Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • World
Skins
  • Light
  • Dark

Collapse

NodeBB

Evolution of Wood Saws on 91mm Victorinox SAKs

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
57 Posts 1 Posters 11.6k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • M
    M
    MiniChamp
    wrote on last edited by
    #4

    Thanks! I think that I took it as far as I can with my own resources. Now I'm hoping for some help. :think: :pok: :think:

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • WspeedW
      WspeedW
      Wspeed
      wrote on last edited by
      #5

      That's a nice bit of information :tu: :like: :like:

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • Ron WhoR
        Ron WhoR
        Ron Who
        wrote on last edited by
        #6

        Impressive! 😎 :tu:

        I :like: woodsaws!

        Your formal expressions to describe woodsaws are very interesting. One thing confuses me though. In an expression like 14+15, the left number denotes the teeth on the right side of the saw, and vice versa. (I guess it´s too late to change it now after you´ve done all that work).

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • M
          M
          MiniChamp
          wrote on last edited by
          #7

          @Ron Who said:
          Your formal expressions to describe woodsaws are very interesting. One thing confuses me though. In an expression like 14+15, the left number denotes the teeth on the right side of the saw, and vice versa. (I guess it´s too late to change it now after you´ve done all that work).

          You are right, of course. I am probably guilty of introducing bad notation. I was thinking of the right side as also being the FRONT side, since this is the side facing the front of the SAK, and of the 15 in 15+14 as being the FIRST, so it somehow seemed to me natural to associate the front direction with the first term. It never really occurred to me before that the expression 15+14 also has its own left/right directions.

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • shadowriderS
            shadowriderS
            shadowrider
            wrote on last edited by
            #8

            That's a great research! :salute:

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • M
              M
              MiniChamp
              wrote on last edited by
              #9

              Many thanks to all those who responded. Ron's remark above convinced me that my proposed Rn+Ln notation is likely to be confusing to people. Namely, it's probably better to say that a saw is right-weighted and has 29 teeth than to say that it has 15+14 teeth (which is equivalent). I will thus refrain from using the Rn+Ln notation going forward.

              I discovered another saw variant that I didn't know exist. :woohoo: It's a left-weighted variant with 39 teeth from the mid-1950's. It is similar to the variant that I called SW2 above, but it's left-weighted instead of being right-weighted. I found images of it on a mid-1950's model 237, while going over some images that I had saved on my PC (mostly from internet sales). I don't know if this left-weighted variant came before or after the corresponding right-weighted variant with 39 teeth.

              This finding of a new variant poses a problem for my previously introduced type designations that relied on a chronological running counter. If I would try to fit this new type to that system, I would run into two problems: First, I don't really know if this should be type SW2 or SW3. Second, most designations would need to change (their counter should get increased by 1), which would make things very confusing. Hence, I decided to drop this system of type designations and to develop a new one that would be based on fully encoding the properties of the different variants in their type designations. In principle, this type of system should allow adding newly discovered variants without changing any existing designations.

              The newly proposed type designations are of the form UVnnWXYZ(x), where U,V,W,X,Y,Z are capital characters, nn is a two-digit number, and x is a single-character optional additional designation that is only assigned in special cases.
              These characters and the number designate the following:
              [Material][Form][Teeth Number][Teeth symmetry][Teeth Weighting][[Nail Nick Type][Finish]([Optional Additional Designation])
              where the corresponding options are:
              [Carbon|Stainless][Narrow|Wide][27|39|29][Asymmetric|Symmetric][Standard|Long|None]Polished|Brushed
              and they are denoted in the shortened form:
              [C|S][N|W][27|39|29][A|S][L|R][S|L|N]P|B

              So far, the only "Optional Additional Designation" that has been assigned is "n" for the current saw variant (which, as far as I can tell, didn't change since the early-1980's).

              For example, the wood saws that are usually encountered on early-1950's 91mm Victorinox SAKs are made of stainless steel and they have a wide form (defined as having a shank wider than 11mm), 27 asymmetric teeth in a left-weighted configuration, standard nail nick and a polished finish. The corresponding designation for these features is SW27ALSP (which stands for Stainless-Wide-27-Asymmetric-Left-Standard-Polished), so I say that such saws are of Type SW27ALSP.

              Another example: The wood saws on current SAKs are made of stainless steel and they have a wide form, 29 symmetric teeth in a right-weighted configuration, no nail nick and a brushed finish. The corresponding designation for these features is SW29SRNB and they have characterized the wood saws on 91mm Victorinox SAKs since the late-mid-1960's. Since, as explained in the opening post of this thread above, there was a subtle change to the tip of the saws around 1980, I use the Type SW29SRNB designation for the first generation of saws with the corresponding features (namely, those made since about the late-mid-1960's to the late 1970's) and for the current saws I'm using the Type SW29SRNBn designation.

