Super Steels ?
-
Hey Sean - I am a self confessed knife newb and was looking recently at how much difference these fancy steels actually make, and read a load of opinions just like the ones on this thread! I've figured out that the S30V blade on my Charge TTi seems to stay sharper longer than the 440 blade on my Core, but it'll be a while yet before I can definitively say that S30V is worth the extra bucks!
I reckon the way to go is to pick the knife you like the look of (i.e. the Emerson) and get it. Noone has slated them, so it looks as though it'll do the job, then in time you'll decide whether you need anything better, based on your own experiences
I only have a very few knives, and the ones I like and use most have nothing to do with the steel, it's all about how comfortable they feel in my hand.
Like I say, I'm a million miles from being an expert on knives and steels, but I say "If it feels good - do it"!
-
@Sean said:
Well thanks for the varied opinions and the extra links into the properties of steel. I will review them. You know I probably don't need a super steel but my folders are all old style knives with old style steels and they have served me well. But I would like to try something different, something with a modern look and with g-10 scales. I love the look of the Emerson line and they are really not all that badly priced I don't think.sean
Sean,
Those are great reasons!

Mike
-
Dave, a believe the Core's blade is actually 420HC... I'd imagine it's pretty close to 440...
-
@Leatherman123 said:
Dave, a believe the Core's blade is actually 420HC... I'd imagine it's pretty close to 440...Which proves how much I know ;)
-
I'll post some pic's when I pick something up. Thanks again for all your help.
sean
-
Just so you are aware, Emerson use a chisel grind on their folders. This is not necessarily a problem and for some people it is a bonus, but it is not my first choice in grind.
And just to comment on what LM123 said, I don't see them as a PITA to sharpen at all. A good sharpener such as a Sharpmaker will make easy work of giving you a superb edge.
-
having looked into them a little bit more I am a little concerned that the Chisel grind might not be for me. Also, I can't quite figure out what and the reason is that they grind the edge the way they do. They are ground differently on either side. One side is showing a different grind/angle than the other side? I just was watching someone's review on youtube. Flipping the blade over showed a difference he pointed it out.
sean
-
They say it gives stronger edge, but it also lower production cost. There is a "v" grind version of commander thou I think.
If you don't know already there's a shop close to you in BC. http://www.warriorsandwonders.com/ Price is higher than u.s. shops thou.
-
440C , 154CM , A2 , VG10 are superb steels . I'm happy with any of the afore mentioned . I have also owned BG42 an S30V , also did what they said on the tin . Customer satisfaction depends more on heat treat and proper edge geometry than numbers an letters .
Chris
-
My Gerber AR 3.0 has a 440 (I believe A) blade and it just doesn't compare with the 154CM on my Charge. I've been wanting a Mini Grip for awhile but can't decide if i want the 154CM or try the new D2. Of course i have time till the ol tax rebate comes in.
leads to :tool: -
I own 1 knife with "super steel", a Spydie with VG-10, and I have no trouble at all sharpening it. I don't know about other super steels but I can highly recommend that one.
-
I haven't ever had sharpening issues either , just a matter of having the right tools for the job . With good steel you just do it less often !
Chris
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login