Things I hate in 'Bug Out Bags', or... How to Start an Argument
-
@Alan K. said:
I honestly don't care for the cold steel special forces shovel because it doesn't fold. I have a combo E-tool that folds so you can use the shovel like a pick which makes for easier digging and it has a spike on the other side for when you hit rocks or really compacted soil. I have used it to dig fire pits for over 20 years. It is a bit heavy on a hike, but then it gets left in camp while we explore with light weight day packs. If I had to rely on a pocket size trowel to dig any holes I'd be there all day.key thing being it was made over 20 years ago. hate to sound like this but many things are not made to the same level of quality today
Outside of the CS shovel some I know are pretty good is the Glock e-tool and Gerber Nato e-tool (at least they used to be)
-
I don't like the Gerber tool either as it has a D handle rather than a long handle. I find the long handle easier to work with especially if the shovel is folded to use as a pick. The German surplus E-tools are about the best in the business.
-
Just found this topic. Read almost everything, amazing views. Hope you dont mind me beeing a grave digger.
Not going to reply to all.My humble view on all these survival kits is a bit different from most of you. Since living in central europe I really dont have a survival kit as a stand alone thing. However I pack some things while hiking, fitting the circumstances of my environment.
To the knife thing: I hike a lot, backpacking in remote areas. And to be honest: Ive never ever seen anyone carry a fixed blade when being more than 3 dayhikes away from the nearest city. Why? You dont need it. Dead weight. For fires I use my pocket knife, never been an issue. Id rather carry a small folding saw than a >4inch blade. Some long distance hikers even go with a classic only.
Ive beaten a SAK when I was a child playing in the woods. Those tools can do amazing things. And for most survival shelters you dont even have to cut down trees, or the saw on your SAK will do the job.
When I see guys with fixed blades I am near civilisation and those dudes often carry some sort of tactical backpack and stuff.
That brings me to the other points mentioned in the first topic.
What is often missed in all those videos is the following: Your first defense is your clothing. Not the emergency stuff in your backpack. Dress for the environment, carry weather protection.
I often see guys in black/camo/khaki clothes tell you to carry a signal mirror to be seen. Really? Those guys missed the first and most important lession in beeing found: be visible. When out in the mountain range I carry a bright red backpack, a bright orange rainjacket, my fleece is red or in some other bright color, too. You better look like a freaking parrot when injured and waiting for the resucue folks and not like a bush or rock.
Color doesnt cost anything, it doesnt weight anything, yet it can save your life.Oh and those "medikits" in the small survival kits....containing like 5 bandaids. Dude, seriously? What emergency are you going to deal with with 5 bandaids? Everyone who has proper training and/or been in a real emergency will just shake his head.
Get a real kit. And get training. Stop this bullsmurf.Most of the kits are build around the boys dream of beeing lost in the wood. How many disasters are like that? I would estimate that more emergencies happen with some ressources or equipment around you rather than beeing in the woods/desert/...
So a Multitool to repair, harvest, forage is better than that builky fixed blade. Oh and if you want to pry, add a crowbar.
Proper clothes, a lightweight bivybag, first aid kid, a map+compass or GPS, Headlight, pocket knife and a whistle plus a phone will get you through a lot of trouble. Stay warm, stay dry and you will make that 3 days without carrying an extra backpack.
Thats what I carry when out in the mountain range or when hiking alone.
You dont want to build up a new civilisation or go camping with your kit.Just my 2 cents.
-
No problem in some grave digging.
Especialy not when it's such a sensible and well worded post

When I was younger I felt the need for an "all out survival bag".
These days however, I evolved into a similar mindset as yours.
I do find a larger folding knife can be a great addition though. Especialy when there can be dangerous wildlife around. (If guns aren't allowed like here in Europe) -
If you’re going to bring a big knife because of the wild animals, it might be a good idea to make sure you know how to use it.

So, training! -
I think I would reach for a big stick before a knife.
-
If you feel like threatened from animals...first thing should be avoiding them. Either by walking away or by letting them know you are there.
How many animals actually attack humans on purpose? And how many of these attacks are defendable? I mean, if a cougar or something like that is sneaking up from behind in the night...good luck reaching for anything in time.
Other than that, pepperspray would make a good addition, for keeping some folks away, too.
I carry one in my EDC. When beeing out in the town at night with my girlfriend and little daugher running away is not an option, stabbing them, neither. So I hope for the best and keep pepperspray at reach. -
-
@Don Pablo said:
I think I would reach for a big stick before a knife.
Me too, but then again, I don’t know how to use a knife.
A stick being waved around might help scare an animal away or be used to keep it at bay as well as for whacking it. I doubt animals are scared of knives.
Good point.
-
@Shuya said:
Most of the kits are build around the boys dream of beeing lost in the wood. How many disasters are like that?Probably my single biggest gripe about "survival" stuff.
everything seems to always revolve around being in the woods with an abundance of natural materials, and nothing man made. Wouldn't work on peat moorland where there's no trees and a fire would set the smurfing ground on fire. Wouldn't work if the thing you were trying to survive was fire or flood. Wouldn't work if you were already injured and exhausted. It only works if you're of good health, in a material abundant situation, no immediate hazards, nobody with you who's in hysterics or who needs constant attention. Complete nonsense. Going rough camping and calling it survival training, is like calling yourself a surgeon because you can clip your own toenails. -
Going rough camping and calling it survival training, is like calling yourself a surgeon because you can clip your own toenails.

