UK Legal Carry Thread!
-
@kingofswords said:
sadiq khan 0
common sense 1Has there been an update?
-
No They're all in meltdown over Brexit at the moment, so no doubt they'll pass the bill because everyone will be blathering on about other things

-
I thought this story was interesting:
Accused PC Joshua Savage says 'officers carry blades'
PC Joshua Savage is accused of attacking a car with a baton and cutting the window with a knife.
BBC News (www.bbc.co.uk)
*A police officer accused of smashing and sawing through a car windscreen claimed "the majority" of response officers carry their own bladed tools on duty, a court has heard.
PC Joshua Savage allegedly attacked Leon Fontana's Ford Fiesta with a baton before cutting the smashed glass with a lock knife on 16 September 2016.
The officer denies possessing his own Swiss army knife unlawfully.
He told the Old Bailey that blades were needed for emergencies.
Mr Savage claimed his job required a "cutting implement" for acts such as slicing seat belts off trapped passengers in emergency situations.
On Tuesday, the court heard the Met Police officer told an Independent Police Complaints Commission interviewer: "You supplement your own issue kit with stuff that's necessary.
"The majority of officers on response teams will carry them along with torches."
*He was cleared of assault, but is still probably in a bit of trouble with the Force.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-44980617 -
I would think he would have a good reason to carry a locking blade as he uses it in his work, as described.
Putting aside the knife part, that particular case was a mess. Inexperienced officer, mistaken identity, whole lot filmed and posted of social media.
-
If he needs a locking blade for work then why is it not issued officially? We get on a slippery slope if we let the officiers decide what they can carry "legally". Pepper spray? Extending baton? Nunchucks? Cattle prod? Samurai sword? Etc?
Personally, I see no reason to deny them a locking blade especially since it is a USEFUL TOOL. And maybe the law will lighten up on the rest of us too.
I would think he would have a good reason to carry a locking blade as he uses it in his work, as described.
I found that strange too.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk
-
@BePrepared said:
If he needs a locking blade for work then why is it not issued officially? We get on a slippery slope if we let the officiers decide what they can carry "legally". Pepper spray? Extending baton? Nunchucks? Cattle prod? Samurai sword? Etc?Personally, I see no reason to deny them a locking blade especially since it is a USEFUL TOOL. And maybe the law will lighten up on the rest of us too.
@pomsbz said:I would think he would have a good reason to carry a locking blade as he uses it in his work, as described.
I found that strange too.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk
The problem is that when a police officer can't justify carry of a locking pocket knife on duty what hope is there for the rest of us? What do you need to do to prove justifiable cause if the benchmark has been shifted that far?
-
So, in the case of blades which are locking, or longer than, or is 3 inches long, if someone is going to camp site, woods, hills or mountains for camping, bushcrafting, hill walking, then it is OK to carry whatever tools in his backpack?
It's just carrying these tools in public streets, town centres and markets ...etc without reasonable purposes, that would be illegal.
Am I correct on this? If not, please correct me.
-
@mtoolman said:
So, in the case of blades which are locking, or longer than, or is 3 inches long, if someone is going to camp site, woods, hills or mountains for camping, bushcrafting, hill walking, then it is OK to carry whatever tools in his backpack?It's just carrying these tools in public streets, town centres and markets ...etc without reasonable purposes, that would be illegal.
Am I correct on this? If not, please correct me.
That's essentially correct. The non-locking blade under three inches is the definition of a knife that can be carried as a general pocket knife. If you have a specific and genuine reason for "more" or for a fixed blade, you're perfectly entitled too, which is the point often overlooked in internet discussion. If you need a billhook for hedging, machete for clearing a vacant lot, fixed blade for fishing or food prep while camping, then go for it. Just be sure that you can justify the reason for carrying more than that sub-3" slippie.
Another example: As I have some health issues which affect my coordination and other motor skills, I would probably be able to put the case forward for having a locking blade over a slipjoint knife, but wouldn't have a cause for carrying longer than a 3" blade. Having submitted this reason, the onus would then be on the police to disprove this, or to prove that I was carrying it with nefarious intent, or was for example using it in an intentionally threatening manner, or making threats to harm someone with it.
The short version, is that you can carry whatever you need, but if you don't have a specific need, the law protects your right to carry a reasonable pocket knife everywhere which doesn't have specific "no blade" restrictions.
-
@50ft-trad said:
So, in the case of blades which are locking, or longer than, or is 3 inches long, if someone is going to camp site, woods, hills or mountains for camping, bushcrafting, hill walking, then it is OK to carry whatever tools in his backpack?
It's just carrying these tools in public streets, town centres and markets ...etc without reasonable purposes, that would be illegal.
Am I correct on this? If not, please correct me.
That's essentially correct. The non-locking blade under three inches is the definition of a knife that can be carried as a general pocket knife. If you have a specific and genuine reason for "more" or for a fixed blade, you're perfectly entitled too, which is the point often overlooked in internet discussion. If you need a billhook for hedging, machete for clearing a vacant lot, fixed blade for fishing or food prep while camping, then go for it. Just be sure that you can justify the reason for carrying more than that sub-3" slippie.
Another example: As I have some health issues which affect my coordination and other motor skills, I would probably be able to put the case forward for having a locking blade over a slipjoint knife, but wouldn't have a cause for carrying longer than a 3" blade. Having submitted this reason, the onus would then be on the police to disprove this, or to prove that I was carrying it with nefarious intent, or was for example using it in an intentionally threatening manner, or making threats to harm someone with it.
The short version, is that you can carry whatever you need, but if you don't have a specific need, the law protects your right to carry a reasonable pocket knife everywhere which doesn't have specific "no blade" restrictions.

