Design philosophies, guidelines, honesty and whatever pops in my head
-
Great thread

My thoughts from end user point of view (typing on a touch screen so please excuse brevity).
Keep it simple. Cost is always a concern so knowing what works in terms of materials and production procedure helps make sound choices. Sound choices will appeal to experienced users and could -possibly- become apparent to not-so-experienced ones. Clever design is always welcome but should not compromise function. Yes to elegance if possible, seek bling elsewhere if that's what you want, firiki said.
In sum, gimme a solid, user repairable, tool that works well and can take a little abuse if needed. Fewer and better implements are preferable to me than more of just OK quality.
-
@GOAT Tools said:
stealing this quote from a completely different community - but also with a lot of people trying to be noticed in a pool of similarities."Do it first, do it better, or do it different"
In regards to plier-based multi-tools: Leatherman did it first, Gerber did it different, and anyone doing it better is subjective and a debate for other threads.
Abe Bauermann Company (Solingen, Germany) made some multi-tool pliers based around the same basic layout as the Leatherman PST. And they did it in the 50s or so. I think has been discussed many times - a quick search found for instance https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/chapter-1-before-there-was-leathermanΒ Β .379737/#post-3448810
Leatherman was certainly first at making a tool that many enough thought was useful and valuable enough to buy it. Which is important - being first doesn't count for much if people don't know about you, you have no distribution or it isn't executed well enough.
As for doing it different there is an endless opportunity for that. It should be different AND better in some respect though. Just being different for difference sake is kind of pointless?
Similarly I think different is necessary. Trying to just be better will be very hard at this point. Aiming to make a better Leatherman than Leatherman, (who also has lots of models optimized towards various users), and at a competitive price at that, while having higher production costs, and selling as an unknown brand, will be difficult.
So for me it is about different and better. Better in the sense of providing more usability in some key aspects users value enough to buy.
-
@firiki said:
Yes to elegance if possible, seek bling elsewhere if that's what you want, firiki said.That is actually another guideline I got, although that spans a bit wider. My aim is to make timeless designs, Not an easy task at all, but one thing to avoid then is bling and the like as that tend to be trendy in nature. And trends are not timeless - almost the opposite.
Elegance is great if possible - but then fitting in with function and construction. What is elegant is certainly also a subjective thing. If my fashion sense is anything to go by there is no hope!

@firiki said:
In sum, gimme a solid, user repairable, tool that works well and can take a little abuse if needed. Fewer and better implements are preferable to me than more of just OK quality.It seems we two are very much on the same page.
As for user repairable I've given that quite a lot of thought. What it basically boils down to is that a user serviceable tool will likely be somewhat larger, more expensive and less precise. Some of the not user friendly assembly option are less expensive, takes less space, and are more sturdy. On the other hand I really like user serviceable... Yet another compromise and balance then I guess.
-
-
Getting to market first has it challenges. Educating the end user is one that comes to mind. While getting the patents has benefits not being able to capture the market has happened to many. Heck being too early can be an issue. Sometimes the general consumer just isn't ready.
Whle Leatherman was not the first to make a MT, we've seen historical accounts of them. A 1800 year old Roman MT is pictured somewhere here on MTO. Tim was certainly first to market his plier based tool. We all know the tenacity and challenges he had. Certainly wasn't an overnight success. Soon to follow were others. Heck even the king of pocket knives got into the action, Victorinox.
With MTs I believe we still have room for some innovation and design tweaks. The basic mold has been cast I think? Lets look at Victorinox for a sec. While the Swisstool seems to be stubbornly unchanged they did actually make several. The plier head was changed over the years. One change in particular was very well thought out. The change in plier pivot from left to right.
What I find interesting is the Story of Bear and Sons MT. When you look at it you can certainly see the pedigree from which the Swisstool was born. Why they couldn't capture the market with that tool is interesting. Victorinox gets the patent and as they are known for does it better. Then continues to do it better. Chako did a nice write up on the Bear and Sons MT see here /topic/52527
The tool was simple and straightforward. Honest and well built. So, what gives? If we are to believe a tool that is honest and well built with materials that make the grade then seriously, what gives?
I believe there are some intangibles and timing, name recognition, certainly quality, amongst other things all must align.
-
@Aloha007 said:
With MTs I believe we still have room for some innovation and design tweaks. The basic mold has been cast I think?There is plenty of room both for improvements to the existing form factors and entirely new ones.
To be concrete let me go on record with the prediction that within 3 to 8 years Leatherman and or Victorinox will offer a Wave/ Spirit sized multi-tool with more functions, stronger and about 30-40% less weight.
I actually think the next 5-15 years will be very interesting with lots of new innovations. Not just within multi-tools, but tools in general.
@Aloha007 said:
Chako did a nice write up on the Bear and Sons MT see here /topic/52527That was very interesting

