Alox or Celidor?
-
I've been using/carrying Celidor based SAKS for over 40-years and have never had a scale break or crack.
What the hell are you guys doing?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
I'm sorry to be the party pooper, but my vote is Nylon.
Sturdier than cellidor (I have broken 6 cellidor scales, either by dropping or crushing but no nylon to date) and more durable to chemicals, heat or damage. Cheaper too, but that's a very little thing to have in mind.
I prefer the grippier texture and tactile feel of nylon.
I like the color of it, maybe no more than the shiny cellidor red but it's very good looking to me. The car we had as a kid (Citröen Xsara Picasso) was exactly that same color, I guess it's nostalgia.then I like Alox, because of the sturdiness, thinness, looks, feel in hand. I don't mind having no T&T, I never use them and carry both on my FAK anyways.
Thirdly I like the **Cellidor + Rubber **scales from the Evogrips, Wenger S557 etc.
And finally normal Cellidor,
well, no, the ones I like the worst are the **Wood scales **(Evowood) and the all **Rubber **(OHO Solider) onesWell said. I've never had an aolx, but have other metal scaled tools. The cellidor is iconic, but nylon outcasts it and is cheaper. Alox must clearly be very durable, but is more expensive and has no backsliding tools
Don't wish to be a pusher man but if you've never had an alox model..... you should prawlbably do something about that... Pioneer's can be had on the cheap. :D
-
here's a link to an auction for a Pioneer... just in case :)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Victorinox-Silver-Alox-Pioneer-Swiss-Army-Knife-New-in-Box/202180630711?hash=item2f12e798b7:g:xAsAAOSwfVhaTX70and here's a brand new dark grey pioneer for $30 shipped: https://www.ebay.com/itm/VICTORINOX-Pioneer-Pocket-Knife-Dark-Gray-V-10127US2/142328307725?epid=0&hash=item21236da00d:g:7GcAAOSwXYtY2aWq
:D
-
I like both cellidor and alox... but been carrying alox mostly these days... no issues with T&T as I have them on my keybar... Don’t mind scale scratches too as they show character...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@El Corkscrew said:
here's a link to an auction for a Pioneer... just in case :)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Victorinox-Silver-Alox-Pioneer-Swiss-Army-Knife-New-in-Box/202180630711?hash=item2f12e798b7:g:xAsAAOSwfVhaTX70and here's a brand new dark grey pioneer for $30 shipped: https://www.ebay.com/itm/VICTORINOX-Pioneer-Pocket-Knife-Dark-Gray-V-10127US2/142328307725?epid=0&hash=item21236da00d:g:7GcAAOSwXYtY2aWq
:D
I just bought one of those dark gray pioneers yesterday. $30 was the best price I could find anywhere, even compared to the plain silver ones.
As for scale color...
For 58mm, I like transparent colored cellidor. It makes them kind of look like jewelry.
For 84/85mm, I like the plain red Cellidor, but red Nylon is fine. Although, I have a yellow/black Evogrip 16 that is SWEET looking.
For 91mm, my #1 preference, and what I put on my Super Tinker, is Stay Glow Nylon. That thing is VISIBLE! And the scales are not wearing out fast.
Backup to the Stayglow Nylon would be Red nylon, followed by Red Cellidor (not Ruby).For 93mm, I prefer (not like i have a choice) Alox, but with no color, if I can get them plain.
For the 111mm, I like red Nylon. I haven't been overly impressed with the dual material scales, and flat out HATE black as a scale color.
I have had issues of losing gear from dropping it in the woods. I prefer scales to assist in being found, not actively go all ninja on me.
Then again, I like Silvertech on the 91s. And I have a few blue 58s that are nice... And a few different colored 91s that are nice enough, I guess... And...

-
In order of preference:
1.**Titanium. **
2.Alox
3,Nylon
4.Celidor
-
Nylon: it's kinda ugly and flat in most colors but it's tough, doesn't scratch as easily, and still allows insert tools.
-
I've never owned a nylon scaled SAK.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
-
Cellidor. I can polish the scratches out.

-
@this_is_nascar said:
I've been using/carrying Celidor based SAKS for over 40-years and have never had a scale break or crack.What the hell are you guys doing?
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Try dropping it - even from a height of 10 feet - onto concrete and see if the cellidor doesn't crack or shatter
-
@this_is_nascar said:
I've never owned a nylon scaled SAK.Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
Better grip under wet conditions, and isn't brittle. I like my Camper II a lot. I wish they inlaid metal Vic symbols into it.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I'm sorry to be the party pooper, but my vote is Nylon.
Sturdier than cellidor (I have broken 6 cellidor scales, either by dropping or crushing but no nylon to date) and more durable to chemicals, heat or damage. Cheaper too, but that's a very little thing to have in mind.
I prefer the grippier texture and tactile feel of nylon.
I like the color of it, maybe no more than the shiny cellidor red but it's very good looking to me. The car we had as a kid (Citröen Xsara Picasso) was exactly that same color, I guess it's nostalgia.then I like Alox, because of the sturdiness, thinness, looks, feel in hand. I don't mind having no T&T, I never use them and carry both on my FAK anyways.
Thirdly I like the **Cellidor + Rubber **scales from the Evogrips, Wenger S557 etc.
And finally normal Cellidor,
well, no, the ones I like the worst are the **Wood scales **(Evowood) and the all **Rubber **(OHO Solider) onesWell said. I've never had an aolx, but have other metal scaled tools. The cellidor is iconic, but nylon outcasts it and is cheaper. Alox must clearly be very durable, but is more expensive and has no backsliding tools
Don't wish to be a pusher man but if you've never had an alox model..... you should prawlbably do something about that... Pioneer's can be had on the cheap. :D
Um...
-
New Pioneers are twice the cost of new cellidor. An even greater price difference between it and nylon. Y-yikes.
-
I like celidor for the traditional look, but I've never owned an Alox Sak to compare and I'm taking the " you don't miss what you never had approach" so I don't get sucked into that trap, I will stand up for nylon because I've been edcing the same nylon scaled Recruit for 25 plus years and it's held up well except for the Shield that is lost to time
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login