Best Lightweight SAK
-
@Fast Bill said:
@El Corkscrew said:
So I just broke out the scale and realized that the Compact doesn't even qualify. The Spartan barely does at 59.4 grams. The 84 mm golfer however, would qualify at the low 50's g mark.
So the compact is disqualified. And so is the Tinker it's at 64 grams. But the small Tinker does qualify at around 55g
By the way my commander does have T & T but it's one of the Snife series
That'll teach me not to pay attention to the OP ! Why 60g Dan? Is that an artificial boundary?
I think that's just where I start to notice a difference... probably relative to the weight of a soldier or pioneer which is closer to 70g
-
@El Corkscrew said:
@Fast Bill said:
@El Corkscrew said:
So I just broke out the scale and realized that the Compact doesn't even qualify. The Spartan barely does at 59.4 grams. The 84 mm golfer however, would qualify at the low 50's g mark.
So the compact is disqualified. And so is the Tinker it's at 64 grams. But the small Tinker does qualify at around 55g
By the way my commander does have T & T but it's one of the Snife series
That'll teach me not to pay attention to the OP ! Why 60g Dan? Is that an artificial boundary?
I think that's just where I start to notice a difference... probably relative to the weight of a soldier or pioneer which is closer to 70g
Thanks for explaining that makes sense. But I'm sensitive to bulk so weight isn't my personal determinant. But hey, it's your call here

-
The Executive eligible?

~ i love whittling and SAK's ~
-
The Recruit for me, I think it would qualify weight wise, and I carried the same one solo for 25+ years, I'm so used to the tools that I can use it in the dark with my eyes closed and have pulled off a lot of things with that little gem.


-
Bantam


in black :-) -
I just took out my scale.
Bantam: 30gr
I also put a Solo on it: 45gr!
And the Pruner: 48gr
Alox Classic: 15gr
Rambler: 25gr -
Small Tinker - it's the winner by far!
Rich -
Most usefull light weight SAK bar none is the Wenger Pocket Tool Chest.

-
Ok, so I took out the 3 lightest SAKs I have and put them on a scale...

I was surprised about the Compact being more than 60g... but would you feel the difference really?

Minichamp qualifies


-
My top picks are:
Compact (eliminated for this thread because >60g but the only thing close with scissors)
Cadet
Small Tinker
Waiter
and some discontinued Wengers:
Commander/Highlander
and the highest functionality to weight champ - the Pocket Tool Chest -
@MTMatt said:
Ok, so I took out the 3 lightest SAKs I have and put them on a scale...
LIDL scale right? :D
Yes, well... I need to safe money for more important things

-
Nice thread. Here are my favorites:
- Compact (but ruled out for weight)
- Alox Cadet
- 84 mm Golfer
- 84 mm Golfer modded with Alox scales. Whoops, that's a Voyageur. ;-)
- Voyageur
Myron
-
@MTMatt said:
Ok, so I took out the 3 lightest SAKs I have and put them on a scale...
LIDL scale right? :D
Lidl does sell a lot of Silvercrest stuff.
:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
