New US Multitool.
-
So last week I got my military swisstool, but I'm kind of disappointed...
Few questions for the swiss experts:
1- Why does the black oxide finish has stains on it?
2- Why they don´t use black rivets on both sides of the tool?
3- What are those circles marks on the rivet area?
4- The large flat screw driver has so much play?
Is this normal?
Here are a few pics...
Let me know what you think.
Thank you.

-
The only thing that I would be worried about from that list is the screwdriver having play in it.
:ahhh -
Will try to make a video, too much play is not normal...
-
The same issues with color / rivets with all my Victorinox BO MT. They're ugly..
Seems, I already wrote about this fact here, in MTO and got an answer that's a regular practice for BO tools from Victorinox.
D - Dissapointment.. [emoji17] -
Pay close attention! There will be a test!
* Anyone can get a CAGE Code (CAGE = Commercial and Government Entity; required for DoD suppliers). Simply apply for it; normal process is about 45 days. * Anyone can get a NSN issued for something they'd **like** to sell to the US Government and Armed Forces. Only requires asking one of the several gov't agencies that sponsors assigning a NSN to something to do it. * It does **not** mean there's any contract from the US Government to buy any or that any US Government agency plans to buy any. * DLA (Defense Logistics Agency) does this routinely for contractors that request it. * Contractors hoping to sell something to Uncle Sam frequently do this and then try to drum up business, almost like door-to-door salesmen.This has all the trappings of the marketing ploy for the US Soldier Knife, a Trekker in U.S. stamped scales. The dudes hawking them showed up at (IIRC) an AUSA convention (Ass'n of the US Army), which isn't a US Government organization or an official military event, but a private convention held by a private organization, the AUSA. They came with a pile of them to sell to anyone who was there that wanted one. They also touted them to the Special Forces Association (another private organization) and offered them for sale to them, but you had to prove you were a member of SFA to buy one. Their marketing strategy was interesting. Seed a few hundred of them into the US Army's officer and senior NCO ranks like planting a crop. Wait for them to return to their units with them hoping most everyone who sees it will want one of their own and create a grassroots demand for them. Caused a huge stir here and on other knife and military forums with rabid speculation that Uncle Sam was suddenly buying gazillions of them for every US Soldier, Sailor, Airman and Marine. Uncle Sam hasn't issued or supplied a single one of them to any member of the US Armed Forces. The eBay auction in Switzerland is, no doubt, a left over vestige of this attempt by a small group of several guys to sell them to Uncle Sam.
This is the same kind of deal. The same company is attempting to sell a Swiss Tool to Uncle Sam as a pass through that has minimal processing done to give it US Government and Armed Forces livery markings.
Just because there's a CAGE Code and NSN does not mean Uncle Sam has bought a single one of them or has any plans to. Items like this typically go through evaluation and testing at the US Army's Natick Soldier System Center (aka Natick Labs) in Natick, Massachusetts. It's the engineering and development center for soldiers' personal clothing and equipment. Even though it's operated by the US Army, the USAF and USMC often coattail on their engineering and development, especially the USAF. Uncle Sam doesn't buy this kind of stuff at the drop of a hat. The enormous clue about what's going on with this is the name of the company and the email address for the dudes hawking them. Same as the alleged US Army Soldier Knife:
Windrose Group, LLC
xxxxxxx@gmail.comWhat company of any size with any revenue uses a "gmail" email address for company email? They can't even get their own domain name from GoDaddy and use it as an alias?
John
-
Good to know, I tough that the gov had a contract with them.
But I wanted a black swisstool any way!
Thank you. -
@tango44 said:
Good to know, I tough that the gov had a contract with them.
But I wanted a black swisstool any way!
Thank you.If a blackout Swiss Tool floats your boat, go for it and get a Swiss Tool BS! Don't get hopes up on getting one marked US with a NSN from Windrose LLC though as I seriously doubt they've got many on hand. It happened with the knife. They wouldn't sell to private parties who wanted to buy one after dumping a pile out to AUSA and SFA as they weren't in any level of actual production and weren't geared or staffed to make private sales of one, two or a few, like a retailer. They needed Uncle Sam to buy a pile of them to put them into production and that never happened.
Soldier Systems is a daily industry rag, or more correctly an "ezine" primarily for companies who are selling and especially for those trying to sell tactical stuff to DoD. You can see the latest in "tacticool" on their web site, but don't jump to any conclusions that everything you see there is being sold to Uncle Sam. Much of it isn't. US companies collectively expend enormous resources marketing stuff to DoD. The big government contractors like Boeing, Lockheed Martin, General Dynamics, Raytheon, Northrup Grumman, etc., spend many millions on it annually. (Notes about former big names: McDonnell Douglas was bought by Boeing 20 years ago, most of Hughes Aircraft was bought by Raytheon about the same time, and TRW was bought by Northrup Grumman 15 years ago).
