What fixed blade are you carrying today?
-
As to the blade on the Koyote "Drop Point Kephart", I think Koyote told me he made it from an old saw blade, an he believed it to be L6 steel . Sounds right.
The stock is about 1/8" thick, It has a convex edge, and I'd be tempted to cal it a 'Scandivex' edge, as long as no one get's his or her feelings hurt here.
I don't know how Koyote achieved that spalting on the blade. I like it aesthetically. I was worried that stuff like peanut butter would be hard to clean off, but that hasn't been an issue.
Regardless of the steel, the knife takes a wicked sharp edge. Edge retention is good, but not astounding by modern "super-steel" standards. But I don't care, it sharpens easily and can be touched up in the field if needed.
The blade geometry in timeless and fairly instinctive to use. The edge does a good job splitting wood as well as slicing foods. I've batonned this knife through small-diameter wood with ease.
I cold see where one might want a slightly thicker blade in a woods knife, but, really I've had no issues using this and it has proven tone reliable and capable. I suppose one advantage of the thinner blade is that the knife is relatively light weight for a 4.5" knife.
I guess that about does it for my insights. If I think of anything else, I'll add some more later.

-
I didn't actually carry it, but I just bought it today, and the question is: does an axe count as a fixed blade?

Sent from my Redmi Note 5
-
I say, "Yes".
Why not?
-
I reckon so as well

This wouldn't ;)

-
Osage orange has been a long time favorite of mine... 
-
@Nix said:
As to the blade on the Koyote "Drop Point Kephart", I think Koyote told me he made it from an old saw blade, an he believed it to be L6 steel . Sounds right.The stock is about 1/8" thick, It has a convex edge, and I'd be tempted to cal it a 'Scandivex' edge, as long as no one get's his or her feelings hurt here.
I don't know how Koyote achieved that spalting on the blade. I like it aesthetically. I was worried that stuff like peanut butter would be hard to clean off, but that hasn't been an issue.
Regardless of the steel, the knife takes a wicked sharp edge. Edge retention is good, but not astounding by modern "super-steel" standards. But I don't care, it sharpens easily and can be touched up in the field if needed.
The blade geometry in timeless and fairly instinctive to use. The edge does a good job splitting wood as well as slicing foods. I've batonned this knife through small-diameter wood with ease.
I cold see where one might want a slightly thicker blade in a woods knife, but, really I've had no issues using this and it has proven tone reliable and capable. I suppose one advantage of the thinner blade is that the knife is relatively light weight for a 4.5" knife.
I guess that about does it for my insights. If I think of anything else, I'll add some more later.

To be fair the more I learn from experience and read, the more I'm convinced that a sub 5" blade very rarely benefits from being thicker than 1/8th.
The handle would be my first concern as well. Not so much that is looks small since the reality of that can only be felt in hand* but rather that is looks slick. Guess that whole experiment with linseed oil at least added to the shiny factor.
The blade profile reminds me a bit of a chef knife. Maybe something that would easily be seen in a Green river catalogue.*what I mean by this can perfectly be explained by 2 Spyders - Sage and Para2. Sage has more width and while it is an excellent knife I find it to be quite awkward in most use due to the handle feeling small. Para2 on the other hand doesn't cause any issues for me
-
Yes, the linseed oil did give the handle a shiny appearance. The handle is in no way slick. Smooth, yes. Shiny, yes. It is still quite 'grippy', though.
I agree. I don't think a knife blade really needs to be over 1/8" - 3/16" in this size range. The exception being in a very wide blade, where a thicker stock will allow for different primary edge geometries.
For comparison, let me put up a photo contrasting a Treeman Pathfinder with the Koyote (the Treeman has a lot of odd angles and it's hard to get a clean shot):

The Treeman is made with a massive 1/4" thick O-1 tool steel stock! Because of that, the blade has a deep hollow-grind. It does give the knife a razor's edge, but it also makes it a less clean slicer. The thick blade stock give this knife a very heft and solid feel. It feels indestructible. And that come with a price: the Koyote comes in at 127 grams on my kitchen scale, the Treeman is a big 317 grams. (For reference: my Vic Explorer and Wenger Esquire together weigh 127 grams.)
Here's a better shot of the Treeman:

It's a beast.
As you can see, the handle is highly contoured with elements of an integral guard and pommel. Your hand is really locked in when holding it with a hammer grip. While the handle looks like it would limit other grips, I have to give Treeman some credit for creating a fairly versatile handle. Saber grip feels good to me, and my thumb lands quite naturally on the big 1/4 flat of the spine, before the false edge up front.
The big choil does let one choke up safely, but I don't think I could do so with gloves. Using a pointing grip (index finger on spine) is less comfortable. The swell at the pommel creates a small point of discomfort and the lanyard attachment loop digs into my palm. That contrasts sharply (bad pun) with Koyote's handle where the rounded pommel fits comfortably in the palm.
The other big problem with this handle comes up when trying to use a chest-lever grip. It's possible do use this grip, but really awkward with bits of the guard and pommel digging into the hand. The Koyote is fantastic when used with the chest-lever grip. I think the Treeman wold start to feel very uncomfortable if one were using this grip to make a large number of cuts, e.g. making six tent stakes.
I think it's interesting to contrast these two knives, because they are both described as "bushcraft" knives. Obviously with very different emphases. While the Treeman is a very versatile knife, I have to give the "Bushcraft" prize to the Koyote design. As a "Hunting" knife, the Treeman has some advantages.....but then there is that weight.....
Since I pulled out the Treeman, I'll be carrying it today. With a stiff belt and the kidex sheath, the Treeman actually carries surprisingly well, despite the weight.
-
Well 2 very popular and very thick designs are the Becker BK-2 and ESEE-5 which are marketed in a similar fashion to one another. They certainly have fans, but for me it still seems like a good bit of sacrifice to get that feeling of imperviousness.
To be fair, maybe I'm missing something. Never had to baton much and even when I did it wasn't some super hard and knotty wood (although I have a firm belief that most people exaggerate the need for battoning and just how tough the local wood is). So I'd rather use that extra weight somewhere else.
-

