Lansky V Sharpmaker
-
I remember years ago using a Lansky sharpener quite a bit at a friends house to sharpen my knives. He ended up replacing it with a simlilar system "Gatco" which we thought was great because you didn't have to fiddle with the iron rods slipping them on and off of the stones. I've never used the Sharpmaker before so will look forward to hearing how you get along with it and what you think.
sean
-
@ducktapehero said:
Which Lansky system will you be comparing to the Sharpmaker?The deluxe kit ;)
-
I sold my Lansky and got a Sharpmaker . The Lansky done a very good job but I found heavy Multitools slipped in the clamp . The Sharpmaker is much quicker and easier to use and if like me you keep all your blades sharp and use frequent touch ups on them then you won't need to spend a long time on them .
Dunc
-
@ducktapehero said:
Which Lansky system will you be comparing to the Sharpmaker?I don't know if this was directed towards me or Flash but I the Lansky I used was the Lansky Deluxe model. The Sharpmaker is quicker to set up or change the stones, too.
-
@Splat-
Thanks for the report on the Smiths vs Sharpmaker. I'll save my pennies for the good stuff!
-RenHoek -
@ducktapehero said:
Which Lansky system will you be comparing to the Sharpmaker?@Flash said:
The deluxe kit ;)Ahh OK.
http://www.knifeworks.com/lanskydeluxediamondsharpeningsystem.aspx
I will be interested in the results. I have a Lansky but mine is the Deluxe Turnbox. Like this
http://www.lanskysharpeners.com/LCS5D.php
I love it.
-
@DTH-
I didn't know Lansky made a rod version like that Crock Stick sharpener. Do you know what the angles are for the two different positions?-RenHoek.
-
Well, I have both and after initial use I can say that in my opinion these are the main differences:
Sharpmaker
Good - Lightspeed set up time
Good - Safety rods
Good - Simple, no fuss system
Good - Can be converted to conventional stone if required
Good - Smaller to carry
Good - Lighter than the Lansky (Just under a 1lb)
Bad - Too much variance and natural error in sharpening angle
Bad - Carry case not the most secure - bits fall out when I open it
Bad - Only 2 angles to chose fromLansky
Good - Perfect angles everytime
Good - A number of angles to chose from (5)
Good - 5 different grades to choose from
Good - Comes with honing oil
Good - Case holds all items solidly - no losing anything out in the field
Good - Has spare parts secure in case
Bad - Takes a while to set up.
Bad - Larger and heavier than Sharpmaker (1 1/4lb)These are initial impressions and they may change after using both for a time, however my tool of choice:
LANSKY DELUXE
For me it just has more precision and seems more user friendly. The choice in stones, the angles and more secure carry system has won it.
However, I am happy I have the sharpmaker for those "quick" fix times.
Let the debate begin.
-
That was interesting, thought provoking and an excellent piece of work coming from a highly loquacious tower of intellect. :D
-
;)
-
I think I'm going to have to agree with you on those points Flash, very well said. I think what it boils down to is convience over quality. I'm not saying the sharpmaker doesnt put a quality edge on the blades (I'm sure plenty of you will fight to the death to prove otherwise!) but two stones and no set angle cannot possibly work as well as a whole range of stones and constant angle every time. I also agree its nice to have the choice of angles, because different applications need , very different edges. I will be purchasing my lansky deluxe very soon and look forward to it.
Note I still think stropping should be used on a blade regarldess of the sharpening method. After reading about it, I think my next project will be to make a nice little strop for myself :D
-Dough
-
Dough,
Thanks for that. I agree with you, I think I need to make myself a strop.

BTW just got your tool...will post my thoughts on the appropriate thread.
-
Never liked the Lansky , except for reprofiling a truly abused knife , too slow , too messy , to fiddly . I still have one , but hasn'y seen use in years . They are also a major pain on longer pieces , just not ready for prime time . For me it's either the Sharpmaker/an strop . or the Japanese water stones , belt grinder/buffer , or once in a while the DMT benchstones .
Chris
-
Very interesting thread especially since I've recently bought a Lansky. At some point in the future I might get a sharpmaker or lansky crockstick for when a tool just needs a quick touch up.
-
It's funny how ppl can have so many different views on so many things :) I never would have thought you would pick the Lansky
but that is because I like the Sharpmaker so well I guess ::) you did bring some good points out Flash thanks
:D -
Knowing nothing about the Lansky, can you do serrations on it?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login