How hard can it be?
-
Don't cut :
High tensile wire
Steel cable/rope
-
@Fuzzbucket said:
Don't cut :High tensile wire
Steel cable/rope
Right! Next thing you'll tell me is that I shouldn't use my stapler for metal sheets and wood

I can... can I? :D

-
I wish I could comment more but I have only used the cutters on my Spirit once in the whole time I've used them and it was to cut tinsel for a Christmss tree.
-
@Fuzzbucket said:
Don't cut :High tensile wire
Steel cable/rope
Or fish hooks, they are the devil.
-
@MTMatt said:
Don't cut :
High tensile wire
Steel cable/rope
Right! Next thing you'll tell me is that I shouldn't use my stapler for metal sheets and wood

I can... can I? :D

Where/How on Earth did you find that gif? ROFLMAO!

-
-
@MTMatt said:
Since my Swisstool Spirit doesn't have replaceable wire cutters I'm trying to find out what I can and what I shouldn't cut with it.I tried cutting various items with various pliers earlier (although not the Spirit). /topic/73020 Many of the multi-tool pliers ended up damaged after that, and I reckon they all would have been if I had tried the real hard stuff. (Which a Knipex specialized cutter did with ease).
There seems to be three main weaknesses with multi-tool pliers. One is the geometry with overlapping cutters. That means cutter support and backing from just one side of the cutting edge, which seem to make them fairly narrow and prone to chipping. In comparison that is rare among specialized tools, and then those for soft materials. The other seems to be quality/ hardness/ brittleness of the cutting edge itself. That varies with manufacturer and pricepoint though. And the third is that many small ones separate sideways at the main plier connection instead of staying close and cutting.
That said the Spirit is a tough quality tool - it should be among the very best multi-tools out there including for cutting. Sadly I didn't have one around for that test.
-
Don't cut :
High tensile wire
Steel cable/rope
Or fish hooks, they are the devil.
Didn't know about fish hooks being that tough.
Good info, thanks Zoid
- Tinsel = OK , HRC like brass
- Fish hook = Not ok , HRC > 40
-
Shamelessly stolen from a jewelry hardness info site: (www.jewelrynotes.com/the-mohs-scale-of-hardness-for-metals-why-it-is-important/)
Lead: 1.5
Tin: 1.5
Zinc: 2.5
Gold: 2.5-3
Silver: 2.5-3
Aluminum: 2.5-3
Copper: 3
Brass: 3
Bronze: 3
Nickel: 4
Platinum: 4-4.5
Steel: 4-4.5
Iron: 4.5
Palladium: 4.75
Rhodium: 6
Titanium: 6
Hardened steel: 7-8
Tungsten: 7.5
Tungsten carbide: 8.5-9To me it seems like most things up to 4-5 should be okish to cut within reasonable thickness and shape.
-
@MTMatt said:
Since my Swisstool Spirit doesn't have replaceable wire cutters I'm trying to find out what I can and what I shouldn't cut with it.
I tried cutting various items with various pliers earlier (although not the Spirit). /topic/73020 Many of the multi-tool pliers ended up damaged after that, and I reckon they all would have been if I had tried the real hard stuff. (Which a Knipex specialized cutter did with ease).
There seems to be three main weaknesses with multi-tool pliers. One is the geometry with overlapping cutters. That means cutter support and backing from just one side of the cutting edge, which seem to make them fairly narrow and prone to chipping. In comparison that is rare among specialized tools, and then those for soft materials. The other seems to be quality/ hardness/ brittleness of the cutting edge itself. That varies with manufacturer and pricepoint though. And the third is that many small ones separate sideways at the main plier connection instead of staying close and cutting.
That said the Spirit is a tough quality tool - it should be among the very best multi-tools out there including for cutting. Sadly I didn't have one around for that test.
Wow Vidar, that's a great thread and testing you did there :o
I'll make myself a fresh coffee and have some quality time reading it
"And the third is that many small ones separate sideways at the main plier connection instead of staying close and cutting"
... regarding that I've observed the following interesting design differences...

-
@Vidar said:
Shamelessly stolen from a jewelry hardness info site: (www.jewelrynotes.com/the-mohs-scale-of-hardness-for-metals-why-it-is-important/)Lead: 1.5
Tin: 1.5
Zinc: 2.5
Gold: 2.5-3
Silver: 2.5-3
Aluminum: 2.5-3
Copper: 3
Brass: 3
Bronze: 3
Nickel: 4
Platinum: 4-4.5
Steel: 4-4.5
Iron: 4.5
Palladium: 4.75
Rhodium: 6
Titanium: 6
Hardened steel: 7-8
Tungsten: 7.5
Tungsten carbide: 8.5-9To me it seems like most things up to 4-5 should be okish to cut within reasonable thickness and shape.
Great find Vidar

Referring to this converter the Victorinox stated 40 HRC would be Mohs 4.37
Rockwell c hardness number 40 - Wolfram|Alpha
Compute answers using Wolfram's breakthrough technology & knowledgebase, relied on by millions of students & professionals. For math, science, nutrition, history, geography, engineering, mathematics, linguistics, sports, finance, music…
(www.wolframalpha.com)
-
@MTMatt said:
Don't cut :
High tensile wire
Steel cable/rope
Or fish hooks, they are the devil.
Didn't know about fish hooks being that tough.
Good info, thanks Zoid
- Tinsel = OK , HRC like brass
- Fish hook = Not ok , HRC > 40
Some High end Japanese made hooks have very good metalurgy . Stainless steel hooks for salt water use can be pretty tuff as well .Any mild steel , of reasonable diameter should be fine . Very important , cut straight , don’t go in and start twisting . I would try to avoid stainless , or braided cables as much as possible .
Chris
-
Thanks Chris, will stay away from cutting Fish hooks.

I think it's a bad idea anyways
-
So basically, since we've figured the hardness limits of...
HRC 40 = Mohs 4.37
Combined with the table below...
Lead: 1.5
Tin: 1.5
Zinc: 2.5
Gold: 2.5-3
Silver: 2.5-3
Aluminum: 2.5-3
Copper: 3
Brass: 3
Bronze: 3
Nickel: 4
Platinum: 4-4.5
Steel: 4-4.5
Iron: 4.5
Palladium: 4.75
Rhodium: 6
Titanium: 6
Hardened steel: 7-8
Tungsten: 7.5
Tungsten carbide: 8.5-9... would you guys have any real life examples to the different hardness levels?
Where in that list would a paper-clip be? Or a pin?

-
I think paper clips are usually made of mild steel so probably around 40. I can say I have cut medium sized ones using a LM PS4 with no damage, though with considerable hand effort involved.
-
Thanks Theo... great info

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