I should clarify that the USMC also has its own facility on Parris Island to test, evaluate and develop things for Marines that are unique to their maritime and seaborne missions, which aren't the same as a land based army. Many things coattail on Natick such as the Kevlar helmet, ballistic vests and similar items, but other things come out of Parris for them, often incorporating work Natick has already done, such as their own OKC-3S bayonet in lieu of the US Army's M9 (they replaced the M7 with it 15 years after the US Army did with the M9).
John
-
Got curious about Windrose Group, LLC that's marketing these Swiss Tool BS and was marketing the Trekker. This is what I found with Google in about 30 seconds . . .
[Cue scene from Wizard of Oz when Toto pulls back the curtain.]
https://www.manta.com/c/m...r1/the-windrose-group-llc
Edit:
Same information as found above is also here:
http://www.buzzfile.com/business/The-Windrose-Group-LLC-570-974-6089Jerald J. Rinder is President of Windrose Group, a privately held company (no surprise for a LLC) founded in 2016, two years ago. Odd that it's called a "group" as Manta and Buzzfile estimates their annual revenue at $56k per year employing a staff of approximately one employee.
John
-
eBay listing. $275 for a Soldier:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Victorinox-Swiss-Army-US-Soldier-Combat-Knife/152955035494?hash=item239cd49f66:g:J4QAAOSwAQBas9c8 -
@smiller43147 said:
eBay listing. $275 for a Soldier:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/...d49f66:g:J4QAAOSwAQBas9c8Yup - the Trekker created by the Windrose Group LLC that the US Government never bought a single one of. There's a number of them in the wild as the Windrose Group LLC (a one person company operating out of his home) took a case of them to the AUSA annual convention and offered them up for those that wanted to buy one. AUSA is a private organization and it was a private convention for AUSA members. Please do not be deceived that these were purchased or issued by the US Government to anyone. Uncle Sam did not buy a single one of them. There's another dude in Switzerland that has one on ePrey as well.
John
-
Looks like there is a NSN# for them.....

-
@Nix said:
Looks like there is a NSN# for them.....
That was posted before from the same article. A NSN means absolutely nothing. I could create John's Combat Framus, make a few for catalog photo shooting, get a CAGE Code for John's Framus Company and then get a NSN assigned to it. More crap has NSNs that the US Government has never sought (with a RFP or RFQ), asked for, contracted for, or bought, all done by big dreamers hoping to make a killing in the GSA Lottery trying to sell bazillions of something to Uncle Sam. If you had access to the NSN database, you'd be astounded at the stuff in it that Uncle Sam has never bought, is not buying and never will buy. This is Jerry's second time around attempting to sell something to the US Government. Hope he doesn't quit his Day Job (I know where he works).
Edit:
The "US Soldier" he created from a Trekker two years ago also has a NSN.John
-
Interesting.
I always thought that if something had an NSN it could be purchased by gov't agencies.
But I note that this particular item seems to always default to "Soldier Systems". Odd.
I haven't had any luck finding a database listing '1095-01-670-1865' as a viable NSN item.
-
I always thought that if something had an NSN it could be purchased by gov't agencies.
But I note that this particular item seems to always default to "Soldier Systems". Odd.
I haven't had any luck finding a database listing '1095-01-670-1865' as a viable NSN item.
A variety of agencies including some state or local ones can request it if they want any. The problem with this stuff that clogs up the NSN database is DLA, GSA, and a couple other US Gov't agencies that buy stuff to put it into US Gov't inventory haven't bought a single one of them. You could "order" one and you'd never see it. There's no procurement contract to buy any and there's no contract award that would result in a procurement contract for them. All the pieces are in place if Jerry can somehow convince Uncle Sam to issue a contract to buy a few rail car loads from him. The CAGE Code sets up how Jerry would get paid by identifying his company as a unique entity. The NSN sets up how they would be procured. How he'd fulfill an order for many thousands in a short time is another matter. It's one man and his garage (or living room, or den, or spare bedroom; take your pick).
How this really works . . .
