Knives Are Too Sharp.
-
The Telegraph is a sensationalist newspaper which feeds on artificial controversy. No pointy blades is an old and extreme idea which has never gained any traction before. I won't deny anyone their daily dose of justified outrage, but I would appreciate if any of our UK members could chime in on whether this is a marginal point of view or whether anybody actually considers this smurf seriously before I join in the Greek chorus.
-
@Steinar said:
The Telegraph is a sensationalist newspaper which feeds on artificial controversy. No pointy blades is an old and extreme idea which has never gained any traction before. I won't deny anyone their daily dose of justified outrage, but I would appreciate if any of our UK members could chime in on whether this is a marginal point of view or whether anybody actually considers this smurf seriously before I join in the Greek chorus.The Telegraph? Do you mean the Daily Mail?
-
Might be. I see from Wikipedia the Telegraph seems to be well regarded. My original questions still stands, though. Does a relevant number of people actually consider ideas like that in the UK?
-
With the exception of the Financial Times, all of the mainstream press in the UK seem to have some degree of sensationalist editorial policy.

Judges are just people. Some are dicks, some aren't.

-
@Steinar said:
Might be. I see from Wikipedia the Telegraph seems to be well regarded. My original questions still stands, though. Does a relevant number of people actually consider ideas like that in the UK?Like most things these days, I would say it's probably more like a large and very
shoutyvocal minority.Edit: which includes a large section of the cultural and political elite.
-

