Multitool categories- Pliers based, scissors based, knife based & driver based ?
-
Hm... What are they on ebay? There's one on Amazon right now for $34.95.
-
Stapler based

What tool is that? I want one for work
Wenger Business Tool, I think.
Thank you

I just found some on evil bay, I won't be having one for work.
Yes, they are very prized possessions apparently :D
Great thread dks
I haven't really thought about how many different tools are based on different types of tools :o 
-
@WoodsDuck said:
Hm... What are they on ebay? There's one on Amazon right now for $34.95.Really :o
that is very reasonable :ahhh 
-
Hm... What are they on ebay? There's one on Amazon right now for $34.95.
Really :o
that is very reasonable :ahhh 
The model 60 was £71 delivered to the UK on evil bay. I saw the model 45 on amazon for £34
-
Let´s not forget shovel based tools (suited for heavy duty door opening as well)..

-
@Ron Who said:
Let´s not forget shovel based tools (suited for heavy duty door opening as well)..
Ooooh! I've heard there is a market for those!
How well does it store in an inner pocket?

Not too well, but there´s an extra small version for people depending on public transport :D
-
I'd add Axe based tools (like the Zippo axe based MT, or the Klecker Axe [KLAX], or Kershaw Tinder axe, Lil'Trucker, Trucker's Friend, ...)
and the Vise Grip based tool (LM Crunch, Schrade Vise Grips, IRWIN Vise Grip MT, Kershaw A100, Gerber Grappler...)
-
I'd add 'Garbage based'... reference most of my reviews in the 'Cheap and Cheerful' section.

And in all honesty, 'card based'. more about form factor. Swisscard and all the 'ninja card multitool' stuff.
-
@dks said:
I would also, now, add the screwdriver based multitool now, based on the Gerber centredrive. Despite having large pliers and bldae the main selling point is the central driver, that dominates the tool and its philosophy.
any disagreement on the classes proposed above ? [/b]Small disagreement.
Centerdrive is still a pliers base MT with driver being its selling point. -
The thing I find interesting, is that the main focus of a MT is normally what it does best, and you would hope it could nearly compare to a standalone tool in that department.
So ideally, to choose the right multitool for you, you would first think about what your basic primary needs are (keeping in mind that jack of all trades is master of none), and then finding a multitool that does those things well. In theory, the best would be something that speSmurfpillses in a few things, e.g. the Gerber centre drive has the pliers and the screwdriver; the skeletool and SOG duo has the knife and pliers, etc.
This was the reason for coming up with the idea of the scissors and pliers based multitool, which a company has made, because you wouldn't be skimping on either.
What I feel though is that MT makers can't help themselves in putting on a few extra tools, which are then invariably crappy, and often end up making the tool larger or bulkier - in my opinion, better to do a few things (i.e. still a multitool), but do them very well.
-
How about pliers/scissors, or a hybrid category?
The OUTU multi-tool has both, and neither is the focus of the design, but rather, the design is build around having both equally featured. -
To avoid having too many categories I will argue that all tools centered around a plier like action are in the same basic category regardless of the actual jaw implementation. The jaws can be pliers, scissors, locking pliers, branch cutters or similar, but the basic workings are similar.
It would be tempting to define it as everything focused around a pivot point and movable handles, but as not all pliers need to work around a pivot point that might become an issue later. A tool with focus on moveable handles used to multiply forces on at least two jaws might be a more catch all definition.
-
I would also, now, add the screwdriver based multitool now, based on the Gerber centredrive. Despite having large pliers and bldae the main selling point is the central driver, that dominates the tool and its philosophy.

any disagreement on the classes proposed above ? [/b]Small disagreement.
Centerdrive is still a pliers base MT with driver being its selling point.The powerduo (powerdud :) ) is also build on a pliers frame. Is it the frame or the focus/selling point that should guide the classification? Maybe we should talk about focus rather than just the structure?
Hybrids are difficult, as with the typical bike tool.
As Reamerpunch mentioned is the Spyderwrench or OUTU pliers or wrench based - the frame says pliers, the name in the spyderco/byrd model wrench, the look says both. It looks more like the pliers are added tot he wrench, rather than the other way round, but this is just how it looks, to me.
You can generalise with categories and just have the one-piece-tools and the moving-parts ones, maybe with a third category for the removable parts ones, though would a pliers tool with removable screwdrivers count as a moving parts tool, or as a removable parts tool.
-
@Vidar said:
To avoid having too many categories I will argue that all tools centered around a plier like action are in the same basic category regardless of the actual jaw implementation. The jaws can be pliers, scissors, locking pliers, branch cutters or similar, but the basic workings are similar.It would be tempting to define it as everything focused around a pivot point and movable handles, but as not all pliers need to work around a pivot point that might become an issue later. A tool with focus on moveable handles used to multiply forces on at least two jaws might be a more catch all definition.
something like the MP650 would fit that description perfectly. Removable head to add shears, pliers, and potentially other types of heads

-
I only need 2 categories, tools I own and tools I don't own.
-
@Alan K. said:
I only need 2 categories, tools I own and tools I don't own.:)
Not all that useful for others though :)
It seems to me that this will end up like some sort of classification tree. At the top all tools should fall in only one category, and dks is definately onto something with the simplifed approach mentioned above. I'd suggest just cutting to just top categories though - multi-part tools and one-piece tools. Tools with removable stuff would then naturally be multi-part tools, no tools would be able to fit both categories at once, and it is easy to see where something belongs.
From there it gets complicated as multi-tools do try to be many things at once with varying degrees of success and compromises at that. Most do have a clear real tool origin though, and one thing they do almost as good as specialized tools. (With actual function being more important than the looks I think). For all others there could be two catch all categories; some glorified jack-of-all-trades category for those that do several things well, and as Lynn suggested a garbage/ mangled frankenstein category for those that do nothing well?
Why are we categorizing by the way? Someone making a database?
-
No specific reason for the thread.
A lot of these categories have been in use for years and since I got a Centredrive recently I was wondering if there could be a screwdriver-centric/based category.
If someone wants to make a database then more power to them.
-
How about "magic mushrooms"-based tools like this thing of beauty? ???

::)

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login