The Mil-K or 'Demo' knife (Lynn's $10 MT Challenge)
-
Part two of blade testing.
I spent another 20 minutes on the blade this morning, trying to get the edge better. Seems okay.
Then I went back to the cardboard test. and...
MOTHER... SMURFING... SMURFER!
Three strokes into the cardbaord test, the blade starts dragging through the cardboard again, ripping, instead of cutting. I do another 20 or so cuts, and take it back to thin paper (phonebook paper this time, because I'm all out of receipt paper). Dull as Flurg!
Two things come to mind. First, one of Murphy's Laws: "Remember, your weapon was made by the lowest bidder". Apparently, so was your pocket knife. And two... I used to wonder, seeing pictures of old pocket knives where the blade had been sharpened so often that it was just a nub. Well, NOW I know why anyone would have to sharpen a knife that often. Because they are apparently made of POT METAL!!!

I sharpened it again... with equal difficulty. I'm not running the cut test again.
Blade as basic cutting tool: The most marginal pass ever.
Blade for edge retention: FAIL, FAIL, FAIL, FAIL, FAIL, FAIL! SMURF YOU, YOU COMPLETE PIECE OF GARBAGE!!What I'm about to say is not even slightly exaggerating. This is the worst knife blade I have ever experienced. Ever. Even compared to the $1 Dollar Tree knife, and every cheap SAK-knockoff I've ever had.
On to something that hopefully works, I guess...
-
I thought this was an interesting thing about this knife. Here it is, compared to the cheap Chinese Marble's Camp Knife, when you look at their ends.
The knife on the left has much more precise machining on the ends. It's not as apparent in the photos, but the layers along the spine is also much better made on the knife on the left. However, the formation of the clevis is somewhat better on the knife on the right.
Now, would you like to guess which is the Marble's Camp Knife, and which is the legendary Camillus Mil-K knife?
Correct. The knife on the RIGHT is the authentic Mil-K knife.
Smurf me.

-
I for one bow to
our superiorthe better chinese manufacturers. :D -
Is there anything POSITIVE I can say about the blade?
Yes.
It is a very STURDY blade. The taper of the blade toward the point along the back spine is very mild for most of the blade, then quickly reducing at the tip. This makes the blade very stiff. It is stiffer than the blade on the 93mm Victorinox Pioneer (equivalent to what would have been the Soldier knife of the same timeframe). Blade retention is somewhat weaker in the Mil-K compared to a (brand new) Pioneer, but that's maybe not a fair comparison, of a knife made in 1981 vs. a brand new (I mean, I bought it 2 weeks ago) Pioneer.
Not exactly a saving grace, but something.
-
Leaving behind the blade testing, shaking off that experience, and coming at this freshly enthused to find something good on this tool...
Let's move on to the flathead driver/Cap lifter.
I've mentioned before, but the retention in closed position is REALLY strong. Nearing to 'nail breaker'. It feels like a fair bit more than the retention strength on a new Victorinox Pioneer in the open position. I think this is the strongest tool retention in the open position I've come across. This gives the tool a very solid feel when using the screwdriver with some effort.
The head of the screwdriver is very well formed.

This is a point where it clearly beats the Marbles knock-off, which had a flathead tip that was overly rounded.
Maybe before going any further, I need to address a rumor about the Mil-K knife. Some people thought that it was called a 'Demo Knife' because it was non-magnetic, and could be used to disarm landmines. Well...

My example is magnetized, and fairly strongly. It will pick up paperclips or screws and the like easily.
Probably best to leave demolition work to the 'anti-explosion pliers'. :D Previously reviewed here...
</topic/75224One other point. The tool does not sit parallel to the scales of the tool in closed position. It 'bends' slightly to the left. This is intentional. I mention this because I don't want folks to think that a particular test I do bends the tool out of shape. Sorry this isn't the best pic.

Alright, so, how is it as a flathead screwdriver? I put it against the screws I usually use for testing. First, the faceplate of a light switch, then against the larger screws in the hinge of a door.

It slots cleanly into screws, and holds well, without camming out. It feels extremely solid even under fair force. The reach on the tool is very nice.
Against the crusty-paint-can pry test, it was effortlessly successful.

In fact, it was so good at this, that, against my instincts, I tried a more brutal test, sticking it between two 2x10 boards, and testing to see how far I could bend it. When i do this, I don't just keep going until the tool breaks. I have an idea of how far I want to push it. 15-20 degrees, then see if it's permanently deformed, or it springs back.

I had mixed results here. The tool flexed and returned to its original shape. Well done.

