Used Victorinox Huntsman (Lynn's $10 MT Challenge)
-
The can opener and cap lifter...
The can opener is in great shape on this tool. The edge has no nicks or damage. The rim hook is in good condition. I would expect it to perform like any Victorinox, leaving a clean cut with no gouges on the inside of the can.
And that's what it did. It got to open 1/3 of a small coffee can. Only 1/3 because it has to share the can with two other contestants. I've only GOT the one can, you understand. I can only drink so much coffee, people!
On to the cap lifter.
Again, this is in fine working condition. And again I'd expect it to make easy work of a cap.
And again it does. I said this in the review of the Explorer. I've opened literally hundreds of bottles with a 91mm cap lifter, and they are very good at it.
BONUS OPENER!! Can't get your fingernail under the tab of a pop top aluminum can? Use the backside hook tool!

Openers: all PASS!
-
The saw and awl
I'm going to be honest. I get a little tired of doing the exact same tests on tools every time. I understand that for comparison, you should keep things consistent, but this tool was going to test like any other Victorinox in good condition for saw and awl, so I skipped the 'bore hole in 1/2" Ash', and 'saw 1" Ash limb' tests. Instead...
I wanted to see how well the awl would punch through industrial plastic.

This is my old trash can. I should chop it up and recycle it, but I haven't yet. But it also doesn't matter if I punch holes in it. This required fair force, with slow, steady pressure, and the awl just gradually pushed through, A few turns reamed the hole out with very little effort.
The edge on the awl has no nicks or damage, and is quite sharp. I doubt it's been used before I owned it.
Then I turned my sights on the saw.
So... uhh... yeah... OBVIOUSLY I'm not a great carpenter...

That is a terrible, wonky cut through dimensional lumber, but it went through. First... WOW, this thing eats through pine WAY faster than ash or oak, and second... WOW is that still a lot of effort. This is not a saw you're going to use to build a house. I used this size saw when working as an electrician's assistant. Sometimes we'd have to notch rafters or enlarge drilled holes to run electrical lines through. It works GREAT for that kind of stuff. I didn't notice any dulling of the saw from this, and really wouldn't expect to, but I've tested so many cheap saws, I still have my eye out for it.
And again, the 4-layer thickness gave a good hold on the tool while using the saw.
Saw: PASS
Awl: PASSIf you want to see some other kinds of tests done with these or any other functions on a tool, feel free to make suggestions.
-
What's left?
Toothpick, tweezers, and corkscrew.
I'm sorry to say that i can't test the corkscrew. But it's in fine condition, with good peening, and I'm certain it works as intended. I've opened a number of bottles of wine with the corkscrew on a 91mm Victorinox before, and I have every confidence in this one.
Toothpick. It's there, and in good shape. This is a used knife, and ... nah. Don't feel like using a used toothpick.
Tweezers. The test I use on tweezers is if they can grasp a hair well enough to pluck it without cutting the hair in the process. This passes that test, having good grip, but not being too sharp.
If I haven't mentioned it before, this tool comes in at 98g (3.46oz).
I guess the last note on function is that the split ring is present and in good shape, should you wish to attach a lanyard.
Final thoughts to follow.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
The saw and awl...
Then I turned my sights on the saw.
So... uhh... yeah... OBVIOUSLY I'm not a great carpenter...

That is a terrible, wonky cut through dimensional lumber, but it went through. First... WOW, this thing eats through pine WAY faster than ash or oak, and second... WOW is that still a lot of effort. This is not a saw you're going to use to build a house. I used this size saw when working as an electrician's assistant. Sometimes we'd have to notch rafters or enlarge drilled holes to run electrical lines through. It works GREAT for that kind of stuff. I didn't notice any dulling of the saw from this, and really wouldn't expect to, but I've tested so many cheap saws, I still have my eye out for it.
And again, the 4-layer thickness gave a good hold on the tool while using the saw.
Saw: PASS
Awl: PASSIf you want to see some other kinds of tests done with these or any other functions on a tool, feel free to make suggestions.
Lynn, your *terrible wonkey cut *brought me here! :D Excellent review though!