@Aloha007 said:
The tool was simple and straightforward. Honest and well built. So, what gives? If we are to believe a tool that is honest and well built with materials that make the grade then seriously, what gives?For one I think lack of awareness among possible customers and distribution? Most people don't even know they exist, which certainly limits the number asking for them. And for those of us that do know they exist they are still difficult to get hold of. (For instance I just tried searching an Amazon.com - nowhere to be found).
-
Well, next time I need a break from CAD I'm going to do some MT history research!
Clearly there are a few tools & companies I was never aware of. Thanks for the info, gentlemen! 
-
Not to mention patent databases - there are way more stuff there than what has ever been seen in the marketplace. (Sometimes I wonder if the patent database is the place where ideas go to die..
The ratio of dead to alive is certainly not good). Many interesting concepts there though - and through references from patents to patents one can follow developments. Some interesting stuff there. 
-
Totally agree Vidar!
Gerber has had some very interesting designs. Anyone remember the Groundbreaker? Cable dawg? JSews showed a reversible plier head in the thread I linked below. How about the defunct build your own tool by Gerber? Gerber tried but maybe they were met with timing issues, came to market ahead of the customer. Maybe quality wasn't the best? Maybe the end user wasn't ready for anything that wasn't Leathermans basic PST layout?
Look at some of JSews Gerbers. You'll see a neat patent for a tool as well.
/topic/49588We know that Tim Leathermans PST and Gerbers MPT went after a military contract. Gerber won yet the PST survived? My guess is they had nearly a decade head start. They ( Leatherman ) may have not been concerned with competing per se but innovating?
Whats also interesting is Gerber having been bought by Fiskars pretty early on then Fiskars clones/cheapens its self by intruding Carolina Tool ( basically Gerber Mr Pinchy ) to the market then Winchester tools ( again basic Gerber Mr Pinchy ).
Again Gerber had some interesting designs. Remember the Military Tech Kit? 5 plier heads and 2 bodies?
Thanks to Chako who graciously made this thread.
/topic/65364 -
-
Lots of great info in the catacombs of MTO

-
-
-
-
-
@Vidar said:
It seems we two are very much on the same page.

I like your way of thinking. Timeless is indeed difficult. You must know that all too well, seen your signature
:ahhh
*
"Man is the measure of all things"*. I think one needs to be efficiently addressing the same old issues that will keep on occurring unless ground breaking changes are made; technical changes in this instance. A functional, well rounded up, unpretentious tool gets my vote any day. Function matters most, ornaments can be added later on.Just do it, without overthinking about the thing being timeless, and everything should sort itself out eventually

By user serviceable, I was mainly referring to materials: not some super steel that I'll need an angle grinder in order to restore a damaged tip or sharpen an edge. One of the things I really like about Victorinox MTs is precisely the use of permanent mechanickal fasteners -rivets

-
@firiki said:
Timeless is indeed difficult. You must know that all too well, seen your signature
:ahhhTimeless is more on the bonus side as functionality is first and foremost. It is not so much an important goal as a choice to not aim for any currents trends or ornaments but rather aim for clean simple lines where possible. It might be a Scandinavian culture thing, but as a Scandinavian that is kind of the default mode.
@firiki said:
Just do it, without overthinking about the thing being timeless, and everything should sort itself out eventually

Not really overthinking the timeless.
In my experiences though absolutely nothing sort itself out. Which is very sad indeed!
Everything has to be designed, simulated as needed, and tested. And every single little thing needs specifications for materials, sizes, tolerances and relations, surface quality, assembly, and making sure the parts are manufacture friendly. And preferably so across the various manufacture options which are economical optimal for various volumes of production..Then there is planning necessary jigs for manufacture and assembly (and changing the parts as necessary), and planning for tests as needed to make sure that parts are indeed as specified. Add product packing and outer packing for shipment. The list goes on.
And the detailed level is necessary, especially for parts of the manufacture process that will be outsourced to others: Anything not specified will either be asked for, guessed or just randomly happening at the subcontractor. The result of that might not be pleasant - or fitting.
(I still have an entire pallet of some USD 30000 of cut but under-specified stainless steel somewhere around here from a project some 15 years ago.
And they say I don't learn?
Luckily it remelts nicely.)Getting the design itself 80% finished is the small part of the work. The remaining 20% from say decently developed 3D design to actual product is by far the most work - and the most tedious and frustrating as progress is not very visible as such, and even the smallest of changes necessary in later stages tends to ripple through and make lots of extra work.
See, I'm a bit ranting frustrated here right now.

@firiki said:
By user serviceable, I was mainly referring to materials: not some super steel that I'll need an angle grinder in order to restore a damaged tip or sharpen an edge. One of the things I really like about Victorinox MTs is precisely the use of permanent mechanickal fasteners -rivets
That is a good point. I thought of user serviceable mainly in terms of some disassembly for easier cleaning if needed, and possibly more disassembly for field repair, changing parts or modding. (And making sure it is repairable at all. Certain kinds of assembly will not undo nicely ever again).
-
Timeless is indeed difficult. You must know that all too well, seen your signature
:ahhhTimeless is more on the bonus side as functionality is first and foremost. It is not so much an important goal as a choice to not aim for any currents trends or ornaments but rather aim for clean simple lines where possible. It might be a Scandinavian culture thing, but as a Scandinavian that is kind of the default mode.
@firiki said:
Just do it, without overthinking about the thing being timeless, and everything should sort itself out eventually

Alec Issigonis? did not care for fashion when he designed The Mini, he was mainly concerned with function. Ironically it has remained popular for well over half a century, much of that due to it's looks (although one cannot say it had absolutely no styling).
-
Purely functional is also a style I guess, although to be fair few things are at that extreme. There is also purely economical vs functional. Where to put the balances is one of the key questions. And it isn't like they are mutually exclusive - if you massage and swear long enough one can often get more of all.
I actually think that is one of the less obvious reasons well designed products often do better. It isn't just about aesthetics or style, but also that the longer process to get there have contributed to making improvements in other areas as well. Thus they might not just look better. but actually work better too, and maybe for lower production cost. (And the other way around - longer process to improve goodness or cost might also improve looks).
I also find it interesting that whatever is the current possible or economical way of manufacture sets the limits for designs. New trends often end up in the wake of new technological developments that opens new possibilities and or lower cost - those are often explored quickly to try and stick out from the crowd. And those new developments will have their own limitations that contribute to forms the design trends. In that respect I think we will have very interesting times in the next few years.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better π
Register Login