If Uncle Sam wants multi-tools for the US Armed Forces, DLA or GSA will publish a RFP in the Federal Register that will contain all the terms, conditions and specs along with how to submit the proposal, what's required with it, how the proposals will be evaluated and items tested, and the deadline for it. Along with that, Uncle Sam will invite a number of contractors known to produce such things in that commodity to bid (such an invitation does not guarantee anything or provide any advantage). If Uncle Sam were going to buy a BS SwissTool, it would, without doubt, come directly from Victorinox to Uncle Sam specs, not a pass-through from Jerry and his one-man company operating out of his home in Pennsylvania. It would be the result of a contract award after Uncle Sam evaluated bids from at least several mult-tool manufacturers with one or more of the losers undoubtedly suing the US Government for one thing or another trying to get the contract award undone to be reevaluated. Several losers to the recent M17 pistol contract awarded to Sig Sauer sued the US Government with a variety of claims about how the evaluation of the competing pistols and contract award decision itself was flawed. This is routine just as all the losers lawsuits not getting any traction is routine. Sig Sauer got the contract and has the contract.John
-
Thanks for the additional info, John. Really helpful. I posted the NSN in our local SAK FB group before I read your comments, and now deleted it.
So its basically a scam by this certain Jerald.
-
@an0nemus said:
Thanks for the additional info, John. Really helpful. I posted the NSN in our local SAK FB group before I read your comments, and now deleted it.So its basically a scam by this certain Jerald.
Not really a scam. He's not interested in selling onesie twosie to private buyers wanting to order one from him like eBay BIN or Amazon. It's a marketing ploy. He's trying to generate interest and clamoring demand from "grass roots" in the US Armed Forces for them with supply personnel trying to order them to issue them as discretionary non-consumable expendable items using the NSN. DLA isn't going to cut a contract or put a RFP in the Federal Register for a handful just because a few supply sergeants try to get a few dozen. Period. He's going about it all the wrong ways, but that doesn't stop the dreams. If Jerry made $3 net profit on every one passing through his house and sold a hundred thousand of them, which isn't a very large number of such an item in the US Armed Forces, he'd become quite rich from it having done very little but manage the pass-through operation. Therein lies the Big Dream. Costs zero to get a CAGE code. Costs all but zero to get a NSN. That's if you do it yourself and it's not that hard if you know who to call and contact which isn't a national secret either.
Discretionary:
Every organization has a small slush fund to expend on certain kinds of low cost items it feels it needs that are not part of the TO&E (Table of Organization and Equipment - what the unit is authorized and required to have, including personnel by MOS and rank).Consumable vs Non-consumable:
A light bulb and toilet paper and bullets and beans are all consumable as is fuel and lubricants. They are naturally consumed in use. Non-consumable is something like the multi-tool. It may eventually wear out or possibly break, but it's not inherently consumed like a case of C-rations - or MREs now. Certain consumables, such as ammunition, are inherently consumed, but you can bet your butt it's accountable by exact number of rounds outside a combat zone (and in one there are other measures used for control). Similarly, fuel is a consumable under considerable control. Mogas, the military gasoline, is dyed red and you cannot get the dye out. Diesel is similarly marked indelibly. Consumption of it is accounted for in logs when it's dispensed - to whom and how much.Expendable vs non-expendable or accountable:
Expendable items include some hand tools or similar things that can be replaced without necessarily having to perform a formal investigation about its loss, damage or destruction. A multi-tool would usually fall into such a class as it's not costly or a sensitive item. "Usually" is important as under some circumstances, an investigation is warranted and required. Otherwise tools and such would be routinely "lost" when the real mechanism is pilferage and theft. In general, to replace a tool you need to produce the one that was damaged or broken or have a damned good story about what happened to the one you had, one that passes multiple BS detectors. Senior NCOs have magnificent ones and by the time I was promoted to captain mine was quite excellent. Non-expendable items are on property books and must be accounted for. Loss, damage or destruction of non-expendables and especially accountable items is always investigated.John
-
I've not read the whole thread, but seriously how can anyone believe these are US made when clearly they are Vic Soldier and Swiss-tool, I can't imagine Vic releasing the rights and patents nor can I believe them sitting idle whilst someone creates clones. Is it that the US army has switched from Gerber to Vic, in which case the thread title is a little misleading to say the least.
In reference to the above post stating Mogas is dyed red and impossible to get out, sounds a little bit like Red diesel used in this country which is tax exempt. It's supposedly only used in off road machinery or farm tractors, but I once heard a certain fertiliser (forget the name) would remove the red if the diesel was filtered through it!
-
Maybe you should read the whole thread tosh. No-one has said they think it’s US made.
-
It's only 33 posts before you so I'm with H here :D
Your post is somewhat of a thunderstrike at clear skies. -
Sorry, you are both correct
I had literally 5 mins this morning before dashing out. I'm typing this pitch side waiting for my sons football match to begin, won't be home till later and won't be able to view MT'o until probably this evening, but suspect it will be tomorrow lunch break at work.
Oh to have a simple life with nothing to do.....
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login