Marbles Camp Knife (Lynn's $10 MT Challenge)
-
So, here's my wrap-up thoughts.
First, I said in the initial post, this thing comes in a set with a knock-off of the Austrailian 'Field Ration Eating Device', or 'FRED'. The Marbles one is a spork, instead of just a spoon. It's not of the review, but here's a look.

This knife seems about 85% finished. It needs some help right out of the package, but none of its deficiencies are all that hard to fix. It feels solid. It feels ROCK solid. It's a tool that I would not hesitate to maybe mistreat a little. It's cheap enough to replace without any real heartache. It's rugged enough to handle crappy storage, rough handling, and some abuse. At about $10 brand new, I think this tool is worth it.
But, I think I can do better.
The one, maybe obvious question would be... if this is a copy of a Mil-K knife, and they made literally millions of the Mil-K, then could an actual Mil-K knife be found at the $10 price point, and if so, how does it stack up against this Chinese made knock-off?
-
Great write-up Lynn.
Sounds like a good 'project' knife for someone who doesn't mind a bit of work. -
I have about 4-5 Demo knives of various ages, and all have been abused and haven't aged super well.
I love the premise and like that you can get "new" ones for short cash. Just sucks a little that you had to put decent effort into making it work correctly.
Carrying my Ulster today because of this
-
@Higgins617 said:
Carrying my Ulster today because of this
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
The one, maybe obvious question would be... if this is a copy of a Mil-K knife, and they made literally millions of the Mil-K, then could an actual Mil-K knife be found at the $10 price point, and if so, how does it stack up against this Chinese made knock-off?And to answer my own question... Yes. The next competitor is a legitimate Camillus made Mil-K knife.
</topic/75741 -
I am about to make what I assume is an unpopular argument.
I think, dollar for dollar, the Marbles Camp Knife is a better value than the Victorinox Pioneer.
Understand, I am in NO WAY saying the Marbles is a better knife. It quite obviously is NOT. I'm just saying that by dollars spent, you get more bang for your buck with the Marbles.
While I was gathering tools for this $10 Challenge, I ALSO purchased the Pioneer that's in these following pictures. During a month of watching, I got it for the best price I'd seen on ebay for new OR used, in anything like decent condition. It cost me $29.99. So, it cost me THREE TIMES as much as the Marbles knife, and that was BY FAR the best price for one I found, with the normal price on Amazon being $35.
These two knives are essentially the same tool, a Soldier Knife. The Pioneer is literally a modern made version of the 1961 model Soldier. The Marbles is a copy of the Queen manufactured Mil-K knife, which clearly shows its tool selection taken from the Swiss Soldier.
Having handled the Legitimate Mil-K knife in this challenge, I can only say that while the tools are essentially the same in function, they differ in terms of finish to an extraordinary degree. There is no doubt. Even the better finished Marbles Camp Knife (compared to the legitimate Camillus made one) is still a good deal less refined than the Pioneer.
Let's look at the blade. Out of the package, the Pioneer had a 'perfect' edge on it. It cleanly cuts phonebook paper. The grind is fine. The Marbles came with a grind that was off, but not badly. It required a few minutes work to get to function at the same level. Blade retention is weak on the Marbles, compared to the strong snap and solid 'lockup' of the Pioneer.
But that doesn't really affect function. Both are slipjoints.
Actual cutting edge is about the same length.

As for the awls, this picture shows the result of each, boring a hole through half inch thick aged ash.

The Pioneer was better. Both faster, and less prone to collapse under force, but both passed. Once again, we don't see a lack of function, only that the Pioneer does it better. And for less thick materials like punching a hole in leather, there is essentially no difference in performance.
They both open cans fine. I know it's been a bit of a hot topic in the past, but I generally find that I'm faster with the Marble's style opener than the Pioneer. But a few seconds difference in the time it takes to open a can is really kind of irrelevant.
The small flathead driver on the tip of the Pioneer's can opener is a function that the Marble's Camp Knife has no answer for. It functions as a very reasonable light-duty phillips driver as well, and that can be an important function. This is one place where the Pioneer has a clear advantage.
I've discussed before about the caplifter on the Marbles, but again, a problem that took a few minutes to rectify. Testing them as they are now, they both open caps, and both do it well. When we move on to the flathead driver paired with the caplifter, I must honestly give it to the Marble's knife, both for reach, AND as being a better pry tool.

Simple physics tell you that the longer lever is going to be the better for prying, but along with just the length of the driver, the steel pins of the Marble's knife make it more robust for this function, which will be trying to force the layers of the tool apart. As much as the can-opener-as-phillips is a clear point toward the Pioneer, the long flathead is a clear point to the Marble's Camp Knife.
It should probably be called another clear advantage of the Marble's clevis versus the Pioneer's split ring lanyard attachments.
I would call the weight difference significant, but adding an ounce and a third still has the Marble's knife under 4 oz. And while slightly thicker than the Pioneer, it's still as slim as a 91mm Victorinox Tinker. It is still quite pocketable.
Let me say again, for the money, it's not that you're getting a better knife. It's that for that money, and a few minutes work, you're getting essentially all of the functionality, and in some cases, the Marble's knife does it better.
If you ever lost the tool, you're out a lot less money. If you break one, same thing.
I expect so many tomatoes to now fly my way that I plan to start a salsa factory.

If I had the choice, I would clearly choose the Pioneer. But sometimes you DON'T have the funds. The Marble's Camp Knife gets you most of the function at about 1/3 of the cost, it just doesn't look or feel as good doing it.
-
-
And, If you break 3 Marble knives, you're still without a knife.
With a Vic, you're not only buying the knife, but also the lifetime warranty...
-
@Mechanickal said:
And, If you break 3 Marble knives, you're still without a knife.With a Vic, you're not only buying the knife, but also the lifetime warranty...
Direct quote from Victorinox's website: " guarantees a life time against any defects in material and workmanship (save for electronic components 2 years). Damage caused by normal wear and tear, misuse or abuse are not covered by this guarantee."
So... no. Vic is not on the hook if you break your tool doing crazy stuff. Whether they WILL fix it or not, I don't know. As far as I know, that's usually yes.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
And, If you break 3 Marble knives, you're still without a knife.
With a Vic, you're not only buying the knife, but also the lifetime warranty...
Direct quote from Victorinox's website: " guarantees a life time against any defects in material and workmanship (save for electronic components 2 years). Damage caused by normal wear and tear, misuse or abuse are not covered by this guarantee."
So... no. Vic is not on the hook if you break your tool doing crazy stuff. Whether they WILL fix it or not, I don't know. As far as I know, that's usually yes.
They never returned a SAK to me unrepaired.
Only shipping needed to be payed.
Broken awl, broken blade... that is NOT normal use
But I understand your reasoning as well

-
@Mechanickal said:
Only shipping needed to be payed.And the difference in shipping cost and just buying a Marble's knife is... $3 I think, where I'm at. Or -$2 if I ensure the package against loss on its way there? And that assumes the problem was damage not 'dropped it in a lake'.
But yes, Vic does have outstanding customer service.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
