Scandinavian Knives
-
these are all excellent cutters but a common denominator in almost all of them is the lack of guard or cover between the handle and the blade.
I know I know, responsible use and common sense go first, but these blades sure were intended to be occasionally used on animals and game, getting covered in blood and fat, thus making them slippery. ???
Scandinavia, Finland, Norway... in such cultures and countries of origin falling snow, ice and water abound so it's not a rare occurence to have the knife covered in snow (melting into water with your hand's heat) while you're using it.
Another thing making it potentially dangerous without a guard
That's my initial impression at least.Please enlighten me

-
@ThePeacent said:
Please enlighten me
I find one of the most intriguing elements of knife design is that all knife designs involve some element of compromise. Seen another way, most knife designs have some degree of specialization. And so many knife designs have evolved to become highly specialized. A good boning knife will not serve well as a Chef's knife.
Some knives are a little more 'general purpose' than others, but that involves some element of compromise. And I think that's why I've ended up owning more knives than I really need. I see some advantage to one design or another, and then find I have to try it out.
While some Scandi knives do have guards, many don't. I have found that a guardless knife can be very handy and allows one to choke up on the grip to allow better control and power in cutting with the heel of the blade. I suspect this is one reason many traditional Scandi knives don't have a guard.
In addition, Scandi knives often have a nice bit of palm-swell. This palm swell is relied on to protect the hand from slipping forward and work well. The HELLE Lapplander I posted above doesn't have much palm-swell, and it could be fairly easy to slip up onto the blade. But it isn't designed to be a poking/stabbing tool. It can poke, but it's really designed for cutting or even small chopping. When used like that, the forces involved don't translate into a slipping motion. Notice that there is some pommel swell to help prevent the knife from slipping out of the hand when chopping.
So the handle is actually well thought out and functional. But, yeah, care does need to be taken.
This Spydie Puukko is a great example of a highly configured handle (with textured G-10) that provides a really well indexed blade and secure grip. For poking/stabbing, the pommel can be wedged into the palm of the hand, thereby preventing the hand from slipping forward. Really comfortable and smart grip.

-
American designer/maker, but seems to be dripping with Scandinavian elements:

-
HELLE exploring some alternative handle options, to include a bit of an integral guard.

Both of these are very comfortable to use in a variety of grips. I got 'em locally at a store specializing in hiking/camping gear. The HELLE knives are popular for being lightweight for their size and nice looking, too.
-
@Nix said:
HELLE exploring some alternative handle options, to include a bit of an integral guard.Both of these are very comfortable to use in a variety of grips. I got 'em locally at a store specializing in hiking/camping gear. The HELLE knives are popular for being lightweight for their size and nice looking, too.
I really like the looks of those 2 Nix!

-
for cheap scandi thrills with a guard get a mora 511
-
Lovely knives Guy's

My two nicest Puukkos (with help from Crow
)
-
Love those!

-
Thank you,

You seem to have a very nice collection yourself Nix
That Spydie
-
@ThePeacent said:
these are all excellent cutters but a common denominator in almost all of them is the lack of guard or cover between the handle and the blade.I know I know, responsible use and common sense go first, but these blades sure were intended to be occasionally used on animals and game, getting covered in blood and fat, thus making them slippery. ???
Scandinavia, Finland, Norway... in such cultures and countries of origin falling snow, ice and water abound so it's not a rare occurence to have the knife covered in snow (melting into water with your hand's heat) while you're using it.
Another thing making it potentially dangerous without a guard
That's my initial impression at least.Please enlighten me

You seem quite enlightened already. Slipping and cutting your own fingers is indeed the main issue with these knives, and it does happen way too often. I suspect some of the sales of traditional smaller Helle style knives are also due to them being decorative parts of traditional outfits. (Then often blinged up with silver here and there).
As the slip and cut problem is well known some manufacturers offers various designs with guards. (A requirement for the military edition). The guard does mess up the tight fit into the sheath though, and the sheath then need some other way to retain the knife.

-
those really are beautiful pieces y'all got there
-
OK, thanks for the replies foks.
Even with no guard, I can see how a contoured grip or a specific swell in the handle would prevent slippage. :salute:And I am also aware about intended use and stabbing with a hand or thumb in the flat pommel,
but I was thinking more about those super slick/polished handles on some Puukos, made of very smooth non grippy material (unlike textured micarta, G10, rubber or plastic) that you often see around.They have no guard, straight no swell handles, no contouring or finger grooves...they seem like dangerous stuff to me :ahhh a few examples here
May 2012 – nordiska knivar
5 posts published by nordiskaknivar during May 2012
nordiska knivar (nordiskaknivar.wordpress.com)
-
Here's one my wife got me many years ago, a Frosts by Mora:

A gem of a Scandi.
-
American designer/maker Koyote's interpretation of a Leuku:

Great handle. The primary bevel is slightly convex, not flat, but it still uses much like a Scandi grind. The drop edge is nice, too. That tiny bit of drop edge and ricasso give a little protection from sliding up onto the edge, but still allows a nice choked up grip.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
