Some Interesting Facts about Alox
-
...maybe thats the reason why victorinox doesn
t answer questions on this forum or others because some take those infos too serious, like those at victorinox are the absolut experts and everything they say or write is perfect and absolutely correct. The people working there and putting infos together are just regular guys who want to know their own history better and sharing the infos with the community. Until some years, victorinox didnt care much about their history and identity. So they don`t have much infos on tool or knife evolution."Strenght and positivity" don`t mean that has nothing to do with christianity. Religious people would maybe consider those attributes as absolutly christian.
-
@ulli said:
...maybe thats the reason why victorinox doesnt answer questions on this forum or others because some take those infos too serious, like those at victorinox are the absolut experts and everything they say or write is perfect and absolutely correct. The people working there and putting infos together are just regular guys who want to know their own history better and sharing the infos with the community. Until some years, victorinox didnt care much about their history and identity. So they don`t have much infos on tool or knife evolution."Strenght and positivity" don`t mean that has nothing to do with christianity. Religious people would maybe consider those attributes as absolutly christian.
Sounds like a very good point.
-
@twiliter said:
What the cross represents is entirely up to you, but many flags use it and it's roots are a historical fact with provenance.https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_national_flags_depicting_a_cross
The Star of David also represents something, but if it means something different to a marginal amount of people, it doesn't mean that it's history is magically erased.

Nope but it doesn't necessarily mean that it is relevant either. If the choice of Victorinox was to use their countries national emblem to describe Swiss values described at positivity and strength then that is valid even if the historical symbolism behind the flag may have been different. The British flag also contains a cross but I doubt the use of the flag to show 'British made' has had any religious significance for centuries, The British flag when associated with a product usually meant (in the good old days) 'quality, engineering greatness, craftman built, etc'. Nowadays it means 'cheap junk made in China for tourists' ::). To determine that the Victorinox original use of their countries flag specifically had a religious connotation or message and describe their own statement denying this as revisionist requires more proof methinks.
I'd love to hear from the Swiss though on the subject. We're all rather guessing at this point. My brother in law is Swiss (born, bred and lives in Zurich) and when I asked him about this denied that the Swiss flag is considered to have any religious significant or connotation by the Swiss. Just one local opinion though.
Incidentally has anyone else noticed that google refuses to accept the existence or spelling of the word 'positivity'? :D
-
What the cross represents is entirely up to you, but many flags use it and it's roots are a historical fact with provenance.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_national_flags_depicting_a_cross
The Star of David also represents something, but if it means something different to a marginal amount of people, it doesn't mean that it's history is magically erased.

Nope but it doesn't necessarily mean that it is relevant either.
Relevance is notoriously subjective. The history of crosses on flags and why they are there is as relevant as you want, it's just history.
If the choice of Victorinox was to use their countries national emblem to describe Swiss values described at positivity and strength then that is valid...
They can describe it any way they want obviously, it's up to the reader to determine the validity. It's opinion if you ask me, the Vic shield based on the Swiss flag has layers of meaning that cannot be detached just because the history is either ignored or not within their body of knowledge.
To determine that the Victorinox original use of their countries flag specifically had a religious connotation or message and describe their own statement denying this as revisionist requires more proof methinks.
I don't think it's revisionist at all, it's just someone's version that leaves some things out. The cross is a culturally embedded symbol worldwide that represents something specific, recognizable, and generally agreed upon. There just isn't any way to separate out the cross from the Swiss flag or the Vic shield and say it represents nothing or something else entirely. The cross is what it is, and it it has layers of meaning, some more obvious and agreed upon than others. Like I said, you can personally have it mean whatever you want it to, in fact, I can say the cross represents the intersection down the street, but I would have a tough time getting people on board with that.
Cheers Ben, enjoying your thoughts on this!

-
Enjoying reading replies as well, agree or not.
Bear in mind, Vic COULD have simply said they put that symbol on the knife as a matter of national identity of a well- made Swiss product, and still not had to have mentioned the religious meaning behind the flag. Instead, they had to politically correctly BS the reader.
Whoever mentioned the V symbol being used in some markets, +1
-
What the cross represents is entirely up to you, but many flags use it and it's roots are a historical fact with provenance.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_national_flags_depicting_a_cross
The Star of David also represents something, but if it means something different to a marginal amount of people, it doesn't mean that it's history is magically erased.

