GEC knives; good for the money
-
@hiraethus said:

L-R: #14 Lick Creek boys knife, #66 Calf Roper, #15 Crown Lifter, #71 Bullnose, #47 Hayn' helperYou've got pretty good taste haven't you... you're alright...

Calf Roper and Crown Lifter especially... especially the Crown Lifter!
-
I watched a factory tour video, they were never on my radar before then, but they sure are now.......
What stunned me were the prices, these are expensive little knives........way out of my price range, not criticizing their prices but I am a little surprised they "get away with it".
Maybe someday I can find a 2nd hand one I can afford.......but I don't want one.......I want most of them

So that answers how&why they get away with it

-
@Fuzzbucket said:
You've got pretty good taste haven't you... you're alright...
Calf Roper and Crown Lifter especially... especially the Crown Lifter!
Thanks Fuzzy.

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
a little surprised they "get away with it".They are very good quality and reasonable value for money - about 50% more than an equivalent Case, and better finished. What's most impressive is the way they've cultivated the market, releasing what amounts to limited edition knives to a growing group of trad enthusiasts. They might only make a few hundred of a particular pattern - or a few dozen of an SFO (Special Factory Order) and then not make any more of that type for several years. Their production totals are interesting: http://greateasterncutlery.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/2016-PRODUCTION-TOTALS.pdf for example.
-
Frankly, I've owned three or four GECs, and the blade play varied between “noticeable” to “incredibly annoying”. None of them was what I would call without play. They are very pretty knives, but not for me. What GEC cares about is not the same as I care about. I have better experience with e.g. Case. Just wanted to add an YMMV to the other voices here.
-
@Steinar said:
What GEC cares about is not the same as I care about.Agree 100%. I think you hit the nail on the head.
I have a few GECs, and would say for me, I have about a 95% satisfaction rate. The few faults could be repaired by me (2nd grinds, sharpness out of the box), or were not really that big enough of a deal for me to send the knife back (spring tension, jigging pattern burn outs, blade rub). There was a time when new out of the box a GEC would barely cut paper and you had to sharpen it yourself. If someone came to GEC out of precision made modern flippers, a lot of that would be unacceptable.
When they first started up, people were hungry for tight, high quality slipjoints. There was much maligning Case and nostalgia for the good old days, and along came GEC with superior product. I think a lot of the hype was well deserved, but some of it also was honeymoon sentiment. To expect perfection from anything is a fool's errand.
As a side note, I think Case and Queen have upped their game a bit since GEC came out.
Anyway, it's important to keep a scope to what you expect from a knife/purchase. I don't have a 95% satisfaction rate from many other companies or brands. A good amount of the criticism given to pocketknives is so far off my radar that a negative YouTube review is meaningless to me, other than to see the knife in hand.
-
Queen? the understanding was that they only upped their prices, before closing shop...
-
Lil' guy[emoji4]

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
-
Lil' guy[emoji4]

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
That too is bloody nice! (I've just commented on your buck Post).
Thanks[emoji4][emoji111]
Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
-
innocent times, when I only had 2 GECs....
-
-
Nearly, automatically in a way,bought a 33 the other day before remembering that I have one from the original run and do not really want or need another one.
-
You can always flip it !
-
I read thru this thread a little while ago. Good read and some comments seem similar to my own ( I don't own a GEC folder ). I have a few traditionals so when I read about GEC I do feel compelled to try one of their traditional folder offerings. When I ordered my first new Case I was very disappointed. The bolsters were horrendous. The tip of the blade was mangled. The knife honestly looked like it had been carried and used really well. I was terribly disappointed. I sent it back hoping they'd make it right. They did and I am very happy.
I am still looking at GEC folders but its a bit annoying as they get snapped up so quick. I am not going to pay double on the secondary market. Whats left on some sites are the knives that clearly didn't sell to collectors. I liked the Dixie Stockman but if I'm gonna pay the asking price I want the covers I like not what has not sold.
Truth is when I look thru whats left on sites, I'm happy with my Case Psalm 23 Trapper and Mini Trapper. I also enjoy my Schatt and Morgan and Camillus 64.
I do think theres something to be said ( believe me I know ) about just wanting. We get to a stage where the next "level" up is part of he process of this hobby.
GEC has a great business and a loyal following. I've seen the video how how they produce their knives which is pretty cool. They really seem to care about quality.
At $70US for a Case and $100-$150 for a GEC ( price range I'm looking at ) it would seem for the $30 to double the price I'd need to really want one. I think I'll keep looking and see if I can pick up one closer to $100 before I commit to double the price of a Case ( all things considered ).
-
In my opinion the 71, bullnose is the best GEC. Consistent quality, reasonably priced and available regularly. A working knife that looks good.
I did a comparison with case and queen etc. models a while ago and it was my choice. The 1095 they use now does not seem to keep an edge as well as the O1 they had originally but it is still a solid knife, and one of my 2, 3 most used slipjoints. If only they made it in SS too.You can usually get what you want if you look around a bit, for regular prices. Most people just focus on the few dealers that are allowed to advertise on BF, or expect the knife to land on their lap, without looking a bit for it.
People were moaning about the 33, and I was seeing several, including stag, on sale at a dealer 99 to 100 USD.
Gone yesterday, but they were available for a few days. -
I do like my Case Sod buster Jr. Thanks dks, I agree just got to be persistent looking around and jump when found.
-
Some GEC knives sell quicker than others. One must be determined and fast to score these days. I remember years ago when GEC's sat on dealers selves for many months. These were small runs. Some of these same knives are selling for $300 to $700 today. :D
-
The pricing of older ones is tricky. What many don't realise is that in the early days (late 2000s, GEC is a new company) the numbers per variant were quite small, 50 was a big run (GEC publishes totals), so they don't show up for auction often, if ever, for a price to be established.
I have a few older ones that, depending on the day, may be valued highly being old and not available, or lowly as they are not the current desirasble/fashionable models.Even a relatively new one, like my stag 33, from the original run, with 440C steel may be worth less than the newer ones to someone that wants to have and show the new fashionable model and wants 1095 steel.
Someone that wants SS and the first edition, smaller production model may pay more.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



