SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
@Zhenchok said:
...when I used the screwdriver on a tinker it felt like it should have been on the side and not the middle.I think the Phillips was an afterthought. I think they just replaced the corkscrew on a few models with it. The corkscrew has to be in the middle to work. At least that's my uneducated assumption.
Makes sense, I also wonder if certain countires used phillips more than others.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
From what others here have shared over the years, it was primarily the American market in the '40s and '50s that really drove the backside phillips. Generally speaking, back in those days, Euros drank wine while Americans didn't very much.

-
hmmmm.... lemme think on this


-
@Benner said:
In the spirit of starting polls, I thought I'd start this one. :DSo, which do you prefer? For me a SAK just has to have a corkscrew (not including glorious Alox
). I hardly ever need one, but cellidor SAK's just scream corkscrew to me and I always have a phillips on my multitool.Benner, we're cut from the same cloth. Hope you're checking in on this thread 9 years later. :D

-
Interesting how tight the voting is, i'm a corkscrew guy though so it got my vote

-
Phillips for me

But I do like the corkscrew as it holds the tiny flathead screwdriver
-
Corkscrew all the way, I'm a working Mechanic and I see no use for a stubby t-handle Phillips, an inline would be useful though and I use the end of the can opener all the time on #2 Phillips when it's convenient to reach into my pocket and extreme torque isn't required
-
Did someone mention the MTO way? :D
Personally I couldn't decide so I ended up with multiple different SAKs (went from DeLue Tinker to Ranger...).
The closest "solution" to have both functions would be a Swisschamp or Cybertool 41 maybe.I use the corkscrew for example to help untie shoelaces when they got wet.

...
sorry for the un-SAKky picAs for the backside Philips I find that it has better grip than the inline one. But I do need to be careful not to overtorque it


-
@Greg Jones said:
Corkscrew all the way, I'm a working Mechanic and I see no use for a stubby t-handle Phillips, an inline would be useful though and I use the end of the can opener all the time on #2 Phillips when it's convenient to reach into my pocket and extreme torque isn't requiredWell, after saying this I purchased a Fieldmaster, I guess I'll see if I was right
:ahhh -
I prefer the corkscrew.
First, it’s works fine (for me) as a wine bottle opener; and it's a great tool to untie knots too.
Second, it holds the micro screwdriver (I wear glasses, so it’s a very good option for me).
And the last, but not least: hоw to differ a soldier from an officer? Only by the presence of a corkscrew in the knife. ;) -
A year ago I was in the Phillips camp and now after going through several SAKs, I'm now in the corkscrew camp to the point that I even AVOID getting a SAK with a Phillips at the back. I find the ones on the bottle and can opener more than adequate than the one on the back

-
I am another of those who started out anti-corkscrew but changed my mind
when I realised how yummy wine iswhen I realised that the back of a SAK is a terrible place for a screwdriver, especially on the 111mm models.
Furthermore, as someone mentions just a few inches up this page, phillips screwdrivers wear down quite quickly. Use a corkscrew for its intended purpose and it should last forever. Use a phillips for its intended purpose and it probably won't last an afternoon of, uh, serious screwing. Settle down, Beavis! -
For years I carried a corkscrew thinking that I should have a phillips. When I finally decided to get a phillips I stoped to think about the many times when I used the corkscrew vs the amount of times I wished I had a phillips...The corkscrew won hands down.
Most of the times when I needed a phillips screwdriver I could improvise something, or I had propper tools readily avaliable. To me, corkscrew+small screwdriver have way more uses than just the phillips driver.
-
corkscrew all the way
Backside Phillips is too awkward to use, corkscrew has sooo many uses :ahhh -
I seem to have voted for the corkscrew at some point, but I can't for the life of me think why. The one true answer is, of course, neither.
-
Famous last words before the Corkscrew Crusades :D
-

:D
-
A far more interesting question would have been Philips or Panasonic...
-
@Thunderpants said:
A far more interesting question would have been Philips or Panasonic...
-
For me it depends if I'm carrying my leatherman with me. W/ Leatherman I prefer a corkscrew for added versatility. (I mainly use it for untying knots and cleaning fingernails, I don't drink nor do I encourage it) w/o a leatherman I'm kind of torn. Victorinox has the 2d Phillips on the can opener so I'd be cool with a corkscrew on a vic. But I'm more of a Wenger guy so if I don't have a Phillips on the back I don't get one. (Although you can jam the flathead in diagonally and turn a Philip's screw)
If could only carry the SAK it would be:
Victorinox-> Corkscrew
Wenger-> Phillip's -
@Thunderpants said:
A far more interesting question would have been Philips or Panasonic...Philips doesn’t sell eneloops.
So, Panasonic. ;)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login