CYC2: Return of the Executive
-
I’ll be honest guys. I participated in the last executive challenge and never took it off my keychain. What conclusions came out of it? An executive is all I really need. I rarely use a knife in the office, and occasionally when I need it, I reach for my executive. For now, this realization helped me slow down my SAK hoarding.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
This was a conclusion I came to many years ago. While still young and growing in the 1950's, most themes I grew up around were all military vets of WW2 and before that the great depression. My dad carried a little two blade Case peanut as his sole pocketknife and go by very nicely with it. That was the typical knife I saw growing up; the small 3 inch or so closed two blade jackknife or pen knife. All sorts of working guys carried one for their knife and did well. They opened boxes, cut twine, peeled fruit, did double duty as a fishing knife for cutting line and bait, as well as gutting and cleaning the catch of the day. Jack knives, Barlow kins, pen knives, all did what they needed to do as a cutting tool. So it was my knife as well. At least up to when I joined the Boy Scouts at age 12 and dd gav me a scout knife.
That set the pattern for me formally years, having a knife with a few tools on it. WehnI ws I the army stationed in Germany, I saw a SAK display in the window of a knife shop in Rothenburg Germany. I got hooked on SAk's then. For years, my carry was a small tinker, or a recruit. Then I discovered alox. The slim cadet took up residence in my coin pocket for a long time.
ONce I reached middle age I just carried a smaller knife as I just didn't think I needed much knife in modern suburbia. With no hostile injuns coming over the hill to take my scalp, or buffalo to skin, a small pocketknife was all that was needed, even in the machine shop I worked in. Look at how much can be done with a Stanley siding blade utility knife with a replaceable one inch blade. Over the years I actually went down to the little Vic classic and got by just fine. The only thing it failed at was food use. Just too short for slicing through a thick loaf of bread, or dealing with stuff away from the home kitchen. Eating out at a BBQ joint and having to separate ribs from the rest of the uncut rack with a classic don't work. Thus the watch/coin pocket of my jeans was always taken up with a knife like the Schrade Uncle Henry 897, or a Case peanut that had that tiny extra bit of blade that was handy, but still in a coin pocket size package.
Now with an executive in hand for the first time, I see how it's just that extra bit bigger that makes a huge difference in real world usability over the 58mm that I used for the past 20 something years. A coin pocket size knife with the extra capability of dealing with small flat and Phillips screws, and scissors, always a handy thing to have. I've already found the spear shaped tip on the exec is good for small Phillips screws in a pinch if I don't feel like digging the Vic quarto out of my wallet.
This is gonna be interesting.
Great insight sbl51. Looking worward to seeing your pictures.
-
The challenge hasn't even officially started and you guys are awlready providing some great insights.
I'm stoked to be doing the Chuck Yeager challenge awl over again. (Perhaps we need a CYC merit badge?)
Zhenchok; you've done it once; you've lived it since; how about joining us for a second round?
c'mon..... 
-
Chuck Yeager is 95 years old and still going strong. In fact he's married to a 45 year old woman he met while hiking, and his kids have sued him thinking the ne wife is going to get all the money. Greedy little bastids. Yeager is a bit of a curmudgeon but he's earned that right with all he's done for tis country. YES, they need a Chuck Yeager challenge merit badge in honor of this man. I've read his books Yeager as well as Press On. Press on is a hilarious at times account of his adventures in fishing and hunting and the famous back packing trips he and his old friend Andy did in the Sierra Nevada mountains after the California Golden Trout, which Yeager had an obsession on caching and cooking over a campfire.
I'm willing to bet that as we talk, he's still got his executive in his pocket.
-
I dearly hope so!
-
This will be fun to follow! I'm in the sans-Executive camp, and I'm pretty sure I won't have one until the start of the challenge, but at some point, sooner or later - maybe when Grant will have some used ones at those nice budget prices at MTO store - I'll join the club, and until then I'll watch and learn!
-
C'mon, Exeter!

Get an Exec and join in!