              Anyway, the attached image has the latest version of the table with the new type designations and also place holders for all the types that I know exist, but for which I don't have appropriate images at present.

              I would greatly appreciate any feedback on the newly proposed type designations (have I gone completely out of my mind? :think:), as well as any help answering the questions in the above opening post of this thread. Thanks!

              VicSawEvolution1.jpg

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • M
                M
                MiniChamp
                wrote on last edited by
                #10

                I recently managed to obtain SAKs with two types of wood saws that were previously missing :woohoo: (the April 2018 version of the table had place holders for these types, but no images). I am thus posting an updated table.

                VicSawEvolution2.jpg

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • N
                  N
                  Nick4
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #11

                  @MiniChamp said:
                  I am thus posting an updated table.

                  Many thanks! :like:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • ThePeacentT
                    ThePeacentT
                    ThePeacent
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #12

                    amazing work!! :like: :cheers:

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • M
                      M
                      MiniChamp
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #13

                      Many thanks for the positive responses! :cheers:

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • jnoxydJ
                        jnoxydJ
                        jnoxyd
                        wrote on last edited by jnoxyd
                        #14

                        Great work MiniChamp!
                        Some thoughts about dating (91mm): I believe they changed 27 teeth style to 29 teeth with small nick in great transition period 1951-1952 when many new tools were introduced. Later (c.1957) they started tip opening wood saw type without nail nick. Time of changing asymmetric to symmetric teeth in 1960s is unknown but earlier JazzBass offered mid. 1965 according to statistics.
                        What do you think?

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • M
                          M
                          MiniChamp
                          wrote on last edited by MiniChamp
                          #15

                          @jnoxyd said:
                          Great work MiniChamp!
                          Some thoughts about dating (91mm): I believe they changed 27 teeth style to 29 teeth with small nick in great transition period 1951-1952 when many new tools were introduced. Later (c.1957) they started tip opening wood saw type without nail nick. Time of changing asymmetric to symmetric teeth in 1960s is unknown but earlier JazzBass offered mid. 1965 according to statistics.
                          What do you think?

                          Thanks for your post, Jnoxyd! :like:

                          Regarding the changes in the 1950's: As I previously pointed out, I believe that Victorinox didn't go from saws with 27 teeth directly to saws with 29 teeth. As shown above, on SAKs from the mid-1950's one often finds saws with 39 teeth. I believe that when Victorinox moved away from 27 teeth, they first changed to a saw version with 39 teeth and only after a few more years they changed to a saw version with 29 teeth. It's hard for me to tell when exactly these changes were made, but if I'm forced to guess, I would put the change from 27 teeth to 39 teeth around 1954 and the change from 39 teeth to 29 teeth around 1956. The removal of the nail nick from the saws seems to have taken place after the change to hidden rivets (also, one finds saws with nail nicks on ELINOX SAKs that supposedly didn't exist before 1957). Hence, I believe that this change occurred sometime after 1957 (possibly in 1958 or 1959, say). The following (previously posted) image illustrates some of the evolution in the 1950's:

                          Note that the bottom SAK has a saw with a nail nick along with hidden rivets.

                          Regarding the change to symmetric teeth: I previously guessed 1966. As far as I can tell, 1965 is certainly also possible.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • jnoxydJ
                            jnoxydJ
                            jnoxyd
                            wrote on last edited by jnoxyd
                            #16

                            You are right, they didn't go from 27 to 29 teeth in early 1950s just changed nail nick type from large one usual in last 1940s to small nick. Looks like they produced 39 teeth saw till 1957. Here is my Champion with 39 teeth saw, post 1957 hidden rivets but old (pre1957?) square LNF nick and rounded bail.
                            What are the blade stamps on your knife with 29 teeth saw with nail nick?

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • M
                              M
                              MiniChamp
                              wrote on last edited by MiniChamp
                              #17

                              @jnoxyd said:
                              You are right, they didn't go from 27 to 29 teeth in early 1950s just changed nail nick type from large one usual in last 1940s to small nick. Looks like they produced 39 teeth saw till 1957. Here is my Champion with 39 teeth saw, post 1957 hidden rivets but old (pre1957?) square LNF nick and rounded bail.

                              Many thanks for these images, Jnoxyd! :salute: I have never seen before now a saw with 39 teeth on a Victorinox SAK with hidden rivets, so this is very interesting for me. Since I did see saws with 29 teeth on SAKs with visible rivets, like the one in the first attached image below, it looks like the transition from 39 teeth to 29 teeth indeed happened around the same time of the transition to hidden rivets (presumably 1957).

                              What is also very interesting for me is the fact that your saw with 39 teeth is right-weighted (type SW39ARSP). Before now I had no way of telling if the right-weighted saws with 39 teeth came before or after the left-weighted ones. Your SAK suggests very strongly that the first saws with 39 teeth were left-weighted and that they got changed later on (possibly around 1955, say) to right-weighted saws with 39 teeth.