Nope but it doesn't necessarily mean that it is relevant either.
Relevance is notoriously subjective. The history of crosses on flags and why they are there is as relevant as you want, it's just history.
If the choice of Victorinox was to use their countries national emblem to describe Swiss values described at positivity and strength then that is valid...
They can describe it any way they want obviously, it's up to the reader to determine the validity. It's opinion if you ask me, the Vic shield based on the Swiss flag has layers of meaning that cannot be detached just because the history is either ignored or not within their body of knowledge.
To determine that the Victorinox original use of their countries flag specifically had a religious connotation or message and describe their own statement denying this as revisionist requires more proof methinks.
I don't think it's revisionist at all, it's just someone's version that leaves some things out. The cross is a culturally embedded symbol worldwide that represents something specific, recognizable, and generally agreed upon. There just isn't any way to separate out the cross from the Swiss flag or the Vic shield and say it represents nothing or something else entirely. The cross is what it is, and it it has layers of meaning, some more obvious and agreed upon than others. Like I said, you can personally have it mean whatever you want it to, in fact, I can say the cross represents the intersection down the street, but I would have a tough time getting people on board with that.
Cheers Ben, enjoying your thoughts on this!

I think the correct solution to this is the following: MTO sends a deputation to Switzerland (all expenses paid) to look into the matter in great depth. I'll volunteer of course and to show objectivity I think that you should join me. To round out this purely academic pursuit (we will NOT be visiting the beautiful scenery or eating the incredible Swiss sausage, neither will we be spending considerable amounts of time in the Victorinox factory being pampered by management and given freebies!), I think we should be joined by others who only have the pursuit of truth at heart. Names that spring to mind are ThundahBeagle, Ron Who, Ulli and Professor Pabs (who is also incidentally the Dalai Lama thereby providing automatic good will).
Anyone object? Good. When do we book the tickets?
Results of our in depth study will be posted up as soon as we're all sober. This may take a while.
-
Count me in!

I may never come home though... :D
-
Sounds very interesting. :D
-
ahem
Hmmmm....mi, mi, mi, mi, miiii.Yodel - eh - HEEEE - hooooo!
Yep. I'm ready to go.
-
I had always believed the Red Cross took their cross symbol directly from the Swiss flag as recognition of the Geneva convention, they just inverted the colours so i'm not so sure its intended to be a religious symbol, it is generally seen as such though, hence the Red Crescent.
I'm guessing the Swiss flag originated from battle flags but then you would wonder why there would be a cross on a battle flag..i'm pretty sure that would be for religious reasons, perhaps we will never know
If you guys are chartering a bus to go to Switzerland save me a seat
-
@Borg said:
I had always believed the Red Cross took their cross symbol directly from the Swiss flag as recognition of the Geneva convention, they just inverted the colours so i'm not so sure its intended to be a religious symbol, it is generally seen as such though, hence the Red Crescent.
I'm guessing the Swiss flag originated from battle flags but then you would wonder why there would be a cross on a battle flag..i'm pretty sure that would be for religious reasons, perhaps we will never know
If you guys are chartering a bus to go to Switzerland save me a seat
Private helicopter, please!
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
ahem
Hmmmm....mi, mi, mi, mi, miiii.Yodel - eh - HEEEE - hooooo!
Yep. I'm ready to go.
The internal train system in Zurich airport has a soundtrack going as it runs. You hear tinkling cow bells, a yoddle or two and then........long pause then........a very loud and distinct cow moo-ing. Honestly I'm sure there's more to be proud of in Switzerland than a cow!
People couldn't work out why I always burst out laughing at that point (been through there many times). Why not have a soundtrack of rifle shooting to celebrate the country with the highest gun ownership in Europe coupled with some of the least crime? :D -
@jazzbass said:
From Jaya's link:Smooth Alox scales
We all know and love the Alox scales with their trademark ribbed finish and bright colors. But in the 1990s, Victorinox released a 91mm Alox Officers knife with blue scales exclusively for the Dutch Army. This was actually the only 91 mm Officers knife ever released with Alox scales and even more unusual, the scales themselves were completely smooth. Soon we found that they scratched and marked quicker than the traditional ribbed Alox scales, so production of these knives was discontinued. Today they are quite a collector’s item.Wow. This is a weird factoid, because a lot of is it fairly inaccurate or misleading.
.- They discontinued them because they discovered the smooth alox scratches easily? Seriously? Victorinox has made knives with smooth alox handles from at least the late 1930s (in the 84mm Pocket Pal/Secretary line) and from the 1960s-1980s with the smooth alox 84mm advertising knives. I think its safe to assume they knew how easily they scratched well before 1990.
That's what I was thinking...

