108mm Knifes Owner's Club!!!
-
Yes, OD green has multiple manufacturers. Good point about the red scales.
Never knew these ad knives existed... -
@Mechanickal said:
Yes, OD green has multiple manufacturers. Good point about the red scales.
Never knew these ad knives existed...I found another advertising special run on the Net. Wish those three were mine........

-
I wouldn't call Mausers "ad knives" ;)
-
@Mechanickal said:
I wouldn't call Mausers "ad knives" ;)Neither would I dare to. It just so happens that this is the only pic of a Brookstone I could find on the Net.
And it just so happens that on this one pic, the Brookstone is overpowered by two menacing Mausers. >:DNext time I will Photoshop it before posting.
-
Great idea!
Turn the scales black and put "Walther" on them!
-
@Mechanickal said:
Great idea!Turn the scales black and put "Walther" on them!
You know what ? it has already been done. The guy who makes the fancy scales is an avid collector, to the point of having a spare Mauser in average condition. He has actually polished the laser engraving away and cast new black scales out of poly-urethane resin. And now he is working on a way to re-create the logo.
for those who can read french :
http://www.forum-couteausuisse.com/t5692-Une-r-plique-de-Walther-108mm.htm -
That doesn't seem right though... :/
Edit: because this comment seems to have hit a soft spot, I'll refrain from this thread from now on.
-
@Mechanickal said:
That doesn't seem right though... :/Edit: because this comment seems to have hit a soft spot, I'll refrain from this thread from now on.
Bottom lines :
Everyone has the right to collect what he wants the way he wants it* . Everyone is entitled to his opinion.
I would be very sad if Mechanickal was to refrain from posting on this thread just because of me.*within the Law, of course
-
@Mechanickal said:
That doesn't seem right though... :/]Actually, this raises a very interesting issue that IMHO goes far beyond this particular knife of thread :
The question is : or are :
- when one is a keen collector ;
- when a resource is exhausted, (I understand roughly 2.000 Walthers were made), and ;
- when it is absolutely positively impossible to get it anywhere at any price ;
Is one entitled to build or buy a replica ? what are the issues ? when does a replica become a fake ?
let us suppose these replicas become available in small quantities ? Will that dilute the value of the original thing ?I would like very much to read the opinion of some fellow members on this issue.
But most of all, I would like to see pictures of your knives, hear about your mods, your stories, your spares. -
Great idea!
Turn the scales black and put "Walther" on them!
You know what ? it has already been done. The guy who makes the fancy scales is an avid collector, to the point of having a spare Mauser in average condition. He has actually polished the laser engraving away and cast new black scales out of poly-urethane resin. And now he is working on a way to re-create the logo.
for those who can read french :
http://www.forum-couteausuisse.com/t5692-Une-r-plique-de-Walther-108mm.htmI think recreating black scales and recreating the logo is fraudulous. First of all for the obvious infringement of Walther's intellectual property (their logo is protected by copyright), and second, if to the eye it is not possible to distinguish from the real thing then, even though the tools are genuine Victorinox, it is making fake SAKs and I think Victorinox would not be happy with that.
-
Great idea!
Turn the scales black and put "Walther" on them!
You know what ? it has already been done. The guy who makes the fancy scales is an avid collector, to the point of having a spare Mauser in average condition. He has actually polished the laser engraving away and cast new black scales out of poly-urethane resin. And now he is working on a way to re-create the logo.
for those who can read french :
http://www.forum-couteausuisse.com/t5692-Une-r-plique-de-Walther-108mm.htmI think recreating black scales and recreating the logo is fraudulous. First of all for the obvious infringement of Walther's intellectual property (their logo is protected by copyright), and second, if to the eye it is not possible to distinguish from the real thing then, even though the tools are genuine Victorinox, it is making fake SAKs and I think Victorinox would not be happy with that.
I am not far away from sharing your position. If anyone and his dog can get a Walther replica, it diminishes the value of the genuine ones.
And you know fine well how hard it is to get a real one. -
Great idea!
Turn the scales black and put "Walther" on them!
You know what ? it has already been done. The guy who makes the fancy scales is an avid collector, to the point of having a spare Mauser in average condition. He has actually polished the laser engraving away and cast new black scales out of poly-urethane resin. And now he is working on a way to re-create the logo.
for those who can read french :
http://www.forum-couteausuisse.com/t5692-Une-r-plique-de-Walther-108mm.htmI think recreating black scales and recreating the logo is fraudulous. First of all for the obvious infringement of Walther's intellectual property (their logo is protected by copyright), and second, if to the eye it is not possible to distinguish from the real thing then, even though the tools are genuine Victorinox, it is making fake SAKs and I think Victorinox would not be happy with that.
I am not far away from sharing your position.
And, being very recently returned to this forum, a junior member of sorts, I do not want to open up the big can of worms, but, in this cas, what about the re-created 108s from Swiss Bianco ?They are not build to be an exact replica of something existing, and that's what makes all the difference. A custom scale or custom tool combination (like the Swiss Bianco models) is something unique of its own. Making a black 108mm with a Walther logo is making a fake Walther knife.
-
I'd be less worried if the creator of the knife would add an inscription to the scales or liner (under the corkscrew) that states it's not an original Walther.
Imagine:
The creator of the knife dies one day,
Relatives find the knife (probably knivES but bear with me here),
They go online and find out that the knife is a Walther and it's rare.
They sell it as "the real deal".
Some unknowing buyer now has a "Walther" and will always believe it's genuine!It's like when people buy old Explorers and change them to a Scientist.
Suddenly it's a rare model that goes for 3x the value of the Explorer.Buyers will get suspicious, prices will drop, the fun gets spoiled for everyone.
Either find the real deal, or keep searching.
-
@Mechanickal said:
I'd be less worried if the creator of the knife would add an inscription to the scales or liner (under the corkscrew) that states it's not an original Walther.It's like when people buy old Explorers and change them to a Scientist.
Suddenly it's a rare model that goes for 3x the value of the Explorer.
Buyers will get suspicious, prices will drop, the fun gets spoiled for everyone.Either find the real deal, or keep searching.
glad to see you back on this thread, mate ! :) -
BTW he is not through yet with the logo. Silkscreening is a complicated process.
Now I have to go, I have these Explorers I must dismantle to make them into Scientists >:D
(this is humor) you are darn right, if there is doubt the value will drop. -


