Tough Tool Experiment
-
Neat experiment
Gppd luck carrying the Taylor Branded one :ahhh :D Can't wait for it 
-
I'm looking forward to your thoughts and experiences with it.
Def
-
Looking forward to it too!

I bought the black one and the quality is horrendous.. The handle flexes just like a toy but I didn't use it extensively enough to warrant it a fail yet. -
Thanks for the support!
My standard tests for both will be:
Undoing and refastening nuts on a car battery.(Pliers)
Sawing on a sapling(Saw)
Paracord cutting, paper slice. (Knife)
Scraping rust(Scraper blade)
Paint can/Door trim prying. (Large Flat blade)
Scraping copper hanger coating off, notching a nail. (File)
Cutting charging cord wire, paper clips. (Wire Cutters)
Also thinking about a drop test, rust resistance test, and log stab test(for the blade tip strength)
Time to see how tough the "tough" tool is.
I won't be easy on them trsust me. I treat my Rebar like it stole money fom me. I've only owned it for 4 months and already sent it in to warranty for the flathead.
Finally got it back and now appreciate the limitations of multitools. -
I think you'll be O.K with those tests, except the log stab. The U.S version has a thin "weakish" clip blade. The Chinese version has a sharpened piece if snipped tin that is called a "blade".

-
I am sure you won't have to worry about rust. I'm quite certain that no iron (or other useable metal) was used in current versions of the Tough Tool.

Def
-
Grant.
I will vouche for the Taylor plier head. Cut about 60 pieces of coat hanger for hanging hooks. They worked flawlessly. Can't speak to the handle tool longevity though. And the factory handle splay is ridiculous on the Taylor version(about twice as splayed as the US version).
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I am sure you won't have to worry about rust. I'm quite certain that no iron (or other useable metal) was used in current versions of the Tough Tool.
Def
oddly enough my switchgrip (that cheap MT with two plier heads) appeared yesterday rusted, horribly corroded and spitted just from storage, and I was sure it was made from pot metal and basically no iron

-
Initial impressions:
Okay so the box was nice, sheath seemed decent, then I took the tool out and LITERALLY almost puked! Words can't begin to describe how bad this tool is. It's stiff, there's scratches all over the tools, and the gray finish rubbed off onto my fingers!
Not to mention how badly ground the pliers head is. Please tell me th US tool is better 
-
The US version will be better for sure. Having said that, as an original owner of one when they first came out they aren't that great either.
-
@_MattGyver_ said:
Initial impressions:Okay so the box was nice, sheath seemed decent, then I took the tool out and LITERALLY almost puked! Words can't begin to describe how bad this tool is. It's stiff, there's scratches all over the tools, and the gray finish rubbed off onto my fingers!
Not to mention how badly ground the pliers head is. Please tell me th US tool is better 
Steve pretty well hit it right on the head. The old U.S. made one isn't the greatest but it's a sight better than the current issue.
And remember that hunk of junk is being issued to the Australian army.

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Initial impressions:
Okay so the box was nice, sheath seemed decent, then I took the tool out and LITERALLY almost puked! Words can't begin to describe how bad this tool is. It's stiff, there's scratches all over the tools, and the gray finish rubbed off onto my fingers!
Not to mention how badly ground the pliers head is. Please tell me th US tool is better 
Steve pretty well hit it right on the head. The old U.S. made one isn't the greatest but it's a sight better than the current issue.
And remember that hunk of junk is being issued to the Australian army.

Def
It is current issue, but not well received by those using it according to this site, http://www.australianmilitaryknives.com/multitool.html They used to issue Swiss Tools. If I were to guess I'd say they were trying to save money by getting end users to buy their own higher quality tools.
-
Well I think I'm going to wrap up this experiment a little early on account of how taken back I am by the low quality of the tool :P Don't even know if I want to drop $35-$50 on a USA one after hearing they're not much better.
-
The quality of the U.S. made ones is much better. The design is still just as limited.
Def
-
@Alan K. said:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Initial impressions:
Okay so the box was nice, sheath seemed decent, then I took the tool out and LITERALLY almost puked! Words can't begin to describe how bad this tool is. It's stiff, there's scratches all over the tools, and the gray finish rubbed off onto my fingers!
Not to mention how badly ground the pliers head is. Please tell me th US tool is better 
Steve pretty well hit it right on the head. The old U.S. made one isn't the greatest but it's a sight better than the current issue.
And remember that hunk of junk is being issued to the Australian army.

Def
It is current issue, but not well received by those using it according to this site, http://www.australianmilitaryknives.com/multitool.html They used to issue Swiss Tools. If I were to guess I'd say they were trying to save money by getting end users to buy their own higher quality tools.
I don't doubt for a second that the soldiers are not happy about it. In all my years of running this site, and the thousands of members that have been and gone in that time, I can't imagine any one of them thinking that this was either an upgrade or at least a decent substitution.
This was absolutely an accounting decision, and I for one think the person or people who made that decision, along with the management at Taylor need to be held responsible for said decision, possibly even with criminal charges.
Def
-
Lol.. The trial was fast..
Me also can't figure out how this smurf can be made a standard issue for an entire Army... ???
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login