Calling all Canucks
-
@Smashie said:
Would they be prohibited to own or just carry?If I am reading this right, and understand Def correctly, it means we from the US may not, nor the Russians by way of the Lomonosov Ridge, nor anyone from, say, Thule Greenland, and presumebly the same by it and sea - none may cross the border into Canada whilst carrying any of those knives described. Which unfortunately now seem to include swiss army knives and certain leatherman tools.
Once there, however, we may purchase them, own them, carry them, trade or sell them, and we may even cross the Canadian border back into our home countries or possibly any other country with them.
The additional fear being that this border restriction might someday be adopted as a national carry law in Canada
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Would they be prohibited to own or just carry?
As it is, it isn't a law. It is an interpretation by the border guards (CBSA= Canadian Border Services Agency) so at this point it is only importation of knives. So, there's only potentially a problem when playing in their neighborhood.
Def
When you say importation, I presume your mean personal importation. The CBSA have no authority to ban a knife nor the import in the commercial Freight Forwarding sense, of any item that is legal in Canada. That would require an act of Canada's legislative branch, I would think. They can only ban personal such items (or crates of contraband such items, which goes without say) from crossing the border, due to safety concerns of their officers, much the same way I can carry a leatherman all day, but not on a plane.
Right?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Would they be prohibited to own or just carry?
As it is, it isn't a law. It is an interpretation by the border guards (CBSA= Canadian Border Services Agency) so at this point it is only importation of knives. So, there's only potentially a problem when playing in their neighborhood.
Def
But it stops the import, so the same as a law but without having to go through all the hassle

Pretty much.
Def
-
@theonew said:
I just tried what you showed in the animated gif in the article with my One Hand Trekker and even flailing my arm wildly I can't get it to open all the way. I guess that just has to do with the pivot tension.The wording includes manual manipulation. If you look closely I open it halfway normally then flick it the rest of the way.
The test board also allowed numerous attempts and will fail the knife even if it takes 3-4 tries to snap it open.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Would they be prohibited to own or just carry?
As it is, it isn't a law. It is an interpretation by the border guards (CBSA= Canadian Border Services Agency) so at this point it is only importation of knives. So, there's only potentially a problem when playing in their neighborhood.
Def
When you say importation, I presume your mean personal importation. The CBSA have no authority to ban a knife nor the import in the commercial Freight Forwarding sense, of any item that is legal in Canada. That would require an act of Canada's legislative branch, I would think. They can only ban personal such items (or crates of contraband such items, which goes without say) from crossing the border, due to safety concerns of their officers, much the same way I can carry a leatherman all day, but not on a plane.
Right?
Wrong.
They have the authority and the latitude to interpret the laws any way they feel is necessary to effectively achieve their mandate.
Def
-
Y-yikes. I can see why this molehill could become a mountain in a hurry.
How the check can they do that, if their jurisdiction is border only, and they don't make law. I hate that crap.
Good luck up there
-
Reading those suggested rules again they will not even work as intended:
If they actually want to ban knives that can be opened quickly with one hand that is exactly what they should write. Instead they try to ban a few specific implementations to that end. Those will just end up being circumvented by other technical solutions offering the same quick one hand opening.
-
@theonew said:
I just tried what you showed in the animated gif in the article with my One Hand Trekker and even flailing my arm wildly I can't get it to open all the way. I guess that just has to do with the pivot tension.I can do it with my "German Army" OHT, but not my camo plain edge variant, which has a pretty stiff pivot. Probably the biggest discrepancy I've experienced in new Victorinox products.
-
So does this mean my Leatherman Wave is in trouble now? What a ridiculous thing that CBSA has the power to do.
-
I really can't contribute anything but my condolences. I'm so sorry, guys. We've also seen this dance, we all know how it ends.
-
@ironraven said:
I really can't contribute anything but my condolences. I'm so sorry, guys. We've also seen this dance, we all know how it ends.That might very well be, but if they bid up to dance then dancing might at least provide some damper to their worst moves. Leaving them well alone to regulate unchecked sounds scary.
It might have been those weird fumes I smelled in a confined space earlier today, but all of a sudden I feel all poetic and smurf:
Though wise men at their end know Raven is right,
Do not go gentle into that good fight,
Rage, rage against the dying of the right.(Free manglement of Dylan Thomas actually great poem
). -
If we're going to go with guerilla dogrel....
The more you hurt me, the more I bleed.
And every drop that falls shall be a seed. -
@ironraven said:
If we're going to go with guerilla dogrel....The more you hurt me, the more I bleed.
And every drop that falls shall be a seed.Interesting one. I hadn't heard that one before.
That said talking about hurting, bleeding and dripping might not be the best rally cry for accessible knives..? ::)

-
Wow! Canada, where most of the population likes the outdoors, camping, fishing, hunting. How do you select your judges?! Probably like we do, for the looks of it.

This can ban ANY knife. You can even flick open a Buck 110, if you hold the blade and flick the knife, letting the heavy handle open and lock in place.

-
See from 2m50s:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
You're smurfed! Big time!
:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
Another video about the same question (from 2013):
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
Yup. It's amazing how many knives this truly covers.
I have managed to open a Skeletool, Surge and numerous other mutitools this way, so many plier based tools will also be illegal to import.
Def
-
How can legislators be so good at making vague laws like this?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