-
Plus one. Heck, I'm starting early, replacing some valves on a drip line in the backyard. I figured I'd use my pocket knife instead of my Stanley. Also tightened up the pivot screw of my utility shears, which are kinda visible in the pic.
Really, I use a 58mm most of the time. I work in an office, not in a warehouse, construction, or anything else requiring a decent sized knife. Scissors in my 58mms get used more than the blade, to boot. I have a paring knife in my lunch box, utility knives in various tool boxes, and kitchen knives in the kitchen. I just don't use big knives. I'm happy with smaller ones.
-
Came out to 3mb, file size limit is 1.. I'll tinker with my photobucket account when I get home from walking the dog.
-
I'm in like Flynn with this old Companion

.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)

-

Eh?
-
Outstanding guys!! FoBo, we need you too!!
-
@Ron Who said:
Still thinking about it. At least I already have a couple and from past experience I know that I like them.But the classic could be just a tad bigger.
The Ambassador would be the way to go then.
I'll be in for this Challenge Nix. Last year I picked up an Ambassador and carried that for CYC1.
As FoBo's recent 58mm etc Challenge reminded me if you put your mind to it 58mm can cover a surprisingly wide base. And I enjoyed the Ambassadors svelte lines just disappearing into my pocket with a decent toolset.
This time round I'll aim to carry my Executive and see what that Orange Peeler can do. My problem is I picked up a MiniChamp for the 58mm etc Challenge and I am thoroughly enjoying what that can do!
-
@getahl said:
Plus one. Heck, I'm starting early, replacing some valves on a drip line in the backyard. I figured I'd use my pocket knife instead of my Stanley. Also tightened up the pivot screw of my utility shears, which are kinda visible in the pic.Really, I use a 58mm most of the time. I work in an office, not in a warehouse, construction, or anything else requiring a decent sized knife. Scissors in my 58mms get used more than the blade, to boot. I have a paring knife in my lunch box, utility knives in various tool boxes, and kitchen knives in the kitchen. I just don't use big knives. I'm happy with smaller ones.
Pretty much the same boat I'm in. Being retired I'm not ut doing heavy stuff, just a lot of fiddling with fishing gear while sitting on the bank of the San Gabriel river or Lake Georgetown. But...even when I was working in the machine shop before I retired, there was a lot of dirty cutting to br done, and it was mostly done with the Stanley unity knives that were on all the work benches. It was very surprising and educational to see what a thin one inch blade can do. After that idiot kid cut off his right index finger when his Buck 110 folded on him from lock failure, the company banned folding knives from the shop and cutting had to done with either the unity knives or shears/snips.
In 98% of civilian life, a small pocket knife is adequate for most cutting jobs.
-
Excellent! Glad you guys are joining in on this!
Current challenge team:
Nix
VICMAN
Barry
GoatDragon
getahl
cbl51
El Corkscrew
Fast BillWe still have room for another 1 or 2 dozen starters......

zrxoa1? Zhenchok? FoBo? Mags? Hiraethus? -
:ahhh Great to have you Bill!!
-
Okay, it's the next day since I got the exec, and so far it's been a time of discovery. Feeling out the new tool. I used it to open a few plastic bags, one of bird seed for the feeders and one of some landscaping border stakes. As far as knife uses its fine. I did use the nail file to smooth out a chipped nail, and it's different. I didn't know that Victorinox uses a different type file from the rough stuff on the 58's nail file. This exec is like a real metal nail file, and I can't say if I like it better or worse than the classic's since I'm so familiar with the classic. All I can say is, it's different, but ti seems to work well.
I can't predict if I will have any good to say about the orange peeler. This was one thing that I think may have kept me from buying an executive in the past, as I just can't see the use of it. I'd really wish that Victorinox would replace it with a combo like tool like on the 58's with a dedicated small Phillips and bottle opener. Or even a full serrated blade like on their paring knives.
But overall, my next day impression is still one of a very very nice knife with enough added handle for added heft and confidence in a bit heavier use. I like it.
-
The orange peeler seems to work well for opening clam-shell packaging. And the tip works like a small driver. I find it is mostly a fun thing to use, but not terribly important in itself.
Reflecting back on a fruit-filled life, I can't say I've ever met an orange I couldn't peel with just a regular knife. So it does seem like an odd tool to include in a knife with two other cutting blades. I just think of it as an extra cutter.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login