the ones holding faceplates onto light switches and outlets.

This did fine on those, and on much tougher screws on door hinges, etc. Nothing SUPER hard, but some pretty 'actual work' size screws. That said, none of these screws were stuck, or offered huge resistance. There is a slight play in the tool, probably from not-great peening, and I'd be very reluctant to try heavy duty screw duty with this. I'd also worry that the not-quite-180-degree open would be more prone to collapsing shut under heavy force.
Large flathead: Win for light duty.
The small flathead. Okay (sigh)... Um... It is a complete fail out of the package. The tip is VERY rounded and has not been tapered to be narrow enough to slot into any screw. Worse than that, the stamping process of making it bulges up the metal at the tip, making it actually a little THICKER than the stock it's pressed from.

Fifteen minutes with a whet stone, and i have something a bit more useful.

It will slot into smaller screws now, and does an alright job on light screwdriver duty. After a LOT of work.
Small screwdriver coupled with can opener: COMPLETE FAIL (out of the package)
Phillips Driver.
I have a number of different phillips screws holding my kitchen cabinets together. This is where I tend to test phillips drivers.

It did fine on the screws farthest left (holding on cabinet handle), and center (holding hinge to door). It was reluctant turning the screw holding hinge to frame. Those frames have to be some kind of hardwood, because that was one difficult screw. The driver wanted to cam out of the screw, and required a good deal of pressure. It succeeded, but I think that was the upper end of its ability. I will NOT be trying it against a woodscrew in the wood bench I go to for hard testing. As with the flathead, the slight play between layers from poor peening makes me think this tool would get torn apart with serious use.
Phillips driver: Pass (for light duty.)
Flathead as pry tool...
I have one benchmark test I do with flatheads for pry tools. I try to pry open a crusty paint can.

How did the OT8 fair?
Mmm....
There are TWO things that could go wrong with this test.
First, the pin holding the tool together could stretch, loosening the layers.
Second, the metal of the screwdriver itself could permanently deform.So...
OT8 as moderate duty pry tool: FAIL
The tool is okay for light duty flathead and phillips work. Anything else is going to wreck it pretty quick. So far, from all the things I've tested, THIS has been the thing that REALLY separates a real Swiss Army Knife from this tool. This thing just isn't up to even moderately hard work. If you don't ever demand that of it, you'll be fine.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
hahah thank you

There was no need to hurry, it's just that I care much more for the flathead and driver capability than I do for it's bottle opening use,
and this one looked like it would be no good
Pot steel, flimsy pins, weak construction like 90% of the cheapos. Like you said, it's what makes a real SAK differentIt wasn't

-
Except for the pry test it seems the OT8 did rather well then
Not what I was expecting but the pry test would eventually wreck it beyond use so not that great either ::)
Great testing Lynn

-
Thank you. Almost done, but yeah, pretty thorough, I think.
If it's for light duty, it's a pretty excellent little knife. Try anything adventurous, and... not gonna be happy.
-
The Can opener.
Works.
I'm not sure there's a lot of waxing poetic to do here. I did a quarter of a can, to figure out how well it worked, and it was fine. It functioned. I didn't have any rim jumps or problems puncturing the can. Neither did it feel like a miracle of our age. Worked, worked ok.
Can opener: Pass
-
@Poncho65 said:
Except for the pry test it seems the OT8 did rather well then
Not what I was expecting but the pry test would eventually wreck it beyond use so not that great either ::)
Great testing Lynn

