Minimalist challenge...
-
So all... thoughts please. Heading to an emergency services social/public education campout this weekend. I do not have to cook. I'm looking to take a 2 layer 84/91mm with me as my blade for the weekend to continue my minimalist challenge. I'll be doing communications and radio demos so it's not super critical that I have a saw. Any suggestions? I'm curious to see the responses so I'll happily take any and all responses, without regard to whether or not I own that model. I'm presently leaning towards the wenger highlander I just received in the mail.
For (camp) cooking the bigger the blade the better, so for that - in theory - I'd choose a 111 mm model, and keeping in mind the layer count it would be the Nomad (blade, proper openers, corkscew, awl).
Of course you said you will not be cooking and you'll want to take an 84/91 mm SAK, so I guess my pick would be the Tinker with proper openers, large blade, small blade, Phillips and awl. The Highlander is a nice knife, but having a smaller main blade as the only blade is a slight disadvantage. (Of course the Spartan is always an option, but the Phillips might be more useful in your situation than a corkscrew.)
The Compact/DofE are always excellent options when we're talking about minimalistic SAK's, but again, you'd only have one blade and a bit of a compromise in the form of the combo tool (still a very good tool in my eyes) but a pair of scissors is always a plus.
All in all, as you already have a Tinker (or two, now that you found the second one) and a Highlander, you can't really go wrong with either, but I'd give the edge to the Tinker simply because of its blade size and blade count.
I agree, something like the Nomad or Centurion would be a good choice. Also may want to look at the HUnter XS for a blade only option.
I also would like the discontinued 93mm woodsman for a two layer outdoor knife. Very

http://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Woodsman -
Day 8:
Decided to try only using the classic today. So far, the only real use was lunch prep.
The apple was slow going, but it did it. Definitely prefer the pioneer's blade for that task, though.



-
Day 8
Today I picked the Sportsman. It has no scissors, but package opening was a breeze with the blade too. Lovely little knife, I love the toolset, I prefer the nail file (small 2D Phillips driver!) instead of the small blade, only the lack of scissors is keeping it from being carried regularly.


-
Today I picked the Sportsman. It has no scissors, but package opening was a breeze with the blade too. Lovely little knife, I love the toolset, I prefer the nail file (small 2D Phillips driver!) instead of the small blade, only the lack of scissors is keeping it from being carried regularly.
Love it Exeter! I just got mine in the mail and cleaned it up at work last night.
-
Day 9, my preferred tinker back in hand.... Even paint covered screws are no issue.

-
Day 9:
This is actually from Monday. Sam's club had a playhouse on sale so I bought it and put it together for my two oldest girls.
The pioneer helped open the packages and tighten a few Phillips screws. Most assembly was accomplished with a power drill and swearing, though ;)
If you have small kids and are in the US, my local Sam's had this set marked down from $400 to $150. Not worth $400 but well worth the $150. May be worth a look


-
Day 9
Today it's the Delemont counterpart of yesterday's Sportsman, the Wenger Commander. Same toolset in a different, and in this particular case, rare-ish package, meaning the Snife scales. No actual use to report.

-
Although I am not officially participating in this challenge, I have been using a 74mm Executive as my EDC for months now and am participating in the Chuck Yeager Challenge II (honoring Chuck's EDC, the Executive).
I think the Executive exemplifies the minimalist value of big function in a small package!
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/ZQX8f9" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4481/37966283112_0d60e77cd1_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>Executive - EDC by NorCal Jim, on Flickr
-
@NorCalJim said:
Although I am not officially participating in this challenge, I have been using a 74mm Executive as my EDC for months now and am participating in the Chuck Yeager Challenge II (honoring Chuck's EDC, the Executive).I think the Executive exemplifies the minimalist value of big function in a small package!
I've been keeping my eye on that challenge and the most important thing I've learned is that I'll have to get an Executive at some point! :)
-
Although I am not officially participating in this challenge, I have been using a 74mm Executive as my EDC for months now and am participating in the Chuck Yeager Challenge II (honoring Chuck's EDC, the Executive).
I think the Executive exemplifies the minimalist value of big function in a small package!
I've been keeping my eye on that challenge and the most important thing I've learned is that I'll have to get an Executive at some point! :)
The Executive is a very intriguing tool. Initially, I ignored it while pursuing other SAKs. Eventually, I decided that I needed a closer look and became a fan. It has some of the key tools that I depend upon (blade, scissor & tweezers) plus one that is very useful in opening plastic blister packaging (Orange Peeler). Excellent functionality that comes in such a small form factor!
Jim
-
Day 10:
Oatmeal in a mug, some light nail maintenance, and tightening of my glasses. A fair amount of work for my little Sportsman
-
Now, to take my sportsman or a Spartan along for the weekend.... Nail file vs extra blade is the big debate. So long as I have a sharpening stone (which I do) I figure I'll be good on a single blade
-
Day 10:
Switched back to ol'Blackie.
After spending several days with the old cross pioneer and now switching back, I can definitely tell a difference between the two when cutting up an apple. The last newer one is definitely better at slicing, whereas the older model starts to wedge the pieces apart halfway through. As I mentioned in an earlier post, I think it's a combination of the slightly thicker blade stock and less polished finish on the older knife.

-
Day 10
"Spartan Thursday" in this minimalist rotation week. I fancied some baked beans, so the can opener saw some use.
Although - and perhaps this won't be so popular - I don't really like the Spartan, and I don't really like Vic's can opener. For me the Spartan is just a big pile of redundancy, two knife blades and two openers - you can get more/better functionality in the same or even smaller form - the Compact/DofE adds scissors while the combo tool can do what the two openers can, the Sportsman gives you the nailfile in place of the small blade, and that can even be used as a 2D Phillips for small screws and it's also smaller, the same is true for the Wenger Commander, and on top of that it has a better can opener. That leads me to my other point: while I know how to you use both types of openers properly, and the Vic opener does a clean, smooth job, for me the hawkbill style opener feels more natural and smoother and it can also be used to make holes, open blister pack or as a scraper.


-
Day 11, sportsman de-ickifying some air fitting threads so they can be possibly reused as I do not have another hose or fittings handy for this machine
hopefully enough pipe dope will make a solid seal.
-
@dkop1 said:
Now, to take my sportsman or a Spartan along for the weekend.... Nail file vs extra blade is the big debate. So long as I have a sharpening stone (which I do) I figure I'll be good on a single bladeWell... You can always choose the Tourist instead of the Spartan too. Same thing in a smaller package, it's a win-win for me... :D
-
Now, to take my sportsman or a Spartan along for the weekend.... Nail file vs extra blade is the big debate. So long as I have a sharpening stone (which I do) I figure I'll be good on a single blade
Well... You can always choose the Tourist instead of the Spartan too. Same thing in a smaller package, it's a win-win for me... :D
If I owned one, I could! I'm really taking a fancy to the 84mm lineup, which is unfortunate timing seeing how much of the line has been cut and the availability of cheap used models is dwindling :-
The Wenger 85mm line seems to still be present on the second hand market though, and I've been gearing myself towards them. -
Now, to take my sportsman or a Spartan along for the weekend.... Nail file vs extra blade is the big debate. So long as I have a sharpening stone (which I do) I figure I'll be good on a single blade
Well... You can always choose the Tourist instead of the Spartan too. **Same thing in a smaller package, it's a win-win for me... **:D
I don't think that's what she said...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login