Lynn's $10 MT Challenge
-
Still in the running...
The Leatherman Micra
The Leatherman PST
The Victorinox Huntsman
The Gerber MP400 Compact SportThis isn't me stalling. This is a tough decision. It's not the 'one is clearly best' situation of the $5 Challenge. All of these tools have real strengths in certain ways.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/21FhMQh" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4622/38513311860_7ebf18627b_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
Four way tie anyone?

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Still in the running...The Leatherman Micra
The Leatherman PST
The Victorinox Huntsman
The Gerber MP400 Compact SportThis isn't me stalling. This is a tough decision. It's not the 'one is clearly best' situation of the $5 Challenge. All of these tools have real strengths in certain ways.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/21FhMQh" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4622/38513311860_7ebf18627b_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
I have one of each.

(2 Micras actually).Just one reamer between them, though.

-
As much as it pains me, I'm going to make one more elimination.
The Micra has a lot going for it. It is absurdly easy to carry. That alone makes it a great option. If size limits carry, and the best tool is the tool you have with you, then the ability to have a Micra on your keychain is a huge benefit.
But here's the thing. These are scissor based. A Micra in pristine condition has some of the best scissors in the MT industry. These were not pristine. The scissors of both the Huntsman and MP400 tested better. And taking away the scissors, all of the functions that it shares with the huntsman, the Huntsman did better. I'm not sure that even if the scissors had been perfect that this tool would be better than a Huntsman. I am personally willing to double the weight for the increased functionality of the Huntsman.
Great tool. Even in the condition I received it. Absolutely worth every cent of $10, and the all-stainless steel construction will give you a lifetime of use, if you don't abuse it. It's a GREAT tool, and pretty easy to find on ebay at the $10-and-under price. There's a reason this tool has been produced for so long. It's a great design. It's just not the BEST tool.
ELIMINATED: Leatherman Micra
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/Ga9DNy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4702/26357807248_0a65d487b1_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> -
Being somewhat stuck for picking a winner, I'm opening this up for YOUR input, with a poll, and your chances to sway me...
</topic/75975The poll will run for 5 days, and you can vote for ONE.
Feel free to visit the poll thread, give me your anecdotes of awesomeness, grievances with a tool, loves, likes, dislikes, happy memories...
We're down to REALLY good tools.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/Giqb7S" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4603/26451367878_888733c698_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> -
@Lynn LeFey said:
ELIMINATED: Leatherman MicraToo cute and cuddly to compete with the big boys.
Not to worry, little one. You may not have won the contest, but you have won our hearts.
-
@ReamerPunch said:
Not to worry, little one. You may not have won the contest, but you have won our hearts.

That was hilariously awesome.

-
going to vote.
Good challenge Lynn, really intense
-
Final piece of this Challenge puzzle.
A GIVEAWAY!
You have a shot at winning NOT ONE, but TWO of the contestants from the $5 and $10 MT Challenges!
Link to thread below...
</topic/76011Good luck to all who chose to enter!

-
Okay, now I announce the winner.
Or, MY winner. Others may pick differently.
Votes have come in, and the clear winner there was the MP400 Compact Sport. Then at about half the number of votes of that, the PST, and half the votes of THAT, the Huntsman.
And...?
I concur with the findings of the Poll. I think the MP400 was the best on offer in the $10 Challenge.
The good: Comfortable, sturdy pliers, with narrow handle splay, so they do 'big' tasks as well as small. Amazing scissors. All locking tools, so you can REALLY crank on drivers, and maybe the best pry tool I've seen in a while. And something I'm not sure I mentioned, but belt carried, it becomes one of the most comfortable tools of the three.
The bad: It came coated in 'something', paint, tar, I dunno, so it required pretty severe cleaning. The broken small flathead wasn't a deal-breaker, but still a problem. The blade was a complete mess as received. Combined, that means the tool needed a bit of time for it's 'tuneup'. It has pretty stubby drivers. It's right on the edge of being able to be carried in-pocket, and doing so would risk the needlenose pliers punching a hole in your pocket.What finally clinched the decision for me was that this tool seemed the most likely to meet whatever task I threw at it. Sure, it lacked the PST's File, and the Huntsman's Saw, but was up to harder use at every task they shared in common. It feels like a little toolbox that would get the job done.
And while I'm calling it 'the winner', the truth is, this challenge had a LOT of good tools, and any one (or combination of them) could find times where it would shine. I was actually amazed at what I came up with at the $5- $10 price point. A Micra, Explorer, or Huntsman can give a lifetime of service. They're even better if you pair them with the IDL T5. Or for harder use, pair the Huntsman or Explorer with the PST or MP400. Those are some incredible combinations. Even for those with absolutely no ability to 'tune up' a problem tool, the Mossy Oak was a solid light-medium duty tool right out of the package.
Hope you all enjoyed this challenge. I would like to say one more time that the funds to purchase all these tools came from Multitool.org, so your support, either from checking out stuff in the store or donating to the site is what allows these kinds of tool tests to happen.
And let me know if there's enough interest to push forward with a $15 Challenge.
-
Excellent read! I truly enjoyed following this challenge.

I'm on the fence about a USD 15 challenge. On the one hand it will be some very entertaining threads, on the other hand, it sounds almost too "easy" after having seen what you were able to get for USD 10.

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Given time and access pawn shops and ebay, there is one obvious elimination.The Mossy Oak is a GREAT tool for a brand-new $10 MT. It has locking tools. The blade was sharp right out of the package. The saw worked, which almost feels like a miracle. But let's be honest. There's a big gulf between 'functional' and 'good'.
There are 4 REALLY good tools left, and the Mossy Oak is only 'good for the price', not just plain old 'GOOD'.
So I have to eliminate the Mossy Oak. However, if you can get over its kind of bulky size, this thing is still pretty amazing for a $10 tool. There are tools for sale out there that cost $20 that aren't nearly as good as this one. If I was in need of a beater/loaner or a tool in short order, I would not hesitate to grab one of these. Still, it's outclassed by the others, so...
ELIMINATED: Mossy Oak
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/KfvHWZ" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4667/28387571329_917bef0127_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>Speaking about loaner tools:
At one point, I had completely avoided buying low-end tools. However, I loaned a Leatherman Super Tool 300 out once, and it was returned wtih one jaw completely broken off of the pliers, with nothing in the sense of "I'll pay for it", just a half-arsed apology. The same individual broke the handle off a fiberglass hammer my grandfather had--same excuses. At least that was $5 bargain bin junk, unlike the ST300. Every time I broke one of my granddad's tools, I gave (or tried to, he wouldn't accept an almost new pair of Channellock needlenose pliers when I lost a pair of Klein needlenose pliers of his out in the woods fixing fences) him one of mine, or repaired it as best I could. Now I've got three or four really cheap MTs that don't care if I let someone I know has no business what they're doing borrow, but are decent enough that I wouldn't mine using them myself should I need a tool I don't care if I lose or get really nasty.
-
I think 'loaner tool' is a perfectly legitimate category of use. AND I honestly think the Mossy Oak is a good tool for that role.
Knucklehead friend (and let's face it, we ALL have one) hands back a wrecked Mossy Oak, and you're out the cost of a big cheeseburger combo meal.
Yes, I equate all cost to the cheeseburger standard. :D
-
I also have a series of loaner tools that I wouldn't really mind having broken, losing, giving away or being stolen so they are stashed at the work site's drawer, the car, mom's house (2 tools), one in the garden shed etc,

which are decent and usable but nowhere near the big 4 brands' stuff

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
