Saw length
-
For straightforward sawing, you´ll need a saw 1.5 times the size of the branch or more. Otherwise you´ll have to go round.
As regards the Bahco, it´s not a bad saw but when you do a comparison with others you´ll notice it takes more time and certainly more effort.
I would say that the saw lengths on the SAKs roughly equal the blade lenghts.
-
@Ron Who said:
For straightforward sawing, you´l need a saw 1.5 times the size of the branch or more. Otherwise you´ll have to go round.As regards the Bahco, it´s not a bad saw but when you do a comparison with others you´ll notice it takes more time and certainly more effort.
Woops I was editing while you replied. :)
I've used the saw on my Leatherman Charge before often. I'm trying to cut down on its weight for a light/minimalist camping bag. All my options above are significantly lighter/smaller and have far less redundancy. The Walker for example would on paper seem like a wonderful solution but I'm trying to picture whether it's saw will be of any use at all.
-
The saw on the Walker is of the same quality as the larger ones. I used it for thin branches (up to 2.5cm/1´´) and it does fine.
-
93mm & 91mm are the same
-
My Walker is in the car right now but I'll retrieve it later. I recall comparing the 84mm saw to the 91mm and being surprised how little difference in size there is. I seem to recall it wasn't more than a tooth or two.
-
Camper vs. Walker

15 teeth for the Camper and 13 for the Walker.
-
Hey pomsbz,
I'd say you should also keep the 'Rucksack' 111mm model on your list of candidates.
The caplifter/can opener layer is lighter than that on the Trekker, and the caplifter/flathead doesn't lock, and you get a backside corkscrew instead of phillips...
But, it's something like an ounce lighter than the Trekker, still has a locking blade (no OHO), and saw. AND... something I personally cared about... it comes with red scales. Instead of the stupid black of the Trekker. Also, not having the OHO blade bump makes sawing with it WAY more comfortable than with a Trekker.
And, for some reason, they occasionally show up on ebay pretty cheap.

-
Yes, good suggestion. Essentially, the Rucksack is a 111mm Camper (without the small blade).
-
84mm "my first Victorinox" saw
58mm effective saw length
64km from tip to tang
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Hey pomsbz,I'd say you should also keep the 'Rucksack' 111mm model on your list of candidates.
The caplifter/can opener layer is lighter than that on the Trekker, and the caplifter/flathead doesn't lock, and you get a backside corkscrew instead of phillips...
But, it's something like an ounce lighter than the Trekker, still has a locking blade (no OHO), and saw. AND... something I personally cared about... it comes with red scales. Instead of the stupid black of the Trekker. Also, not having the OHO blade bump makes sawing with it WAY more comfortable than with a Trekker.
And, for some reason, they occasionally show up on ebay pretty cheap.

The Forester also comes in red and non-oho blade... another option for pomsbz... 
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Don't forget the 130mm SAKs, which have the biggest saws by far.

Sent from my SM-P900 using Tapatalk
-
Lynn's quite right about the Rucksack. The Trailmaster/Forester's chunky cap-lifter/screwdriver may look like an improvement, but if the most you're doing with it is busting open beer bottles (yep) then having a locking mechanism behind it is total overkill. I have never heard of anyone losing a limb cos a cap-lifter inadvertently snapped shut on their finger!
-
@stoneshank said:
84mm "my first Victorinox" saw
58mm effective saw length
64km from tip to tang
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
64km?! :o

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
84mm "my first Victorinox" saw
58mm effective saw length
64km from tip to tang
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
64km?! :o

Cuts down forests with a single stroke!
-
@theonew said:
Camper vs. Walker
15 teeth for the Camper and 13 for the Walker.
Thank you, very useful!
@Lynn LeFey said:
Hey pomsbz,
I'd say you should also keep the 'Rucksack' 111mm model on your list of candidates.
The caplifter/can opener layer is lighter than that on the Trekker, and the caplifter/flathead doesn't lock, and you get a backside corkscrew instead of phillips...
But, it's something like an ounce lighter than the Trekker, still has a locking blade (no OHO), and saw. AND... something I personally cared about... it comes with red scales. Instead of the stupid black of the Trekker. Also, not having the OHO blade bump makes sawing with it WAY more comfortable than with a Trekker.
And, for some reason, they occasionally show up on ebay pretty cheap.

The Forester also comes in red and non-oho blade... another option for pomsbz... 
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The Forester was one of the options I mentioned above but I didn't know about the Rucksack, I had searched for the 3 layer equivalent of my wife's Outrider and seen the Forester, I hadn't realised the Forester is beefier. I'm still very much not sure about going for a full 111mm sized model though.
@Thunderpants said:
Lynn's quite right about the Rucksack. The Trailmaster/Forester's chunky cap-lifter/screwdriver may look like an improvement, but if the most you're doing with it is busting open beer bottles (yep) then having a locking mechanism behind it is total overkill. I have never heard of anyone losing a limb cos a cap-lifter inadvertently snapped shut on their finger!I still don't get the SAK insistence on not using a combo tool to be honest.
@AndyTiedye said:
Don't forget the 130mm SAKs, which have the biggest saws by far.
Sent from my SM-P900 using Tapatalk
At that size I'm not sure it's worth not just taking my LM Charge.
@stoneshank said:
84mm "my first Victorinox" saw
58mm effective saw length
64km from tip to tang
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
Perfect! Thank you!
-
@AndyTiedye said:
Don't forget the 130mm SAKs, which have the biggest saws by far.
Sent from my SM-P900 using Tapatalk
How did you get a clip on that rangergrip?
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
-
Lawl! Autocorrect is the villain haha
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
-
Smallest camp knife (Walker) 45.2 g, 1.59 oz
Medium camp knife (Camper) 74.2 g, 2.62 oz
Large camp knife (Rucksack) 100.7 g, 3.55 ozFor a modern liner lock OH type with woodsaw add another 50 g, 1.75 oz
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
