I got Duped!
-
While i think it’s entirely possible that the seller knew what he was doing, I don’t think it’s wise to immediately jump to that conclusion. There are people that don’t know one red knife from another.
I don't think it matters. He still sold an item with a Victorinox shield & cross although it was a piece of crap (no, I don't think those are original Victorinox scales).
Except it does matter. Several of you are ready to form a lynch mob for some guy who may be a victim himself.
Lynch mob? I never said anything like that. If he is a victim himself, he should try to get his money back from whomever he bought in in the first place.
Selling counterfeit items is not allowed, regardless of the seller knowing about it or not.
Well I don’t disagree there.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I don't think it's an innocent mistake.
Nobody uses that strange camera angle, ever, unless they are trying to hide something!
Edti - on ebay I often see alox Pioneers in beautiful colours, photographed ever so carefully so that you cannot see the shop logo on the back. Obviously Victorinox alox with no third party logo is the most cherished so some sellers go to great lengths to let you think that's what you're getting. They deceive without actually telling an explicit lie.
-
I am not an expert, but the knife does have some "red alerts" to its authenticity.
My opinion is that both parts have a smal blame on the matter; You for assuming that "swiss army knife" must mean Vic/Wenger and not recognizing the tells on the pics, and the seller for selling a counterfeit item, knowingly or not.
I would check other items the seller has for sale, and past sales to see if it's someone versed in knives or if it's someone that never delt with one, and from there I would choose how to act next, either by learning my lesson and moving on, or going for the seller's throat... -
it is obviously not a vic.. so it is yourr own fault

-
and for the price given it is stupid to be a smurfhole about it... seller just didnt know what he sold and u didnt know what u bought
-
I don't think I would of noticed

But this is a good topic as I will be more aware
From now on especially the way people describe the item

-
@Thunderpants said:
Obviously Victorinox alox with no third party logo is the most cherished so some sellers go to great lengths to let you think that's what you're getting. They deceive without actually telling an explicit lie.See, that’s what I’m talking about. I had no idea that unmarked Alox knives were more desirable than marked ones. I’d be the guy who happened to take a picture not showing the mark and then get blasted as if I knew what i was doing.
Yes, there are people out there who are shady, but there are also people that just don’t know what they have.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I am learning something new everyday on this forum

-
Obviously Victorinox alox with no third party logo is the most cherished so some sellers go to great lengths to let you think that's what you're getting. They deceive without actually telling an explicit lie.
See, that’s what I’m talking about. I had no idea that unmarked Alox knives were more desirable than marked ones. I’d be the guy who happened to take a picture not showing the mark and then get blasted as if I knew what i was doing.
Yes, there are people out there who are shady, but there are also people that just don’t know what they have.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
And those are the people we should redirect to this great forum, so they can learn!

-
The good thing is that you learned that it isn't an actual SAK. I'd keep the knife, as to show others what isn't a real SAK. Even Vic does for this reason. I have a few I had as a kid that I retain for this same purpose, although most of mine are the old 1990s dark red, and those with the fake Aitor shield.
-
@jazzbass said:
Yeah, I can see instantly that it's a fake. It's all kinda wrong, but the tang stamp is a dead giveaway. The price should also make you suspicious. Personally, I wouldn't be too pissed at the seller. They never said "Victorinox" and they showed lots of pictures. "Swiss Army Knife" is sorta a trademark, but 99% of the world who are not on this forum call any red knife with lots of tools a "Swiss Army Knife". It's a concept that's been genericized like "Kleenex". BTW - the actual trademarks are "Original Swiss Army Knife" for Victorinox and "Genuine Swiss Army Knife" for Wenger.Ask nicely if you can return it. Most likely the seller will say yes. It's easier to take a return than to deal with negative feedback. Don't need to go into accusations of fraud or anything like that - most likely this is just some random seller that got a red knife in a box of crap from an estate sale, dumped it on eBay for $15 with a simple description that matches what most non-knife people would call it.

This...
-
@LJUSMC said:
While i think it’s entirely possible that the seller knew what he was doing, I don’t think it’s wise to immediately jump to that conclusion. There are people that don’t know one red knife from another.If I gave a red handled knife with a lot of blades and screwdrivers to my father and he put it on eBay, I guarantee he would call it a “Swiss Army knife,” with absolutely no idea of its legitimacy, and i highly doubt the thought has ever crossed his mind that one would ever be counterfeit.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Your father is a horrible person!!!!
;)
-
When in doubt, ask for more pics. Ask for pics of the tang stamp, of some specific tools, of the front and back scales.

-
@cody6268 said:
The good thing is that you learned that it isn't an actual SAK. I'd keep the knife, as to show others what isn't a real SAK. Even Vic does for this reason. I have a few I had as a kid that I retain for this same purpose, although most of mine are the old 1990s dark red, and those with the fake Aitor shield.I like this idea. Good thing is it wasn't a great deal of money spent. There are signs that the seller could have known however I would not flat out state that he/she did. I would however let them know it wasn't a Victorionx and let them know how you now know this. If they were unaware ( interesting description they gave ) then they are a smarter seller. If they knew then at least you have some piece of mind.
I'll get the pics up in a bit for you.
-
From looking at the seller’s pic alone seems shady... apart from the polish on the tools, the liners definitely don’t look like it was made by Victorinox... The shape of the liners are never the same for non-alox models...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@pfrsantos said:
When in doubt, ask for more pics. Ask for pics of the tang stamp, of some specific tools, of the front and back scales.

+1... it never hurts to ask...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@captain spaulding said:
The pliers are a dead giveaway for me but I could see how it will fool people. Seems the seller knows what they are doing.I second the Capn'. Easy to miss if you never had a SAK with plyers, but they do tend to be the thickest layer of any SAK in which they reside, and these seem rather thin.
-
Couple of points...
Some say the seller may not know what they had. This is possible. Could be a grandmother whose husband died and she's selling his stuff. He may have been duped years before.
Everyone calls this type of knife a Swiss Army Knife, after all.
Some say the seller knew it was a B.S. sale, and deliberately took photos and gave descriptions designed to mask this knife's true lack of family lineage. I can subscribe to this and believe this is more likely, based on the picture angles and such.
Don't feel bad. The shield was there, if a little skewed.
What might I do? Depends what you want.
If you want to know if this seller is a fraud, Return it asking for my $ back. Return in whether or not you get a refund. Return it with a polite letter explaining that it is not genuine, and explain each point, politely, saying that this knife is just not what you thought and you don't want it. Then just watch eBay to see if they post it again with the disingenuous pics and description. Then you will know this seller's intent.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
