Which FOLDING KNIFE did you carry today?
-
As I mentioned in another thread, today I purchased a new old stock, year 2011, Buck 110 deep forest green Paperstone Ecolite.
Fickin sharp. The green is like that of a 1990's Jeep Grand Cherokee or a darker hunk of jade.
Not the classic, but it sure is nice. Utilitarian. A little over half the weight of the original. Great for hiking.
One thing I noticed though...looking at the open knife spine from the top, the liner is slightly separated from the backspring. Under the right angle, I can see a tiny sliver of light between them.
In the even anyone chimes in stating this might be a product of just this Paperstone model, I looked at and handled every 110 and 112 variant in the display case. None was perfect. It does not appear to affect the action at all, but does anyone else notice this?
-
My new Buck 110 compared to my 20something year old Browning 810 Featherweight...
-
.

-
Above, (or actually, on the bottom of the previous page) my new Buck is on the right, while my old Browning is on the left. You can see the liner of the Buck is slightly away from the backspring, and actually, the joint of the Browning is a tighter tolerance as well.
Again, it doesn't seem to affect the Buck's action, and the lockup is solid...
What do yours look like? Nix? VicMan? Bueller? Shark_za?
-

Zoid, you take some of the best pictures and I want to live there
Cheers mate.
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
What do yours look like? Nix? VicMan? Bueller? Shark_za?Sorry for the crappy lighting......


I'm not seeing a gap similar to yours. All manufacturing processes have some tolerances. In the case of your knife, these tolerances may have 'stacked'.
You might consider sending your picture to Buck and asking if your knife is within design specs. Or just use it. Buck has a lifetime warranty.
The BUCK Forever Warranty
We warranty each and every Buck knife to be free of defects in material and workmanship for the life of the knife, and we will repair or replace with a new Buck knife, at our option, any Buck knife that is defective. Buck Knives does not warrant its products against normal wear, misuse, or product modifications. Buck Knives are not intended to be used as hammers, chisels, pry bars, or screwdrivers.
If your knife was damaged due to misuse, our repair department can analyze the damage and repair it for a reasonable fee. If the knife is unable to be repaired, we will extend a one- time courtesy offer, allowing you the option to purchase a new knife for 50% off of our MSRP price listed on the website, excluding any custom knives or web specials.
-
@Nix said:
I'm not seeing a gap similar to yours. All manufacturing processes have some tolerances. In the case of your knife, these tolerances may have 'stacked'.You might consider sending your picture to Buck and asking if your knife is within design specs. Or just use it. Buck has a lifetime warranty.
I agree with Nix's assessment.
-
Thank you both.
Although...I'm not quite so sure, Nix. Zooming in on your comparative photo, your Paper stone may have a slight separation on the left side, similar to my right. If I size the pics evenly, my slight gap seems reasonably similar in width, but on the right instead of left.
Do you see it or am I looking through filtered glasses?
I read somewhere that placing the closed knife in the middle of a phone book (if one can be found these days) and tapping it with a hammer might peen that pin a bit tighter. Then again, the warrantee route is sensible, as you mentioned.
I don't know, it works fine.
The same hardware store had a 110 50th anniversary edition and a 110 Buck's 100th anniversary - that 2002 model with an anvil as the year code. I've a feeling I'll be back for at least one more of these.
Nix, Shark, Vicman, anyone know of any special care these handles require? Not a whole lot about them on the Web in English. There's more in Russian than English, I think
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Although...I'm not quite so sure, Nix. Zooming in on your comparative photo, your Paper stone may have a slight separation on the left side, similar to my right. If I size the pics evenly, my slight gap seems reasonably similar in width, but on the right instead of left.Do you see it or am I looking through filtered glasses?
Actually, I think you are right. Looking more closely this morning, with better light, I do see a slight 'gap' between the left liner (looking at the back) and the lockbar. I think this is just a tolerance issue. The knife locks up solidly and the lock is quite tight. So, aside from an aesthetic question--and, perhaps a potential cause for increased accumulation of dirt, leading to wear--it doesn't seem like an issue. I don't think I'd want to peen it further. If this weren't a discontinued model, maybe I'd give it a try, but the knife is 100% functional and the tolerance gap doesn't bother me (I wouldn't have likely noticed it if you hadn't had me double check!).
I treat "Paperstone" like Micarta. No special treatment, but I try not to run over the scales with my truck.
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Thank you both.Do you see it or am I looking through filtered glasses?
I read somewhere that placing the closed knife in the middle of a phone book (if one can be found these days) and tapping it with a hammer might peen that pin a bit tighter. Then again, the warrantee route is sensible, as you mentioned.
I don't know, it works fine.
The same hardware store had a 110 50th anniversary edition and a 110 Buck's 100th anniversary - that 2002 model with an anvil as the year code. I've a feeling I'll be back for at least one more of these.
Take a straight edge and hold it up next to the back spring on the side where the gap is and see if it looks like the back spring is bowed to the left where it fits against the blade, causing the gap.
It may be an optical illusion, but it looks to me like the back spring is not perfectly straight.
I think what Nix said makes sense "I don't think I'd want to peen it further..........The knife locks up solidly and the lock is quite tight. So, aside from an aesthetic question--and, perhaps a potential cause for increased accumulation of dirt, leading to wear--it doesn't seem like an issue."
I don't have a Paperstone 110, but this was in the description for a Paperstone Buck 110: " The Paperstone™ handles are made from 100% post-consumer recycled products so they are truly green. They can withstand extreme temperatures and are very rugged and durable."
-
Fallkniven PC

-
Lovely!
-
0410181716a by Poncho 65, on Flickr
0410181716 by Poncho 65, on Flickr -
Nice folders and pics!
-
SOG Vulcan again.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

