Access to Power -SOG 30-day Challenge! Starting June 1st! Access & Access Deluxe
-
Nice test GLBM

I will try that and use the file from the LM Supertool
For comparison and take some pics
Thank you, W! I look forward to reading your report.

As far as the file on my particular PAD goes, I have had to admit that I stuck my foot in my mouth in public. It is pretty embarrassing.

It is in no way a "good" or even "mediocre" file, but (at least in my case) it did work. :ahhhI am really surprised that you got the file to work
And I want to test the file on aluminium
As you tested mild steel and wood with ok results
I will see if I can do the test tomorrow
-
Spoiler:
I am not, usually, one to rock the boat. But, curiousoty got the best of me today.I made a crappy video (three parts, because I suck at youtube) about the file. If you dare to see what happens with the file, please feel free to watch. :)
Part 1:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ls5kkgQ_RKY
Part 2:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p_muxRa6jXE
Part 3:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=mYvZ5EsPaA4Apologies for the video being crappy. I am not a youtube person. :ahhh
Edit: I think that qualifies as using the file. One more checked off. And I just realized I hadn't used the medium driver yet! Will do that one tomorrow.
Thanks for taking the time to record and upload these.

-
Great challenge and pics guys [emoji16] And good idea with the checklist [emoji106]
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
Spoiler:
I am not, usually, one to rock the boat. But, curiousoty got the best of me today.I made a crappy video (three parts, because I suck at youtube) about the file. If you dare to see what happens with the file, please feel free to watch. :)
Part 1:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ls5kkgQ_RKY
Part 2:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p_muxRa6jXE
Part 3:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=mYvZ5EsPaA4Apologies for the video being crappy. I am not a youtube person. :ahhh
Edit: I think that qualifies as using the file. One more checked off. And I just realized I hadn't used the medium driver yet! Will do that one tomorrow.
Thanks for taking the time to record and upload these.


@Wspeed said:
I am really surprised that you got the file to work
And I want to test the file on aluminium
As you tested mild steel and wood with ok results
I will see if I can do the test tomorrow
I look forward to reading about your experience with SOG-filing aluminum. Primarily, because it clogs(for my lack of a better term) even the best files in short order. :ahhh
Whatever the results, please don't <u>file</u> them away. :D
-
Yes this could be interesting to see what will happen
I am going to use the LM Supertool file for comparing
The SOG PAD file on the same aluminium
This way I will have a better idea if the file works or not
-
Day 12
Not wanting to steal your thunder Wspeed, but great minds think alike, it seems... I've just finished a quick comparison between a loose LM Supertool 300 file and the one on the PAD, on a piece of aluminium.
Verdict: even loose, i.e. with no handle, the ST file works better than the one on the PAD (i.e. with a sizable handle), I'd estimate about twice to three times as well in terms of abrasive qualities per unit of transversal force applied. No surprise, but... having said that... what is surprising is that even the PAD file works, after a fashion, despite only the most minimal of grooves and the entire absence of any apex worthy of the name between them.

-
Nice one DT

Do you think that the Supertool 300 file
Would be able to fit the PAD
Is there enough metal on the pivot end
To copy the PAD file pivot profile
-
Thank you for checking on it as well, DT!
The PA/PAD file is a perplexing phenomenon. It seems that we really jumped into presumption, if it turns out, that most (if not all) of our PADs have a barely mediocre file (and not useless ). We must go back and reevaluate some assertions I think.

But, all in all, I cannot say I am upset. This makes the file usable. :)
Now, I start to ponder, is it better or worse than a file on a "seriously" low quality MT? Say, an Ozark Trail $3.88 MT, perhaps?
I shall endeavor to test this possibility before the challenge is completed.
-
For the challenge day 12:
- Used the plain edge blade to cut splintered wood and dried wood glue out of a poorly repaired foot on this cedar chest. I cut stuff out until I had two flush surfaces to glue back properly.
- I tried out the medium driver on the bottle opener. I drove four wood screws into cedar foot-support blocks with it. I did make starter holes with the awl to make it easier. The piece pictured is the one glued back together.
Thankfully only one foot was jacked up, because it took several hours to get it all sorted. :ahhh


-
Day 12
Wow was it difficult to get some old
style cans with something I like to eat
It looks like it won’t be long and all cans will have a ring pull
And the can opener will be obsolete :ahhhFor the test I bought 3 cans
2 normal size tins and 1 large tin
Now I can tick all three task boxes for
Opening the cans in one day :DThe can opener works but it is more
Like just puncturing the tin
I had 3 tins to test and I tried different
ways to open the tins but couldn’t get the
Tin opener to work any better
All I got was butchered tinsI am left handed and have no problem
using the SAK or LM can opener
Looking at the can opener you can see
it’s got no proper cutting edge and it’s very bluntNow I have tested the can opener I
will have a go at reshaping the opener
I can’t make it any worse I hope
I don’t really use a can opener
But it should work why put one
on the PAD if it doesn’t work
Or does SOG already know that
Cans will all be ring pull soon
So SOG can’t be bothered to make it work


-
Great job, W! I imagine that was arduous at best.