-
Huntsman, now we're talking.

Got a used one for $12 in excellent condition, so not too far off yours.
-
@ReamerPunch said:
Got a used one for $12 in excellent condition, so not too far off yours.
$12 is a GREAT price for a Huntsman in good shape. That's money well spent.

And Fuzz...

If I can't be competent, at least I can be entertaining.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@ReamerPunch said:
Got a used one for $12 in excellent condition, so not too far off yours.
$12 is a GREAT price for a Huntsman in good shape. That's money well spent.

And Fuzz...

If I can't be competent, at least I can be entertaining.

-
So, verdict on this tool?
Worth every CENT of $10. Actually, I'd say worth a lot more.
This is one of the few 'out of the box' tools that has just worked. The blades were sharp. The scissors were good. It didn't smell funny (unlike the Explorer). Nothing fell off while testing it.
This is absolutely in the running for best $10 MT.
The 4-layer size of SAK might be a bit uncomfortable for some folks to pocket carry. I personally find that with a pocket clip to keep it vertical, it's fine. I carry a similar SAK when I play disc golf, and have used the saw a couple times on the course, mostly to cut branches to shape to retrieve discs in the water or trees. For that kind of task, the saw is great. The scissors on 91mm SAKs are some of the best in the industry. I'm picky about my scissors, and these have my approval. The rest of the toolset is standard to the Spartan, which has the same toolset as the original Officer's Knife. Whether or not you need a can opener isn't so much the issue as it has been traditionally included since forever, and it still adds function, both as a light-duty phillips AND general scraping tool.
This is very simply a great tool, and useful in a lot of environments and situations. It's a good indoor/outdoor tool, and if you can't or don't want to get multiple knives if you switch between indoor/office functions and outdoor/hiking/woodscraft functions, then this one tool pretty well has you covered. For $10... and the weight of 14 quarters (in theory).
And, while it looks strong to win the $10 Challenge, there is still some stiff competition to come from the last two contenders.
-
Great review as always!

I prefer the Explorer but have a new/unused Huntsman as well a new/unused Camper that I tried to sell cause I don't need them (got them in a package deal with others awhile back) but no one wanted them, not even for only $20 for the Huntsman or $15 for the Camper or both for $30! Maybe now I will have to relist it after this review gets read! :)
I too use a clip for any sak at 4 layers or more! I actually even use the suspension with 3 layer ones too!
-
Some forget that if you test the saw(or knife, can opener, etc) on one SAK, you’ve tested it on ALL the SAKs.
You know, because Victorinox makes each tool very consistently. Different levels of (ab)usage aside, they’ll all perform identically good.
-
I would wholeheartedly agree. To the best of my knowledge, Victorinox is not most consistent, in terms of quality assurance. Every new example of a tool I've had was pretty much the same as every other new tool, and wear was the only difference. Every company, no matter how good, can still slip up occasionally. So, testing must be done.
And at the $10 price point for a tool that's normally $36 on Amazon, I would seriously have expected more issues from wear. But no, this one was in excellent condition.
Just LOOK at that beauty... :D

Sorry, couldn't resist. I took the shot for the 'Which SAK is getting pocket time today' thread.
-
Thanks Lynn for another great review.
I've once bend the cap-lifter screw driver in 90 degree position. I can tell you that it didn't damage the liners or pivot at all. It's good to know what performance you can expect from your tool.
Always love your reviews.Btw, may I suggest to test the saw "before" the cap lifter next time?


-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Lynn LeFey said:
I would wholeheartedly agree. To the best of my knowledge, Victorinox is not most consistent
Should read 'Victorinox is most consistent'. No idea what happened in edits there.
I was wondering what happened there, but I decided to keep quiet.

Inconsistent typing irony :)
Brain-finger mismatch, That should be an official error message somewhere.
-
I also prefer the Explorer but at that price it's as bargain.
You see them here used for 15€ min (about $18) :Pgood review a usual

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