Although I do like to be able to baton a knife to process wood. And axe is a better choice, but I don't carry an axe much. And I agree that the absolute *need *to baton is probably overrated. Still, if the available wood is snow covered or wet, it is very nice to be able to split open some wood to get to dry-stuff when making a fire. Here, the pines grow up in the wind and twist, makes this wood a pain to spit cleanly. And it is very knotty. But, again, I've found that judicious use of a knife with reasonable sized wood isn't a problem for most knives.
I've used that 1/8" Koyote to baton reasonably sized wood without a problem.
I have a BK-2. I'm not a fan. It's too chunky, and I think that chunky quality reduces it's overall utility. And it just plain weighs too much. I often think of getting rid of it......but it makes for a nice "sharp pry-bar". It does take a hair-shaving edge as well.
The handle on the BK-2 (same as the BK-7, 5, and 9) is pretty comfortable for me, although I prefer the micarta scales. The plastic scales feel too slippery to me.
-
well you never know when you'll need to baton a really nasty piece of wood so having that BK-2 handy is a smart move. plus batoning might be safer. a lot of people aren't that used to an axe, being tired, cold, might be later in the day are all factors to consider. plus axes are heavy as well.
even without an axe, in my head there is some choice to be made. now this comes from 0 practical experience and is pure theory, so it should be taken with a grain of salt. if you had access to enough wood that is properly sized to baton it and there is a realistic need for doing so (like the wood being wet), wouldn't it make more sense to baton the straighter pieces with fewer knots and leave the gnarly pieces to just burn as larger fuel?
here we've never needed an abundance of small pieces, just enough to get the fire going enough to accept the larger fuel. that usually meant having 3 or 4 forearm sized pieces busted to thirds or quarters and 1 or 2 pieces to smaller chunks, so the theory above might make sense or i might be talking out of my smurf
-
In my experience, once the fire gets going, you don't really need to baton. Just put wood on the fire, although, split woods catches fire and burns more easily.
Batonning for me has been most helpful when trying to get a fire started by exposing inner, dry wood that can be shaved into tinder and kindling. If you have enough dry tinder and kindling available, you don't even need to baton. Sometimes the 'feather stick' method is perfect, although, here in the mountain west, straight grained wood that is easy to turn into a bundle of perfect curls isn't easy to come by.
A few weeks ago I was staying at Forrest Service cabin. There was some cut firewood available, but no kindling. And the ground was covered in 6"-36" of snow. I used a big "Canadian Camp Knife" to baton actual logs into kindling. Then broke some kindling down into fine pieces of wood to use as tinder. Worked perfectly and, even slightly frozen, I got a good blaze going in a matter of minutes.
My hunting buddy had not seen this technique. He wasn't sure e could have gotten a fire going. He was impressed enough by the technique that he bought himself a big camp knife after we got back.

-
BRKT Canadian camp knife? that is a thing of beauty. But that is also a larger knife that really should be able to handle such use. You ever tried Fallkniven knives? I'm curious what you think of their performance and handles since your enviroment is not really forgiving and you've got big hands
-
Stand by.....
-
I really like everything I know about Fallkniven.
After a bit of research and consideration, I got this S1:

OK, so it looks a bit funny.......
While I love the Fallkniven S1, I tend to not carry it. The handle is a bit small for me. So....I added some camo grip tape. This made a big difference for the way the knife feels. But I'm not sure it's a durable solution for me. (I could make it durable by soaking it in superglue, but that is a one-way ticket.) Since adding the grip tape, I have only used the S1 for relatively light tasks.
Still, the handle feels better to me.
The sheath is some kind of plastic. It is well designed and very sensible....but I found it could be noisy. Like loud noisy. So I added a bit of tape to the sheath. This seems to help, but then I stopped carrying the knife. I took it on some motorcycle camping trips, but never really used it.
Aside from the edge being a bit polished, it looks nearly new:

So here's a funny thing. I've got a knife I really like, but one that doesn't really suit me. A knife that gets left at home more often than it gets to go out on the road. For a while I thought it might serve as an emergency kit knife.....but it doesn't even do that.
** sheesh!* * Just checked the edge and it's sharp! Hair cutting sharp!
I'm at a loss as to an opinion about this knife. One the one hand, I think it is the best thing since Excalibur, on the other hand.....it doesn't really suit me.
If you want to give it a tryout, Styx, I'll send it over to you. It ain't doing much here.

-
That sounds a lot like me and the Spyderco Sage I mentioned earlier. Funny thing I've actually carried that knife a good bit but anytime I thought there would be more than a quick cut it got switched out for a SAK. Still managed to put a few unappealing scratches on it while sharpening

Thanks for the offer, I might take you up on it one day. The handle of the S1 being small is concerning though. You were spot on with the Para2 so wouldn't surprise me if I got to the same conclusion
-
Well, the offer stands. Give it some thought. There is a lot to like about the S1. Cheers,

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
Me, too!