Only "good" can opener I have seen on a SOG is on the early ParaTool and PowerPlier. Those resembled the Leatherman can openers. :)
-
Thanks GLBM

It wasn’t easy opening the cans
But got there in the end
It doesn’t look like a can opener will
be needed soon anymore it will be interesting
To see what companies will replace
The can opener with instead on their MT
-
@Wspeed said:
Nice one DT
Do you think that the Supertool 300 file
Would be able to fit the PAD
Is there enough metal on the pivot end
To copy the PAD file pivot profile
I'm thinking there might be... there remains the fact that the file proper would have to be made lower-profile as well, and I don't know how the steel's tempering would react to a cutting disc being put to it...
Good job on the cans as well - looks like a battlefield. Methinks a grinding job cannot possibly make the opener worse

-
@gerleatherberman said:
Thank you for checking on it as well, DT!The PA/PAD file is a perplexing phenomenon. It seems that we really jumped into presumption, if it turns out, that most (if not all) of our PADs have a barely mediocre file (and not useless ). We must go back and reevaluate some assertions I think.

But, all in all, I cannot say I am upset. This makes the file usable. :)
Now, I start to ponder, is it better or worse than a file on a "seriously" low quality MT? Say, an Ozark Trail $3.88 MT, perhaps?
I shall endeavor to test this possibility before the challenge is completed.


-
Nice one DT

Do you think that the Supertool 300 file
Would be able to fit the PAD
Is there enough metal on the pivot end
To copy the PAD file pivot profile
I'm thinking there might be... there remains the fact that the file proper would have to be made lower-profile as well, and I don't know how the steel's tempering would react to a cutting disc being put to it...
Good job on the cans as well - looks like a battlefield. Methinks a grinding job cannot possibly make it worse

Thanks DT

I think cutting the file will be fine
If the file has enough metal to make it fit
Than I would definitely try and make the file work :DI don’t think I can make the can opener
Any worse than it already is right now
It would be nice for the can opener to work properly
-
So, the question begs to be asked, do those of you who used the can opener so far have experience using knife/mt can openers? If so, a fair side by side with a SAK can opener would be more reasonable than just saying the sog can opener is garbage. Photos of a can opened with the pad next to a can opened with a sak. Seems only fair to me.
The pad can openers did work, seeing the photos. They are just not good at it(or difficult to use). In a pinch, it looks like it can do the job. And with practice, may get easier to use.
Just some food for thought, as I have observed, judging the PAD in absolute terminology isn't going to end with a fair and unbiased final result.
We have to keep the challenge grounded in reasonability and not emotion.
Adopting an absolute stance on multitool performance based on two tools is a very narrow in scope and fails to address any nuances that may shed some favorable light on it as a whole.And PN,
It isn't a "punk". It boils down to poor design, resulting in the file and can opener not being "sak-like" in function.
Just, because something is mediocre, doesn't make it useless. The nuance being that the truth is somewhere in the middle.
You seem to present yourself as an authority on the PAD, but honesty, I don't think you had enough experience using it to make absolute claims about it.
Have you read over the file correction part of the thread yet? The file is actually useful on metal and wood. The perplexing phenomenon being that it feels/looks smooth and doesn't work well on fingernails. But, it sure seems to work on harder materials. Even the notching side.I know crapping on stuff is an international past time, but I would like to see this thread end up being objectively true and not riddled with absolute false assertions.
Ex. Instead of saying the can opener is garbage, try discussing if it can be used in an emergency.
Whatever. Too tired to type anymore. :ahhh -
Day 13
I tested the file Today on the SOG PAD and yes it works
Looks like we are wrong about the file
I tested aluminium 3mm thickI tested the PAD first I had no problems removing
The burr using the cross cut side
Than I used the same side of the file
To chamfer the edge again no problemsThen I used the fine side of the file
To remove the corner of the aluminium
Again it worked but the groove on the file
Got in the way when trying to
remove the point on the cornerI tested my LM Supertool with the same aluminium
And yes it was easier to remove material not by muchBut I didn’t have much luck using the thin side
Of the file on the PAD hardly did anything
And couldn’t show this up in a picSo yes the SOG PAD has got a file that works
Maybe not the best and that groove cut out
Is not useful as it gets in the way filing thinner metalI tried to get some pics but have bad lighting
So hopefully you can see what I did on the aluminium



-
Awesome comparison, W!

It is mind boggling that the SOG file works as it does. One would think, the fact it hardly works on fingernails, it means it wouldn't work on harder materials at all. Does not compute...does not compute. :ahhh
Now, I must admit, I flew to everyone's house in each respective time zone/geographic location and replaced all of your PA/PAD files with ones that work while you were sleeping. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login