CYC2: Return of the Executive
-
Faced with this morning's poll, I debated between a 4 and a 5. I finally decided on a 5 based on fit. The Executive perfectly fits my needs and does so in such a small and convenient package. I have several multi-tools and SAKs that are far more useful and have a superior universal appeal but my needs are modest and are easily accommodated by the Executive. Since I am not grading the Executive on its universal appeal (probably a 3) but on its appeal to me and how it fits my needs, it gets a solid 5!
My wife and I look and act much longer than our age. I have been told that I look like I am in my mid 50s (pretty amazing since our daughter will be turning 50 in December). However, this senior citizen is grateful that he can depend on the Orange Peeler rather than (no longer available) brute force to open people proof plastic blister packs. With all tools retracted, the Executive doesn't look anywhere near as useful as it is and definitely "Punches way above its weight" to use an old boxing analogy.
Jim
-
@NorCalJim said:
With all tools retracted, the Executive doesn't look anywhere near as useful as it is and definitely "Punches way above its weight" to use an old boxing analogy.Got that right!

I think compared the Executive to Sugar Ray Leonard at one point before the challenge started. Nothing has yet changed my mind.

-
@cbl51 said:
As this challenge draws to a close, I have my definite opinions that have not changed from the begining. I rated this SAK at a 4. I did not give it the highest rating for just a couple of reasons, but in spite of it being a 4 instead of a 5, it has become my new real world EDC. It is almost the same size class as my old Case peanut that I carried for years, but the peanut had to be teamed up with another knife/tool to come close to the wide ranging capability of the executive. The peanut was always backed up with a classic on my keyring and a few flat one piece tool in my wallet.This knife makes the classic unneeded in my life. The longer main blade can do anything the Case peanut can do, like cut a sandwich in half or slice a baguette and sausage. The nail file tip or SD tip on the orange peeler gives it small Phillips screw capability. The scissors are a bit larger than the classic scissors and are very functional. The easy SAK springs are much easier to open than there stiffly sprung small jackknife like a Case peanut. Important for an aging arthritic fossil like myself.
The executive in a watch pocket and the few little tools in zip compartment of my Eagle Creek wallet do everything I need in the course of the day for a retired gentleman of leisure fishing on the San Gabriel river in Williamson county Texas. I've never been a large knife guy, and after watching my dad go through his whole life with his well worn Case peanut, I learned for 98% of most things a small sharp pocket knife is all that is needed in modern life. I'm not Rambo, I do not need to take out enemy sentries or other Walter Mitty fantasy stuff and a small pocket knife is what I do need and use. I'm not hacking my way through any jungles, or skinning a buffalo out on the plains or dealing with hostile Comanches coming over the hill to take my scalp. I've always been a very pragmatic person and in my old age I've become more so in the extreme. My mania for what I call *maximum minimalism * has only increased as I aged, and the Victorinox executive fits my lifestyle very very well. Teamed up with the Victorinox quarto 4-way keychain screw driver and P-38 in my wallet, and the Fenix E01 on my keyring, I can do a heck of a lot.
As an old fart that is having problems with arthritis in my fingers, the larger body of the executive gives me a much better grip on it than the smaller 58mm.
To me, the smaller SAK's have always been the modern answer to the old "pen knife" that was the common knife of my boyhood in the post WW2 era of the 1950's. I remember that every single man who had pants on, had a small pocketknife in one of those pockets.It was just a given. Mostly the "pen knife" was a generic name for a small two bladed jack or pen pattern about 3 inches closed in size. Back then people used a pocketknife much more than the new office cubicle IT age we live in now. Packages came wrapped in heavy brown paper tied up with white twine that you really needed a knife to open, much like the modern accursed plastic blister packages. People lived a more rural agrarian life style than now, yet the little two blade "pen knife" was the over whelming pocketknife of the day. This test has shown me that the executive can be the universal "pen knife" of the modern age. I grew up in an era long before the ridiculous tactical knife craze with zombi combat now a requirement for the EDC pocket knife, so a small "pen knife" is all I feel the need for. If I need protection, that's what the gun in my pocket is for.
What kept it from getting a 5?
I'd love to see the orange peeler replaced with a small combo tool, or even a fully serrated sheep foot blade. A small awl to make starter holes for a wood screw would be way to much to wish for. But the executive is darn near perfect as it is for the modern "pen knife" and that's good enough for me.

-
I've given the Executive a 4. To be fair I really like the Executive. But ....
The Executive (or Ambassador) doesn't have a corkscrew where I can store a small screwdriver. And that's a really clever piece of kit. It's a nice little insurance policy if my glasses need to be fettled. And that, for me at least, is a big gap in the Executive toolset.
I was lucky enough to pick up a PTC from FoBo recently and that impressed with its small screwdriver. And I have a couple of LM Micra's which also have a combo small screwdriver tool. It wouldn't be beyond the wit of Victorinox to alter the end of the excellent file or the orange peeler for example to up the tool choice in this way surely?
Am I missing something here? Or is Victorinox?


-
To be honest I don´t understand the love for that litttle screwdriver. I´ve been wearing glasses for nearly 50 years but never needed one. Am I just being lucky or what?
-
@Ron Who said:
To be honest I don´t understand the love for that litttle screwdriver. I´ve been wearing glasses for nearly 50 years but never needed one. Am I just being lucky or what?very lucky. to be fair I've fixed my own glasses only a few times in the past 18 years but there is about a 3 or 4 need every year because people just assume I can fix theirs
-
@Ron Who said:
To be honest I don´t understand the love for that litttle screwdriver. I´ve been wearing glasses for nearly 50 years but never needed one. Am I just being lucky or what?Having had mine disassemble once or twice Ron ... the Force is Strong with this One

If you find you need one you'll understand in about 2 seconds flat !
-
@Ron Who said:
To be honest I don´t understand the love for that litttle screwdriver. I´ve been wearing glasses for nearly 50 years but never needed one. Am I just being lucky or what?
very lucky. to be fair I've fixed my own glasses only a few times in the past 18 years but there is about a 3 or 4 need every year because people just assume I can fix theirs
This

-
@Nix said:
Chuck Yeager Challenge, Day 26 :Opened and modded a new lighter to add to the camping cook system
These scissors are sooooo handy.

File blade got used to pop the child safety off the striker. Mrs. Nix has a hard time firing up a Bic with that safety in place, so off it goes!
I've used the pliers on a multi to remove the safety cover, but the Executive's file blade may be the perfect tool for this little job.

Great pics and good use of the scissors and file Nix!

-
It's been a fun challenge, VICMAN. And you've kept things positive and energized!

....and still a few days to go! :ahhh
-
@NorCalJim said:
Happy Chuck Yeager Challenge II Day 26!I needed to remove the small VISA receipts that were stapled on top. This time, I used the Executive's nail file...
Nice pic and good use of the nail file Jim!

-
@cbl51 said:
As this challenge draws to a close, I have my definite opinions that have not changed from the begining. I rated this SAK at a 4. I did not give it the highest rating for just a couple of reasons, but in spite of it being a 4 instead of a 5, it has become my new real world EDC.The executive in a watch pocket and the few little tools in zip compartment of my Eagle Creek wallet do everything I need in the course of the day for a retired gentleman of leisure fishing on the San Gabriel river in Williamson county Texas.
What kept it from getting a 5?
I'd love to see the orange peeler replaced with a small combo tool, or even a fully serrated sheep foot blade. A small awl to make starter holes for a wood screw would be way to much to wish for. But the executive is darn near perfect as it is for the modern "pen knife" and that's good enough for me.
Nice review of the Executive cbl!

I rated it a 4 also,

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
