MLCT Crony - Need your input!
-
Can tool steel be polished up to a nice shiny finish? I think for a keychain / pocket tool, the appearance needs to be aesthetically pleasing.
-
I like the idea of a tool/carbon steel.
Like Loudliam said, a cool patina would be good. -
I don't think tool steel can be polished, but I think carbon can to a certain degree, but I prefer the patina, as you can make designs in it, and it gives it a more satin look.
-
I'm unfamiliar with the term or idea of "patina" but i will look into it with more detail. it seems this can be achieved on steel by simply applying some gun bluing, which makes it look cool and prevents rusting, so that would be cool. I'd like to get some more people's input regarding the steel before I move forward though, but thanks for your input so far guys.
-Dough
-
If you've seen a old carbon steel knife, there is a layer of oxidation that forms basically making it look brown or silvery in color. This is called a patina, and can be forced or allowed to happen over time. A lot of people who buy carbon steel moras, case xx, or other popular carbon steel knives will soak them in: Sprite, vinegar, hot sauce, lemon juice, basically anything acid and it will force a layer of oxidation. They do this to not have to worry about rust forming.
-
@DoughDTD said:
Ok guys, I wanted to bump this thread up because I need your help on some design ideas. I am going to try and heat treat the blades myself, and a 440c would be too difficult to do at home. A tool steel, however, would not be. This means were going to have a stronger tool, but the possibility of easier rusting. My question to you guys is whether or not this trade off is worth it. I want to try and do the heat treating myself to keep the costs down, and I know I can do tool steel or plain carbon steels effectively, but not the stainless. So please chime in with your input, especially if you know about the qualities of the various grades of steel. Thanks guys-Dough
anyone else?
-Dough
-
Check out crucible's website, they have lots of data on various tool steels, and recommended heat treatment.
I.e. pdf on D2, give comparison of toughness and wear resistance among D2, A2, O1 and a few others: http://www.crucibleservice.com/datash/dsD2v12NEW.pdf?CFID=115604&CFTOKEN=10788854
I like D2 in tool steels, relatively stainless and very wear resistant. Not as tough as many others but I don't think it's important in such a small tool.
-
Yea ive read up alot on the various grades and heat treat methods, and I think I'm leaning in that direction. Thanks for the additional reference though, you can never read too much about something! Great data sheet.
Anyone else have any input with respect to chaning from 440c to a tool steel?
-Dough
-
Fine by me.. for what that's worth :)
Neil
-
@DoughDTD said:
Yea ive read up alot on the various grades and heat treat methods, and I think I'm leaning in that direction. Thanks for the additional reference though, you can never read too much about something! Great data sheet.Anyone else have any input with respect to chaning from 440c to a tool steel?
-Dough
Whatever you choose should have at least some rust resistance. I have a couple of transmission gears which I think is made of some sort of tool steel and they literally would rust if you looked at them wrong, one even rusted under clear coat of paint I put on.
-
@Loudliam said:
. . . basically anything acid and it will force a layer of oxidation. They do this to not have to worry about rust forming.LOL. That's like saying I impregnated my girlfriend so I don't have to worry about contraception for the next nine months. :o
Rust, however, is a very good barrier for rust. Once metal molecule is an oxide, it doesn't react with additional oxygen.
-steve
-
But its a prettier rust...if that means anything. I always thought a patina was strange, it makes since, but still strange, but I do like the way it looks.
-
Damascus!
And not the fake patina stuff; the real deal. It might take you a few decades to perfect the process, but you could charge $2000 for each Crony then.
If tool steel is really what you want, 4130 is fine. Reasonable cost, difficult but not impossible to machine. No additional heat treat necessary.
When you start shopping for the exotics like D2 from botique foundrys like Crucible, you're gonna be in way over your head. Might be worth it if you were making a knife, but the Crony doesn't have an edge anywere. Doesn't make sense if you ask me.
Aluminum would be fine I would think... a nice 6061 in a T6 temper. Tough and cheap as a material. You can't get enough torque on such a short tool to damage it, can you? Plus you could anodize, hardcoat, passivate, etc. Pretty colors!
Just my never humble opinion. ::)
-steve
-
@SteveRacer said:
Aluminum would be fine I would think... a nice 6061 in a T6 temper. Tough and cheap as a material. You can't get enough torque on such a short tool to damage it, can you? Plus you could anodize, hardcoat, passivate, etc. Pretty colors!It got my attention :o That would be very cool.
-
Aluminum won't work. It doesn't have the hardness compare to steel nuts to resist stripping, the whole tool may not break but wrench tooth would be damaged the first time it slips.
-
Yup, as would the screwdriver and prybar tip. I made an aluminum prototype with no intention of keeping the part aluminum, but it surely did strip. Not a horrible idea though. PS. no dice on damascus
Too hard for me to get it right, I'm looking to get a relatively easy heat-treat steel.-Dough
-
What if you made it out of 420?
-
420 stainless? the stainless steels have a much more complicated heat treat unfortunately...ill look into the 420 with more detail, but I know the carbon and tool steels are easier to heat treat.
-Dough
-
As long as you don't go for something that will turn orange at the sight of water I don't think it will be an issue.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login