Great info. Thank you for your confirmation.

-
@50ft-trad said:
That's essentially correct. The non-locking blade under three inches is the definition of a knife that can be carried as a general pocket knife. If you have a specific and genuine reason for "more" or for a fixed blade, you're perfectly entitled too, which is the point often overlooked in internet discussion. If you need a billhook for hedging, machete for clearing a vacant lot, fixed blade for fishing or food prep while camping, then go for it. Just be sure that you can justify the reason for carrying more than that sub-3" slippie.Another example: As I have some health issues which affect my coordination and other motor skills, I would probably be able to put the case forward for having a locking blade over a slipjoint knife, but wouldn't have a cause for carrying longer than a 3" blade. Having submitted this reason,** the onus would then be on the police to disprove this**, or to prove that I was carrying it with nefarious intent, or was for example using it in an intentionally threatening manner, or making threats to harm someone with it.
The short version, is that you can carry whatever you need, but if you don't have a specific need, the law protects your right to carry a reasonable pocket knife everywhere which doesn't have specific "no blade" restrictions.
Almost completely correct, however only a judge can decide guilt and or intent

-
The list of legal carry knives in Australia is easy
1...................In fact, under Australian law, just about everything is considered illegal.
Bunch of keys..........weapons
Tiny Victornox knife.........weapons
Screwdriver............weapons
Walking cane.......weaponsThey say that if you have a good reason to carry, it's ok.
But any cop with a chip on his shoulder can charge you and you have to fight it in court.I had my sai in my car (boot) on my way to martial arts training one night.
I was wearing my Gi
Pulled over for a random breath test.
Cop started laughing at my Gi. ( As if martial arts means anything he laughhed"
I ignored his stupidity and he got all annoyed, he was showing off to the female cop.
He searched my car (looking for drugs he said)
Found the sai
I explained I was off to training.He was about to arrest me when an old sergeant came over and asked what the trouble was.
The cop said I threatened him.The seargent took him off to the side and had a chat with him
Then he came back and told me to go.There are good and bad cops in Australia
But unlike other countries we do not have a bill of rights
In most cases we are considered guilty until we can prove our innocence.
Every day, laws are being enacted to erode away at our rights.My father carried a small blade every single day of his 90 years.
I have carried a small blade every day since I was a boy scout, I'm 60
I will continue to carry as I have found many many uses for my Victornox craftsman.But I still don't trust the cops.
-
A bit of common sense goes a long way whichever country you're in.
If you have to explain your machete in the supermarket when you've been clearing undergrowth on your allotment you really might not have thought it through enough.
-
@50ft-trad said:
That's essentially correct. The non-locking blade under three inches is the definition of a knife that can be carried as a general pocket knife. If you have a specific and genuine reason for "more" or for a fixed blade, you're perfectly entitled too, which is the point often overlooked in internet discussion. If you need a billhook for hedging, machete for clearing a vacant lot, fixed blade for fishing or food prep while camping, then go for it. Just be sure that you can justify the reason for carrying more than that sub-3" slippie.
Another example: As I have some health issues which affect my coordination and other motor skills, I would probably be able to put the case forward for having a locking blade over a slipjoint knife, but wouldn't have a cause for carrying longer than a 3" blade. Having submitted this reason,** the onus would then be on the police to disprove this**, or to prove that I was carrying it with nefarious intent, or was for example using it in an intentionally threatening manner, or making threats to harm someone with it.
The short version, is that you can carry whatever you need, but if you don't have a specific need, the law protects your right to carry a reasonable pocket knife everywhere which doesn't have specific "no blade" restrictions.
Almost completely correct, however only a judge can decide guilt and or intent

Not quite :D
Magistrates (2 or 3) or a district judge but only if you hit a a magistrates’ court might pass judgement
but if you go to a crown court the judge is there to define points of law, direct the jury and pass sentence
The Jury decides guilt
-
Boom.. And I'm back with my new favorite UK legal pocket knife.... The Bestech Junzi

<a href="https://flic.kr/p/24i47ER" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7909/40230751053_d93b07000c_c.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>[
(with companion Huntsman)
[]
](https://flic.kr/p/24i47ER)<a href="https://flic.kr/p/24jsLte" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7870/40246682283_fdd3c47eaf_b.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>[url=https://flic.kr/p/24jsLte]
-
Related question. I finished making a puukko for a friend but given the pandemic I would have to ship it rather than meet. Does anyone know how to send one? Most couriers seem to have exclusions for knives and sharp objects.
-
@JK said:
Related question. I finished making a puukko for a friend but given the pandemic I would have to ship it rather than meet. Does anyone know how to send one? Most couriers seem to have exclusions for knives and sharp objects.I send knives by Royal Mail all the time. Knives are ok as long as they aren’t on the banned weapons list. Just say it’s cutlery when they ask what it is.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

