Is this Evolution?
-
Not a fan of the EVO scales, much prefer the Vic awl, either way on the different can openers, but really wish they'd lose the contoured scales that add so much thickness with no utility gain.
-
For me an EDC SAK must have scissors, so I love my Climber (Golfer, DofE, etc.), I love my Wenger Traveler even more, and only just a couple of days ago bought a Teton on eBay, baceuse I love the 85 mm Wenger form with the traditional scales. So: yes, please, I want 84 mm Vics with scissors and without the silly EVO sclaes, for me they're a no go, too much pocket space!
Either repair that damned 84 mm scissor-making machine (or build a new one), or just use the Wenger scissors, but please, Victorinox, give us 84 mm models with some snipping fuction...
-
I also dislike the Wenger/Vic Evolution scales. it adds nothing but bulk and thickness to me. My S16 also sits in the drawer for most of the time since i got it.
I don't understand why Vic couldn't carry on with the Classic side of Wenger line and decided to go with that bloody Evo line...

This it's the typical case of: "If it 'aint bloody broken, don't bloody fix it!"
And yes, an Alumnus would be great... but id prefer the Small Climber myself...

Anything with 84/85mm and scissors and standard scales would be a winner
-

I've lamented the end of the traditional Wenger scales on this forum before. -
I haven't been attracted to cellidor Evolution scales and have no hands on experience with them. I have a Traveller though and like the thin Classic cellidor scales. I'd catch an Evolution it were thrown to me.
However, thick as they are (and perhaps off topic), Evowood scales make a knife truly beautiful and in my opinion worth the premium price. The Evowood 14 feels good in my hand. While it's as thick as an Explorer, it's shorter and lighter. As a big fan of the Sportsman I voted for the return of the Alumnus, but I'm satisfied that the Evowood 14 is available instead. :)
-
Pretty much agree with what's been said already... I have nothing original to add...

-
@Fuzzbucket said:
Pretty much agree with what's been said already... I have nothing original to add...
Who does?!

Spoiler:
He's not been around much, though...

-
Why not go the MTo way? Keep both!

-
I theory I like the evogrip scales. I have 2 Wenger with them yet I dont use them. What I really like about Wenger is the cutout for the awl. Not sure why Vic isn't now using this
. I am a fan of bringing back any 84mm with scissors. -
@Sawl Goodman said:
I haven't been attracted to cellidor Evolution scales and have no hands on experience with them. I have a Traveller though and like the thin Classic cellidor scales. I'd catch an Evolution it were thrown to me.However, thick as they are (and perhaps off topic), Evowood scales make a knife truly beautiful and in my opinion worth the premium price. The Evowood 14 feels good in my hand. While it's as thick as an Explorer, it's shorter and lighter. As a big fan of the Sportsman I voted for the return of the Alumnus, but I'm satisfied that the Evowood 14 is available instead. :)
I've got an Evowood S10. Makes for a fun Tourist variant. But, then, it's only two layers.
-
@Aloha007 said:
What I really like about Wenger is the cutout for the awl. Not sure why Vic isn't now using this
.Really...?

That's like, the one thing i really dislike about the Wenger look is that ugly cut out for the awl on the front scale. I'm happy Vic didn't copy that one. IMO Vic's awl deployment placement is perfect. The back awl is probably one of the easiest most enjoyable tools to open on a sak, for me...
-
I think you pretty much illustrated why. Width and thickness both went in the wrong direction as did length. Over all the tool pushes the 85mm parameters a bit too much for me. The evogrip is nice in hand both left and right handed I'll say that.
I am holding a 84mm Tinker and Wenger S10 right now and the scales are thick on the S10 both visually and feel wise ( make sense?). Its not terrible in any way just thick IMO for added "grip"
. I'm not sure its worth it.I do like that Vic went with their can opener. It maybe that I'm just used to it. As to the scissors, its a toss up. Scissors are always a welcome addition, especially in this size SAK. I like the narrower bottle opener tip of the Wenger. I also really like the "locking" feature of it. When pushed hard it "seats". What a brilliant design. My S10 has the clip point small blade :( which is not a deal breaker but I like that Wenger used the small nail file in place of that small blade. The notch on the scale is also very welcomed for the awl. As for a sharpened awl or Wengers
. I like Wenger blades. The added belly is welcomed big time. I also like the stop on this S10s main blade. Not quite 90 degree stop but again very welcomed.I'm sure I've missed some things.
-
What I really like about Wenger is the cutout for the awl. Not sure why Vic isn't now using this
.Really...?

That's like, the one thing i really dislike about the Wenger look is that ugly cut out for the awl on the front scale. I'm happy Vic didn't copy that one. IMO Vic's awl deployment placement is perfect. The back awl is probably one of the easiest most enjoyable tools to open on a sak, for me...
Yes I really like cut out. Its simple and brilliant. In terms of the look, I like the look too. I also like how Wenger stows their T&T. :D
-
@Aloha007 said:
I think you pretty much illustrated why. Width and thickness both went in the wrong direction as did length. Over all the tool pushes the 85mm parameters a bit too much for me. The evogrip is nice in hand both left and right handed I'll say that.I am holding a 84mm Tinker and Wenger S10 right now and the scales are thick on the S10 both visually and feel wise ( make sense?). Its not terrible in any way just thick IMO for added "grip"
. I'm not sure its worth it.I do like that Vic went with their can opener. It maybe that I'm just used to it. As to the scissors, its a toss up. Scissors are always a welcome addition, especially in this size SAK. I like the narrower bottle opener tip of the Wenger. I also really like the "locking" feature of it. When pushed hard it "seats". What a brilliant design. My S10 has the clip point small blade :( which is not a deal breaker but I like that Wenger used the small nail file in place of that small blade. The notch on the scale is also very welcomed for the awl. As for a sharpened awl or Wengers
. I like Wenger blades. The added belly is welcomed big time. I also like the stop on this S10s main blade. Not quite 90 degree stop but again very welcomed.I'm sure I've missed some things.

I do want to be aware that I might be biased because I'm just more familiar with one design (grips, can opener, etc...) than another. I'd like to think I'm open-minded, but here the changes just fall flat (or fat) for me.
Still, it's nice to see a few members seem to like the Evolution designs!

(I like the Wenger T&T as well.)
-
As with a lot of things, familiarity does play a role. Do I dislike Evo? Its best said, I prefer the flat scales of SAKs.
-
For what it's worth the Evo / Evolution scales are, as others have mentioned, a bit bulky and I don't particularly like that in a pocket though I can tolerate it for 2 layers. I do like the Evolution 10 toolset much as I like the 84mm Sportsman.
Given that the Vic can opener has now been popped into the Evolution line (a good thing) I quite agree that putting Wenger scissors into 84mm would get be a welcome way to get back another layer of versatility there. I really ought to try an Evolution with scissors though just to see how it rolls...
I don't like Wenger T&T arrangements. Very happy with Vic's approach in Evolution scales. A side issue here - I don't understand the absence of T&T in 111mm Vic dual density scales when they're in 130mm Rangers ?

So, my ha'porth is the Delemont approach is ok and provides some interesting variation in the SAK range. Maybe not my preference but I'd accept one if you're offering

-
I voted Keep the 14/16 as i like the Evo's, i only have a couple of Delemonts though and have to say i like those too, i don't find them too thick and i find they fit in the hand nicely they also have a good feel to them

Get yourself an Evowood and set about caressing it with baby oil, you will soon see the light :D
Some of my better looking ones, i don't tend to carry the Esquires much but the rest get carried frequently


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login