EDC steel preference.....?
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I've seen his videos and enjoyed them.
He's just not ready to test steel.
Everything else is fine, but that I cannot agree with......
Pete does not take himself too seriously......
He is intelligent and logical enough to recognize his own mistakes and shortcoming, given time those might be addressed.
(disclaimer) I don't know of anybody else with that volume of data, even if imperfect, and there's a lot of value in that.
He might not take hardness into account, but he's most definitely aware of it's influence unlike some YT'ers...........doesn't hit me as the type of guy that would benefit from owning a Rockwell tester......

Ok, Pete does not take himself to seriously, that's fine for reviews on action, feel in the hand, fit and finish, etc. Like I said I've enjoyed some of his reviews.
I agree he's intelligent and recognizes his own mistakes and short comings and those should be addressed before posting hard data.
For example Viper Keeper D2 listed at 67/70 – cuts, that's down there with no name steels. So does that mean Viper doesn't heat treat correctly. Does it mean Viper isn't using D2 but instead some no name like “surgical steel”. Or does it mean it is because of Cedric's mistakes and shortcomings.
How many people passed on the viper because of Cedric's incorrect data.ZT0909 CPM-S35VN listed at 109 & 113 cuts but the ZT 0220 CPM-S35VN 194 cuts. Does that mean the 0909 had a bad heat treat or his it because of Cedric's mistakes and shortcomings.
Cedric puts his data online and there are people who may rely on his data for their purchasing decisions. Are they expected to weed thru his mistakes and shortcomings, to find the real facts.
-
Dean whats your take on Cliff Stamp? Not trying to open a can of worms just curious. :)
-
Choosing steel is just a mater of what you expect from a knife. If you want easy to sharpen it's out there. If you want edge retention it's out there. The same with toughness, it's there, if for some reason you would want to chop with a knife.
I enjoy a blade steel that performs and I haven't found that point of point of diminishing returns yet,I had two jobs in the mid 70's that planted a complaint about knife steels in my head and it stayed there.
One job was a bit varied but I would often cut the top off boxes to stock parts for the assemblers and cut the sides out of boxes for better access to the parts. Too many days I've had to sharpen that stockman every night, sharpening can get old when you have to.
The other job was in a tool and die shop, why was it, I could hog off a pound of steel on the lathe and not sharpen my cutter but a few cardboard boxes would dull my Case Stockman.About 15 years ago I started discovering these so called super steels. I've been in knife heaven ever since.
Some care what the knife looks like, how well it fits the hand and how fast it will whip out and deploy.I care what the knife looks like and how well it fits the hand and pocket, But I could care less how fast it will whip out and deploy. I fill that space with Blade geometry and steel type, How well it cuts and how long it will cut.
I picked up a S90V blade a couple months back and love it. Easier to sharpen than I expected and it stays sharp to the point it blows M390 out of the water.
I will be the first to admit it's not for everyone, jump in to CPM S90V with out the proper sharpening gear and you'll be a very unhappy camper. -
S90V is good stuff.

-
For me the interest is sort of academic.........I'm surviving without a super steel no worries......
That's why I love Spyderco, if I had the money I'd have one of their knives in each of these super steel, preferably spread over 2 or 3 models

But I don't so I don't

-
rather not...
-
I guess I take things a bit too seriously. I look up the steel from manufacturer and distributor pages, then base my decision on buying the knife (usually more of the carbon content, as that oftne determines edge retention) on the metallurgy of the steel, taking in effect how decent the heat treat is--I have 440As that have to be sharpened frequently, then others (Vic steel, which is essentially 440A, as well as Eickhorn) that have such good heat treats, they don't have to be sharpened that often.
-
I like is how super steels have come about as an improvement to more familiar steels. Sure we can get along with more basic steel but for what purpose. I appreciate the fine tuning of the next steel as an attempt to improve upon features and qualities. While I don't have all the latest and greatest steels I sure appreciate all the options. I'd love to get my hands on come CPM CRU WEAR and CPM M4 for starters.
-
I voted for no preference. I am ok with Victorinox steel, or Leatherman 420HC.
I went with stainless when it came to my Opinels and Moras. I guess I'd choose stainless over carbon given the option.The only kind of high end steel I have is the 154CM blade of the Charges. Certainly nice, but for edc, as long as it takes an edge, I am good to go.
-
@ReamerPunch said:
I voted for no preference. I am ok with Victorinox steel, or Leatherman 420HC.
I went with stainless when it came to my Opinels and Moras. I guess I'd choose stainless over carbon given the option.The only kind of high end steel I have is the 154CM blade of the Charges. Certainly nice, but for edc, as long as it takes an edge, I am good to go.
+1

-
I voted carbon. But in reality anything will do as long as it’s not too soft (douk douk) or too hard.
I find it annoying if a steel won’t keep a decent edge and boring if I don’t need to sharpen it for weeks on end.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login