Access to Power -SOG 30-day Challenge! Starting June 1st! Access & Access Deluxe
-
Day 11
I had some time this morning to test the cutters
The cutters cut everything I tried
Until I tried to cut the 2.5mm nail
It cut the nail without any problem
But when I checked the jaws on the cutters
That I noticed some damage on one side of the cutters
You can see the damage clearly on the pics
In the next post


-
**Day 11 continued **
Here are some close ups of the damage
I don’t know how Powernoodle
got away with cutting that nail he did



-
@Wspeed said:
**Day 11 continued **Here are some close ups of the damage
I don’t know how Powernoodle
got away with cutting that nail he did
that's exactly what happened to my Powerlock :P
Powernoodle's nails must be untempered or made of brass ???@Wspeed said:
I was looking at the can opener on the PAD and a can opener on a SAK
And noticed that the opener on the SAK has a cutting edge like a knife
And the SOG opener only one side has a cutting edge
and only halfway on the curved edgeI also noticed that the PAD can opener looks left handed
As the SOG and SAK have the angles and grinds are opposites
I am left handed so it will be a good test for me
Just need to find some cans now as most now have ring pulls :ahhh
Here are a few pics of what I am talking about
well judging by its construction and previous experiences with my SOGs it looks more like the now famous* can't* opener present in this company's multitools :ahhh
Also, what happens when the pull-to-open ring gets separated or torn from the can? I've had that happen more than once

also, seeing that it barely has an edge (ie, it is blunt) and judging by Nix's mess with the tomato can and the can lid submerged in tomato soup, this is more like a "Press And Destroy" can opening implement :D
-
So bad cutters a file that is not a file and
a can opener that is more like a can’t opener
SOG is doing well
-
Nails are a tough order. I'm not surprised to see some rolling from that test. But, I think this is where LM's replaceable cutters are a good idea. It's not often I need to cut a nail (or other hard wire), but it's nice to know that one could and then replace a mangled cutter if required. And, even with regular use, I suspect all cutters can dull or chip (I've got some dedicated wire cutters with the odd chip in them).
-
@Nix said:
Nails are a tough order. I'm not surprised to see some rolling from that test. But, I think this is where LM's replaceable cutters are a good idea. It's not often I need to cut a nail (or other hard wire), but it's nice to know that one could and then replace a mangled cutter if required. And, even with regular use, I suspect all cutters can dull or chip (I've got some dedicated wire cutters with the odd chip in them).have you seen Tim Leatherman's famous test? :D
-
Yes I have seen his test
He stands on the tool to cut that big nail

-
I am going to buy 3 cans today
So I can try to use the can opener for day 12
I am left handed and have no problems
using a can opener on the SAK or LM
And after seeing Nix opening the can
I don’t know if it will work for me
It will be a interesting task for Day 12
-

At least for the can't opener, there is some hope it can be turned into a can opener easily, i.e. by grinding it a little. Of course, that is something SOG should have done in the first place...
I am almost dreading my nail cutting test now... :o
-
At least for the can't opener, there is some hope it can be turned into a can opener easily, i.e. by grinding it a little. Of course, that is something SOG should have done in the first place...
I am almost dreading my nail cutting test now... :o
I was thinking the same about the can’t opener
If I have the same problems as
Nix when I test the can’t opener
I will try and regrind the opener like on the SAK or LM
It’s not like you can make it any worse
:ahhh 
-
Day 11
Phillips driver test - passed. I agree however with whoever said this that this tool is not suitable for much more deeply recessed screws...