                              Regarding the changes in the late 1940's/early 1950's: Some of the wood saws on SAKs from the 1946-51 period, like the one in the second attached image below, have standard nail nicks. I thus tend to believe that the change from extra-long nail nicks to standard nail nicks (namely, the change from type SN27ARLP saws to type SN27ARSP saws; the only difference between these two types is in the nail nicks) occurred at some point towards the end of the 1946-51 period (possibly 1950, say). This change is not the big change that occurred a little later in the early 1950's. What happened with the big changes of the early 1950's (along with the change of distances between the rivets, change to aluminum liners, introduction of several new tools, etc.) is first and foremost a significant change to the shape of the saws from what I called above narrow-form saws to wide-form saws. The narrow-form saws of the 1940's have shanks that are about 10mm wide and 1.75mm thick, whereas the shanks of the wide-form saws are about 11.5mm wide and 1.65mm thick (like the ones on current SAKs). It looks like along side this change from narrow-form to wide-form (namely, from type SN27ARSP saws to type SW27ALSP saws) the teeth weighting also changed from right to left, but I believe that the type of the nail nick changed a little before then.

                              Do you happen to know when they started with the extra-long nail nicks?

                              What are the blade stamps on your knife with 29 teeth saw with nail nick?

                              The blade stamps on the model 236fmaU from the image above are identical to the blade stamps on the model 236aU in the first attached image below: VICTORIA-OFFICIER-SUISSE (which can be seen in the image) on the back along with the usual VICTORINOX-SWITZERLAND-STAINLESS-ROSTFREI on the front. However, the same saw variant can also be found on SAKs with the VICTORIA-OFFICIER stamp on the back of the blade, such as the one in this post by GigaHz.

                              236aU_c1957.jpg

                              236a_1946-51.jpg

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • jnoxydJ
                                jnoxydJ
                                jnoxyd
                                wrote on last edited by jnoxyd
                                #18

                                My Benrus and other 1940s knives have long nail nick [emoji6]

                                Earlier knives from my friend Rene (aka Der Eidgenosse YouTube ) have small nail nick. So we need more knife pictures from that period to tracing the changes [emoji6]. Maybe MTO members can show knives they have.

                                BTW 236 aU you shown above has visible rivets and VOS CB/ VSSR stamp that was introduced c.1957 (IMHO) instead of previous VO CB/VSS (1952-1957) so your knife is c.1957.

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • M
                                  M
                                  MiniChamp
                                  wrote on last edited by MiniChamp
                                  #19

                                  @jnoxyd said:
                                  My Benrus and other 1940s knives have long nail nick [emoji6]
                                  Earlier knives from my friend Rene (aka Der Eidgenosse YouTube ) have small nail nick.

                                  Thanks a lot for these images, Jnoxyd! :tu: I'm learning interesting things from them. :woohoo: I'm particularly intrigued by the middle SAK on the second image. The saw on this SAK is right-weighted and looks very similar to the saw on my above Benrus SAK. This makes me think that it may be from around the same time, but the color of the scale seems a bit wrong for a cellidor SAK. Do you have more images and/or other information about this SAK?

                                  So we need more knife pictures from that period to tracing the changes [emoji6]. Maybe MTO members can show knives they have.

                                  Yes. It would indeed be great if more MTO members will post relevant images. Please please please... :gimme: :pok:

                                  BTW 236 aU you shown above has visible rivets and VOS CB/ VSSR stamp that was introduced c.1957 (IMHO) instead of previous VO CB/VSS (1952-1957) so your knife is c.1957.

                                  I believe that you are correct.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • jnoxydJ
                                    jnoxydJ
                                    jnoxyd
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #20

                                    Sorry, MiniChamp, I forgot to show another side of this knife. It has fiber scales and older style can opener. I'll ask Rene show us blade stamps when he come back from his Switzerland trip.

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • M
                                      M
                                      MiniChamp
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #21

                                      @jnoxyd said:
                                      Sorry, MiniChamp, I forgot to show another side of this knife. It has fiber scales and older style can opener. I'll ask Rene show us blade stamps when he come back from his Switzerland trip.

                                      Very interesting. If it has fiber scales, I guess it's probably from the late 1930's. I have never seen a right-weighted saw on a Victorinox SAK from around this time before. It would indeed be great to see the blade stamps on this SAK. Thanks!

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • jnoxydJ
                                        jnoxydJ
                                        jnoxyd
                                        wrote on last edited by jnoxyd
                                        #22

                                        Blade stamps of knives shown above from Rene ES aka Der Eidgenosse

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • ddoguD
                                          ddoguD
                                          ddogu
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #23

                                          Sir, you are one diligent person! Hats off :hatsoff: :hatsoff:

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0

                                          Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                          Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                          With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                          Register Login

                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Popular
                                          • World