SAK Evolution: Soldier and Officer Knives
-
Well done Ulli! Thank you sir

P.S. Add please something like "made by Ulli", I'm sure a lot of guys will share this cool picture everywhere -
Indeed, the 1903 catalog mentions the possibility of adding the cross to fiber scales as an option that costs 0.35 Franks, but I suspect that there may have been a point in time beyond which ALL of the officer's knives with fiber scales were produced with the cross. (This is unlike Wenger that produced some officer's knives with blank fiber scales for a long time; possibly until around 1950.) Is it true that there was such a point in time? If so, was it 1909? Later?
Still some mistakes :-) I will change them soon.
Just one thing: from the online 1903 catalog are only the first 4 pages from 1903, the other pages are from a different, later catalog (aprox. 1913). It would be better to make 2 documents out of it, one with 1903, the other with the later date, just to prevent further mistakes/misinterpretations.
-
@ulli said:
Just one thing: from the online 1903 catalog are only the first 4 pages from 1903, the other pages are from a different, later catalog (aprox. 1913). It would be better to make 2 documents out of it, one with 1903, the other with the later date, just to prevent further mistakes/misinterpretations.Really?!?! :o Are we talking about this document? It seems to be an extraction of pages A7-A13 from the Victorinox document "Everything you need to know about Multi-tools and cutlery." These pages are also a copy of pages 130-136 from the Victorinox 1984 book "The Knife and its History." Are you saying that Victorinox mixed different catalogs in this compilation? If so, how can you tell this? Also, since the last three pages are the ones showing pocket knives, how does it fit together for them to be from around 1913 along with moving to only three visible rivets in 1909 (all of the shown officer's knives have 4 visible rivets)?
-
Yes, its exactly that document. On the corner in the left you see the marking 1903/09.
Its a bit complicated with catalogs. They used them for a couple of years without changing pictures/drawings. They just changed the prices or crossed out the knives no longer produced. For them, a 3 rivet or 4 rivet Model 205 is the same; same tool configuration, same size. No need to make a new catalog. I think the costs for new catalog, to make new drawings, was too expensive to make it every couple of years. The 1942 catalog for example was used for decades.
So if you see a knife in an old victorinox catalog, the only thing you can say about is: the start of the production of this model can
t be later than the year of the catalog. In this "1903" catalog, you see those Victoria razors. The brand Victoria - and about that Im sure - was not used before 1909. So the only thing you can say about this catalog: it can`t be a catalog from 1903 :-).So catalogs are not a super reference to date a knife. Some of the knives shown were never produced :-) Better are advertising knives with a year marking.
-
@ulli said:
In this "1903" catalog, you see those Victoria razors. The brand Victoria - and about that Im sure - was not used before 1909. So the only thing you can say about this catalog: it cant be a catalog from 1903 :-).Wow! You are right. This Victoria thing never occurred to me before. Now I noticed that the word "VICTORIA" also appears on the blade of the Studentenmesser (but one needs to look at a high resolution version to see it). Thanks a lot for this explanation!
I guess maybe we should start calling this compilation "Early 20th Century Catalog" or something similar. 
-
So here is the latest version.
For me its no problem at all to edit those files. But better would be to delete old stuff/versions, what I cant (or don
t know how). Its the same with the tang stamp compilation and other sheets. For me, those are dynamic processes. Like Derek Jackson did this first sheet of officer and soldier knives, Im sure he was absolutely convinced that those dates and changes were correct. But as time goes by, you get to know more things and could clarify those compilations, what is good!. The problem is: on the web there are many old sheets. Some people use them, other take them from those people and so on. After a while, you have the problem that there are many incorrect/old reverences on the web. So always make sure, you get to know the "original" link or the correct producer of that stuff.Grooved Corkscrew: I checked most of my knives. I couldn`t finde any 4 rivet knife with a grooved corkscrew, and no 3 rivet knife model 1909 with a non grooved corkscrew. So I would date the change to 1909. Maybe someone has more info on that?

-
Great information! Thanks for sharing.

-
This is great!
There is just the following minor issue: it now says "mady by Ulli" in several places. I believe that it should say "Made by Ulli" instead.For me its no problem at all to edit those files. But better would be to delete old stuff/versions, what I cant (or don
t know how). Its the same with the tang stamp compilation and other sheets. For me, those are dynamic processes. Like Derek Jackson did this first sheet of officer and soldier knives, Im sure he was absolutely convinced that those dates and changes were correct. But as time goes by, you get to know more things and could clarify those compilations, what is good!. The problem is: on the web there are many old sheets. Some people use them, other take them from those people and so on. After a while, you have the problem that there are many incorrect/old reverences on the web. So always make sure, you get to know the "original" link or the correct producer of that stuff.You are right. It's a problem. Some people keep using old versions of your table of tang stamps and I suspect that many of them don't even know its origin. Maybe it will help a little if you do the following: instead of writing just "Made by Ulli," you can write at the top something like:
Preliminary version by Ulli. For the latest version, please check /topic/79865Grooved Corkscrew: I checked most of my knives. I couldn`t finde any 4 rivet knife with a grooved corkscrew, and no 3 rivet knife model 1909 with a non grooved corkscrew. So I would date the change to 1909. Maybe someone has more info on that?
Thanks!
It's quite difficult to find information about such very old SAKs. I'm learning a lot from this picture and this thread. I'm very grateful for that. 
-
Thanks for making and sharing this chart. Great work!

-
Thanks for starting this thread, and also thanks to everybody for the following discussion. This was really interesting and enlightening.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