-
@Wspeed said:
**Day 11 continued **Here are some close ups of the damage
I don’t know how Powernoodle
got away with cutting that nail he did
I gotta call ya out on the nail thing, W.
PN shouldn't have done it either. Makes little to no sense.
That is not a fair test to be honest. SOG doesn't advertise the cutters as "hard nail cutters".
That will not likely be covered under warranty. It is basically abuse.
Edit: For the record, and I emphasize this, I am not cutting hardened nails with my PAD. I don't do it with any other MT, so why ruin my PAD warranty? I urge anyone to NOT void their warranty by cutting hardened nails.
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
I am almost dreading my nail cutting test now... :oThen don't do it. :D It is not on the challenge sheet. Nor is cutting hardened steel nails listed as a function of the PAD.
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
On that last pic GLBM, how solid was the sensation you got from the PAD when tightening the bolt? Haven't tried that yet...The only thing I wasn't too thrilled about is the slight looseness of the tool inside the socket. But, that is not a problem with the tool, it is just an issue with having 1/2 of a 1/4" driver to do it. :)
-
@gerleatherberman said:
don’t know how Powernoodle got away with cutting that nail he did
Skill. Talent. Good looks. Its all part of the same continuum.
In Nutnfancy's Youtube review of the Swisstool several years ago, he cut a nail in half too with no damage.
PN shouldn't have done it either. Makes little to no sense.

Now, you know that MTO is not about making sense. A bunch of semi-grown men posting pictures of MTs on the internet makes no sense.

For one, I did not care if I destroyed the PAD because I just didn't like it, and because I own more MTs than I can ever use. That is to say, I was prepared to totally destroy the hard wire cutter. And, its fun to cut a framing nail. We do this stuff for fun. Further, it like what "Tim" does on the Military Arms Channel on Youtube. He dunks a gun in water, dirt, sand and mud, and then sees if it still goes bang. That's not the intended usage of a firearm, and not really "fair" to the maker, but that's how you see where its failure point is. You do what's not fair.
Fair or not, its just a data point. You might remember that I've buried more than one MT in the ground for a year to see if it will rust.
/topic/61008 Again, that's outside the MTs design parameters, just like cutting a 10-penny nail may be, but this is not about being fair to SOG. Its about having fun, and maybe learning what your MT can do and what it cannot. My PAD would cut a big, fat nail in half, but that is something I would never do for real. -
powernoodle,
I cannot disagree with your excellently written reply. However, with that said, I should restate my assertion to make more sense.
I should have been clear with my original comment. In essence, regarding the current thread, this particular challenge is about seeing if the PAD can handle routine multitool tasks. Cutting big-smurfin' nails IS fun to try an MT on, but isn't something a majority of us will EVER need to do.
-
**Day 11 continued **
Here are some close ups of the damage
I don’t know how Powernoodle
got away with cutting that nail he did
I gotta call ya out on the nail thing, W.
PN shouldn't have done it either. Makes little to no sense.
That is not a fair test to be honest. SOG doesn't advertise the cutters as "hard nail cutters".
That will not likely be covered under warranty. It is basically abuse.
Edit: For the record, and I emphasize this, I am not cutting hardened nails with my PAD. I don't do it with any other MT, so why ruin my PAD warranty? I urge anyone to NOT void their warranty by cutting hardened nails.
I was in no way trying to test the cutters to their limits
I just wanted to test the cutters with the nail
As Powernoodle cut that large nail
After his test I thought it would
be no problem to cut a 2.5 mm nail
I also tested this with my LM Supertool
And no problems or damageI will say that it’s only a small bit of damage
As I made close up pics to show the damage
I tested the cutters again with the bit of damage
And they still cut everything I used for the test
Just didn’t try a nail again as I now know it’s limitI am not saying that the cutters are no good
As they work and cut everything I tried and still work
I am more a bit surprised after
Powernoodle cutting that large nail
That my cutters got that bit of damageBut I totally agree don’t try and cut nails with the hard wire cutters

-
On that last pic GLBM, how solid was the sensation you got from the PAD when tightening the bolt? Haven't tried that yet...
The only thing I wasn't too thrilled about is the slight looseness of the tool inside the socket. But, that is not a problem with the tool, it is just an issue with having 1/2 of a 1/4" driver to do it. :)

-
@Wspeed said:
I don’t know how Powernoodlegot away with cutting that nail he did

I honestly did, though. I would lie to you about most things
, but not that. I could not take a pic of the actual cutting because it took two hands to bear down on the PAD.I believe that you cut that nail
I was more surprised that a
2.5mm nail would of been a problem
I didn’t even use a lot of force to cut the nail
This is why I said I don’t know
how you got away with no damage
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login