And I'm pretty sure I confused Daily Mail and the Telegraph. Mail and telegraphy are the same basic principle, right? :D
-
Daily Telegraph in the UK is a mainstream establishment newspaper, probably to the right wing, IMHO. Daily Mail keeps running stories about Lady Di and Elvis.
In the UK there is a perception we have a problem with knife crime. There are knife amnesties and disposal bins where you can take knifes for disposal in UK cities. We also have moderately strict laws on what can be carried (e.g. even a screwdriver has a blade and could get you in trouble if you took into a pub). And we cannot carry for self-defence since we cannot carry weapons (even for self-defence).
But I don't think the opinion in the story is mainstream serious. Judges sometimes say weird stuff (and get mis-quoted or taken out of context). But this story seems an over-reaction, probably because the cricket match between England and Pakistan finished early (3 days instead of 5) so they needed to fill column inches.
-
A very apt thread....
My home city of Sheffield had 4 fatal stabbings in one week. The young lad who recently teamed up with me at work lives in the area of one of the victims stabbed last week. According to him, all the young kids now carry knives for protection....most of these are school kids!!
Personally the way I feel about this at the moment if you are caught carrying what can only be described as an offensive weapon, i.e Kitchen knife, fixed hunting knife etc etc I think it should be a mandatory 3yr sentence. If you are stupid enough to actually use one to commit crime, then it should be mandatory 10yrs, if its fatal stabbing then it should be life without parole.
To hell with them!!
-
@Don Pablo said:
Cultural difference, I say.
North America is influenced by the self reliant people that moved there hundreds of years ago, while in Europe... Rich nobles were in charge for hundreds of years.
Back in the middle ages, peasants could be punished for having things like swords?
Ding ding ding.
But don't worry. American culture is bound and determined, come hell or high water, to create a noble ruling class. We get to pick our helpful, friendly overlords.
-
I really liked that tax idea.....
Throw a massive tax on knives (and everything else, while we're at it)
Tradesmen can claim it back as an operating expense at tax time, everyone else helps fill the coffers of parliament.
I should run a country.
(I don't see a problem with this at all? What does a domestic user need knives, or tools, or anything at all for?
I mean, sure, I can imagine a professional rally driver might need a spanner? but the home user? I think not!Waterproof Jackets? Who do you think you are? Edmund Hillary? NOT LIKELY, pay the tax!
Computers? Sure, Charles Dickens might need one; the rest of these plebs? TAX!
Quick set Cement is it? Oh, you're installing a letterbox? OR ARE YOU CONCEALING THE BODIES OF YOUR VICTIMS? Well, I can tell you one thing, unless you can show me your builder's permit, you'll be paying a TAX.Dunno if it'll reduce crime at all, but I'll sure as hell profit from it (and every other mundane activity you can conceive of)
now off you all go and eat your powdered mash potato, or whatever the hell it is the british live off that requires no preparation or skill (or taste)
-
A very apt thread....
My home city of Sheffield had 4 fatal stabbings in one week. The young lad who recently teamed up with me at work lives in the area of one of the victims stabbed last week. According to him, all the young kids now carry knives for protection....most of these are school kids!!
Personally the way I feel about this at the moment if you are caught carrying what can only be described as an offensive weapon, i.e Kitchen knife, fixed hunting knife etc etc I think it should be a mandatory 3yr sentence. If you are stupid enough to actually use one to commit crime, then it should be mandatory 10yrs, if its fatal stabbing then it should be life without parole.
To hell with them!!
I like the way we bandy about things like "10 years" or "life without parole"
Like that helps anything at all.
You've really got two choices, either sack up and be willing to just kill "undesirables", or create and support a rehabilitation based system that treats the issues and returns people to society (you'll just have to get over your desire for "justice" (aka vengeance?)
-
Haven't the UK already made it illegal to stab people? Maybe even gone as far as to ban carrying knives without due cause in public in an effort to reduce impulsive misuse? (Or more likely to give the police a legal footing to take action against some people who carry knives and who seems to be up to no good).
If some people are already willing to break the above laws then I figure chances are that they will disregard any pointy knife law too.
-
@Sea Monster said:
be willing to just kill "undesirables"When you disarm the populace, or worse they disarm themselves, you create a situation where the government has a monopoly. In this case, effective force. Yes, there is "accountability", but the agents of the state are accountable to the state. If the people want to protest, well, they're rioting. Riotous and revolting peasents- kill a few of them. Kill a few more until they are cowed.
I'm not going to call out any nation state for this (my own would be among them), but when you get right down to it, what is the difference between a government and organized crime? Both have armed enforcers. Both charge taxes, in large part to provide protection from their enforcers. Both wipe out any competition, and to hell with the collateral damage. The difference is, governments get to print money.
-
I'm guessing
that the vast majority of stabbings is in some way related to drugs??
I don't understand why governments be it the US or UK, or any for that matter, have not yet created a genetic disease that could be released to wipe out drug crops. Surely those drugs that were needed for science could be grown under license.But I guess there/s too much money been made by those in power.
-
But they say its for public safety. Forbidding alcohol would do a lot more to public safety... at least in theory. But then there is no guarantee that forbidding pointy things will reduce the number of victims.
That was tried in the USA...with disastrous results.
Wait, all those cool movies are a disaster and isn't like the whole Chicago-Detroit car industry built on moonshine money :D
I agree completely and that is exactly my point. Forbidding something is not as easy as it sounds and not nearly as effective, especially if whatever is forbidden can be replaced easily with something else. The only way to solve a problem is by tackling the problem. The knife is not the cause of the stabbing, its just the tool used.
-
@Etherealicer said:
The knife is not the cause of the stabbing, its just the tool used.True, but I am sure it is much easier for authorities to ban knives rather than try to fix the underlying problem.
@tosh said:
I'm guessing
that the vast majority of stabbings is in some way related to drugs??
I don't understand why governments be it the US or UK, or any for that matter, have not yet created a genetic disease that could be released to wipe out drug crops. Surely those drugs that were needed for science could be grown under license.Or legalise drugs so crims can't make money off them.
-
I can't believe I'm saying this, but... lets not get to political, guys. Lets just make fun of the stupid idea and derail this thread, create some memes and let it fade away...


-
@Etherealicer said:
The knife is not the cause of the stabbing, its just the tool used.True, but I am sure it is much easier for authorities to ban knives rather than try to fix the underlying problem.
@tosh said:
I'm guessing
that the vast majority of stabbings is in some way related to drugs??
I don't understand why governments be it the US or UK, or any for that matter, have not yet created a genetic disease that could be released to wipe out drug crops. Surely those drugs that were needed for science could be grown under license.Or legalise drugs so crims can't make money off them.
There's not enough time in an election cycle to tackle the large problems properly, so it's better to slap a band aid on it, chalk it up as a win and hope it holds until it's someone else's problem.

Def
-
Vote Don Pablo dictator of Earth for life!
Then he’ll be in charge long enough to fix these problems!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login