You should have written this blurb, JB! :D

-
@El Corkscrew said:
From Jaya's link:
Smooth Alox scales
We all know and love the Alox scales with their trademark ribbed finish and bright colors. But in the 1990s, Victorinox released a 91mm Alox Officers knife with blue scales exclusively for the Dutch Army. This was actually the only 91 mm Officers knife ever released with Alox scales and even more unusual, the scales themselves were completely smooth. Soon we found that they scratched and marked quicker than the traditional ribbed Alox scales, so production of these knives was discontinued. Today they are quite a collector’s item.Wow. This is a weird factoid, because a lot of is it fairly inaccurate or misleading.
.- They discontinued them because they discovered the smooth alox scratches easily? Seriously? Victorinox has made knives with smooth alox handles from at least the late 1930s (in the 84mm Pocket Pal/Secretary line) and from the 1960s-1980s with the smooth alox 84mm advertising knives. I think its safe to assume they knew how easily they scratched well before 1990.
That's what I was thinking...

You should have written this blurb, JB! :D

JB on the team to teach Victorinox their history!
-
@El Corkscrew said:
From Jaya's link:
Smooth Alox scales
We all know and love the Alox scales with their trademark ribbed finish and bright colors. But in the 1990s, Victorinox released a 91mm Alox Officers knife with blue scales exclusively for the Dutch Army. This was actually the only 91 mm Officers knife ever released with Alox scales and even more unusual, the scales themselves were completely smooth. Soon we found that they scratched and marked quicker than the traditional ribbed Alox scales, so production of these knives was discontinued. Today they are quite a collector’s item.Wow. This is a weird factoid, because a lot of is it fairly inaccurate or misleading.
.- They discontinued them because they discovered the smooth alox scratches easily? Seriously? Victorinox has made knives with smooth alox handles from at least the late 1930s (in the 84mm Pocket Pal/Secretary line) and from the 1960s-1980s with the smooth alox 84mm advertising knives. I think its safe to assume they knew how easily they scratched well before 1990.
That's what I was thinking...

You should have written this blurb, JB! :D

Same hardness of anodize so same scratching ability, its just that on textured (especially colored) you dont notice it as much.
I have no doubt that jazzbass knows more about SAKs than anyone working at Vic today. :D Its not the first time Ive seen something written I didnt agree with.
While we are on the subject, I used to think that none of the liners on a standard cellidor were anodized, but the liner adjacent to the blade for sure is clear anodized (you can tell with conductivity test). No other liners are, but why did they do just that one liner and still do it currently? All current cellidor blade liners are indeed alox.
-
@Syph007 said:
While we are on the subject, I used to think that none of the liners on a standard cellidor were anodized, but the liner adjacent to the blade for sure is clear anodized (you can tell with conductivity test). No other liners are, but why did they do just that one liner and still do it currently? All current cellidor blade liners are indeed alox.I didn't know that.
Really odd.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
While we are on the subject, I used to think that none of the liners on a standard cellidor were anodized, but the liner adjacent to the blade for sure is clear anodized (you can tell with conductivity test). No other liners are, but why did they do just that one liner and still do it currently? All current cellidor blade liners are indeed alox.
I didn't know that.
Really odd.

