When did the Vic 91mm family start ?
-
Well the 1951 Soldier and Alox Soldier did not overlap
But it did overlap with the earliest Alox Pioneers - As this knife was the basis for the Alox Soldier
See History section of 1961 Soldier... -
@Huntsman said:
Well the 1951 Soldier and Alox Soldier did not overlapThis is not entirely accurate. While the year stamps of model 1961 soldier knives go back at least to 1962, there exist model 1951 soldier knives with year stamps going up to (at least) 1964. Here is an example of such a model 1951 soldier knife from 1964 that is currently being offered for sale on eBay. More information is also available here.
-
@Huntsman said:
Well the 1951 Soldier and Alox Soldier did not overlap
But it did overlap with the earliest Alox Pioneers - As this knife was the basis for the Alox Soldier
See History section of 1961 Soldier...Hmm...
@MiniChamp thats what I meant, watching the two knifes Ive posted here at evilbay.


-
There are more knowledgeable than me here, but here is my understanding:
The 1891 Soldier and the original Officer and Sportsman knives were 100mm.
In 1951 the soldier was shortened to 93mm and stainless tools.
The 93mm alox line started in 1957 and in 1961 was adopted by the swiss army as the 1961 soldier. -
@ MC and Shuya - OK - But it is only Wenger who produced the 1951 Soldier design after 1960 - Correct?
@Smiler - So you believe that the original Officers Knife was 100mm .... Which means the statement in the Wiki 91mm page is wrong !
Any idea when they switched to 91mm for the Officers' Knives?Can anyone else shed any light please? ???
-
Vic considers the Spartan to be the direct descendent of the Officer's knife. Here's the history from the 2012 commemorative Spartan.
No mention of size, but cellidor starts in 1937, the 1968 looks like current production.

-
I'll measure my 1902 Officer... give me a few
-
1902: 90.5mm
1936: 90mm -
@Mechanickal said:
1902: 90.5mm
1936: 90mmWhere did the missing length go?
You haven't been using them as hammers, have you? :ahhh
-
@Huntsman said:
@ MC and Shuya - OK - But it is only Wenger who produced the 1951 Soldier design after 1960 - Correct?Most likely, yes. In fact, this page says that "the manufacturer Elsener did not deliver any knifes in 1960 and 1961 (official information)" so it seems likely that the latest Vicorinox model 1951 soldier knives are from 1959.
-
@Don Pablo said:
1902: 90.5mm
1936: 90mmWhere did the missing length go?
There is no "missing length." As funny as it may sound, Pre-1951 "91mm" Victorinox SAKs are actually 90mm long (with small fluctuations from this precise length being quite likely for very old SAKs). The 1903 catalog didn't mention any length in mm, but listed the corresponding size as "9 cm." By the 1940's they already formally described the length as "90 mm," as indicated by the attached image of a page from a late-1940's catalog. The actual length changed to 91mm in the early 1950's, along with the many other major changes that occurred around that time (change to aluminum liners, change of distances between the rivets, introduction of the new 1951 can opener, etc.).
Similarly, Pre-1951 "84mm" Victorinox SAKs are actually 83mm long...
To minimize potential confusion, I think that it may be a good idea to have these facts mentioned in SAKWiki.

-
Thank you!
-
Hmm, interesting! I wonder why they went 91mm instead of 90mm, which is a nice round number.
-
@Don Pablo said:
1902: 90.5mm
1936: 90mmWhere did the missing length go?
There is no "missing length." As funny as it may sound, Pre-1951 "91mm" Victorinox SAKs are actually 90mm long (with small fluctuations from this precise length being quite likely for very old SAKs). The 1903 catalog didn't mention any length in mm, but listed the corresponding size as "9 cm." By the 1940's they already formally described the length as "90 mm," as indicated by the attached image of a page from a late-1940's catalog. The actual length changed to 91mm in the early 1950's, along with the many other major changes that occurred around that time (change to aluminum liners, change of distances between the rivets, introduction of the new 1951 can opener, etc.).
Similarly, Pre-1951 "84mm" Victorinox SAKs are actually 83mm long...
To minimize potential confusion, I think that it may be a good idea to have these facts mentioned in SAKWiki.
I got a kick out of the ‘Pocket-Knives for Peasants’. I love finding printed material with what was acceptable word usage which isn’t politically or socially correct.
I do wonder how they came up with ‘s’ for black. Interesting read...thanks for sharing. -
S for schwar(t)z. Haven't you watched Breaking Bad? ;)
-
Hey Knights
Thanks so much for all this feedback and interaction
That's what I love about this place - There is so much knowledge here - And it is all freely shared
Particular thanks to MC, Smiler and MechanicalAnyway that's it ...... The Officers knife has a new home on the 91mm page
I've also updated the Officers page with that interesting size information from MC
Please check it all out (via the new home link above) and feedback any comments -
*Oh - MC - I put your catalogue page in the Wiki (crediting you as the author) - I hope that is OK *This was quite a big error / omission in the Wiki - eh? ???
@Mechanickal said:
I'll measure my 1902 Officer... give me a fewWHAT !!!: You have a 1902 Officer's Knife ...... and ....... a 1936 one

Or are they already in the vintage SAK thread
-
@Huntsman said:
Thanks so much for all this feedback and interaction
That's what I love about this place - There is so much knowledge here - And it is all freely shared
Particular thanks to MC, Smiler and MechanicalYou are most welcome. Many thanks for all your great work on SAKWiki!

Anyway that's it ...... The Officers knife has a new home on the 91mm page
I've also updated the Officers page with that interesting size information from MC
Please check it all out (via the new home link above) and feedback any comments -
*Oh - MC - I put your catalogue page in the Wiki (crediting you as the author) - I hope that is OK *Hmmm...
The reason that I attached this image of just one page is that I couldn't attach the whole catalog (it's a 4.5MB PDF file with 28 pages; too big). I think that it would be better to do things as follows: First of all make the full catalog available on SAKWiki (it's an interesting document that should anyway be publicly and conveniently available, IMO). After that replace the link to the image by a link to the full catalog. Since the double "as" in "as 90mm as" doesn't look very nice (my fault; but removing the coma made it worse), I think that it would be better to also cut the relevant sentence and say:
By the 1940's the length is formally described as 90mm. This can be seen from the page before last of this late-1940's catalogue.
(Where "this late-1940's catalogue" becomes a link to the full catalog.) Moreover, I would also turn "The 1903 catalogue" to a link to the 1903 catalog.A compact version of the 1903 catalog is available at this link, but since I'm not familiar with a current public link to the late-1940's catalog, I propose that we get it added to SAKWiki. The question is: how do we do that? It so happens that there is a mysterious dead link to a "1948 Victorinox Catalog" on the SAKWiki Vic catalogs page, and since I'm not aware of more than one Vic catalog floating around from around this time, it's possible that this catalog was once available there and maybe is even still on the system somehow. Otherwise, I would be happy to upload it if someone would arrange for me to able to do it (I have a "MiniChamp" SAKWiki username, but as far as I can tell, it cannot do anything).
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login