However, there was a bit of side-to-side blade-play after the test, meaning I probably stretched the pins a bit. This didn't surprise me. It was a bit of a torture test, and I don't tend to do it with tools held together with brass pins.
Overall, this means that the tool handles a LOT more than most pocket knives would as a pry tool. The Marbles knock-off did better, but it has steel pins, not Nickel Silver. For those that don't know, 'Nickel Silver' is a brass alloy.
So, it's a good screw driver, and good light pry tool, but how is it at opening bottles?
This is one of the best cap lifters I've ever seen on a multitool. That's a weird point of praise, but...
I guess you take the good where you can find it. The only cap lifter I've seen that was clearly better was the one on the Gerber Dime.I guess the military had it's priorities. :D
I honestly don't know how the flathead/caplifter could be made better in a tool this size. I actually LIKE that it's magnetized. You could use it to pick up screws that have fallen into small spaces. It is robust, has great retention, great prying ability.
Flathead screwdriver: Pass with distinction
Flathead for light pry duty: Solid Pass
Cap Lifter: Pass with distinction. -
This is the can opener on the Mil-K. How can I tell?
Because I can READ.
Like with many other things surrounding the Mil-K knife, there are legends concerning WHY the words 'CAN OPENER' are stamped on the can opener. The one that seems to be most prevalent is that the Allies, in WWII, feared that if a soldier was captured with one of these, the enemy would presume some nefarious 'implement of torture' function for this tool, and so they were clearly labeled to prevent this. And that's the MOST reasonable story I heard. A more humorous one was that you had to label them because you were issuing them to the idiots in (fill in the military branch you wanted to make fun of). A bit like the jokes around the 'This side toward enemy' label on the claymore mine.
I wrote this in the review of the Marbles copy of the Mil-K, but I thought it bore repeating.
@Lynn LeFey said:
The can opener... was designed specifically for the Mil-K knife, and the patent held by Imperial. Imperial and Ulster together formed a company called 'Kingston' solely to fill their military knife contracts. The can opener design was known as the 'Safety Can Opener'. I would call it a great leap ahead in can opener design, compared to previous versions. I would go further in saying that it lives on to this day as the basic design of the can opener on most Leatherman tools, and WAS the same basic design as that on the Wenger knives.This one works fine.
Can Opener: Pass
-
Final implement, the awl.
Unlike essentially every awl on every modern tool, the awl on the Mil-K knife is concave on one side. I wanted to do this test without sharpening the edge of this tool, even with it being a bit ragged-feeling.
I skipped the leather punch test, feeling very confident that it would do it effortlessly, and went straight for the wood boring test. Could it drill a hole through a half-inch thick piece of aged Ash?
Yes. It did so very quickly, too. I would guess that it was pretty close to the same speed I'd see from a Victorinox Awl. Top notch awl.
I... uhh... I COULD stand for it to have a little more retention. I got a little zealous toward the end, and leaned in hard. The awl collapsed, and my left index finger paid the price. Warning, the picture contains a little blood. Not loads, but I know some people are squeamish.
Spoiler:

Sorry the picture is a little blurry, but I was trying to take it fast, so I could get to a sink, and not drip blood all over my carpet.
Ergonomics on this thing are not great. The ends of the tool, as has been shown previously, are not well formed, and they bite into your palms when you press hard on the awl. Still, it got the job done. It DOES require caution. I had two near-miss collapses, and one full collapse resulting in a class-1 boo-boo.
-
The last function of the tool is the Clevis. I'm just going to quote from the Marble's Camp Knife review, since it's the same.
@Lynn LeFey said:
And that really just leaves the Clevis. You can call it a bail or shackle if you want. The Mil-K spec says 'clevis'.
It is solid. I don't know how I feel about it. Sometimes it feels like it's in the way. It WILL fold pretty well clear of any tool, but you have to fold it away, instead of just getting to your tool immediately. If you need a lanyard to ensure that you don't lose a tool, the clevis is a very secure connection point. I understand that it was a great addition to the tool for comms guys in the military who had to string wire. They would throw a line over a branch, using the Mil-K knife as their weight. The closest modern equivalent I can think of is throwing a line while hiking to string up a bear bag. I suppose this could be done with the split ring on most SAKs and SAK-like knives, but none of those seem nearly as sturdy as this clevis.Now... okay, don't laugh. This brings up a strange possible application for this knife. I have gone on and on (and ON and ON) about just how bad, how utterly stupid it is to consider pocket knives as a self defense tool. Except this one. Not as a blade, but as part of a Kusari-fundo, a weight on a short length of chain (or possibly strong cord). If this knife were on a lanyard, or 2 or so feet of light chain, I would take it 10 times out of 10 over a blade of any reasonable length for self defense. Considering the stoutness of the clevis, I don't think it would break being used in that way.
With that said, there's really just a matter of asking if this is worth it. Do I think it's in the running for best tool at or under $10. No. There. I said it. The Mil-K knife has a long, interesting history. It spanned a service life of something like 60 years. That's an amazing feat. But I'm sure that the quality among the numerous manufacturers of the tool over that time... uhh... 'varied'. I'm sure there are great examples of this tool out there. This isn't one of them. This tool is... bad. IT has some great features, and it is very sturdy, but if you are a 'Knife, Pocket, General Purpose', then your first and most vital function is as a KNIFE, and AS a knife, this thing is pretty much garbage. The funny thing is that everything else worked fine.
If you want to own an interesting bit of American history, then sure, get one. If you want a TOOL to use... then at very least avoid the 1981 Camillus-made version. It's not good.
I would go so far as to say the Marble's Camp Knife is better. It's better crafted, and while it ALSO had a somewhat defective grind on the blade, it wasn't nearly so bad as this one. It can also repeatably be had at the $10 price point. And if you wreck it, you're not destroying anything of any historic value.
If you want a legitimate American Made modern version of this, I found at least one, and possibly two manufacturers.
Colonial Knives makes one. The cheapest I could find it (new) was for $28.95
https://www.jensentools.com/colonial-knife-2205-military-scout-knife/p/479-798Failing that, you can go directly to the Colonial Knife Corp's site to buy it (for about $35)
https://www.colonialknifecorp.com/products/military-scout-knife-2205Also, there SEEMS to be another manufacturer of the Mil-K. As far as I can tell, they're not just rebranding the Colonial-made knife, but I haven't confirmed that. There is a $29 version from Guideboat.
http://www.guideboat.com/2205-military-scout-knife.htmlThe reason I can't tell if it's one manufacturer or two is that the awl are different when comparing the pic on Colonial's web site to the one on Guideboat's, but when i search on-line images, there are pics where the awls are the same, and fairly distinctive. I presume that Colonial makes them, updated it a bit, and didn't change the picture. But I don't know this to be 100% true.
I am not endorsing either. I don't own either, and haven't had them in-hand. They could be utter garbage. I don't know. Or they could be amazing. I'm just putting this here as alternatives to shelling out $35 for a beat-up version of the Camillus knives on ebay. Because I CAN (and just have) tell you what the Camillus knife is like.
Oh... yeah... also... For sale: A GENUINE Camillus 1981 Mil-K 'Demo' knife. $10+S&H. You will almost certainly not be able to find one cheaper. May have some genuine Lynn blood on it.

-
that awl...

the sacrifices you do for us shall not be forgotten

our fingers thank you
-
For a point of note. I had been trying to remember the word for the strange 'bend' in the blades of this tool. I mean the intentionally manufactured 'bend'. It is called 'Crinking'. I mentioned it most notably with the Flathead driver.
-
so..... Excellent 10 dollar bottle opener????
-
@Higgins617 said:
so..... Excellent 10 dollar bottle opener????Absolutely TOP NOTCH!

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
so..... Excellent 10 dollar bottle opener????
Absolutely TOP NOTCH!

Quick change in branding and well be calling it the best multifunction bottle opener money can buy!
-
I feel your pain on the folded awl- I've been there, but usually with a screwdriver on a SAK, coupled with a tough screw and a moment's inattention. :ahhh
Then there was the time I was using a PST II to drill a hole into something and the serrated blade folded right into the end of my middle finger. The look on the doctor's face when I asked him if I'd be able to keep driving with an injured middle finger was priceless, and almost worth the stitches.

Great review- I have a couple of these knives but almost never do anything with them as they seem more like a bigger,bulkier, heavier, less effective Soldier than anything else.
Def
-
I got a new sharpening system in today, largely because of this knife. I'm not the best sharpener in the world, and that gets worse when the blade needs serious work. This one needed serious work.
So after assembling the new sharpener, I set to work on the Mik-K knife, to see if i could fix the uneven grind.
And in fairly short order, I'd guess half an hour, including learning curve of using the sharpener, I had it looking pretty good to my eye. I gave it the paper cut test and it did fine, then back to corrugated cardboard.

Then back to the paper cut test, both thin receipt paper and phonebook paper, and it would still cut both.
I was VERY aggressive with the coarser stones, to get this edge into shape. Even after the work I'd done before, it still needed a lot more.
However...
Blade: PASS... after a LOT of work.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I have a couple of these knives but almost never do anything with them as they seem more like a bigger,bulkier, heavier, less effective Soldier than anything else.I think that would 100% sum up my impressions as well.
Given the money, I would ALWAYS go with a Vic Soldier/Pioneer, but I could not even come close to finding one for $10, so...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