The only thing I can think of is the blade steel is different than the rest of the tool's steel and there is an adverse reaction between the blade and bare aluminum liner. Although that cant be it either since the outer liner the scale snaps onto is not anodized.
-
I had always believed the Red Cross took their cross symbol directly from the Swiss flag as recognition of the Geneva convention, they just inverted the colours so i'm not so sure its intended to be a religious symbol, it is generally seen as such though, hence the Red Crescent.
I'm guessing the Swiss flag originated from battle flags but then you would wonder why there would be a cross on a battle flag..i'm pretty sure that would be for religious reasons, perhaps we will never know
If you guys are chartering a bus to go to Switzerland save me a seat
Private helicopter, please!
Um, Lear Jet please!
-
@Borg said:
I had always believed the Red Cross took their cross symbol directly from the Swiss flag as recognition of the Geneva convention, they just inverted the colours so i'm not so sure its intended to be a religious symbol, it is generally seen as such though, hence the Red Crescent.
I'm guessing the Swiss flag originated from battle flags but then you would wonder why there would be a cross on a battle flag..i'm pretty sure that would be for religious reasons, perhaps we will never know
If you guys are chartering a bus to go to Switzerland save me a seat
By that, yes, at the first Geneva convention. Original red cross was started by a man in Geneva whose family was indeed very religious and also was influential in society, while expecting social work to be a part of daily life.
So he was indeed a devout Christian. Durant, I think his name was.
He took it upon himself to start helping troops on both sides of a battle he witnessed in Italy in the mid 1800's and soon thereafter the Red Cross was born
-
This is my first real post here on the MTO forum. I collect SAKs and I'm very interested in their evolution. I know this place for quite a few years and I learned a lot from reading posts here. Although I usually prefer to just read and learn, this thread touches something that I researched a little bit (by observing the SAKs in my collection), so it seems appropriate to point out what I know.
@Pablo O'Brien said:
While we are on the subject, I used to think that none of the liners on a standard cellidor were anodized, but the liner adjacent to the blade for sure is clear anodized (you can tell with conductivity test). No other liners are, but why did they do just that one liner and still do it currently? All current cellidor blade liners are indeed alox.
I didn't know that.
Really odd.

According to my observations, it's indeed true that recent (since some point in the late 1980's) regular-line 91mm Victorinox SAKs have exactly one anodized liner as Syph007 describes. It's the internal liner of the blades layer (namely, the central liner on a Spartan). The full picture, however, is more complex and is part the SAK evolution.
Victorinox used to anodize all aluminum liners of their 91mm and 84mm SAKs since around their official switch to aluminum liners in the very early 1950's (I'm not sure what was before then) to some point in the early 1970's (1973?). Then they completely stopped anodizing the liners of SAKs in the Elinox/Economy/Ecoline line. This change may have coincided (at least roughly) with the other changes that were made to this line around that time (change of tang stamps from big ELINOX over a crossbow to small ELINOX-SWITZERLAND-STAINLESS-ROSTFREI, change of corkscrew to a special economy version, change to polished openers, etc.). It persists to this day, so that except for the use of nylon scales, current ecoline/II versions of 91mm Victorinox SAKs differ from their regular-line versions also by lacking the anodized liner.
Anodizing of all liners persisted for regular-line SAKs until sometime in the late 1980's (1988-89?), at which time Victorinox stopped anodizing all of their liners except for the above mentioned single liner that still gets anodized on regular-line 91mm SAKs.
The next change involved only 84mm knives. They stopped anodizing all liners on all 84mm knives, so that current 84mm SAKs have no anodized liners at all. I don't really know when this happened. Possibly 2005, but for all I know it may have been several years earlier or later (I simply don't have enough 84mm SAKs to determine this at present).
As far as I can tell, Wenger never anodized any liners in their SAKs. This seems to persist for the Victorinox Delemont line.
I have no idea what happens with other sizes (like 111mm) of Victorinox knives that have some aluminum liners.
Finally, while I don't really know why they keep anodizing the particular single liner that they do on 91mm SAKs, my personal theory is that this is due to this liner having an exposed portion (next to the corkscrew/Phillips SD) that is visible and also tends to get easily scratched. Anodizing the corresponding liner usually helps to make this exposed portion look a bit nicer on used SAKs.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login