Someone seems to be having a larger spending budget soon...
-
Beer is a good idea !
I'm off for tonight. Keep well you allJust one thing about pictures :
MOAR MOAR MOAR pictures !

-
Well, well... The Bushcrafter replica that Mags made for me is indistinguishable from a SwissBianco one, because the original didn´t have their logo etched on the blade.
Since it only requires the opener layer to be removed of a Farmer, it´s about half the cost of a +B knife. Noone ever complained about it. -
Swissbianco sells copies to start with!

In my humble opinion...
-
@Ron Who said:
Well, well... The Bushcrafter replica that Mags made for me is indistinguishable from a SwissBianco one, because the original didn´t have their logo etched on the blade.
Since it only requires the opener layer to be removed of a Farmer, it´s about half the cost of a +B knife. Noone ever complained about it.And you won't hear me complain about it! For you it's probably mostly about functionality and not about the pretending it's a rare +B knife. If you ever sell it, I have no doubt you'll state clearly that it's a mod.
I know it's probably a thin line and hard to define it clearly, but to me there's a big difference between a functional mod (like people building a mod Yeoman or something like that) and a collectible like the Walther. I would totally have no problem with someone constructing a 108mm with an extra clip point blade and black scales, but as soon as you are adding a Walther logo on it, it crosses a big red line for me. At that point you're creating something with a whole different intention: you're creating a tool with no other purpose than misleading, and not with the purpose of creating a useful tool.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login