I think that is the problem, durability and reliability.
Lynn, may I suggest another test? Drop it 10 times from medium hight (e.g. a table) onto a hard surface. This to check how well it maintains structural integrity.
Oh, and thanks for all the hard work.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
The Can opener.Works.
I'm not sure there's a lot of waxing poetic to do here. I did a quarter of a can, to figure out how well it worked, and it was fine. It functioned. I didn't have any rim jumps or problems puncturing the can. Neither did it feel like a miracle of our age. Worked, worked ok.
Can opener: Pass
so I guess it's not a *can't *opener then.
Good -
@Etherealicer said:
Lynn, may I suggest another test? Drop it 10 times from medium hight (e.g. a table) onto a hard surface. This to check how well it maintains structural integrity.Great idea. I'll save it for last, and do the drop test in my basement, on a concrete floor.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Etherealicer said:
Lynn, may I suggest another test? Drop it 10 times from medium hight (e.g. a table) onto a hard surface. This to check how well it maintains structural integrity.Great idea. I'll save it for last, and do the drop test in my basement, on a concrete floor.
Drop a Victorinox too.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Etherealicer said:
Lynn, may I suggest another test? Drop it 10 times from medium hight (e.g. a table) onto a hard surface. This to check how well it maintains structural integrity.Great idea. I'll save it for last, and do the drop test in my basement, on a concrete floor.
Drop a Victorinox too.

I will certainly get to that. I won a lot on e-bay with a Vic Tourist. Don't think I'm going to treat it more kindly than the OT8. In fact, it might get treated much LESS kindly, assuming that it can take more punishment.
ON WITH THE TESTING!!
As requested, I dropped the knife from about 3 feet. I did this on the same end for every drop, 10 times onto our basement concrete floor.
The effect was minimal scuffing of the scales. At least brand new, the plastic seems to have a good ability to take some abuse without cracking.

And that's it.
Oh, wait... one more thing. As a celebration of what feels to me like an actually decent tool for under $5 new... We will see if it's up to the task of opening a bottle of wine.
I mentioned in this thread that I would inevitably compare this to the Coghlan's 7-function Army Knife. Well... how do I think they compare? If I had to pay the same for both, i'd chose this one, and I was relatively happy with the Coghlan's. But halfway through a month of using that one, I had to take the scales off and repeen it. I DID loosen a pin on this when I tried to pry with the large flathead driver, but nothing serious. The BIG difference is the Scissors. This tool is worth it for the blade and scissors alone, both of which performed very well, incredibly well for a tool in this price range. Everything after that is gravy, in my opinion. And mostly, it did everything it was supposed to do. Just don't pry with it.

-
-
I've already started the review on the (hilariously terrible so far) PST Knock-off.
</topic/75161 -
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Etherealicer said:
Lynn, may I suggest another test? Drop it 10 times from medium hight (e.g. a table) onto a hard surface. This to check how well it maintains structural integrity.Great idea. I'll save it for last, and do the drop test in my basement, on a concrete floor.
Firstly, I had the Coughlans version as a kid, before production went to China. It had both the corkscrew and the Phillips head, along with the awl on the backspring. Worked fine for me for years. I think today's are much worse. When I finished high school, I bought myself a Super Tinker.
Secondly, that Super Tinker lasted almost 25 years before I dropped it from some height (maybe 30 feet) to the hard black top below. And got run over by a truck before I could get down to it. Cellidor was shattered, and the tracks were so bent in, that I couldn't open some of the tools at all.
-
I'm pretty sure there aren't many scale materials minus stuff like micarta that would survive a 30-foot drop. Horn, wood, and cellidor are all good materials and durable enough but they have their limits.
The 'run over by a truck' is a real bummer. This can kill the best of MTs, depending on the angle it's at when run over, and the size of the vehicle.

-
-
Except for the pry test it seems the OT8 did rather well then
Not what I was expecting but the pry test would eventually wreck it beyond use so not that great either ::)
Great testing Lynn

I think that is the problem, durability and reliability.
Lynn, may I suggest another test? Drop it 10 times from medium hight (e.g. a table) onto a hard surface. This to check how well it maintains structural integrity.
Oh, and thanks for all the hard work.
I think my parents did this to me when I was a kid!!
-
I thought this was very interesting.
As of this writing, the Walmart website has these listed on sale for $3! :ahhh
These might be the best SAK-knockoff I've seen in a while, and are ABSOLUTELY worth $3 plus tax.
-
-
Weird. It's listing at $2, but when you open the item, it still shows $3.
-
It's nice at $3, but I'd still pay $5 for the Aitor. ::)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