-
Regarding the animals:
Pepperspray is considered a first class weapon here. So illegal.When you're walking in the forrest and end up standing in between a wild boar and it's child, you won't have time to search for a big stick.
Don't overturn this whole topic from extreme BOBs to "even a folding knife is never needed".
-
@Shuya said:
Most of the kits are build around the boys dream of beeing lost in the wood. How many disasters are like that? I would estimate that more emergencies happen with some ressources or equipment around you rather than beeing in the woods/desert/...I agree a BOB/Survival Kit is like the EDC, very individual and strongly depending on where you are, what you plan on doing and what your abilities are.
I would like to add that building a shelter/camp is way overrated and could kill you, especially if water is scarce. If you read this story on knife news: Man Survives Four Days Lost in the Mountains with Buck 110, you will realize that his "survival skills" almost killed the man. Had he not lost his lighter he would probably have ended up so dehydrated that he could not save himself anymore.
Preparing does not just mean "bring as much gear as possible", but think about exit strategy / inform someone where you are going, and when you will be back etc. -
@Shuya said:
Most of the kits are build around the boys dream of beeing lost in the wood. How many disasters are like that? I would estimate that more emergencies happen with some ressources or equipment around you rather than beeing in the woods/desert/...I agree a BOB/Survival Kit is like the EDC, very individual and strongly depending on where you are, what you plan on doing and what your abilities are.
I would like to add that building a shelter/camp is way overrated and could kill you, especially if water is scarce. If you read this story on knife news: Man Survives Four Days Lost in the Mountains with Buck 110, you will realize that his "survival skills" almost killed the man. Had he not lost his lighter he would probably have ended up so dehydrated that he could not save himself anymore.
Preparing does not just mean "bring as much gear as possible", but think about exit strategy / inform someone where you are going, and when you will be back etc.So this man (Hutter) was out hiking without water, flashlight or map/compass (or knowledge) of local area and did not know where he was going when he "stepped off the path for a moment, and then couldn’t find it again.". Then he proceeded to walk in an unknown direction for 2 hours? It wasn't that a Buck 110 saved his life or losing a lighter saved his life...IT WAS BLIND LUCK THAT HIS STUPIDITY DID NOT KILL HIM!
-
@Shuya said:
Most of the kits are build around the boys dream of beeing lost in the wood. How many disasters are like that? I would estimate that more emergencies happen with some ressources or equipment around you rather than beeing in the woods/desert/...I agree a BOB/Survival Kit is like the EDC, very individual and strongly depending on where you are, what you plan on doing and what your abilities are.
I would like to add that building a shelter/camp is way overrated and could kill you, especially if water is scarce. If you read this story on knife news: Man Survives Four Days Lost in the Mountains with Buck 110, you will realize that his "survival skills" almost killed the man. Had he not lost his lighter he would probably have ended up so dehydrated that he could not save himself anymore.
Preparing does not just mean "bring as much gear as possible", but think about exit strategy / inform someone where you are going, and when you will be back etc.So this man (Hutter) was out hiking without water, flashlight or map/compass (or knowledge) of local area and did not know where he was going when he "stepped off the path for a moment, and then couldn’t find it again.". Then he proceeded to walk in an unknown direction for 2 hours? It wasn't that a Buck 110 saved his life or losing a lighter saved his life...IT WAS BLIND LUCK THAT HIS STUPIDITY DID NOT KILL HIM!
Saddest part is that he is thinking about teaching survival to others

Of course it was sheer luck. But loosing the lighter made him walk away from the camp and allowed luck to save him. I of course primarily mention the lighter as item that "saved" him, because his plan for the future is to carry 2 lighters.
-
Everyone who survives something like that needs luck.
He did know what to eat, how to build camp. I'm not going to say he's an expert. But luck is always needed.
If you're a true survival expert out there on your own, but you break a leg... it might kill you.
-
@Mechanickal said:
When you're walking in the forrest and end up standing in between a wild boar and it's child, you won't have time to search for a big stick.Taking on such an animal in such a situation would be my absolute last resort. One would probably be bitten and/or gored before they can stick a knife in. Using trees for cover, putting my pack or anything else between myself and the animal, making lots of noise, throwing rocks or using a stick (they are actually quite common in forests)...
I would still want a knife to reach for if it came to that.@Mechanickal said:
Don't overturn this whole topic from extreme BOBs to "even a folding knife is never needed".I didn't.

-
@Mechanickal said:
Everyone who survives something like that needs luck.He did know what to eat, how to build camp. I'm not going to say he's an expert. But luck is always needed.
If you're a true survival expert out there on your own, but you break a leg... it might kill you.
The problem in this story is, that his knowledge almost got him killed and that he does not realize that. And while there is no problem with being lucky, the whole point of survival skills is to not rely on luck.
To me, survival skills are not just knowing how to build a camp, it is also to understand what it means if you build a camp and why you are building a camp (just building a camp because some dude on a survival channel suggested it seems ridiculous).
Survival also means to re-evaluate your decisions (which he did).In short survival skills are not just to know how to make a fire, but also when to make a fire.
-
Heading out unprepared was a mistake. Not telling anyone where he was going and when to expect him back was a mistake. "Stepping off trail" was a mistake since all he prepared for was a 15 min hike.
He made the fire and found prickly pears.
This thread is about what Lynn hated about BOBs. I'm pretty certain if he had a few more pieces of gear ( even gear she hates ) he might have "camped" a little longer. Making the decision to venture out and find rescue was a good decision.
His scenario is exactly what kills many who venture out thinking they'll "only" be out for an hour or less. His story, I mean this with NO DISRESPECT at all, is one of a cautionary tale.
Even his tongue in cheek “I sometimes take an extra lighter, now,” he laughingly admits. is lame. He said he burned all fuel he could find then oddly the writer says he lost his lighter while trying to light a larger signal fire

While the thread is about BOBs and some gear Lynn hates I again say, To each their own.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login